Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 7: The Energy of an Orbit
Chapter 7: The Energy of an Orbit
In this chapter: Use gravitational potential energy U = -GMm/r and kinetic energy to show that a circular orbit has total energy E = -GMm/2r, and use this to explain why a satellite that loses energy to air drag moves faster and lower, and why climbing to a higher orbit costs energy.
Noodles had a theory, and he had brought it up the stairs with him like a tray.
“I have been thinking about SkyClub-1,” he said, settling on the folding chair with the gravity of a lawyer. “And I have found a problem in the design. A serious one.”
“Go on,” said Memoon.
“At four hundred kilometres there is still a little air. Nimo said so. The air rubs on the satellite. It is like rubbing your hands. It slows it down. When it slows down, it falls. So the satellite goes slower and slower and drops out of the sky. That is the end of the project.” He folded his paws. “I would like the Club to acknowledge that I am right.”
“You are right about two things,” said Memoon, “and wrong about one. And the wrong one is the interesting one.”
Noodles considered this. “Which one is wrong?”
“The part where it goes slower.”
He stared. “It is rubbing on air. It has to go slower.”
“That,” said Memoon, “is the prediction. Let us test it.”
She opened the notebook and wrote a heading: What is the energy of an orbit?
The bowl orbit and Noodles’s theory
Kachui had been waiting for this one. “We have two kinds of energy that matter for a satellite,” he said. “The first is the one everyone knows: kinetic energy, the energy of motion. K equals half m v squared. A faster thing has more of it.”
“And the second?” asked Simbha.
“The second belongs to the position in the gravity field. It is called gravitational potential energy. When you lift a book, you do work against gravity and store energy. Near the ground we use m g h. But that is only good for small heights, where g hardly changes. For a satellite, g changes a lot, so we need the full version.” He wrote it:
U=-GMm/r
“Why the minus sign?” asked Noodles, who had spotted it at once and was suspicious of it.
“A good question,” said Kachui. “It comes from a choice. Energy differences matter, not the energy itself, so we are free to choose where to call it zero. For gravity, the natural choice is ’very far away’, at infinity. If you are far away, you are not bound to Earth. As you come closer, gravity does work on you, and the energy of the system drops below that zero. So inside the gravity field, U is negative. The closer to Earth, the more negative.”
“Like a hole,” said Beautine.
“Exactly like a hole,” said Kachui. “A satellite is somewhere on the side of a very deep hole. Climbing out takes energy. Falling in releases it.”
Memoon was already writing. “For a circular orbit we know v squared is G M over r. So kinetic energy is half m times G M over r, which is G M m over two r.”
K = + G M m / (2 r)
“And potential energy is minus G M m over r. Add them.”
E = K + U = G M m/(2r) - G M m/r = - G M m / (2 r)
“The total energy is negative,” said Simbha slowly. “And it is minus the kinetic energy.”
“E equals minus K,” said Memoon. “And U is minus two K. In a circular orbit the potential energy is always exactly twice as negative as the kinetic energy is positive. Do you see why that matters?”
Nobody did.
“A negative total energy means the satellite is bound,” she said. “It cannot escape on its own. To get out to infinity it would need to gain energy until the total reached zero. We will use that in Chapter 8. But for now, look at what happens when the total energy changes.”
She drew a little graph: a vertical axis for energy, a horizontal axis for orbital radius, a curve for E that climbed from far below zero on the left towards zero on the right.
“If the satellite loses energy to air drag, E becomes more negative. Look at the curve. A more negative E means a smaller r. The satellite sinks to a lower orbit.”
“That is what I said,” said Noodles.
“Wait for the next part. At the lower orbit, the speed is the circular speed there. And the circular speed is v equals the square root of G M over r. Smaller r means larger v.”
There was a pause long enough for a cloud to go by.
Energy of a circular orbit (per the same satellite)
500 km orbit K = +GMm/2r (kinetic) 0.5 U = −GMm/r (potential) E = −GMm/2r (total) energy in units of GMm/R
zero energy = infinitely far away
-0.5
-1
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
distance from Earth's centre, in Earth radii (r/R)
At every radius U is twice as negative as K is positive, so E = −K. Raising the orbit raises E toward zero.
Potential, kinetic and total energy of a circular orbit, in units of GMm/R.
“No,” said Noodles. “That is silly. It is losing energy and going faster.”
“The total energy is going down,” said Memoon. “The kinetic part is going up. The potential part is going down twice as fast. K goes up by a little. U goes down by twice that. The total drops by exactly the amount that is taken by the air. Gravity does the extra work, and some of it ends up as speed.”
“Gravity pulls it down, and so it speeds up as it falls,” said Simbha.
“Exactly,” said Memoon. “It is just like a ball rolling downhill with some friction. The friction takes away energy, but the hill gives more than the friction takes. The ball ends up going faster at the bottom.”
Noodles sat with that for a long time. “So the air is a thief,” he said at last, “but gravity is a generous friend who gives back more than she is robbed of.”
“That is a better summary than I could have written,” said Kachui.
They put numbers on it. SkyClub-1, a small satellite of about four kilograms, goes round at 400 kilometres, where the speed is 7,672 metres per second. Its kinetic energy is half times four times the speed squared, which is 1.18 times ten to the eight joules. Its potential energy is twice that, with a minus sign. Its total energy is minus 1.18 times ten to the eight joules.
“Now drop it to 300 kilometres,” said Memoon. “The circular speed there is 7,730 metres per second. It has gone faster by fifty-eight metres per second, and total energy has fallen by about 1.8 million joules.”
“Is that a lot?” asked Beautine.
“It is about what a one-kilowatt heater produces in half an hour,” said Kachui. “For a four-kilogram satellite it is about one and a half percent of its orbital energy, lost for a drop of only a hundred kilometres. Which is why people watch the height of satellites very carefully.”
Nimo’s bubble floated up. “May I give a small analogy? Not for the energy. For the air.”
“You are always welcome,” said Memoon.
“The air up there is very thin. I would say it is like a pond that has been drained to a few drops. Each drop is hardly noticed. But the satellite crosses it at seven kilometres every second, and every second it meets a few more drops. Day after day, those drops add up.”
“That is a fair picture,” said Kachui.
“But,” said Nimo, “I must be honest about the limit. In my pond, drops move randomly. In the sky, the thin air also expands and shrinks with the Sun. When the Sun is active, it heats the upper air, the air puffs up, and the drag grows. So the drag is not a steady trickle. It is a tide.”
“I did not know that,” said Noodles.
“Nor did most people, for a long time,” said Nimo. “Skylab, a space station launched in 1973, came down in 1979, earlier than planned, because the Sun was more active than predicted. The International Space Station loses about two kilometres of height a month in quiet times, and it must fire its engines every so often to climb back up.”
“Climb back up costs energy,” said Simbha. “Which is why we need to count it.”
“We do,” said Memoon. “Let us count what a boost costs for SkyClub-1.”
She set the problem on the page. Raise the satellite from 400 kilometres to 500 kilometres. At 400 kilometres its energy is minus G M m over two r, which is minus 1.177 times ten to the eight joules. At 500 kilometres, r is 6,871 kilometres, and the total energy is minus 1.160 times ten to the eight. The difference is plus 1.7 times ten to the six joules.
“Only 1.7 million joules,” said Beautine. “That is not very much.”
“That is the energy the satellite gains in orbit,” said Memoon. “It is a tiny fraction of what the rocket spent getting it up there from the ground. We will see that in Chapter 10. But look at the sign. The total energy goes up, and the speed goes down. The satellite moves from 7.67 to 7.62 kilometres per second.”
“Which is the reverse of what Noodles first thought,” said Beautine.
“To go higher, you speed up first,” said Memoon, “and then you slow down on the higher path. And the whole thing is run by energy.”
She tapped the page. “And this is the reason for Kepler’s second law, which I said I could not explain. In an ellipse, the energy is fixed. When a planet is closer, U is more negative, so K has to be larger. That means faster. When it is farther, U is less negative, so K is smaller. That means slower. The area law is a statement about turning motion. The energy gives us the speed at any distance. You can check it for Earth: at 147 million kilometres the speed is 30.3 kilometres per second, and at 152 million it is 29.3.”
“It does check,” said Kachui, who was already tapping his calculator. “Close to the Sun by three percent, and faster by three percent. A coincidence?”
“A consequence,” said Memoon.
Noodles got up, walked to the parapet and looked up at the dark.
“I was wrong,” he said, to nobody in particular. “But it was a useful wrong.”
“It is the best kind,” said Kachui.
Mr Rao, passing the top of the stairs, paused to ask who was wrong. Noodles said it was him. Mr Rao said that was a pleasing change from the usual arrangement, in which it was Mr Rao, and took a biscuit.
Science Corner Kinetic energy K = half m v squared. Gravitational potential energy U = -G M m / r, measured from zero at infinity. It is negative inside the field, and more negative closer in. For a circular orbit, v squared = G M / r, so K = G M m / (2 r) and U = -G M m / r = -2K. The total energy is E = K + U = -G M m / (2 r) = -K. The negative sign means the satellite is bound. Drag: air drag removes energy, so E becomes more negative, r decreases, and the circular speed v = √(G M / r) increases. The satellite speeds up as it spirals down. Raising an orbit means increasing E (less negative): U rises by twice the amount K falls, so the speed goes down. SkyClub-1, 4 kg: from 400 km (E = -1.177 × 108 J) to 500 km (E = -1.160 × 108 J) needs about 1.7 × 106 J. Worked problem (maths track): For a 4 kg satellite at r = 6.771 × 106 m, K = G M m / (2 r) = 3.986 × 1014 × 4 / (2 × 6.771 × 106) = 1.177 × 108 J. Concept track: in a circular orbit, the total energy is the same size as the kinetic energy but negative.
In any ellipse, E = -G M m / (2 a) is constant, so the body is fastest where it is closest. This is the energy view of Kepler’s second law. Story note: Treating U as zero at infinity is a choice; only differences in energy have physical meaning. The ’rolling downhill’ picture fits the energy bookkeeping, but gravity pulls toward the planet’s centre and the satellite’s path is sideways, so it does not actually roll on a surface. The pond analogy fails because the upper air is a thin, changing gas, not still water; its density depends strongly on solar activity. The 1.8 × 106 J figure for dropping from 400 to 300 km is rounded, and the drag figures for the space station are typical and vary from month to month. Skylab (launched 1973) re-entered in 1979, partly because of high solar activity. All masses and speeds are rounded to three or four figures.
Space Detective 1. A 4 kg satellite orbits at r = 6.771 × 106 m with v = 7,672 m/s. Find its kinetic energy, its potential energy and its total energy. Explain why the total energy is negative. 2. Air drag takes energy from a satellite in a circular orbit. Explain, using energy, why the satellite descends and why it ends up moving faster, not slower. 3. Moving SkyClub-1 from a 400 km orbit to a 500 km orbit raises its total energy by about 1.7 × 106 J, but its speed falls from 7.67 to 7.62 km/s. Explain how both can be true.
Try it: The Bowl Orbit Time: 15 minutes. Adult: An adult should supervise, because marbles are small and a dropped bowl can break. You need: a large smooth round bowl (steel or plastic), a marble or a small steel ball, and a table. Do: Hold the bowl steady on the table. Gently roll the marble round the inside wall so that it circles near the rim. Watch what happens over the next few seconds. Time how long each lap takes near the top and again near the bottom, using a phone stopwatch. What to expect: The marble circles, loses a little energy to friction, and spirals lower. As it descends, it goes round faster, so laps get shorter. Eventually it settles at the bottom. Cloudy or low-resource day: This works indoors in any weather. If no bowl is available, use a video of a coin rolling in a spiral funnel or a gravity-well demonstration at a science centre. Limitation: the bowl gives an inward pull from the surface, not from a central body, and the speeds do not follow the same law as a real orbit. Rolling friction takes energy in a way that is much stronger than the thin air at 400 km.
Next time: We know how much energy it takes to sit in an orbit. But what if a rocket goes on pumping in energy until the total reaches zero? How fast must you go to leave a planet behind for good?
← Chapter 6: Weighing a World · Book 11 contents · Chapter 8: Escape →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment