Memunic Space Explorers › Book 4: Memoon and the Mystery of the Changing Moon › Chapter 4: Noodles's Theory
Chapter 4: Noodles's Theory
On day ten Noodles came up to the terrace wearing two shawls, one sock and a woolly hat that belonged to somebody’s baby brother.
“I have a theory,” he said, through chattering teeth. “And I am so sure of it that I will bet my whole tin of fish treats.”
Beautine’s eyes went very wide. “The whole tin?”
“The whole tin.” Noodles drew a big squashed oval on the mat in chalk, with a Sun near one end. “Earth goes round the Sun on this path. In May, Earth is here, close to the Sun, so it is baking hot. In December, Earth is way over here, far away. So it is freezing. That is why we have seasons.”
It was a good, bold theory. It even matched what he could feel: the tiles of the terrace were icy under his paws.
Noodles’s theory: Earth far from the Sun in winter. He bets his tin of fish treats on it.
Memoon crouched beside the drawing. “I like it because we can test it,” she said. “If Earth is far from the Sun in December, what else must be true?”
Noodles thought. “The calendar people must say Earth is farthest away in December.”
“Good. What else?”
Nimo floated closer. “If Earth is far from the Sun, all of Earth is far from the Sun. So everyone on Earth should be cold in December. The whole planet should have winter at once.”
“Two predictions,” said Memoon, writing them in the Sky Notebook. “One: Earth is farthest from the Sun in December. Two: everybody has winter in December.”
Kachui was already turning the pages of the little sky almanac that had come with Simbha’s planetarium poster. He read for a while, checked, and read again, because Kachui always checked.
“Here,” he said at last. “Earth at its closest to the Sun: 2 January. Earth at its farthest from the Sun: 6 July.“
Noodles’s whiskers drooped. “January? But January is the coldest month here!”
“The closest point has a name,” said Kachui, reading carefully. “Perihelion. It happens every year in early January. This year it is two days after Simbha’s party.”
“So prediction one is wrong,” said Memoon. “Earth is nearest the Sun in our winter, not farthest.”
“Maybe the almanac is wrong,” said Noodles hopefully.
“Then let us test prediction two as well,” said Memoon. “Two bits of evidence are better than one.” She propped her phone against the water tank and made a video call.
The screen filled with bright sunshine. Guddu’s face appeared, squinting and laughing, her dark ponytail tucked under a straw hat. Behind her was a park full of green trees, and people in shorts and T-shirts.
“Memoon! Hi, everyone! Hello, Noodles, why are you wearing a hat?”
“Because it is winter,” said Noodles with dignity. “Where are you?”
“Buenos Aires, in Argentina, visiting Mausi for the holidays. It is half past ten in the morning here.” Guddu held up an ice lolly that was dripping onto her wrist. “And it is boiling. It is summer! The days are so long the Sun does not set until after eight.”
Winter on the terrace, summer on the screen. Guddu calls from Buenos Aires.
Noodles stared at the screen. “Summer. In December.”
“Argentina is in the southern hemisphere,” said Memoon. “The half of Earth south of the equator. We are in the northern half.”
“In December,” said Guddu, “the whole southern half has summer and the whole northern half has winter. Then in June we swap.”
“But we are on the same planet,” said Noodles slowly. “At the same distance from the Sun. At the same moment.”
“So distance cannot be the reason,” said Kachui. “If it were, Guddu would be shivering too.”
Nimo bobbed thoughtfully. “Besides, the difference is small. The almanac says Earth is about 147 million kilometres from the Sun at its closest and about 152 million at its farthest. That is a change of about 5 million kilometres, only about 3 parts in every 100.” He bubbled. “In my pond, if I swim 3 per cent closer to a warm stone, I hardly notice.”
Earth's real path: Noodles's idea almost a perfect circle
far too squashed
| early January | early July |
|---|---|
| closest: | farthest: |
| about 147 million km | about 152 million km |
Sun
The path shape is close to true. The Sun and Earth are drawn far too big.
The path shape is close to true. The Sun and Earth are drawn far too big.
“Where does that idea stop working?” asked Memoon.
“The Sun is not a stone in a pond, and space is not water,” said Nimo. “But the numbers still say the change is small.”
Noodles looked at his chalk drawing for a long time. Then he rubbed out the squashed oval with his paw and drew a shape that was very nearly a circle.
“That is much closer to the real shape,” said Kachui. “Earth’s path is almost round.”
“My theory is wrong,” said Noodles. He pushed his tin of fish treats into the middle of the mat. “Fairly tested and fairly wrong. Everybody take one. Except Nimo, who is a fish, which would be strange.”
Beautine took three. “A wrong theory that teaches us something,” she declared, “deserves a place in a museum.”
“Then what does make the seasons?” asked Guddu from the screen.
Memoon was looking at Guddu’s sunny park, at the short shadows under the trees and the high, bright light. “I do not know yet,” she said. “But I think it is about how the sunlight hits the ground, not how far it travels.”
Science Corner Seasons are the parts of the year with different temperatures and day lengths, such as summer and winter. Earth’s path round the Sun is almost a circle. Earth is closest to the Sun, at perihelion, in early January, about 147 million km away. It is farthest in early July, about 152 million km away. The equator is an imaginary line round the middle of Earth. It divides Earth into two halves, the northern hemisphere and the southern hemisphere. India is in the northern hemisphere; Argentina and Australia are in the southern hemisphere. When it is winter in the northern hemisphere, it is summer in the southern hemisphere, at the same distance from the Sun. So distance cannot be the main cause of the seasons. Remember from Book 3: Earth’s trip round the Sun is called revolution, and one trip takes a year. Story note: Noodles’s chalk oval was far too squashed; the real path looks almost exactly like a circle. The almanac distances are rounded to the nearest million km, and the closest and farthest dates shift by a day or two from year to year. The pond analogy only shows that a small change in distance makes a small difference; sunlight does not travel through water to reach Earth.
Space Detective 1. Write Noodles’s theory as a prediction that can be tested. Then write the two pieces of evidence that showed it was wrong. 2. Copy and complete the table: City, Hemisphere, Season in December, Season in June. Use Delhi, Buenos Aires and Sydney. 3. Draw Earth’s path round the Sun as almost a circle. Mark where Earth is in early January and early July.
Try It: Two-City Temperature Table Time: 10 minutes a day for one week. You need: a notebook, a ruler, a newspaper or an app that shows temperatures. Adult: An adult helps you find the temperature for a city in the southern hemisphere. Do: Make a table with three columns: Date, Our city (highest temperature), A southern city such as Buenos Aires or Sydney (highest temperature). Fill in one row each day for a week. Then circle the warmer city on each day. What to expect: In November to February, the southern city is usually warmer in the daytime than a city in north India. In May to August, it is the other way round. Cloudy or indoors: Use one week of old newspapers, or ask a relative in another country to tell you how hot or cold it is. Limits: one week of temperatures is not the same as a whole season, and some places near the equator are warm all year.
Next time: If distance is not the reason, what is? Beautine’s spinning top is about to give the friends a clue.
← Chapter 3: Calendars in the Sky · Book 4 contents · Chapter 5: The Tilted Top →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 4: Memoon and the Mystery of the Changing Moon, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment