Memunic Space Explorers › Book 5: Memoon and the Rocket Riddle › Chapter 7: Is Space Noisy?
Chapter 7: Is Space Noisy?
Learning goal. Explain that sound is a vibration that needs a medium such as air, water or a solid, that space is nearly empty so sound cannot cross it, and that radio waves carry messages through space instead.
Thursday evening started with thunder.
A late storm was rolling in from the south, with clouds as dark as Kachui's shell. The Club had moved under the shelter by the tank, with the mat and a plate of banana chips from Memoon's mother. Every few minutes a flash lit the whole terrace, and every few seconds after that, a deep rumble followed.
"Flash," said Kachui, pressing his timer. "Rumble. Six seconds."
"Count it again," said Memoon.
Another flash. Kachui pressed. The rumble came. "Five seconds."
"Why does the thunder come after the flash?" asked Nimo, bobbing in his bubble. He was very pleased to be the one to ask.
"Because light travels faster than sound," said Memoon. "Light is so fast we see the flash almost instantly. Sound is much slower, so it arrives a few seconds later. Sound takes about three seconds to travel one kilometre. The lightning must be about two kilometres away."
"Five divided by three is a bit under two," said Kachui, writing it down.
Noodles was lying on his back looking at the sky. "I have been thinking about what Nimo said. About the Moon and the boom."
"What did I say?" asked Nimo.
"You said it was your question. Well, I will explain it myself. The rocket goes whoosh, the engine goes boom, the Moon goes ba-boom. Everybody hears it. That is what I have seen in films."
Thunder over the terrace: Kachui times the gap between flash and rumble.
"Let us test your prediction," said Memoon, rather cheerfully. "But it should be a fair one. What is sound made of?"
"Noise?" said Noodles.
"Vibrations," said Nimo. He had thought about this a lot. "When I flick my tail, I push the water, and the water pushes the water next to it, and the push travels along. Sound travels faster in water than in air. About four times faster."
"About 1,500 metres every second in water," said Kachui, "against about 340 in air. And faster still in steel, about 5,000."
"That makes sense to me," said Nimo happily. "Sound moves faster when the stuff is packed more tightly. And space is so big and so wide that it must be the fastest sea of all. A sound there would zoom across the whole sky."
"Hold on," said Memoon, gently. "What is the stuff in space?"
Nimo opened his mouth. His bubble wobbled. "Oh."
"Space between planets and stars is almost empty," said Memoon. "There is very little air, or water, or anything else to pass the push along. If sound is a push that travels from one bit of stuff to the next, then where there is almost no stuff..."
"...it has nothing to travel through," finished Nimo. He sank to the bottom of his bubble with a gloomy bloop. "I did it again. I thought what is true in my pond is true everywhere."
"Water is a good example, but not the only rule," said Memoon. "It is brave to say that out loud."
"Let us test it," said Beautine, bouncing up. "We have no way of making a space. But we can try different stuff!"
"A good plan," said Memoon. "Predictions first. I will tap the table with a spoon. We listen in three ways: standing in the air, with an ear on the table, and through a string telephone."
Kachui had made two paper cups with a long string between them. Beautine pulled the string tight.
Noodles guessed first. "All the same."
They did it carefully, three times each, and Kachui wrote down what they heard in a table.
Where we listened How loud (1 to 5)
Through the air, standing 2
Ear on the table 4
String telephone 5
"Louder through the solid things," said Kachui. "Table, then string."
"So sound travels through air, and through a table, and along a string," said Memoon. "It needs something to travel through. Scientists call that a medium."
Noodles was frowning. "But what if there is just a little bit of stuff, out in space?"
"There are a few atoms," said Memoon. "But they are so far apart that sound cannot pass from one to the next. It is like trying to pass a message along a line of people who stand a kilometre apart."
Sound needs stuff to travel through
Air Water Space
Sound passes along Sound passes along (faster) No sound passes
Simplified. The dots stand for tiny particles, drawn far bigger and far fewer than real ones. Space is not perfectly empty, but its particles are too far apart to pass sound on.
Diagram. Sound needs stuff to travel through. Simplified: the particles are drawn bigger and fewer than real ones.
"Imagine Mode," said Nimo, brightening. "I can show you."
The bubble shone silver. "Imaginary," Nimo announced. In the middle of the terrace, a glass bell appeared on a table, with a little bell inside it. "This is a bell in a glass jar. If I ring it, you hear it. Now imagine that we take all the air out of the jar."
The little bell kept ringing. They could see it jump. But the sound faded, fainter and fainter, until the bell was shaking silently.
"Real scientists do this with special pumps," said Memoon. "It is a job for a laboratory with a teacher, not for us at home. Imagine Mode off, please."
Nimo's bubble went clear.
"So no BOOM on the Moon," said Noodles unhappily. "I have been fooled by films."
"Films add sound so that we enjoy them," said Beautine. "I have been fooled by them too. It is a scandal."
"What about Chiku?" asked Kachui. "How would a mouse on the Moon talk to us?"
"Radio," said Memoon. "Radio waves are not sound. They are more like light. They can travel through empty space, so spacewalking astronauts talk to each other and to Earth by radio, not by shouting. It is also how Rover Nine's real cousins got their messages back from the Moon."
"Inside the Space Station there is air," said Kachui, "so people can talk normally there."
"And on Mars," said Memoon, "the air is very thin, but a little is there. NASA's Perseverance rover carries microphones and has recorded the wind and its own wheels. Scientists found sound travels slower there, about 240 metres a second."
"A rocket would sound very different if we stood next to it," said Simbha thoughtfully, sitting behind the tank. "Outside, in air, it is incredibly loud. People wear ear protection."
"But on the Moon, with no air at all, the engines would be silent," said Memoon. "The astronauts inside their ship would hear it only through the ship's shell and their boots."
"I think I finally understand Noodles's plan," said Beautine. She stood on her hind legs on the stash bag. "He wanted a mouse to go up with a throw. A mouse who would hear a BOOM. And he is wrong about all of it."
"Not all of it," said Noodles quietly. "I was right that the Moon is up."
"You were," said Memoon, "and that was where you started. Now I think you have learned how to finish."
The thunder rolled again, farther away. Kachui pressed his timer. "Nine seconds. The storm is leaving."
Chiku popped up from behind the tank. "Does this mean I do not go to the Moon?"
"It means something better," said Memoon, her eyes shining. "It means we plan a mission properly. Tomorrow is Mission Design Day."
Science Corner Sound is a vibration that travels from one bit of matter to the next. It needs a medium: air, water or a solid. Sound moves at about 340 metres per second in air, about 1,500 in water and about 5,000 in steel (rounded, for normal conditions). It is slower than light, which is why thunder comes after lightning: about three seconds for each kilometre. Space between planets is almost empty, so ordinary sound cannot travel across it. Inside a spacecraft or a spacesuit there is air, so people can speak and hear there. Radio waves are not sound. Like light, they can travel through empty space, so astronauts and robots send messages by radio. On Mars the air is very thin, but the Perseverance rover's microphones have recorded sounds. Scientists measured sound travelling at about 240 metres per second there.
Medium Speed of sound (about)
Air (normal room) 340 m/s
Water 1,500 m/s
Steel 5,000 m/s
Empty space no sound travels
Story note: The bell jar in Imagine Mode was imaginary, and real labs use special pumps with trained teachers. Nimo's water idea is a good model for how sound travels in liquids but fails for space, where there is hardly any matter. The diagram simplifies matter into a few dots, drawn far bigger and fewer than real atoms. The pass-the-message line of people is also an analogy. The table of loudness is a simple classroom ranking, not a measurement.
Space Detective 1. Why does thunder arrive after lightning? Use the numbers in the chapter to estimate how far away a flash is if the thunder takes six seconds. 2. Nimo thought sound would move fastest in space. What rule did he wrongly carry over from water, and what does Memoon's reasoning show? 3. Draw three boxes labelled "air", "water" and "space". Use dots to show how close the particles are in each, and mark where sound can and cannot travel.
Try It: Sound Needs Stuff Time: 20 minutes. Needs: a spoon, a table, two paper cups, 3 metres of string, a pencil and paper. An adult should check the string is tied firmly and that nobody puts the cups near anyone else's ear while shouting.
Predict which route makes a spoon tap sound loudest: through the air, with your ear on the table, or through a string telephone. Tap the same way every time and listen three times for each route. Rate each from 1 to 5 and record it in a table.
What to expect: The sound is usually loudest through the solid table and the tight string, and quietest through the air. Cloudy or low-resource day: Hold the middle of a long string with a metal spoon hanging from it, press the ends against your ears with your fingers, and gently tap the spoon against a table edge. Limitation: this shows that solids carry sound well, but it cannot show the absence of sound in a vacuum.
Next time We know what a Moon trip needs. Can the Sky Club pull it all together into a real mission plan?
← Chapter 6: Robots Go First · Book 5 contents · Chapter 8: Mission Design Day →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 5: Memoon and the Rocket Riddle, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment