Memunic Space Explorers › Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars › Chapter 8: Galaxies Everywhere
Chapter 8: Galaxies Everywhere
In this chapter: Explain how astronomers showed that other galaxies exist and are far outside the Milky Way, and estimate the number of galaxies by counting a small patch of sky and scaling up.
On Sunday morning the Club did something unusual for astronomers. It looked at the sky in daylight, which is to say it did not look at the sky at all.
Beautine had spread a huge printed picture across the blue mat, weighed down at the corners with Mr Rao’s tomato pots, and she was crawling across it with a magnifying glass, muttering numbers. Kachui was sitting beside the picture with a pencil and a mug of tea. The picture was black. Or rather, it looked black, until you looked closely, and then it was crowded with thousands of tiny fuzzy smudges, in every colour and shape.
Counting galaxies in a deep-field picture.
“One hundred and forty,” said Beautine, “one hundred and forty-one. One hundred and forty-two. They are everywhere. I am not even a quarter of the way across.”
“It is called the Hubble Deep Field,” said Memoon, kneeling beside her. “In December 1995 the Hubble Space Telescope pointed at a patch of sky that looked completely empty. No bright stars, nothing special. It stared at it for about ten days, collecting faint light. This is what appeared.”
Simbha, who had arrived with a flask of lemon water, stood and stared. “These are not stars?”
“A few are,” said Memoon, “the ones with little spikes. Most of these smudges are galaxies. Each one is a vast collection of stars, like our own Milky Way.”
Beautine sat back on her tail. “Each one is an entire galaxy,” she said, very slowly. “And I am counting them with a magnifying glass.”
“Last night we asked a question,” said Memoon. “Is the Milky Way all there is? And a hundred years ago, astronomers asked the same thing.” She held up a small printed photograph of a hazy oval patch in the sky. “This is Andromeda. You can see it faintly with your eyes on a dark night, like a tiny smudge of light. Astronomers used to call it the Andromeda Nebula. Was it a cloud inside our galaxy, like the Orion Nebula? Or was it another galaxy altogether, much farther away?”
“How would you tell?” asked Nimo. “It is just a smudge.”
“You need its distance,” said Memoon. “And we have already learned that distance is tricky. Remember parallax? It works well for nearby stars but not for something this far. We need another trick.”
“A variable star,” said Kachui, suddenly alert. “The star that changes brightness. Like Betelgeuse.”
“Exactly like Betelgeuse in that way, though a different kind of star,” said Memoon. “There are stars called Cepheids that brighten and fade like a clock, over days or weeks. In the early 1900s, a woman called Henrietta Leavitt was studying photographs of Cepheids in a small galaxy near ours. She noticed something remarkable.”
Kachui’s whole shell seemed to straighten. He loved Henrietta Leavitt. “She spent years comparing thousands of photographic plates,” he said. “Every star, one by one.”
“And she found a rule,” said Memoon. “The longer a Cepheid takes to pulse, the more light it truly gives out. A Cepheid that takes ten days is brighter than one that takes three. So if you time a Cepheid, you know how much light it really gives out. Then you only need to
measure how bright it looks. Remember Simbha’s two photographs? Brightness depends on both how much light a star gives out and how far away it is. If you know the first, the second tells you the distance.”
longer period, greater true light output
true light output brightness
one period
time (days) period (days)
1 Measure the period
2 Read the true light output
3 Compare with how bright it looks: the dimmer it looks, the farther away it is Schematic, not data.
A Cepheid’s pulse gives away its true brightness. Schematic, not data.
“A streetlamp,” said Noodles, who had arrived with a bag of biscuits and was now eating one over the Hubble picture. “If you know it is a hundred-watt lamp and it looks very dim, it must be far away.”
“Noodles,” said Memoon, with real respect, “that is exactly it.”
Noodles looked around to see if anyone had noticed. Nobody had, so he told them.
“In the 1920s,” Memoon continued, “an astronomer called Edwin Hubble found Cepheids in the Andromeda smudge. He timed their pulses, worked out their true brightness, and compared that with how faint they looked. The answer was not just far. It was much too far to be inside our own galaxy. Andromeda is a separate galaxy. His first number was too small, and later astronomers corrected it. We now think it is about two and a half million light-years away.”
“Two and a half million years of light,” said Kachui softly. “Meaning that the light you see when you look at Andromeda left it two and a half million years ago.”
“When our oldest ancestors were making their very first stone tools,” said Memoon.
Nimo’s bubble turned slowly, golden fins fanning out. “There is an old phrase for this,” he said. “Island universes. A galaxy like an island in a very wide ocean. I like it. It means we are on an island, and there are other islands.”
“I like it too,” said Memoon. “Just remember that space between galaxies is not water. It is almost empty, and the islands are held in place only by gravity.”
Beautine had finished a rough count of one corner of the Hubble picture and was looking at her fingers. “I have a headline,” she said gravely. “There are TRILLIONS of galaxies and every one has a trillion stars.”
“Source?” said Kachui.
“I made it up,” admitted Beautine. “But it feels right.”
“It may be close for some,” said Memoon. “But feeling right is not the same as being checked. Let us work it out. Beautine, how many galaxies are in this picture?”
“About three thousand,” said Beautine, “if I do not miscount.”
“This picture covers about one twenty-four-millionth of the whole sky. That is a tiny, tiny patch, like a tennis ball seen from a hundred metres away. It was chosen to look unremarkable, with no nearby stars. If the whole sky looks about the same, how many galaxies would be in the whole sky?”
Kachui multiplied. “Three thousand times twenty-four million. Seventy-two billion.”
“Seventy-two billion galaxies,” said Simbha. “from a patch of sky the size of a tennis ball at a hundred metres.”
“And it is probably an undercount,” said Memoon. “This picture only shows galaxies that were bright enough for Hubble to see. Later telescopes, such as the James Webb Space Telescope, have found many more, fainter and farther. Astronomers’ current estimates for the observable Universe range from a couple of hundred billion to about two trillion galaxies. Nobody has counted them all.”
“So ’trillions’ was possible,” said Beautine.
“Possible at the top end of a range, and you did not know that,” said Kachui, kindly. “A range is something you write down with its edges.”
“What about the other galaxies, though?” said Simbha. “Are they all like ours?”
“Many are spiral galaxies like the Milky Way and Andromeda,” said Memoon, tapping the picture. “Some are smooth, egg-shaped balls of old stars, called ellipticals. And some have no neat shape at all, and are called irregular. Some are close and big and some are tiny and so far away that their light started travelling billions of years ago. In a deep field like this, you are looking back in time.”
Beautine pounced. “Andromeda!” she said. “Andromeda is coming TOWARD us! It will crash into the Milky Way in four billion years! Headline!”
“It used to be the standard prediction,” said Kachui, adjusting his scarf. “And a good example of how science changes. In 2025, astronomers redid the sums with better measurements of how the nearby galaxies move. Their new result says there is only about a fifty-fifty chance that Andromeda and the Milky Way merge in the next ten billion years. Also, even if they do merge, the stars are so far apart that they will mostly slide past each other.”
Beautine put her paws over her face. “My headline has been corrected.”
“It is a very good headline,” said Memoon. “It just needs a new date, and a coin.”
Nimo had been quiet. Now he spoke, in the careful voice of a fish about to ask something enormous. “If there are billions of galaxies, and each has billions of stars, and each star has a life story like Betelgeuse’s... then somewhere, right now, stars are being born and stars are dying, all the time.”
“Yes,” said Memoon. “Many times every second, somewhere in the Universe, a star is being born, and many times a second one is ending.”
Simbha looked up at the blue morning sky, where no stars showed at all. “And one of them is mine,” he said, “orange, and not yet finished. I think the Club knows enough to give me an answer.”
Science Corner Galaxies come in three main shapes: spiral (like the Milky Way), elliptical (smooth and egg-shaped) and irregular. The Andromeda Galaxy is the nearest large galaxy, about 2.5 million light-years away. It can be seen with the eyes alone from a dark sky, as a faint smudge. Cepheid variable stars pulse like a clock, and the longer the pulse, the more light the star gives out (Henrietta Leavitt, early 1900s). Comparing that true brightness with how bright the star looks gives its distance. In the 1920s, Edwin Hubble used Cepheids to show that Andromeda lies far outside the Milky Way. A deep field is a very long exposure of a patch of sky that looks empty. The Hubble Deep Field (1995) shows about three thousand galaxies. Counting a small patch and scaling up gives an estimate for the whole sky; current estimates for the observable Universe range from about 200 billion to about two trillion galaxies. Looking far is looking back in time: the light of a galaxy 2.5 million light-years away left it 2.5 million years ago, and the light of the most distant galaxies has travelled for billions of years. Story note: Counting a small patch and multiplying works only if the patch is typical, and Hubble’s patch was chosen to be unremarkable. The result is a rough lower estimate because faint galaxies are missed. Hubble’s first distance to Andromeda was too small and was corrected later. “Island universes” is an old phrase and an analogy; galaxies are not floating in water. The 2025 study found about a 50% chance of a Milky Way and Andromeda merger within 10 billion years, and only about a 2% chance of an earlier head-on collision in 4 to 5 billion years. The Club and its printed picture are story elements.
Space Detective 1. Explain how a Cepheid variable star lets astronomers find a distance, using the idea from Chapter 1 that brightness depends on both light output and distance. 2. A deep-field picture covers about one twenty-four-millionth of the sky and shows 3,000 galaxies. Estimate how many galaxies are in the whole sky, and explain two reasons the true number may be larger than your estimate. 3. Explain, in a few sentences, why looking at the Andromeda Galaxy is looking at the past.
Try it: Deep-Field Count Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult should help find a suitable image and print it. You need: a printed copy of a deep-field image (from a space agency or observatory website), a ruler, a pencil and a calculator. Do: Draw a grid of 4 columns and 4 rows over the picture (16 squares). Choose three squares at random and count the galaxies in each, ignoring bright stars with spikes. Find the average count per square, then multiply by 16 to estimate the total. Repeat with three different squares and compare your two estimates. What to expect: The squares will not all have the same number, and your two estimates will differ by some amount. That difference shows how much a small sample can vary. Cloudy or low-resource day: This works indoors with a printed picture or on a screen. Limitation: faint galaxies are hard to see, some overlap, and nobody can be certain what each smudge is, so counts are estimates.
Next time: The Club has a star that faded, a life story for stars, a place in a galaxy and a Universe full of galaxies. It is time to give Simbha his answer.
← Chapter 7: Our Galaxy · Book 8 contents · Chapter 9: Simbha’s Verdict →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment