Memunic Space Explorers › Book 9: Memoon and the Clockwork Sky › Chapter 3: Reading the Dance
Chapter 3: Reading the Dance
In this chapter: turn a table of nightly positions into a graph, read a period and an amplitude from it, and see why too few readings can give a wrong pattern.
The rooftop smelled of cold concrete and Kachui’s flask of ginger tea. It was the fourth night of the Clockwork Log, and Noodles had a plan.
“I do not need nine nights,” he announced, tapping the notebook. “I have the pattern already. Io, the little inner moon, was on the right of Jupiter on Night 1, on the left on Night 2 and on the right again on Night 3. So it goes right, left, right, left. Tonight it will be on the left. Tomorrow, right. I predict it, and then I take a nap.”
“Write it down,” said Kachui, and Noodles did, with an elaborate signature.
The club had a routine by now. At half past eight every evening, Memoon set up the telescope, Kachui checked the time against the clock on his phone, and they measured each moon’s distance from the middle of Jupiter. Kachui had made the measuring scale himself from a strip of clear plastic marked in steps. One step was one Jupiter radius, half of the planet’s width, because it was a unit that went wherever Jupiter went. The names came with them. East of Jupiter was a plus and west was a minus.
The table in the notebook now looked like a small timetable. Ganymede, the largest moon, had been out at fifteen steps on the east side on Night 3 and was already swinging back towards Jupiter. Callisto, the outermost, moved so slowly that its position barely changed from night to night. Europa and Io were harder. Io hid in the glare close to Jupiter, and some nights Memoon needed her darkest hood to find it.
“Tonight, Io on the left,” said Noodles, and went back to his sleeping bag.
It was on the left. He sat bolt upright. “I was right. The pattern holds. Beautine, put it in the minutes.”
“I do not have a minutes book,” said Beautine, “but I do have a very loud voice, and I will remember.”
“Tomorrow, right,” said Noodles.
On Night 5, it was on the left again.
Noodles stared at the notebook for a long time. “It cheated.”
“It did not cheat,” said Kachui. “Your pattern was wrong.”
The club gathered round the page. Memoon read out Io’s position on each night in order: plus six, minus five, plus three, minus one, and minus one-and-a-bit. Beautine drew a line through the dots. It zigzagged, and then stopped zigzagging.
“A swing that jumps from side to side and then forgets to,” said Simbha. “That would be a swing of a very odd kind.”
“Or we are not watching it often enough,” said Memoon, slowly.
She went to the telescope. It was still early. She looked at Io, a tiny dot just west of Jupiter, and noted its distance. Then, instead of leaving it for twenty-four hours, she went down to help her mother wash up. An hour later she checked again. The dot had slid further west. An hour after that, further still.
“Kachui,” she called. “Io is moving, and quickly. Two hours ago it was one step west of Jupiter. Now it is three.”
“Nearly a step an hour,” said Kachui, “and you only saw that because you looked between our usual times.”
“Exactly,” said Memoon. “If Io makes a whole lap in about two days, then between two visits it goes round once and then most of another lap. We never see the lap. We only see where it ends up. That looks like jumping from side to side, and nobody can tell which way it is really going.”
Why reading Io once a night can mislead One reading each night (orange): it seems to jump from side to side
+6 readings too far apart
−6
A reading every 3 hours (blue): the smooth swing appears
+6
−6
Time: day 0 to day 4.5
Io's true period is about 1.77 days. Positions in Jupiter radii (east +); path simplified to a circle seen edge on.
One reading a night hides the real motion of Io. The blue dots show readings every three hours.
“Like the wheels in old films,” said Noodles, brightening. “The ones that look as if they are spinning the wrong way.”
“Like that,” said Memoon. “It is a camera taking one picture each time, and the wheel has gone nearly all the way round between pictures. We are the camera. Once a day is too slow for Io.”
Beautine put a paw to her forehead. “So the clockwork is real, but we have been looking at it in the wrong way.”
“We have been looking too rarely,” said Kachui. “Which is not the same thing, and it has a name: how often you take a reading is the sampling interval. If something moves fast, the interval must be short, or you will see a pattern that is not real.”
That night the club changed its plan. For Io they would take three readings: at half past eight, half past nine and half past ten. For Europa, two. For Ganymede and Callisto, which moved more slowly, one a night was plenty. It was a more tiring way to observe, but the plan made
sense.
Noodles was given the job of sitting by the telescope with a clock and a torch with a red cover. “Why red?” he asked.
“A red light keeps your eyes ready for the dark,” said Memoon. “A white torch makes the sky disappear for a few minutes.”
The next four nights were clear. By Night 9, the table had grown to a block of numbers. Kachui drew a graph on squared paper from the Ganymede column: night number along the bottom, position in steps up the side. Memoon watched the dots go in. They began near zero, curved up to a peak near fifteen steps, curved down through zero again, went to a trough near fourteen steps on the other side, and began to climb.
“A wave,” said Beautine. “It looks like a wave.”
“It looks like a swing seen from the side,” said Memoon. “Of course it does. We are looking at a circle edge on, so a steady circular trip becomes a smooth wave. A graph of a moon’s sideways distance against time is how the shape of a circle looks from the side.”
Kachui laid a flexible plastic ruler over the dots and bent it into a smooth curve through the middle of them. “We draw a line that follows the dots as well as it can. Not through every point. Dots always sit a little off the true curve, because we are people and not machines.”
“What can we read from it?” asked Simbha.
Kachui tapped two places. “First, how far out the moon swings. We call that the amplitude. For Ganymede it is about fifteen steps, give or take one. Second, how long it takes to get back to the same place moving the same way. We call that the period. Look. The curve crosses the middle going east just before Night 1. And it crosses the middle going east again between Night 8 and Night 9. That is a gap of just over seven days.”
He wrote: Period of Ganymede: about 7.2 days, plus or minus 0.3. Amplitude: about 15 steps, plus or minus 1.
Ganymede: position against night (Jupiter radii, east +)
amplitude ≈ 15 Position
-5
-10
-15 period ≈ 7.2 days 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Night number Story data, rounded. Orange dots show readings with ±1 error bars; the blue curve is the line of best fit.
Ganymede’s log with error bars and a line of best fit. Story data, rounded.
“Seven point two,” said Beautine, thrilled. “Can I predict where Ganymede will be?”
“On Night 15,” said Memoon, “we should see the same thing as Night 8. If the period is seven days or so.”
“That is a risky prediction,” said Noodles.
“That is a good one,” said Kachui.
For Io, Memoon measured the sideways speed at the moment it crossed the middle, when a moon moves fastest across the line of sight. She watched its position over three hours and found it changed by about two and a half steps. “About 0.9 of a step each hour,” she said. “Io’s swing is about six steps wide. If a circle has a radius of six and the moon travels at about 0.9 steps an hour, then a full lap, which is two times pi times six, is about thirty-eight steps.”
“Thirty-eight steps at 0.9 an hour,” said Kachui, tapping on his phone. “About forty-two hours.”
“One and three-quarter days,” said Memoon. “I think that is Io’s period. About 1.7 days, with an error of about 0.2.”
Nimo bubbled up from the parapet. “Astronomers measure Io’s period as about 1.77 days. You are within your own uncertainty.”
“That is a rather satisfying sentence,” said Beautine, who had been waiting for the clockwork to produce something dramatic and now found it did.
“But the point,” said Memoon, “is not that we got Io right. It is that we nearly got it wrong. If we had kept sampling once a night, we would have invented a pattern that was not there. A good measurement needs a good plan.”
Noodles raised a paw. “And a good nap?”
“Later,” said Simbha. “First I would like to know what is making the moons swing at all. Why do they stay with Jupiter? Why do they go round? What is pulling them?”
“A force,” said Kachui. “But what does a force actually do to a moving thing? That is a question for tomorrow.”
Science Corner A graph of a moon’s position against time, seen edge on, is a smooth wave. The amplitude is the greatest distance from the middle; the period is the time for one complete repeat. The sampling interval is the time between readings. If it is too long compared with the period, the data can show a false pattern, a problem often called aliasing. Ganymede’s period is about 7.2 days; Io’s is about 1.77 days. The club found values within their own uncertainty. A line of best fit is a smooth line or curve drawn to follow the general trend of the points, not through every one. For a circle of radius r, the distance round once is 2πr. Dividing it by the speed gives the period. Story note: the club treats Io’s path as a circle seen edge on, and measures its speed only at the middle of the swing, where the sideways motion is closest to its real speed. Real moon orbits are slightly elliptical and tilted, and the telescope scale in the story is invented. Where this idea stops working: a wave graph shows the side-to-side view only, not the moon’s motion towards and away from us.
Space Detective 1. A moon is seen once a night, on opposite sides of a planet on consecutive nights. Explain two different motions that could produce those observations. 2. Ganymede’s amplitude is 15 steps and its period is 7.2 days. Use these to describe where you expect it to be 3.6 days after it crosses the middle going east. 3. Sketch a graph of position against time for a moon with a period of 4 days over 12 days, with the amplitude marked.
Try it: A Swing Seen From the Side Time: 20 minutes.
Adult: An adult should be nearby and the ball should be soft and light. You need: a small ball tied to a string, a bright wall, a stopwatch, squared paper, a pencil.
Do: Swing the ball in a circle slowly at arm’s length at about waist height, away from people. Ask a friend to stand at the side and note its left–right position every second for 10 seconds. Plot position against time.
What to expect: a wave shape whose period matches the time for one lap.
Cloudy or low-resource day: use a drawing of a clock face and mark the position of the tip of the minute hand along the horizontal line through its centre, at 5-minute steps.
Limitation: the hand’s tip moves in a circle by design, not because of a force like gravity.
Next time: Jupiter’s moons keep circling. What does it take to make anything move, stop or change direction?
← Chapter 2: Galileo’s Four Little Stars · Book 9 contents · Chapter 4: A Push, a Mass and a Number →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 9: Memoon and the Clockwork Sky, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment