Skip to main content

Featured

Space Explorers Book 7: Answers and Explanations

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Answers and Explanations Answers and Explanations Habitable means life could live there; inhabited means life does live there. A world can be habitable and empty, as an unoccupied flat has a roof and water but nobody in it. The Moon has almost no air, so water would boil or freeze, and its gravity is only about one-sixth of Earth’s, too weak to keep air. Accept also: no greenhouse blanket, so it swings between very hot and very cold. Venus. It matches Earth in size and roughly in mass, but its thick carbon dioxide air traps heat, making it hot and crushing. “Twin” is only true for size and weight. A dip of 1 per cent means (planet width divided by star width) squared is 0.01, so the ratio is 0.1: the planet is about a tenth as wide as the star. Repeats at the same gap show the planet is going round the star in 12 days, and rule out a one-time event such as a passing object. A planet shines only by reflected l...

Space Explorers Book 11: Chapter 2 – Newton’s Cannon

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 2: Newton’s Cannon

Chapter 2: Newton’s Cannon

Illustration for Space Explorers Book 11: Chapter 2 – Newton’s Cannon

In this chapter: State Newton’s law of universal gravitation, use F = GMm/r squared and the inverse-square scaling in calculations, explain why G is tiny while gravity feels strong, and see how Newton tested the law against the Moon.

The next afternoon Noodles threw a tennis ball off the edge of the terrace, and then, since nobody had stopped him in time, another one.

“Stop,” said Memoon, “for science.”

“I am doing science,” said Noodles, holding a third ball behind his back. “I am testing the cannon. You said the first question on the list was about a cannon on a mountain, and I am a very practical cat.”

The Club had gathered on the terrace after school in the thin gold light of late afternoon, in a rough semicircle around the water tank. Mr Rao, on the roof of the neighbouring block, was pretending to hang out washing and watching with the focus of a man who is not watching. Memoon had spread a sheet of paper on the parapet and drawn a big arc for the Earth and a little peak for the mountain, and she had put a cannon on the peak with a pencilled flame.

“Newton’s cannon,” she said. “Isaac Newton, 1687, in a book called the Principia. It was a thought experiment, so nobody actually builds it. Suppose a mountain so high that its peak is above all the air. A cannon at the top fires a ball sideways. Without air there is nothing to slow it down. What happens?”

“It falls,” said Beautine, “in a curve. And lands. Bang.”

“Fire it harder.”

“It lands farther away.”

“Harder.”

“Farther. Even farther.” Beautine’s tail had begun to twitch. “And at some point the Earth is round, and the ground is curving away, and it is dropping and dropping and the ground is dropping away too, and it never actually gets there.”

“That,” said Memoon, drawing a long closed curve that circled the whole Earth and came back to the cannon, “is the idea. Orbit is just a very fast throw. Nothing different happens at the top. Gravity pulls the ball down the whole time, and the ball always falls toward the Earth, and the ground always falls away just as fast.”

Simbha tilted his head. “How fast?”

“About eight kilometres every second at the surface of the Earth,” said Kachui, who was in the habit of having the number ready. “That is about eighty-four minutes for one lap, if there were no air. I looked it up last night. We will derive it properly in Chapter 4. For now we want to understand the pull.”

“Which Newton understood how?” asked Noodles, hopefully.

Kachui laid his flipper on the sheet. “By noticing that an apple and the Moon might be the same story. The story is probably a little too neat: Newton himself told it later, in old age, and the real thinking took many years. But the question was real. If the pull that drops an apple reaches all the way up to the Moon, then the Moon is falling too. It is falling around the Earth. And if so, there is a single rule.”

“A rule for apples and moons,” said Memoon, and wrote it down. “Any two masses attract each other. The pull is proportional to each mass, and it gets weaker as the distance squares.” She wrote the formula big enough for the whole terrace to read.

F = G M m / r squared

“F is the force on each, in newtons,” she said. “M and m are the two masses, in kilograms. r is the distance between their centres, in metres. And G is a number that makes the units come out right, the same everywhere in the universe, as far as anyone has found: six point six seven four times ten to the minus eleven, in newton-metres squared per kilogram squared.”

“That is a very small number,” said Beautine, who had counted the zeros on her paws. “Ten to the minus eleven. That is, what, a decimal point and ten zeros and then a six?”

“Correct. Which makes me wonder something, Memoon.” Kachui turned slowly. “If G is that tiny, why does gravity feel strong?”

Memoon opened her mouth and then, with some effort, shut it again. She had begun to say because gravity is strong, and it was the kind of sentence that would have sounded fine in a classroom and been wrong. “Because it is not G that is big,” she said slowly. “It is Earth. The pull on a one kilogram mass at the surface is G times Earth’s mass, which is six times ten to the twenty-four kilograms, over the square of Earth’s radius. A tiny number multiplied by an astonishing one.”

“Do the sum,” said Kachui.

She did it on the page, line by line, the way she had learned to do it in Book 9, with units in every line:

F = (6.674 × 10−11) × (5.972 × 1024) × 1 / (6.371 × 106)2 = 9.82 N.

“That is the weight of one kilogram,” she said. “It is what a bathroom scale reads as one kilogram of force. It is the g I use every week, nine point eight newtons for each kilogram, so g is nine point eight metres per second squared.” She looked up with some pride. “I have just got g out of G.”

Newton's cannon (Imagine Mode: imaginary)

Each path starts at the top of the mountain, moving sideways. The faster the shot, the farther it goes before it meets the ground.

C just right: a circle

A slow: lands close

B faster: lands farther

D faster still: an ellipse

Not to scale: the mountain is far taller than any real one, and the air is ignored.

Newton’s cannon. Imagine Mode: the mountain is imaginary and drawn far too tall, and air is ignored.

“And two ordinary people standing a metre apart?” asked Beautine. “Do they attract each other?”

“Of course. Two one-kilogram masses a metre apart pull on each other with a force of G, which is six point seven times ten to the minus eleven newtons. About a hundred-billionth of the weight of a grain of sand.”

“So gravity between me and a biscuit is not what is stopping me eating it,” said Beautine.

“The biscuit’s mass is far too small, and so is yours,” said Simbha. “Gravity only becomes obvious when one of the two bodies is as big as a planet.”

Noodles had been silent for a while, which was alarming. Now he raised a paw. “I have a theory. If the force is proportional to the mass of the thing, then a heavy ball is pulled harder than a light one. So it should fall faster. Heavy things fall faster. Aristotle said so. Probably.”

“He did say so,” said Memoon, “and the idea sounds as reasonable as anything. But look at the formula. The force on the ball is proportional to its mass m. So is its resistance to being accelerated, which is what mass means in Newton’s second law. F equals m a. When you put them together, the m on each side cancels.”

She wrote it as a short line, so everybody could see the cancellation:

m a = G M m / r squared, so a = G M / r squared.

“The acceleration does not depend on the ball at all. A heavy ball is pulled harder and is harder to move, and those cancel exactly. That is why Galileo’s balls hit the ground together.” She drew a firm line under it. “Remember Book 9, where we found that the acceleration of a freely falling object did not depend on mass? That is the reason.”

“Then I have discovered nothing,” said Noodles, “and I am pleased to have discovered it.”

“You discovered a good test,” said Kachui. “Drop a heavy one and a light one from the same height, in a vacuum, and see. People have done it, on the Moon, with a hammer and a feather. They landed together.”

Nimo’s bubble rose over the tank. “May I show the cannon?” he said. “I would prefer to see it with my own eyes before it is a fact.”

“Go on,” said Memoon. “But label it.”

Nimo blinked, and the air above his bubble shimmered. Imagine Mode on. What follows is imaginary.

They stood on a mountain, but it was a mountain with no snow and no wind, and its peak rose above a thin blue curve of air that lay like a skin on the planet below them. A cannon of old brass sat on the summit, absurdly large, with a fuse that nobody had lit. Noodles, who could not help himself, had lit it.

The first shot went out horizontally and curved away and hit a plain a mile below. The second went further. The third crossed an ocean. The fourth, much faster, rushed away beyond the curve of the Earth, and Memoon’s stomach lurched as she saw the ground fall away from the ball in just the way the ball fell from the line of its flight. The fifth shot left the cannon and did not come down. Instead a small dark point travelled around the whole blue planet, tracing out a steady circle, and came back, ninety minutes later, to pass over the mountain top where they stood, so that Noodles was forced to duck.

Imagine Mode off. We are back on the real terrace.

“Ow,” said Noodles, from the floor. “It came back.”

“It was always going to come back,” said Memoon. “A ball fired fast enough returns to where it started, or goes round forever. The cannon is a model. In real life no mountain is high enough, and there is always some air, so a real satellite is launched by a rocket, which pushes it up and sideways above the air. But the idea is the same: a satellite is a cannonball that never lands.”

Kachui leaned over the diagram. “There is still a loose end,” he said. “The formula says the force goes as one over r squared. How did Newton know it was squared? Not cubed, not just r?”

Memoon nodded. This was the question she had been waiting for someone else to ask. “He tested it on the Moon,” she said. “The Moon is about sixty times farther from the centre of the Earth than we are. If the force goes as the inverse square, the Moon’s acceleration should be nine point eight divided by sixty squared.”

“Three thousand six hundred,” said Beautine, instantly.

“Three thousand six hundred and forty, if we use sixty point three, which is the real ratio.” Memoon was writing. “So the Moon’s acceleration toward the Earth should be about zero point zero zero two seven metres per second squared. Now the other side. The Moon goes round in 27.3 days at a distance of three hundred and eighty-four thousand kilometres. Its speed is the circumference divided by the time, which is about one thousand and twenty-three metres per second. The acceleration of anything on a circle is v squared over r.” She worked the line out: 1023 squared divided by 3.844 × 108 = 0.00272.

“It matches,” said Simbha, very quietly.

“Within about one percent,” said Memoon, who had checked twice. “The Moon is falling toward the Earth by exactly the amount that a distant apple would fall, if the pull weakened as the square of the distance. Newton did that with the best numbers of his day, and it was close enough that he published.”

A short silence settled over the terrace. On the roof next door, Mr Rao had dropped his washing.

“One more thing,” said Kachui, breaking the silence in his gentle way. “The gravitational constant, G, was not measured by Newton. He wrote the law without being able to give its number. The number came out of an experiment by a man called Henry Cavendish, in 1798, with two lead balls on a delicate twisting rod, and it took him months, because the pull between the balls was so small that he had to build the room around the experiment and read the rod from outside, with a telescope, to stop his own breathing from disturbing it.” He paused. “What he reported was the density of the Earth, which is a way of weighing it, and modern versions of his experiment give us the number G. Chapter 6 shows another way to weigh the Earth.”

“Chapter 6,” said Beautine, writing it on the back of her paw.

Memoon looked down at the paper. “I have one more sum for us,” she said. “Then we are ready for the real question. How strong is gravity at the height of SkyClub-1?”

Science Corner Newton’s law of universal gravitation: any two masses attract each other with a force F = G M m / r squared, where r is the distance between their centres and G = 6.674 × 10−11 N m squared per kg squared. The force is proportional to each mass and falls as the inverse square of the distance: doubling the distance cuts the force to one quarter; tripling it cuts it to one ninth. Acceleration of free fall: the m on each side of F = m a cancels, so a = G M / r squared, which does not depend on the falling object. At Earth’s surface this gives g of about 9.82 m/s² (9.81 is the standard rounded value). Newton’s cannon is a thought experiment: a projectile fired fast enough from a high mountain falls toward Earth at the same rate as Earth’s surface curves away, so it goes into orbit. It is a model of the idea, not a real design. Maths track: the Moon test. g / (60.3 squared) is about 0.0027 m/s², and v squared / r for the Moon’s real orbit is about 0.0027 m/s². Concept track: a small constant times an enormous planet mass is why gravity is obvious near planets and invisible between everyday objects. Story note: The Newton’s cannon demonstration is imaginary; a real mountain cannot rise above the air, and a real satellite is launched by a rocket. The apple story is traditional and was told by Newton in later life, so it should be read as an illustration of an idea that took years. Cavendish’s 1798 experiment is described in simplified terms; he reported his result as the density of the Earth, and G was derived from it later. The Moon test is approximate; Newton’s own numbers were less precise. The calculation treats the Earth and Moon as point masses at their centres and ignores the Sun’s pull, which is an assumption. The value 9.82 differs slightly from the standard 9.81 because it comes from rounded constants and a mean radius.

Space Detective 1. A satellite is at a distance of 3 Earth radii from Earth’s centre. By what factor is the gravitational pull on it reduced compared with the pull at the surface? Show your reasoning. 2. Noodles thought a heavier ball should fall faster because the force on it is bigger. Use F = m a and F = G M m / r squared to show why this is wrong, and say what he is right about. 3. Draw Newton’s cannon with three paths: one that lands, one that is only just in orbit, and one that goes round the whole Earth. Mark the direction of gravity at one point on each.

Try it: Water-Jet Cannon

The water-jet cannon: a faster jet lands farther away

Time: 20 minutes. Adult: An adult should make the hole and supervise the pouring and the climb to a safe height. You need: a plastic bottle with a small hole near the bottom, water, a tray, ruler, a chair or low wall.

Do: Fill the bottle and let water squirt out sideways from a hole in the side, outdoors or over a sink. Measure how far it lands from the base. Raise the bottle by a fixed height (for example a chair) and measure again. Try pressing the sides of the bottle to speed up the jet. Plot distance against speed estimated from how hard you squeezed. What to expect: A faster jet lands farther away, and the stream always bends into a curve, never a straight line. This is Newton’s cannon in miniature: speed sets how far the curve reaches. Cloudy or low-resource day: Roll a marble off a table at different speeds with a ruler as a ramp and mark where it lands. Limitation: a marble on a table hits the floor within a metre, so you cannot reach orbital speed; the experiment shows that a faster throw goes farther, not what orbit speed is, and air resistance and spin slightly alter the result.

Next time: We know the rule. How strong is gravity at a satellite’s height, and what happens to the idea of weight when the pull comes from a whole planet?

← Chapter 1: The Design Brief · Book 11 contents · Chapter 3: The Strength of Gravity →

Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers

Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CA-7 Job Status and Failure Reason Codes

Here are the various status codes that You may see for jobs in the Queue or Logs in CA-7. R-C0002 R-C0003 R-C0099 R-C0255 R-JCLER A-U0002 A-U0004 A-U0015 A-U0043 A-U4095 A-SOC7 A-U4000 Reason Code/Job Status Code explanation: The indication of the job's current disposition. Values and their meanings are: A-Snnnn-- The job has failed with a system abend. A-Unnnn --The job has failed with a user abend. C-Cnnnn --The job has completed successfully and is going through completion processing. E-ARFATT-- An error occurred during the attempt to attach ARF definitions. This can result if the ARFSET specified is not defined. A diagnostic message may have been written to the CA-7 log, the OS console, or to the trailer queue for the job (in which case it can be displayed using LQ,JOB=x,LIST=ALL). E-ARFERR ---The job encountered an error in the ARF processing. Do a LARFQ command for the job to get more specific information. E-SEGERR --The job has been requeued...

Whistling Winds and Waterfalls: 4 Days of Magic in Shillong

Nestled in the clouds, where the scent of pine trees mingles with the rhythm of waterfalls and the tunes of local guitar-strumming youth—Shillong is more than a place. It’s a vibe. If you’ve got 3 nights and 4 days, you’ve got just enough time to fall in love. Here’s how to make the most of it—food, fun, fog and fantastic views included. Day 1: Shillong, We’re Coming for You! You land in Guwahati, barely out of the airport when the hills start calling. You hop into your cab, Spotify on, windows down, and the three-hour ride to Shillong begins. Just when you think it can’t get better, you stop at Umiam Lake —a lake so calm, it looks like someone ironed the water. By evening, you’re sipping hot chai in Laitumkhrah, maybe nibbling on spicy momos or pork jadoh from a roadside stall. You’re checked into your charming hotel ( Tripura Castle if you fancy old-world royalty, Ri Kynjai if you’re into lakeside poetry). The breeze whispers secrets of waterfalls and pine forests. Sleep well, drea...

Installing and Configuring Hadoop on Ubuntu as a Pseudo Distributed Single Node Cluster

Briefly what is psuedo-distributed single node Hadoop cluster: It is a Hadoop distributed cluster having Single Node. All the five daemons (NN,DN,JT,TT,SNN) are running as individual JVM (java process) instances. We will get all distributed features of Hadoop. This mode is used to develop, test, and staging (before production) Map Reduce programs quickly. It writes all the system, daemon and user logs to different files on the cluster To install Hadoop in this mode, we have to modify the hadoop-env.sh, core-site.xml, hdfs-site.xml, mapred-site.xml. hadoop-env.sh contains all the Environment variables which are required for running Hadoop. All the default values are fine, Only we have to modify the JAVA_HOME=“The location of Java Home Directory” Core-site.xml contains all the cluster specific information like io, temp directory, sorting, file system uri etc. Hdfs-site.xml contains all the parameters which are specific to HDFS like name node directory, data node directory...