Skip to main content

Featured

Space Explorers Book 7: Answers and Explanations

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Answers and Explanations Answers and Explanations Habitable means life could live there; inhabited means life does live there. A world can be habitable and empty, as an unoccupied flat has a roof and water but nobody in it. The Moon has almost no air, so water would boil or freeze, and its gravity is only about one-sixth of Earth’s, too weak to keep air. Accept also: no greenhouse blanket, so it swings between very hot and very cold. Venus. It matches Earth in size and roughly in mass, but its thick carbon dioxide air traps heat, making it hot and crushing. “Twin” is only true for size and weight. A dip of 1 per cent means (planet width divided by star width) squared is 0.01, so the ratio is 0.1: the planet is about a tenth as wide as the star. Repeats at the same gap show the planet is going round the star in 12 days, and rule out a one-time event such as a passing object. A planet shines only by reflected l...

Space Explorers Book 11: Chapter 6 – Weighing a World

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 6: Weighing a World

Chapter 6: Weighing a World

Illustration for Space Explorers Book 11: Chapter 6 – Weighing a World

In this chapter: Rearrange Kepler’s third law with gravity to get M = 4 π squared a cubed / (G T squared), use it to find the mass of Earth and of Jupiter from a moon’s orbit, and explain why the answer is the mass of the central body, not of the moon.

On Thursday the first thing Simbha did, before he said hello, was put a bathroom scale on the terrace floor.

It was an ordinary bathroom scale, white, with a round dial and a small crack across the glass. He stood beside it with the proud stillness of someone who has brought an exhibit.

“Everybody has to step on it,” he said. “One at a time. Then I will ask a question.”

Memoon stepped on. The needle swung and settled. “Thirty-six kilograms,” she read.

“Thirty-six kilograms,” said Simbha. “But the scale does not measure kilograms. It measures a push. Your feet push down on a spring, and the spring pushes back. The dial is only a translation. It is saying that on this planet, a push of this size means about thirty-six kilograms.”

“That is Chapter 3,” said Kachui. “Apparent weight.”

“It is Chapter 3,” agreed Simbha, “and here is the question. The scale works because Earth pulls on you. Which means that, somewhere inside that pull, there is a number for how heavy Earth is. So how heavy is Earth? And you are not allowed to say ’very’.”

A bathroom scale, the Moon and a very proud lion

Noodles raised a paw. “Put Earth on a very big scale.”

“We do not have one,” said Simbha.

“Then build one.”

“Noodles has just described how people solved it for two hundred years,” said Memoon. “They did not build a big scale. They found a way to weigh Earth without a scale at all.”

She opened the notebook to a page with three lines of equations, copied from Chapter 4:

T squared = (4 π squared / G M) times a cubed

“We have been using this to find T when we know a,” she said. “But nothing says we have to use it that way. If we measure a and T, and we know G, we can solve for M.”

She rearranged it in front of them, and the page filled up in a line:

M = 4 π squared a cubed / (G T squared)

“There,” she said. “The mass of the central body. Given the distance of anything that orbits it, and how long it takes to go round.”

“Then we need something that orbits Earth,” said Kachui.

“We have a very good one,” said Memoon, and looked up.

It was a clear evening. The Moon, a bit past half, hung over the water tank like a lamp left on in an upstairs window.

They set up the calculation in the notebook, in plain SI units so that nothing could go wrong. The Moon’s average distance from Earth’s centre is about 384,400 kilometres, which is 3.844 times ten to the eight metres. The time it takes to go once around, measured against the stars, is 27.32 days, which is 2.360 times ten to the six seconds. G is 6.674 times ten to the minus eleven.

Memoon did the arithmetic out loud. “The distance cubed is 5.680 times ten to the twenty-five. Four π squared is 39.48. The top is 2.242 times ten to the twenty-seven. The time squared is 5.57 times ten to the twelve. G times that is 371.9. Divide.” The calculator beeped. “6.03 times ten to the twenty-four kilograms.”

“Six million million million million kilograms,” said Beautine, who had come up the stairs in time to hear the answer and had immediately taken a seat at the back to enjoy it. “I mean, I understand what the exponent means. I do not think I understand it.”

“That is a reasonable position,” said Kachui. “Nobody does.”

“Is it right?” asked Noodles.

“The accepted value is 5.97 times ten to the twenty-four,” said Memoon. “We are about one percent too high. And I would like to know why.”

She looked at the page for a while, and it was Simbha who spoke first.

“The Moon is not nothing,” he said. “The Moon has mass. When Earth pulls the Moon, the Moon also pulls Earth, with exactly the same force, by Newton’s third law. So the two of them do not go round Earth’s centre. They both go round a point between them.”

Memoon’s head came up. “Say that again.”

“A balance point. Like two children on a seesaw, one heavy, one light. The pivot is nearer the heavy one. The Moon goes round a point, and Earth goes round the same point, in a much smaller circle. The point is called the barycentre. You told me this in January and I did not believe you.”

Earth and the Moon circle a shared balance point It lies about 4,670 km from Earth’s centre, inside Earth (radius 6,371 km).

balance point (barycentre)

centre

Moon

Earth // 384,400 km between the centres

Not to scale: the Moon is really about 60 Earth radii away and much smaller than drawn here.

The Earth–Moon barycentre. Distances and sizes not to scale.

“I told you that in a planetarium,” said Memoon. “I did not give you numbers.”

“Here are the numbers,” said Kachui, who had been calculating while they talked. “The Moon is about 1.2 percent of Earth’s mass. So the balance point sits that fraction of the way from Earth’s centre to the Moon: about 4,670 kilometres. Earth’s radius is 6,371 kilometres. So the point is inside Earth, about three quarters of the way down. Earth wobbles round it once a month.”

“So the formula,” said Memoon, working it through, “actually gives the total mass. Earth plus Moon. If I subtract the Moon, which is 7.35 times ten to the twenty-two kilograms, I get 5.96 times ten to the twenty-four.” She looked up. “That is within about one fifth of a percent of the accepted value. The rest is rounding.”

“Simbha,” said Kachui. “You noticed what the number was missing.”

“I noticed it did not feel right,” said Simbha. “It was too big. Heavier than a planet should be, for the Moon to be so far away. Since when do we trust a calculation that does not feel right?”

“Since we have shown the reason,” said Kachui. “Not before.”

Nimo’s bubble had risen, and he waited for the pause.

“Allow me an analogy,” he said. “When I swim round a rock, I feel the water change as I go. If the rock is a tiny pebble, it hardly makes the water move. If it is a huge boulder, it steers every current. The size of the swirl tells me the size of the rock. That is what the Moon’s orbit is doing. It reports on the thing at the centre.”

“I like that,” said Memoon.

“The limitation,” said Nimo, “is that my rock affects the water by pushing. Earth does not push the Moon at all. It pulls, across empty space, without touching. So I can sense a boulder by touch, but the Moon senses Earth with nothing between. The picture is only a hint.”

Beautine had her hand up again. “If this works for Earth, does it work for anything with a moon?”

Memoon grinned. “I was hoping someone would ask.”

She turned the laptop around. On the screen was a plain table from the observatory archive, with four rows and four columns and, in the heading, a name she had written on a sticker and put on the screen: GALILEO’S MOONS.

Moon Distance from Jupiter’s centre Period

Io 421,700 km 1.769 days

Europa 671,100 km 3.551 days

Ganymede 1,070,400 km 7.155 days

Callisto 1,882,700 km 16.689 days

“In January 1610,” said Kachui, “Galileo pointed a small telescope at Jupiter and saw four little lights in a line. The next night, the line had changed. He understood: moons. Going round Jupiter, in the same way that the Moon goes round us. It was one of the first pieces of evidence that not everything in the sky goes round Earth.”

“And these are the numbers from that,” said Beautine.

“These are modern values,” said Kachui. “Galileo’s own were rougher. Do Io.”

Memoon did Io. The distance was 4.217 times ten to the eight metres, and the cube was 7.50 times ten to the twenty-five. The period was 1.769 days, which is 152,800 seconds, and the square of that was 2.336 times ten to the ten. She multiplied it by G and divided it into four π squared times the cube.

“1.90 times ten to the twenty-seven kilograms,” she said.

Beautine grabbed the calculator. “Divide by Earth’s mass.”

“318.”

“Jupiter is three hundred and eighteen Earths,” said Beautine slowly. “And we got that from a moon. With a table and a calculator. On a roof.”

“Do Europa,” said Simbha.

She did. The same answer came out, to three figures. They did Ganymede. It came out the same. Callisto. The same. Four moons, four different distances, four different times, and the same mass for the thing in the middle.

“That is the beauty of it,” said Kachui quietly. “If the answer changed from moon to moon, the model would be wrong. It does not change. So the model survives four tests.”

“It is the moon’s orbit that does the work,” said Memoon, “but the answer is not about the moon. A heavy moon and a light moon at the same distance take the same time, because the mass of the moon cancels, just like the mass of SkyClub-1 cancelled. So the orbit tells us the mass of the centre.”

“Then we can do it for the Sun,” said Noodles. “Use Earth. One year, 150 million kilometres.”

“We can,” said Memoon. “And we get about two times ten to the thirty kilograms, which is the accepted figure to within rounding. About 333,000 Earths.”

They sat with that for a moment.

“The Moon is not a scale,” said Beautine. “It is a signpost.”

“The Moon is a witness,” said Kachui. “And I would like us to remember what we did not do. We did not touch Earth. We did not drill. We watched something go round and used a rule. Every mass in this chapter is an inference.”

“But a good one,” said Memoon.

“But a good one,” agreed Kachui. “The best kind: one you can check.”

Simbha picked up the bathroom scale and looked at the dial. “So when I step on this,” he said, “the number depends on how heavy Earth is. And the answer I just got for Earth came from the Moon. So the Moon and this scale are connected.”

“By the same G,” said Memoon.

“By the same G,” he said. He set the scale down gently, like a man putting away a trophy. “I think I am going to enjoy being weighed this evening.”

Mr Rao, hearing the laughter from the stairs, called up to ask whether anyone needed biscuits. Four voices said yes. A fifth said that it was not a matter of need but a matter of principle. It was Noodles, and he had already found the tin.

Science Corner

Rearranging the third law with gravity gives M = 4 π squared a cubed / (G T squared). Measure the distance a and the period T of anything orbiting a body, and you get the mass of that body. The orbiting object’s own mass cancels. Earth from the Moon: a = 3.844 × 108 m, T = 27.32 days = 2.360 × 106 s gives M of about 6.03 × 1024 kg. This is really the combined mass of Earth and Moon. Subtracting the Moon’s 7.35 × 1022 kg gives about 5.96 × 1024 kg, matching the accepted 5.97 × 1024 kg to about 0.3 percent. Jupiter from Io: a = 4.217 × 108 m, T = 1.769 days = 1.528 × 105 s gives M of about 1.90 × 1027 kg, or about 318 Earth masses. Europa, Ganymede and Callisto give the same answer, which is a check of the law. The Sun from Earth: a = 1.496 × 1011 m, T = 3.156 × 107 s gives M of about 1.99 × 1030 kg, about 333,000 Earth masses. Two bodies orbit their shared centre of mass, the barycentre. For Earth and Moon it lies about 4,670 km from Earth’s centre, inside Earth. Worked problem (maths track): A moon orbits at a = 2.0 × 108 m with T = 4.0 × 105 s around a planet. M = 4 π squared a cubed / (G T squared) = 39.48 × 8.0 × 1024 / (6.674 × 10−11 × 1.6 × 1011) = 3.158 × 1026 / 10.68 = 2.96 × 1025 kg. Concept track: a moon that is far away and takes a long time can still reveal a heavy planet, if the numbers fit the rule. Story note: ’Weighing’ is a figure of speech. What the calculation gives is mass, found from motion and gravity, not from a scale. The seesaw picture of the barycentre is accurate for the balance point but not for how the pull acts; the pull is gravity across empty space. Nimo’s boulder analogy fails because water pushes while gravity pulls through empty space. The values of a and T are averages, since the orbits are slightly elliptical, and the formula assumes the two-body case; other bodies add small changes. Values are rounded to three or four figures, so matches such as 5.96 and 5.97 agree to the accuracy of the inputs. The mass of Earth is known more accurately than G, because the product G M is measured directly from satellite orbits, to many more figures than G itself.

Space Detective 1. Explain in your own words why the mass of a moon does not appear in the formula M = 4 π squared a cubed / (G T squared), and what mass the formula does give. 2. The Moon’s orbit gave 6.03 × 1024 kg for Earth, about one percent more than the accepted value. Give the main reason, and say what Simbha’s idea of the shared balance point adds to the picture. 3. Callisto is 1,882,700 km from Jupiter and takes 16.689 days. Without a full calculation, say whether its T squared over a cubed should be larger than, smaller than or the same as Io’s, and say why.

Try it: Jupiter’s Moons Over Four Nights Time: 15 minutes on each of four clear nights. Adult: An adult must come with you for night watching. Use at night only, and never aim binoculars at the Sun. You need: a pair of binoculars, a free planetarium app or website, a notebook and a steady rest such as a wall or a tripod. Do: When Jupiter is visible in the evening sky, find it with the app. Brace the binoculars against a wall and look for up to four small points of light in a line close to Jupiter. Sketch their positions and compare with the app. Repeat over four nights and note which moon seems to move the most. What to expect: The moons appear as tiny points in a rough line. Their pattern changes from night to night, and the inner moon, Io, shows the biggest changes, because it takes the shortest time to go round. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use the app’s simulation of Jupiter’s moons across a week, or look up a table of their positions on a free astronomy site. Limitation: the simulation shows predictions based on the same orbits, not your own observation, and some moons may hide behind Jupiter or lie too close to its glare.

Next time: We can weigh a world by watching a moon go round. But there is a strange thing about orbits near Earth: a satellite that brushes through the thin air at the top of the sky loses energy and yet speeds up. How can losing energy make it go faster?

← Chapter 5: Kepler’s Three Rules · Book 11 contents · Chapter 7: The Energy of an Orbit →

Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers

Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CA-7 Job Status and Failure Reason Codes

Here are the various status codes that You may see for jobs in the Queue or Logs in CA-7. R-C0002 R-C0003 R-C0099 R-C0255 R-JCLER A-U0002 A-U0004 A-U0015 A-U0043 A-U4095 A-SOC7 A-U4000 Reason Code/Job Status Code explanation: The indication of the job's current disposition. Values and their meanings are: A-Snnnn-- The job has failed with a system abend. A-Unnnn --The job has failed with a user abend. C-Cnnnn --The job has completed successfully and is going through completion processing. E-ARFATT-- An error occurred during the attempt to attach ARF definitions. This can result if the ARFSET specified is not defined. A diagnostic message may have been written to the CA-7 log, the OS console, or to the trailer queue for the job (in which case it can be displayed using LQ,JOB=x,LIST=ALL). E-ARFERR ---The job encountered an error in the ARF processing. Do a LARFQ command for the job to get more specific information. E-SEGERR --The job has been requeued...

Whistling Winds and Waterfalls: 4 Days of Magic in Shillong

Nestled in the clouds, where the scent of pine trees mingles with the rhythm of waterfalls and the tunes of local guitar-strumming youth—Shillong is more than a place. It’s a vibe. If you’ve got 3 nights and 4 days, you’ve got just enough time to fall in love. Here’s how to make the most of it—food, fun, fog and fantastic views included. Day 1: Shillong, We’re Coming for You! You land in Guwahati, barely out of the airport when the hills start calling. You hop into your cab, Spotify on, windows down, and the three-hour ride to Shillong begins. Just when you think it can’t get better, you stop at Umiam Lake —a lake so calm, it looks like someone ironed the water. By evening, you’re sipping hot chai in Laitumkhrah, maybe nibbling on spicy momos or pork jadoh from a roadside stall. You’re checked into your charming hotel ( Tripura Castle if you fancy old-world royalty, Ri Kynjai if you’re into lakeside poetry). The breeze whispers secrets of waterfalls and pine forests. Sleep well, drea...

Installing and Configuring Hadoop on Ubuntu as a Pseudo Distributed Single Node Cluster

Briefly what is psuedo-distributed single node Hadoop cluster: It is a Hadoop distributed cluster having Single Node. All the five daemons (NN,DN,JT,TT,SNN) are running as individual JVM (java process) instances. We will get all distributed features of Hadoop. This mode is used to develop, test, and staging (before production) Map Reduce programs quickly. It writes all the system, daemon and user logs to different files on the cluster To install Hadoop in this mode, we have to modify the hadoop-env.sh, core-site.xml, hdfs-site.xml, mapred-site.xml. hadoop-env.sh contains all the Environment variables which are required for running Hadoop. All the default values are fine, Only we have to modify the JAVA_HOME=“The location of Java Home Directory” Core-site.xml contains all the cluster specific information like io, temp directory, sorting, file system uri etc. Hdfs-site.xml contains all the parameters which are specific to HDFS like name node directory, data node directory...