Memunic Space Explorers › Book 3: Memoon’s Model Solar System › Chapter 7: How Far?
Chapter 7: How Far?

On Tuesday, Kachui carried a long roll of paper out to the garden path. It was the backs of Beautine’s old calendars, taped end to end.
“This is my model of distances,” he said. “Ten centimetres on this strip stands for the distance from the Sun to Earth. That is about 150 million kilometres in real life.”
He put the Sun at one end and made small pencil ticks. “Mercury at 4. Venus at 7. Earth at 10. Mars at 15.” He crawled along the strip. “Jupiter at 52. Saturn at 96. Uranus at 192. Neptune at 302.”
“That is three metres and two centimetres,” said Beautine, who had counted with her tail.
Kachui’s paper strip: the first planets are close to the Sun, and then the gaps grow.
Noodles walked slowly along the strip. “The first four planets are squashed together at one end,” he said. “And then there are huge gaps.”
“The inner planets are close together, and the outer planets are far apart,” said Kachui. “And look at this. On this strip, how wide is the Sun?”
“A hand?” guessed Noodles.
“About one millimetre. A pinhead. And Earth is far too small to see.”
Distance from the Sun on the paper strip 10 cm on the strip stands for the Sun-to-Earth distance
| 4 cm | 7 cm | 10 cm | 15 cm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mercury | Venus | Earth | Mars |
0 cm 50 cm 100 cm 150 cm 200 cm 250 cm 300 cm
| 52 cm | 96 cm | 192 cm | 302 cm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jupiter | Saturn | Uranus | Neptune |
The four inner planets are squeezed into the first 15 cm.
Distances only, drawn to one scale (10 cm is about 150 million km, rounded). Planet sizes are NOT to scale, and the planets are not really in a line.
Noodles tried to set the bead down on the strip, right on the 10 cm tick. “The bead we used for Earth is more than a thousand times too big.”
“Then let us do the opposite,” said Memoon. “Keep the beads and the fruit, and put the planets where they belong on that scale. Simbha, you are our measuring lion. Your stride is about one metre.”
Simbha placed the chalk Sun at one end of the lane. He took the bead and began to walk, counting in a deep rumble. “...one hundred and fifteen. One hundred and sixteen. One hundred and seventeen.” Far away, he put the bead down.
Noodles squinted. The Sun back at the start was just a white circle, and the bead was almost invisible. “That tiny dot is Earth?”
“One hundred and seventeen metres from the Sun,” said Kachui. “And the Moon would be a seed about 30 centimetres from the bead, as far as a ruler. Neptune would be about three and a half kilometres away, about three-quarters of an hour of walking.”
Simbha places the bead 117 strides away. The chalk Sun is a tiny circle far behind him.
“I do not walk,” said Noodles. “I am carried.”
Nimo’s bubble wobbled. “There is so much room. Something must fill it up, the way water fills my pond, to hold the planets in place.”
“That is a very fishy idea,” said Memoon kindly. “But the space between the planets is almost empty. Water holds a fish up. Space does not hold a planet up. We will find out what keeps the planets going round in a later adventure.”
“Imagine Mode on,” said Nimo, and his bubble shot down the lane, quick as an imaginary thought, past Simbha, past the bead, all the way to the end. “Imagine Mode off,” he called, and rolled back to the others.
“That is not how real spacecraft travel,” said Memoon. “They are much slower, and they take years to reach the outer planets.”
Memoon sat down in the middle of the lane with her notebook. “Now I know why our model kept going wrong,” she said. “On one table we can show how big the planets are, or how far apart they are. But not both on the same scale. If the Sun were on the table, Neptune would be about three and a half kilometres away. And if everything fitted on the table, the planets would be too small to see.”
“So what do we do for Fair Day?” asked Beautine.
“We make more than one model,” said Memoon. “And each one says what it shows well and what it gets wrong.”
She wrote: Fix number five. Space is mostly empty. One table cannot show real sizes and real distances at the same scale.
“One question is left,” said Kachui, looking up at the evening sky. “Dot.”
Look closer The distances between planets are huge compared with the sizes of planets. The Solar System is mostly empty space. On a paper strip where Earth is 10 cm from the Sun, the planets are at Mercury 4 cm, Venus 7 cm, Earth 10 cm, Mars 15 cm, Jupiter 52 cm, Saturn 96 cm, Uranus 192 cm and Neptune 302 cm. On that strip the Sun is about 1 mm wide, and Earth is far too small to see. If Earth is a 1 cm bead and the Sun is a circle 109 cm wide, Earth is about 117 m from the Sun and Neptune is about 3.5 km away. The Moon is a tiny seed about 30 cm from the Earth bead. One table cannot show real sizes and real distances at the same scale. A good model says which one it shows. Story note: Imagine Mode is the story’s way of pretend travel. Real spacecraft are much slower and take years to reach the outer planets. Nimo’s idea that space is full of water is a mistake: the space between the planets is mostly empty, and what keeps the planets going round comes in a later book. On the strip, 10 cm stands for about 150 million km, the distances are rounded, and the planets are not really in a straight line. Simbha’s stride is taken as 1 m. Talking animals are part of the story; the science is real.
Space Detective questions 1. On Kachui’s strip, how far from the Sun is Jupiter? How much farther from the Sun is Jupiter than Earth? 2. Why could the friends not show real sizes and real distances at the same scale on one table? 3. Draw a short strip with the Sun at one end. Mark where Earth (10 cm), Mars (15 cm) and Jupiter (52 cm) would go, using any scale you like.
Try it: The Solar System Strip Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult helps with measuring and any cutting. You need: a strip of paper about 3 m 10 cm long (taped sheets or an old roll), a ruler or tape measure, a pencil and sticky notes. Do: Put the Sun at one end. Mark each planet at 4, 7, 10, 15, 52, 96, 192 and 302 cm from the Sun, and write each planet’s name on a sticky note. Then walk along the strip and say the planets in order. Expect: the first four planets are crowded into the first 15 cm, and then the gaps grow wide. Indoors or low-resource: no paper? Tie knots in a rope or a washing line at the same distances. You can feel the gaps with your hands. Limits: the planets are not really in a straight line, and the planets themselves are far too small to show at this scale.
Next time: One question is still unanswered. What is the bright dot that does not twinkle?
← Chapter 6: How Big? · Book 3 contents · Chapter 8: Planet or Star? →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 3: Memoon’s Model Solar System, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment