Memunic Space Explorers › Book 3: Memoon’s Model Solar System › Chapter 9: Fair Day
Chapter 9: Fair Day

The Space Fair began at ten o’clock with a loud drum and a very long queue at the Sky Club’s table.
The long table now held three models. Beside each one, Memoon had pinned a card with two halves. One half said SHOWS WELL. The other said GETS WRONG.
At the first model, the lantern stood on its stool with a HOME-stickered ball beside it. Shows well: spin makes a day, and a trip round the Sun makes a year. Gets wrong: ten turns stand for 365, and the lantern is small and close.
At the second, the bead, the peppercorn and the fruit sat beside a big chalk Sun. Shows well: sizes. Gets wrong: no distances, and Saturn’s rings are left out.
At the third, Kachui’s paper strip ran away along the garden path. Shows well: distances. Gets wrong: the planets are not in a line, and they are far too small to see.
Fair Day: three honest models and a Planet Parade. Where is Earth in the parade?
“A model that says what it gets wrong,” said a visitor, reading a card. “That is a strange thing to put on a table.”
“It is the most useful thing,” said Memoon.
Beautine had invented the Planet Parade for the youngest visitors. Eight children each held a planet card and lined up in order from the lantern. A small girl with a ribbon in her hair held the third card.
“Where is Earth in the parade?” she asked.
“Third!” said Noodles, before anyone else could answer. “After Mercury and Venus, and before Mars. You are Earth.”
“I am Earth,” said the girl, delighted.
“The parade shows the order of the planets,” said Memoon. “It does not show their sizes or distances. Real planets go round at different speeds, so they are never lined up like that.”
The planet parade: order from the Sun
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Mercury Venus Earth Mars Jupiter Saturn Uranus Neptune
Earth is third
Order only. Sizes and distances are NOT to scale, and the planets are never really in a line.
Order only. Sizes and distances are NOT to scale, and the planets are never really in a line.
Beside the table sat a glass jar with a label in Kachui’s neat writing: QUESTION JAR. “When a question is too big for today, it goes in here,” said Kachui. All morning, visitors dropped in folded slips. One said: Why is it hot in some months and cool in others? Another said: What happens when the Sun goes dark in the daytime?
“Excellent questions,” said Memoon. “Into the Jar.”
At noon, Guddu joined by video call and looked down the whole table. She asked her three questions again.
“Does Earth move?”
“It spins, and it goes round the Sun,” said Memoon. “The lawn model shows it.”
“Is Neptune the same size as Mercury?”
“No. Neptune is about ten times wider,” said Kachui. “The bead and fruit show it.”
“Are the planets standing in a polite line, one step apart?”
“They are not,” said Beautine. “The strip shows how far apart they really are.”
“And is your model true?” asked Guddu.
“No model is,” said Memoon. “But ours tells you what it gets wrong.”
Guddu smiled. “That is the most honest answer a scientist can give. The ribbon for the Most Honest Model goes to the Sky Club.”
“I knew it,” said Noodles, polishing the ribbon on his collar. “I am a genius.”
“You are a cat who tried to fit eight planets on a table,” said Nimo.
That evening, when the fair was packed away, Kachui opened the jar and read the slips by lantern light. At the very bottom lay the oldest one, soft with age: Where did everything come from?
He read it twice and put it back. “That one is for much later,” he said. He screwed on the lid.
Kachui opens the Question Jar. The oldest slip stays at the bottom.
Memoon turned to the page headed Why does our model keep going wrong? She wrote: No model is perfect. The best one says what it gets wrong. Then, on a fresh page, she wrote: Next question.
Look closer Earth is the third planet from the Sun, between Venus and Mars. A good model shows what it is for and says what it gets wrong. The Sky Club’s three models showed motion, sizes and distances. A planet parade shows the order of the planets only. The planets are not really in a line, and they travel at different speeds. Scientists test models against evidence and improve them. Models help us think; they are not the real thing. A question that is too big for today can be written down, kept, and answered later. Story note: the parade is a model of order only, and the planets are never lined up like that. Guddu’s judging and the ribbon are part of the story. The Question Jar is the Sky Club’s own way of keeping questions for later. Talking animals are part of the story; the science is real.
Space Detective questions 1. Where is Earth in the planet parade? Name the planet before it and the planet after it. 2. Choose your favourite model from this book. What does it show well, and what does it get wrong? 3. Look back at the Solar System drawing you made in Chapter 1. Draw it again with what you know now. What changed?
Try it: Planet Parade Time: 15 minutes. Adult: An adult helps to organise the line. You need: eight cards or eight family members or friends, and a marker. Do: Write one planet name on each card and hand them out. Line up in order from a lamp that stands for the Sun. Each planet says one fact. Then ask everyone to guess which planets are rocky and which are giants. Expect: Earth is third in the line. The four planets nearest the lamp are rocky, and the last four are giants. Indoors or low-resource: no helpers? Place eight shoes or stones in order along a path. Limits: the line shows the order only. Real planets are never lined up, and their sizes and distances are very different.
Next time: Kachui lifts the lid of the Question Jar. What is the first question inside?
← Chapter 8: Planet or Star? · Book 3 contents · What We Found Out →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 3: Memoon’s Model Solar System, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment