Memunic Space Explorers › Book 9: Memoon and the Clockwork Sky › Chapter 7: Falling Sideways
Chapter 7: Falling Sideways

In this chapter: explain circular motion and orbits as falling sideways around a body, and test the idea against the Moon.
Simbha had been quiet all morning, which in a lion usually means he is thinking about a very large idea.
“I have a question about the Moon,” he said, as the others arrived on the terrace after school. “Last night Memoon said it is falling and missing. I have been trying to picture that. A thing that falls and does not land is a strange thing to picture. Where does it keep going?”
“Sideways,” said Memoon, and then realised she had said it before thinking. “I mean, I think it goes sideways. But I cannot prove it yet.”
“That is how most good ideas start,” said Kachui.
Nimo bobbed on the parapet. “Shall we do it in Imagine Mode? As always, everything in the bubble is a story, and a safe one. You will see a thought experiment that Isaac Newton described more than three hundred years ago.”
The bubble filled with a picture. It showed Earth as a great blue ball, with a very tall mountain rising from it. On top of the mountain stood a small cannon.
Imagine Mode: everything in the falling lift falls together. Imaginary; never try this.
“Let us imagine,” said Nimo, “that the mountain is so tall that it rises above the air, so air does not slow anything down. In real life no mountain is that tall and the air would matter very much, but it helps us think. The cannon fires a ball sideways.”
The ball in the bubble flew out and curved down and hit the ground not far away.
“Gravity pulled it down,” said Noodles.
“Now fire it faster.”
The ball flew farther before it landed.
“Now faster.”
Farther again. Beautine leaned in. “The ground is curving away under it. Earth is round. As the ball travels, the surface drops.”
“Yes,” said Nimo. “Now imagine a speed so great that, as the ball falls, the ground curves away just as fast as the ball drops towards it.”
In the bubble, the ball went round the whole planet. It passed under the cannon’s tail and kept going.
Newton's cannon (Imagine Mode: air ignored)
1 slow: lands near 3 fast enough (dashed): 2 faster: lands farther goes all the way round
At about 8 km/s just above the surface, the ground curves away as fast as the ball falls. Not to scale: Earth's curve and the mountain are exaggerated.
Imagine Mode: Newton’s cannon. Air is ignored and the picture is not to scale.
“It never lands,” breathed Noodles.
“It is still falling,” said Simbha slowly, “all the time. But the ground keeps curving away.”
“We can check that with a number,” said Kachui. “How much does the surface of Earth curve away over, say, eight kilometres?”
“I do not know,” said Beautine, “and I admit it.”
Kachui drew a circle in the notebook, with Earth’s radius of 6,371 kilometres marked, and a straight horizontal line touching it at one point. “Take the straight line eight kilometres along. At that point, how far is the curved surface below the line? A bit of geometry says it is about eight squared over twice the radius. Sixty-four divided by twelve thousand seven hundred forty-two, in kilometres.”
“Zero point zero zero five kilometres,” said Memoon. “Five metres.”
“So over eight kilometres, Earth curves away by about five metres. Now, how far does a falling thing drop in one second?”
“We use the second law,” said Memoon. “Distance equals a half times g times time squared. A half times 9.81 times one is about 4.9 metres.”
The terrace went silent for a moment.
“A ball moving sideways at eight kilometres each second,” said Kachui, “falls about five metres in a second, and the Earth curves away by about five metres in the eight kilometres it travels. They match. The ball keeps falling and keeps missing.”
“Eight kilometres a second,” said Noodles. “That is fast.”
“Very. Almost twenty-five times faster than the speed of sound, and that is the reason orbits are hard to reach. That is why you need big rockets, not to go up, but to go sideways at that speed.”
“So when you do go sideways,” said Memoon, “gravity does not pull you out of orbit. It keeps you in it.”
Nimo bobbed with satisfaction. “There is a limit to this picture. The numbers are for a ball just above the surface with no air. A real satellite flies above the atmosphere, so a little higher, and at a slightly smaller speed. The space station’s speed is 7.66 kilometres per second.”
“Now, an orbit is a circle, more or less,” said Kachui. “And a circle is a very odd kind of motion. Look at it again.”
He asked Simbha to take a soft sponge ball tied to a thread and swing it slowly in a horizontal circle, in open space away from everyone. Memoon watched carefully. “The ball is moving at a steady speed,” she said. “But its direction is always changing.”
“A change in direction is an acceleration,” said Kachui, “even if the speed stays the same. And by the second law, an acceleration needs a net force. What force is keeping the ball in its circle?”
“The string,” said Beautine. “I can see it pulling.”
“Pulling inwards, towards the middle of the circle. Let go.”
Simbha, who had been told to expect this, released the thread. The ball flew off in a straight line, tangent to where it had been.
“Not outwards,” said Memoon. “Straight along. It goes the way it was heading at that moment.”
Beautine peered. “I thought it would fly outwards. Like the feeling in a car taking a corner. You get thrown outwards.”
“That outward feeling is your body wanting to go straight, as the first law says,” said Kachui, “while the car turns. What is real is the inward push.”
“We call the inward force in circular motion the centripetal force,” said Memoon. “It is not a new kind of force. It is just the name for whichever force is pulling inward. For the sponge ball it is the tension in the string. For a car on a bend it is friction. For the Moon, it is gravity.”
“Whatever the thing is that is keeping it in the circle,” said Simbha.
“Right.”
Noodles had been counting something on his claws. “There is a rule for how much inward acceleration a circle needs, isn’t there? Something with speed squared.”
“There is,” said Kachui. “Inward acceleration equals speed squared divided by the radius of the circle. We write it a = v²/r. Faster in the same circle needs more, and a tighter circle needs more.”
Memoon stood up. “Then I would like to try the test Newton tried. The Moon, in a circle, around Earth. The inverse-square rule says the Moon is sixty times farther from Earth’s centre than we are. Sixty squared is 3,600. So the Moon should feel a gravity 3,600 times weaker than the 9.81 here.”
“Nine point eight one divided by 3,600,” said Kachui. “0.00272 metres per second squared.”
“That is the prediction from gravity,” said Memoon. “Now let us see what circular motion says the Moon actually needs. The Moon is 384,400 kilometres away and goes round once in 27.3 days. In seconds, that is 2.36 million. In metres, the radius is 384 million.”
She did the work on the notebook page and read it aloud. “The Moon’s speed is the distance around the circle, two times pi times 384 million metres, divided by 2.36 million seconds. That is about 1,020 metres each second. Speed squared is a little over a million. Divided by 384 million metres...” She stopped. “Zero point zero zero two seven.”
Kachui checked it. “0.00272.”
Nobody said anything for a long moment. Even Noodles was still.
“The gravity we measure on the ground, weakened by distance,” said Simbha, “is exactly what the Moon needs to stay in its circle.”
“Same pull,” said Memoon, “for a falling stone and for the Moon. Newton did a calculation like this in the 1660s. It was one of the pieces of evidence that the force on a falling apple and the force on the Moon were the same kind of force.”
Beautine put her paws together, and for once she did not make a speech. “The Moon is falling around us,” she said, quietly. “And so is the station.”
“Yes,” said Memoon. “And now we can predict its period. The station’s orbit has a radius of about 6,784 kilometres from Earth’s centre, at 7.66 kilometres per second. Distance round is two pi times 6,784, about 42,600 kilometres. Divide by 7.66 and you get about 5,560 seconds.”
“About ninety-three minutes,” said Kachui, nodding. “Ninety-two point seven, if we use our rounded numbers. The published figure is about 92.9 minutes, and the difference comes from rounding and from the orbit not being a perfect circle.”
“Ninety-three minutes to go all the way round Earth,” said Noodles, awed. “That means the astronauts see about sixteen sunrises every day.”
“Fifteen and a half orbits a day,” said Kachui. “Close enough. The station crosses from day to night and back about once every forty-six minutes.”
Memoon looked across the dark rooftops to the east, where the first thin line of Jupiter’s light was rising again. “Then we have all we need to predict the station,” she said. “We have its period. We know it is the same orbit each time. We only need to know where Earth is turned beneath it.”
Science Corner An orbit is the path of an object falling around another body, kept in a curve by gravity. A body in orbit is in free fall: gravity is the only force, and its sideways speed keeps it from reaching the ground. In circular motion at steady speed, direction changes, so the object accelerates inward. The inward force is the centripetal force, and the acceleration is a = v²/r. Just above Earth’s surface, in a world without air, a sideways speed of about 8 km/s makes the ball fall as far each second as the ground curves away. The station moves at about 7.66 km/s at roughly 413 km altitude. Moon test: gravity at the Moon’s distance (60 Earth radii) should be 9.81 ÷ 3,600 ≈ 0.00272 m/s², and the Moon’s circular motion needs a = v²/r ≈ 0.00272 m/s². They agree. Period from speed and radius: T = 2πr ÷ v. For the station, about 5,560 s ≈ 92.7 minutes from rounded numbers; the published period is about 92.9 minutes. Story note: Newton’s cannon is Imagine Mode. A real cannon on a real mountain would be slowed by air, so no ball would orbit. The Moon test uses round numbers for distance and period and treats the Moon’s orbit as a circle, but its real orbit is slightly elliptical. Where this idea stops working: the “falling sideways” picture shows why orbits do not need engines, but the station still needs small occasional boosts because a trace of air at its height slowly drags it.
Space Detective 1. Explain why a ball on a string flies off in a straight line, not outwards, when the string is released. 2. A satellite moves at 7.0 km/s on a circle of radius 7,000 km. Calculate its period in minutes and compare with the station. 3. Draw Newton’s cannon with three paths: one that lands close, one that lands farther, and one that goes all the way round. Mark the curve of Earth.
Try it: Circle and Release Time: 15 minutes.
Adult: An adult should supervise, keep others well back, and choose a soft ball only. You need: a soft sponge ball tied to 50 cm of thread, an open outdoor space, chalk.
Do: Swing the ball slowly in a circle at waist height. Feel the thread pulling inwards. Then, with the adult’s go-ahead, let go. Mark with chalk the direction it flies and compare it to the circle. What to expect: the ball moves in a straight line tangent to the circle at the moment of release.
Cloudy or low-resource day: draw a circle with a ruler and mark the “release points” with straight tangent lines using a ruler touching the circle.
Limitation: a drawing shows direction but not the force.
Next time: We have a period for the station. But when exactly will it cross our sky, and where?
← Chapter 6: How Gravity Fades · Book 9 contents · Chapter 8: The Station’s Timetable →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 9: Memoon and the Clockwork Sky, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment