Memunic Space Explorers › Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow › Chapter 3: Bending Light
Chapter 3: Bending Light
In this chapter: Explain refraction as a change of light’s speed at a boundary, use Snell’s law (n1 sin i = n2 sin r) to predict and measure bending, and recognise that the direction of bending depends on which side has the larger refractive index.
Noodles lost the coin on purpose.
He had proposed the trick himself, because he had watched a magician at a school fair and believed that every magic trick could be reproduced by a cat with enough confidence. He placed a coin at the bottom of Mr Rao’s steel bucket, stepped back until the rim of the bucket hid it from his eye, and then said to the Club, “Now. Without moving my head, I will make the coin come back.”
“With magic?” asked Beautine.
“With water,” said Noodles, and slowly, carefully, poured a jug of water into the bucket. The coin, which had been hidden behind the rim, rose into view as the level climbed, as if lifted by an invisible hand.
Beautine gasped. “It floated up!”
The coin has not moved. The light from it bends at the water’s surface.
“It did not move at all,” said Kachui. “Mark the coin’s position on the base with a pencil. See? The same spot. Something else moved.”
“The light,” said Memoon quietly. She had gone very still, as she always did when she found the thing behind the thing. “From the coin to your eye, the light is bending at the surface. You see the coin where the light seems to come from, which is higher than the real coin. Last night’s bucket was the clue. When the beam went into the water, it changed direction.”
“Refraction,” said Nimo, with enormous satisfaction, rising in his bubble to the very top of the water tank. “At last. A subject on which I am, in the very strict sense, an expert. I live inside it.”
“Then tell us what it is,” said Simbha.
Nimo thought. “When I look up from my pond, the world above is crumpled like a leaf. Straight things are bent. The sky above the surface looks like a round window. I always thought it was a property of water, like wetness. But the light is bending because it moves from air into water, which changes how it travels. I believe it slows down.”
“That is the key,” said Memoon. “Light has a speed limit, about three hundred thousand kilometres per second in empty space. In any material it goes slower. Water slows it by about a quarter. Glass slows it by about a third. When a beam arrives at a boundary at an angle, one side of the beam enters the new material and slows first. The beam swings, like a marching line when one end gets stuck in mud.”
“I like the mud,” said Beautine.
“The mud is an analogy,” said Kachui, who was always fair to analogies by pointing out where they failed. “Real light is not marching in rows. The mud explains the turning. It does not explain why the speed changes in the first place, which depends on how light interacts with the atoms in the material, and we will not need to know that today.”
Memoon set up the measurement. Mr Rao’s second mirror, taped upright, held a cardboard marker. Behind the bucket, a protractor lay on the table. She shone the slit beam from the air into the water in the bucket at five angles of incidence, and Kachui, lying on the ground with his face level with the water, read off where the beam pointed after it entered.
They drew the normal again, because the normal is the line from which all angles must be measured, and noted down the results:
Incoming angle in air: 20, 30, 40, 50, 60 degrees. Angle in water (measured): 15, 22, 29, 36, 40 degrees.
“The beam bends towards the normal,” said Simbha, “every time. Going into water, it leans closer to the perpendicular.”
“A rule, then,” said Noodles, trying to sound wise. “Light always bends towards the normal when it goes into something.”
“Wait,” said Memoon. “Always? Into anything? Test the prediction before we swallow it.” She wrote a question mark in the margin. “But first, how much does it bend? Look at the numbers. Is there a pattern like there was for reflection?”
The numbers were not as tidy as the mirror’s. The bend did not grow in proportion to the angle: 20 turned into 15 (a five-degree bend), 60 into 40 (a twenty-degree bend). Beautine tried dividing the angles, then subtracting them, then rearranging them like a conjurer dealing cards.
“Try sines,” said Kachui, mildly.
Beautine stopped. “Try what?”
“The sine of each angle. Willebrord Snellius, a Dutch scientist, found around the year 1621 that for light going between two materials, the ratio of the sine of the angle in the first to the sine of the angle in the second stays the same. It is a very old idea, much older than the Club.” He tapped the calculator. “Divide sin 20 by sin 15, then sin 30 by sin 22, and so on.”
Noodles pressed buttons. Beautine read results. Memoon wrote them down.
“One point three two,” said Beautine. “One point three three five. One point three two six. One point three oh three. One point three four seven.”
“One point three three,” said Simbha. “Average, one point three three.”
Memoon stared at the number. “That is the refractive index of water. It tells us how much slower light is in water than in empty space: the speed in water is the speed in empty space divided by the index. Three hundred thousand divided by one point three three is about two hundred and twenty-five thousand kilometres per second.” She wrote the law in the notebook, slowly:
n1 sin i = n2 sin r
“Air is almost exactly one, so we wrote one point zero for it. Water is about one point three three. Glass is about one point five. The bigger the number, the slower the light, and the more the beam bends towards the normal when it goes in.”
“So that proves my rule,” said Noodles. “Bends towards the normal.”
“It proves it for air to water,” said Memoon. She pointed her pencil at the question mark. “Now we need a case where the beam goes the other way.”
Nimo, who had been trying not to say it for ten minutes, burst out: “I can show you! May I go in the bucket?”
“No,” said Memoon. “There is not enough water, and your bubble is an imaginary travel device. I will use the torch.”
She set the torch low in the bucket, in its waterproof pouch, shining up towards the surface from below, as if a beam were leaving the water. At a small angle, the beam went out of the water into the air and bent away from the normal, skimming closer to the surface.
“It bent the other way,” said Simbha slowly. “Going out of water, it leans away from the perpendicular. So our rule was wrong.”
“Wrong as a general rule,” said Kachui, “but the data from air to water were right. The better rule is: the beam bends towards the normal when it enters a material with a larger refractive index, and away from the normal when it enters one with a smaller index. Your rule was a good description of one case, Noodles. It went wrong when it was stretched.”
Noodles grinned. “That is the most flattering way anyone has ever told me I was wrong.”
“Nimo,” said Memoon, “you assumed the water rules apply everywhere, didn’t you? Be honest.”
Nimo’s bubble sank an inch with embarrassment. “I thought all bending was towards the middle. I have never lived in glass or air.”
“That is why we test,” said Kachui. “Even an expert inside water can mistake water’s behaviour for a law of the universe.”
Memoon raised the torch angle in the bucket a bit more. The beam leaving the water skimmed along the surface at a glancing angle, then, at a slightly larger angle, the beam vanished from the air entirely and was reflected from the underside of the surface, as bright as in a mirror.
“The beam is bouncing back inside the water,” said Simbha, amazed. “The surface is acting like a mirror.”
“Total internal reflection,” said Memoon. “Going from water to air, the beam can only emerge if its angle from the normal is smaller than the critical angle. For water and air that angle is about forty-nine degrees. Past that, no light escapes. All of it is reflected back in.”
“It is how fibre optic cables work,” said Kachui, “and why a diamond sparkles.”
Nimo, his bubble floating up and rotating slowly, said dreamily, “This is why my sky is a circle.”
“What do you mean?” asked Beautine.
“From deep underwater, looking up, I see the whole world above the surface squeezed into a round window,” said Nimo. “Outside the circle, I see only the reflection of the pond floor. Forty-nine degrees to each side of straight up. About ninety-seven degrees wide, edge to edge. I never knew why. It is the critical angle.”
There was a silence of pure respect.
Air into water Water into air Past the critical angle
air n = 1.00 air n = 1.00 air n = 1.00
40°
41.7°
28.9° 30° 55°
water n = 1.33 water n = 1.33 water n = 1.33
bends toward the normal bends away from the normal total internal reflection critical angle for water: 48.8°
Fish view: the whole sky fits inside a cone about 97.5° wide (2 × 48.8°). Angles are measured from the normal and come from Snell’s law.
Light bends toward the normal going into water and away from it coming out, and reflects completely past the critical angle.
“Nimo,” said Beautine, “I have been calling you ’the little fish’ for months and you have been living inside Snell’s law the whole time.”
“I noticed it,” said Nimo. “I did not measure it. That is the difference between a fish and a scientist.”
The Club sat quietly in the cold air. Down in the stairwell Mr Rao’s footsteps went one flight down, then stopped, then came back up and went down again, in the way of a person who is wondering whether it would be rude to ask what a sine is.
Memoon looked up at the sky and the little twinkling lights, and at the bucket full of bending light, and she put the two thoughts together in the notebook. Air is a material. It has a refractive index close to one, but not exactly one. It changes with temperature and pressure. What happens to starlight when the index changes from place to place?
She underlined it, circled it, and left it as the last line of the page.
Science Corner Refraction is the change in direction of light when its speed changes at a boundary between materials. The refractive index n of a material is the speed of light in empty space divided by the speed in the material. Air is about 1.0003, water about 1.33, ordinary glass about 1.5. Snell’s law: n1 sin i = n2 sin r. Entering a larger index bends the beam towards the normal; entering a smaller one bends it away. Total internal reflection happens when light tries to leave a material with a larger index at more than the critical angle; for water and air the critical angle is about 49 degrees. Story note: The angle readings are invented but consistent with water’s real index; the average ratio of 1.33 is computed from them. The marching-line picture explains the turning of the beam, not why the speed changes, and real light behaves like a wave. The refractive index depends slightly on colour, which becomes important in Chapter 5, and varies with temperature and pressure for air, the idea Chapter 4 builds on. Nimo’s circular view of the sky is a fair account of what a fish would see, simplified; waves and murk would blur the edge.
Space Detective 1. A beam hits glass (n = 1.5) from air at 40 degrees. Use Snell’s law to find the angle in the glass, and say whether it bends towards or away from the normal. 2. Noodles’s rule said that light always bends towards the normal. Describe the observation that disproves it, and rewrite the rule so it survives the data. 3. Draw a ray from a coin on the bottom of a bucket to an observer’s eye. Draw where the coin appears to be and explain why it looks shallower than it is.
Try it: The Rising Coin Time: 15 minutes. Adult: An adult should help carry the water and keep the floor dry. You need: an opaque cup or bucket, a coin, a jug of water, a pencil, a protractor and a torch with a slit card. Do: Place the coin in the empty container and step back until the rim just hides it. Hold your head still and ask a friend to pour in water gently. Mark the coin’s true position with a pencil. Then, if you want numbers, shine a slit beam into a clear tank of water at 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 degrees and measure the angle in the water, then compute sin i divided by sin r for each. What to expect: The coin comes into view as the water rises, although it never moves. The ratios are about 1.33, scattered by about 0.03 from reading errors. Cloudy or low-resource day: Put a pencil in a glass of water and look from the side; it appears bent at the surface. Limitation: this shows refraction but gives no numbers, and a curved glass also acts as a lens.
Next time: If air bends light a little, and air is never the same from place to place, what would that do to a beam that crosses fifty kilometres of sky?
← Chapter 2: Bouncing Light · Book 10 contents · Chapter 4: The Shimmering Sky →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment