Memunic Space Explorers › Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow › Chapter 4: The Shimmering Sky
Chapter 4: The Shimmering Sky
In this chapter: Explain atmospheric refraction (stars and the low Sun appear higher than they are) and twinkling as light bending through moving pockets of air of different density, and explain why a planet’s disk steadies its light while a star’s point does not.
At noon the terrace floor shimmered like a pond.
Memoon had come up at midday on a Saturday with a hat, a bottle of water, a notebook, and Mr Rao’s permission, which had been given from the doorway and with great seriousness. The rule of the Club was that anything involving the Sun needed an adult nearby and a promise that nobody would look at it. Nobody did. The Club’s business that morning was not with the Sun but with the air just above the sun-warmed floor.
She crouched with her eye almost level with the floor tiles and looked along the terrace at the edge of the water tank at the far end. The straight edge of the tank wobbled, rippled and wavered, as though painted on the surface of a stream.
Midday shimmer above the warm terrace floor.
“The edge isn’t moving,” said Kachui, standing beside her in the shade of the stairwell door. “It is a solid object. What is moving?”
“The air,” said Memoon. “Last night we measured water. Water’s refractive index is one point three three. Air is one point zero zero zero three. Almost the same as empty space, but not exactly the same, and that tiny difference changes with the air’s density. Hot air expands, it is less dense, and light goes through it very slightly faster. The refractive index of hot air is a hair closer to one than the refractive index of cool air.”
“A hair,” said Noodles. “That is not a big bend.”
“A hair is enough if the air moves,” said Memoon. “Over this floor there are rising warm columns and sinking cooler ones, a hundred small blobs, each a very weak lens. They drift and change shape in seconds. The light from the tank’s edge crosses a bundle of them on its way to my eye. Each blob bends the light a tiny amount, and the sum of the bends changes from moment to moment. So the edge dances.”
Nimo’s bubble floated into the shade. “That is what I see on the pond bottom on hot days. A great net of bright and dark lines, wriggling.”
“The lines are bright where the blobs happen to focus the light and dark where they spread it,” said Memoon. “Now imagine a column of air that is not two metres high but a hundred kilometres high, and a light that is a single point.” She stopped. A thought had arrived, and everyone could see it arrive, because her pencil stopped moving mid-sentence.
Simbha let her have the silence. He had learned from long evenings that silence was where Memoon found the most.
“A star’s light,” she said at last, “comes through the whole atmosphere. Layers of air, thinner at the top, thicker at the bottom, warmer here, cooler there, wind moving them. The star is so far away that it is a single point of light. Every ray from it follows nearly the same path through the air. Each pocket of air bends or focuses the beam slightly, and the pockets drift and fade and re-form. So the star’s light arrives brighter for a moment, then dimmer, then shifted a little, then back. That is twinkling.”
“Three clues, three predictions,” said Kachui, and opened the logbook. “The first was that a low star twinkles more, because its light crosses more air. The second was that a planet low in the sky should twinkle a little. The third was that a planet should twinkle less than a star of equal brightness, even when both are high.”
“Simbha’s counts,” said Memoon. “Sirius: twenty-four low, fourteen at middle height, eight high. Jupiter: five low, three high. They match all three.”
“But why?” said Noodles. He was sitting on an upturned bucket, which was Noodles’s way of showing that he intended to stay in the argument. “I follow why low twinkles more. More air means more blobs. But what is different about a planet? The air does not know which of them is a planet.”
“Excellent,” said Memoon, “and it does not. The air treats them identically. What differs is the size they appear in the sky.”
She drew a large circle on the notebook’s page, representing the sky, and inside it she placed a single tiny dot, and next to it a slightly bigger dot with a thin outline. “Sirius is a huge ball of fusing gas, but so far away that even the best instruments see it as a disc about six thousandths of an arcsecond across. An arcsecond is one three-thousand-six-hundredth of a degree. Jupiter, on average, is about forty arcseconds wide. That is thousands of times bigger. Jupiter looks like a very small disc to a telescope, though to your eye it still looks like a point.”
“To my eye, then, they look the same,” said Beautine.
“To your eye, yes. To the air, no. The air-blobs near the ground are only a few centimetres to a few metres across. Light from Sirius crosses them as one thin pencil of rays. When a blob moves, the whole pencil bends together, and the star flickers. Jupiter’s light is thousands of pencils, each from a different spot on the disc, each passing through slightly different parts of the air. Some are brightened while others are dimmed. When your eye adds them up, the flickers cancel.” She drew a bundle of arrows. “The planet’s light twinkles in tiny pieces and cancels out in the sum.”
Star: a point Planet: a small disc
one thin pencil of light
one path: the whole beam flickers many paths: wobbles cancel
Blobs show moving pockets of air. Real star: about 0.006 arcsecond; Jupiter: about 40 arcseconds. Not to scale. Even a planet may twinkle a little when it is very low in the sky.
A star is a point; a planet is a small disc. Not to scale.
Kachui tapped the page with a flipper. “That also explains why a very low planet can still twinkle. Near the horizon the light crosses so much air that even the average cannot hide the swings. And it explains why Mercury, small and often low, twinkles more than Jupiter.”
“The disc argument is also an approximation,” said Memoon. “I should say so. Air isn’t a single uniform curtain; the bigger the air-blobs, the bigger the pieces of the disc that move together. But for a planet viewed at a good height, the average wins.” She wrote it. Planets twinkle much less because their light comes from many points, not one. They can still twinkle, especially when low.
“Beautine,” said Simbha, in a tone that suggested he was about to hand the stage to someone who badly wanted it. “You’ve been quiet.”
Beautine rose from the shade like a rising curtain. “I have a discovery,” she announced. “The Sun does not exist.”
“I beg your pardon,” said Mr Rao, from the doorway.
“At sunset,” said Beautine. “When the Sun touches the horizon, it has already set. We are looking at its ghost! Light bent by the air! The thing we see is not there at all!”
Memoon was delighted and slightly alarmed. “Beautine, that is a wonderful idea and a wrong one. Let’s make it right. What do we know about the bend?”
She drew a diagram: a curved Earth, a thin shell of air around it, a straight dashed line to where a star would appear without any air, and a curved solid line, bending gently downward, to where the star really is. “The air gets denser as we go down, so its index grows as the ray goes in. Each layer bends the ray a little towards the normal, which is straight down. The ray curves, but our brain assumes it came straight. So we see the star higher than it is. Near the horizon the bending adds up to about thirty-five arcminutes, which is just over half a degree.”
“And the Sun is about half a degree wide,” said Kachui, who had checked. “Thirty-two arcminutes.”
There was a pause.
“So when the Sun’s lower edge looks like it’s touching the horizon,” said Simbha slowly, “the true Sun has already moved down?”
“About its own width,” said Memoon. “The whole Sun is, in fact, a little below the horizon. We see it a couple of minutes longer than we would in a world without air. About two and a half minutes, if you work it out, because the Sun moves across the sky at fifteen degrees per hour. At the equator, thirty-four arcminutes is about two minutes and a bit.”
The air bends starlight, so stars look higher than they are
where the star seems to be true direction of the star thinner air above
denser air below
Observer
About 35 arcminutes (a little over half a degree) at the horizon, zero straight overhead. Bending is greatly exaggerated; Earth and air layers are not to scale.
The air bends starlight, so a star looks higher than it is. Bending greatly exaggerated.
“Then I was right!” said Beautine, spreading her arms.
“You were dramatic,” said Memoon, “which is different. You said the Sun does not exist. The Sun exists. What does not exist is the position where we think the Sun is. The light is real. The place is off by about its own diameter.”
Beautine bowed, sat down, and wrote in the logbook, Sun exists. Sun is slightly later than the Sun. Kachui looked at the entry and quietly crossed out the second sentence and wrote a corrected one.
Simbha had been quiet again, which meant he had been thinking. He pulled the Club’s old photograph album from the bag and opened it to the page where Mr Rao had taped a printed photograph of a sunset taken from the beach, with a proper solar filter on the camera and an adult at the lens. The Sun in the photograph was squashed flat, like a bun, wide and short.
“The bottom edge is bent upward more than the top edge,” said Memoon. “At the horizon the bend is about thirty-five arcminutes. Half a degree higher, it’s about twenty-nine. The bottom of the Sun is lifted a few arcminutes more than the top. So the Sun is squashed vertically by roughly one sixth of its height.”
“Nobody tries to look at that through binoculars,” said Kachui, who read the Club rules aloud every month. “Even a low Sun can burn an eye through a lens.”
“No one does,” said Memoon. “We use photographs, and our own bare eyes only for the Moon.”
Nimo, who had been drifting thoughtfully about the edge of the circle, said, “Memoon. Remember the red Moon? Book 4. The lunar eclipse, when the Moon went the colour of rust.”
Memoon stopped. “I do. We said it was Earth’s shadow. We never explained why the shadow was red and not black.”
“The shadow of Earth is not empty,” said Nimo. “The Sun’s light that just skims the edge of the Earth goes through the air. Doesn’t it bend?”
A slow smile crossed Memoon’s face. “It bends inwards. Through a thin ring of air all around the Earth’s edge, sunlight is turned toward the shadow, by about a degree. And on the way, the blue light is scattered away, as at every sunset, and the red passes through. The Moon in eclipse is being lit by every sunrise and sunset on Earth at once.”
Noodles looked at the sky as if it had played a trick on him. “A ring of sunsets. All of them, bending, bent into the shadow, falling on the Moon.”
“It’s the same air,” said Nimo, with satisfaction. “The same refraction. Only last night, it was a coin in a bucket.”
“And a torch,” said Kachui, who could not help it.
They sat in the heat of midday, with the tank edge dancing in the distance, and finished the entry. Memoon read it back: Twinkling is caused by moving pockets of air of different density bending a star’s light. Planets steady their light by being discs and not points. The Sun at sunset is lifted by about its own width. The red Moon is lit by bent sunlight from Earth’s edge.
“One thing remains,” said Simbha. “The colours. Sirius flashes red and green, and nothing in this answer explains why.”
“Because the air does not bend all colours the same,” said Memoon softly. “Not by much. But the index of refraction depends a tiny bit on colour. I think that is the secret rainbow.”
Nobody asked what she meant. They knew she was not yet sure. She picked up the torch, switched on the beam in the shade, and held a glass of water in front of it, where a faint coloured fringe had appeared at the edge of the shadow on the wall.
“Tomorrow,” she said. “Prisms.”
Science Corner Atmospheric refraction: the air is denser near the ground, so a ray from a star curves as it comes down. We see the star higher than its true position; the effect is zero at the zenith and about 35 arcminutes at the horizon. Twinkling is caused by turbulence: moving cells of air with slightly different refractive index that focus and defocus a star’s light. Stars twinkle because they are essentially point sources; planets show small discs, so their flickers average out. Near sunset the Sun is lifted by about its own diameter and appears flattened because the lower edge is lifted more than the upper edge. During a total lunar eclipse, sunlight is bent through Earth’s atmosphere into its shadow, and the blue light is scattered away, so the Moon looks copper-red. Story note: The angular sizes (Sirius about 0.006 arcsecond, Jupiter about 40 arcseconds) are typical values; Jupiter’s size varies from about 30 to 50 arcseconds. The averaging explanation is a simplification: real scintillation theory involves the size of air cells relative to a telescope or eye aperture, which Chapter 9 touches again. The refraction numbers are standard values for ordinary conditions and change with temperature and pressure. A low Sun is never safe to watch through binoculars or a telescope. Beautine’s “ghost Sun” claim is deliberately exaggerated and then corrected. The ring-of-sunsets picture of a lunar eclipse is a model of the light’s path; the deflection of about one degree is approximate.
Space Detective 1. Explain, using the size of the source and the size of air cells, why a planet at the same height as a star twinkles less. 2. The Sun moves 15 degrees per hour. If refraction at the horizon is 34 arcminutes, estimate how many minutes later the Sun sets than it would in a world with no air. 3. Draw the path of a ray from a star near the horizon through three layers of air of increasing index. Mark the apparent direction of the star and its true direction.
Try it: Shimmer Walk Time: 20 minutes at midday on a sunny day. Adult: An adult should be present, and no one should look at the Sun. You need: a hat, water, a notebook and a sunny open floor or road with a distant straight edge in view. Do: Crouch near the ground and look along a sun-warmed surface at a far straight edge, such as a building or a lamp post. Sketch the edge for one minute and note how far it moves. Then stand up and look at the same edge from head height, and compare how much it shimmers. What to expect: The edge shimmers more when seen low along the warm surface, because the light passes through more warm, turbulent air. This is a model of what starlight does at the horizon. Cloudy or low-resource day: Have an adult use a hairdryer, held well away from water, to blow warm air across a path in front of a printed page seen from two metres away. Limitation: the warm air column is tiny compared with the atmosphere, so it shows the idea but not the scale.
Next time: Prisms split sunlight into colours. Does the sky do the same thing to starlight, and what does the colour tell us?
← Chapter 3: Bending Light · Book 10 contents · Chapter 5: Splitting White Light →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment