Memunic Space Explorers › Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow › Chapter 7: Fingerprints of Light
Chapter 7: Fingerprints of Light
In this chapter: Identify an element from the pattern of its spectral lines, explain why dark absorption lines appear when a continuous spectrum passes through cooler gas, and judge what a spectrum can and cannot say about the composition of a star.
Beautine counted the street lamps on the road in front of the building, which was the kind of job she did when she was nervous.
“Fourteen lamps,” she reported. “Eleven are the new white ones. Three are the old orange ones. The orange ones are at the end of the road, and one of them keeps going off and on.”
“Our one is the third from the end,” said Memoon. “I’ve been looking at it for two evenings with the shoebox. Two lines, very close together, in the yellow-orange. I want to put a number on them.”
Fourteen street lamps, three of them orange.
She held the shoebox against the parapet and read the pixel of the pair against the scale made from the lamp the night before. Kachui read the same scale from behind her shoulder. Beautine wrote down the numbers.
“Five hundred and eighty-nine nanometres,” said Memoon. “Plus or minus two. That is what the scale says.”
“That is almost exactly the wavelength of something very famous,” said Kachui. “Sodium. Sodium atoms in a hot gas give out two lines, at five hundred and eighty-nine point zero and five hundred and eighty-nine point six nanometres. They are so close together that our little instrument sees them as one.”
“So the lamp is full of sodium,” said Noodles.
Kachui lowered his head. “I did not say that.”
“You said sodium makes those lines!”
“I said sodium makes lines at that position,” said Kachui. “What I have seen is one blob at five hundred and eighty-nine, plus or minus two. Other things could make a line near there. One line is a suggestion, not a proof. A fingerprint has many ridges, and identifying a person from one ridge would be careless. Does the lamp show other sodium lines?”
“No other sodium lines are strong,” said Memoon thoughtfully. “But the lamp is the low-pressure type, which gives almost nothing except that one pair. Everything depends on whether we can resolve the pair. We cannot. Our instrument has a two-nanometre limit and the pair is six-tenths of a nanometre apart.”
“Then what is the claim we can make?” said Simbha.
Memoon wrote it carefully. The lamp’s light is nearly all at 589 ± 2 nm. This is consistent with sodium. We have not shown that it is sodium. A better instrument that splits the pair into 589.0 and 589.6 would make the claim much stronger.
“That is how you write a result,” said Kachui, with approval.
Beautine fanned herself dramatically. “I think it’s sodium. I will bet my entire acorn collection.”
“We do not take bets,” said Kachui. “We take lines.”
Mr Rao, who had been listening in the doorway with his tea gone cold, cleared his throat. “If you want to see something that does not need a bet, I have a book in my study. A very old one. It has a picture of the Sun’s spectrum.”
He went and fetched it. The book was heavy, bound in green cloth, and the picture inside it was an extraordinary thing: a long coloured strip, red at one end and violet at the other, as bright and continuous as the shoebox’s torch spectrum, but crossed by hundreds and hundreds of thin dark lines, like a barcode.
“Fraunhofer lines,” said Kachui, breathing the name. “Joseph von Fraunhofer, in Germany in 1814, mapped hundreds of them in sunlight. He did not know what they were. He gave the strongest ones letters. He called the pair in the yellow D.”
Memoon put her finger on the page, on the D lines. “Five hundred and eighty-nine nanometres. The same place as the street lamp.”
There was a pause.
“The lamp has bright lines there,” said Simbha slowly, “and the Sun has dark ones.”
“Why dark?” said Noodles, who found dark lines suspicious.
“Because of three things you can do with a source of light,” said Memoon. She was already writing three rules on the page, and Kachui, who knew them, nodded as she wrote. “First, a hot, dense object gives a continuous spectrum, all colours. Second, a hot, thin gas on its own gives bright lines, only its own colours. Third, if you put a cooler, thin gas in front of a continuous source, the gas takes out exactly its own colours, and leaves dark lines.”
“A gap in the same place as a bright line,” said Simbha.
“Right,” said Memoon. “Sodium gas glowing in a lamp gives bright lines at 589. Sodium gas in front of a bright background takes light away at 589. The wavelengths are the same, because they belong to the atom, not to the situation.”
Three kinds of spectrum, one wavelength scale Hot, dense source: continuous
Hot, thin sodium gas: bright lines
Sunlight: dark (Fraunhofer) lines same place
400 450 500 550 600 650 700 wavelength (nm)
H, K calcium 396.8, 393.4 F H-beta 486.1 C H-alpha 656.3
G iron 430.8 D sodium 589
Only some of the many hundreds of dark lines are shown. Colours are approximate; line positions are true wavelengths. Never point the spectroscope at the Sun: the Sun strip is read from published images.
Three kinds of spectrum on one wavelength scale. Colours approximate.
“This was the thing Gustav Kirchhoff and Robert Bunsen showed in Germany around 1859,” said Kachui. “They found that several of Fraunhofer’s dark lines lined up with the bright lines of heated elements, sodium among them. That meant those elements were in the Sun’s outer layers, the cooler gas above the bright surface. Nobody had ever been able to say what the Sun was made of until then. Many thinkers had said it could never be known.”
“They were wrong,” said Beautine, with satisfaction.
“They were wrong because someone found a way to read it,” said Memoon.
She pointed at the printed strip. “And look at the red end. There is a strong dark line at six hundred and fifty-six point three nanometres. That is hydrogen. And at four hundred and eighty-six, another one: hydrogen again. Hydrogen’s lines come in a family, red, blue-green, blue, violet. If we see that family in a star, hydrogen is in the star’s outer layers.”
“And the other lines?” said Simbha.
“Calcium, iron, magnesium, many more,” said Kachui. “There were so many lines in the Sun that astronomers spent decades labelling them. Each element has its own set, like a fingerprint or a barcode. And the same pattern holds on Earth and in the Sun and in a star a million times further away. The atoms are the same everywhere we look.”
A hush fell over the terrace. Out past the parapet, Sirius had risen above the buildings and was beginning, as always, to flicker and change colour.
“A star I can’t touch,” whispered Beautine, “whose light has travelled for years, and it carries a list of the elements in its air.”
“That list helped find a new element,” said Kachui. “In 1868, during a total solar eclipse seen from India, a French astronomer named Pierre Janssen pointed a spectroscope at the Sun’s edge and saw a bright yellow line that matched no known element. Norman Lockyer in England reached the same conclusion soon after. They called the unknown element helium, after the Greek word for the Sun. It was found on Earth only in 1895.”
“Helium was in the Sun before it was in a lab,” said Simbha, astonished.
“Light carried the news,” said Memoon.
But Kachui, who was more careful than anybody, put his flipper on the page. “Before we celebrate, we should be fair to a woman who got something wrong, and then right. When Cecilia Payne measured stellar spectra at Harvard in the 1920s, she noticed that the Sun’s spectrum was full of metal lines: iron, calcium, magnesium. The simple reading was that stars are made of metals, like Earth. But she saw that the strength of a line does not only depend on how much of an element there is. It also depends on the temperature, because temperature decides how many atoms are in the right state to absorb at that wavelength. Once she corrected for temperature, the metals were rare. Almost everything was hydrogen, with helium next. In 1925 she wrote that the Sun and the other stars are made almost entirely of hydrogen and helium.”
“I know that,” said Noodles. “Book 8.”
“It was very hard to believe in 1925,” said Kachui. “The leading astronomer of the day told her the result was ’clearly impossible’. Her conclusion was confirmed a few years later and is now one of the foundations of astrophysics. The lesson is that a spectrum does not give you a list of ingredients. It gives you evidence, and you have to interpret it with care.”
“Line strength is not the same as abundance,” said Memoon, writing quickly. “That is a warning to myself. I almost wrote: strong sodium line means lots of sodium.”
“You would have been in good company,” said Kachui.
Memoon looked up from the page, thinking about colour. “Remember Book 8: the colour of a star tells its temperature. Sirius is blue-white and very hot. Aldebaran is orange and cooler. Their spectra differ for the same reason. Hot stars show strong hydrogen lines. Cooler orange stars show lots of metal lines. The lines tell composition, temperature and more, but only if we learn to read all three together.”
The terrace was quiet. Down in the road, one of the three orange lamps flickered, went out, and came back on. Noodles said, “Is the old lamp’s sodium running out?”
“The lamp is old,” said Memoon, “and the pair of lines is steady. I’ll keep watching it for the project.”
She turned the shoebox towards Sirius, low over the roofs. In the narrow world of the slit she could make out a thin smear of colour, much too dim to resolve any lines. But she could see that the colour was bluish and the smear was long.
“With a bigger telescope,” she said, “it would show lines. Hydrogen, in a long family of lines. We can’t do that tonight. But I know something we can do. Look, the lines are not always where the textbook puts them.”
“What do you mean?” said Simbha.
“In some stars, they move,” said Memoon. “A few billionths of a metre, from where they should be. And the size of the move tells us how fast the star is going.”
Science Corner Each element gives out and absorbs light at its own set of wavelengths, its spectral lines, a pattern fixed by the structure of its atoms (Book 12 will look inside the atom). A continuous spectrum comes from a hot dense source; a bright-line (emission) spectrum from a hot thin gas; a dark-line (absorption) spectrum when a continuous source shines through a cooler thin gas. These are often called Kirchhoff’s three kinds of spectra. The Sun’s spectrum has hundreds of dark Fraunhofer lines, including hydrogen at 656.3 nm and 486.1 nm and the sodium pair near 589 nm. Matching them to laboratory lines shows which elements are present. Line strength depends on temperature as well as abundance. Cecilia Payne showed in 1925 that stars are mostly hydrogen and helium. Story note: The sodium pair is at 589.0 nm and 589.6 nm; the Club’s instrument cannot separate them, so its claim is limited. Modern lighting is replacing many sodium street lamps with LEDs, whose spectra have no sodium line. The dates given (Fraunhofer 1814, Kirchhoff and Bunsen about 1859, helium in the Sun 1868, Payne 1925) are standard but were checked only against partial sources and are listed in the sources section. The account of Payne is simplified; the full story includes the work of Meghnad Saha on how temperature changes the state of atoms. Do not use any instrument to look at the Sun directly; the Club uses printed spectra.
Space Detective 1. The street lamp’s lines appear at 589 ± 2 nm. Explain why this is “consistent with sodium” but does not prove sodium, and name one extra observation that would strengthen the claim. 2. A cool gas cloud lies in front of a hot bright star. Which kind of spectrum do you expect, and what would be at the same wavelengths as the dark lines if you studied the cloud alone? 3. Sketch the three kinds of spectra, one above the other, with their wavelength scales aligned, and mark where a sodium line would appear in each.
Try it: Street-Lamp Spectra Time: three evenings of 15 minutes. Adult: An adult should go with you for any evening observing, and the spectroscope must never be pointed at the Sun. You need: your shoebox spectroscope, a notebook and a street or room lamp. Do: Calibrate your instrument with a compact fluorescent lamp (436, 546 and about 611 nm). Point it at an orange street lamp, a white LED lamp and a neon sign if one is near. For each, sketch the spectrum, mark the positions in pixels, convert them to wavelengths and state what the evidence supports. Write the claim with its uncertainty. What to expect: A sodium lamp shows one bright yellow-orange line at about 589 nm. A white LED shows a blue spike over a broad hump. A neon sign shows several lines in the orange-red. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use the lamps inside your home and a printed spectrum from a textbook or observatory website. Limitation: indoor lamps are mostly LED or filament, so you will see fewer line spectra.
Next time: The lines of a distant star are never quite in the right place. What does a shifted line say about how the star is moving?
← Chapter 6: The CD Spectroscope · Book 10 contents · Chapter 8: Moving Lines →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment