Memunic Space Explorers › Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow › Chapter 8: Moving Lines
Chapter 8: Moving Lines
In this chapter: Explain the Doppler effect for sound and light, calculate a radial velocity from a measured wavelength shift using v = c × (change in wavelength) ÷ (rest wavelength), and recognise what must be corrected before a measured shift is trusted.
The ambulance came down the road at twenty minutes past eight, and Noodles, who had been silent for nearly a minute, announced his prediction before anyone had asked for one.
“The siren will sound high as it comes, and low as it goes.”
“That is not a prediction,” said Beautine, “that is a thing everyone knows.”
“It is a prediction until it happens,” said Noodles, and they all waited. The wail grew louder, high and thin, rushed past the building with a sudden drop in pitch, and faded into the distance on a lower, calmer note.
“It dropped,” said Simbha. “The pitch dropped at the instant it passed.”
Recording the ambulance siren from the parapet.
“Which is odd,” said Kachui, “because the siren itself did not change. The driver did not slide his finger down a scale. The sound that left the ambulance was the same note all the way.”
“So what changed?” said Memoon. She was already holding Simbha’s old phone, which she had had the foresight to leave recording on the parapet. “Let me look. There is a spectrogram app on this.”
She pulled up the recording and zoomed in on the siren’s strongest sound. The app drew a horizontal line when the note was steady and a sloping stripe when the pitch changed. As the ambulance approached, the stripe sat at about seven hundred and forty-two hertz. As it receded, it sat at about six hundred and sixty hertz. Between those two, a clean step.
“Seven hundred and forty-two, six hundred and sixty,” said Memoon. “A drop of eighty-two hertz. Now I can explain this.”
Nimo’s bubble floated into the circle of the torch. “May I? I have a picture for it.”
“Go on,” said Memoon.
“I drop pebbles into the pond at a steady rate, one every second,” said Nimo. “The ripples go out in circles. If I stand still, the ripples reach the edge at one per second. But if I swim fast to the right while dropping them, I am now catching up with my own ripples on the right. On that side, they are bunched together. On the left, I am swimming away from my own ripples, and they are stretched.”
“Wavelength,” said Kachui. “Squeezed ahead of the moving source. Stretched behind. A listener ahead of the siren receives crests faster. The pitch is higher. A listener behind receives them slower. The pitch is lower.”
Moving source: wave crests bunch up ahead and stretch out behind
longer waves behind moves this way (lower pitch, redder)
shorter waves ahead (higher pitch, bluer)
Star at rest
Star moving toward us: blueshift
Star moving away from us: redshift
400 450 500 550 600 650 700 wavelength (nm) Shift greatly exaggerated. Real shifts are far smaller: 30 km/s moves a hydrogen line by only about 0.066 nm.
The Doppler shift of a spectral line. Shift greatly exaggerated.
“That is the Doppler effect,” said Memoon, “after Christian Doppler, who explained it for waves in Austria in 1842. For a source moving at speed v through air where sound goes at speed c, the pitch ahead is the source pitch times c divided by c minus v. The pitch behind is c divided by c plus v.”
“There’s a trick,” said Kachui, with relish. “Take your two measured pitches, subtract them and divide by their sum. The result is the speed of the source divided by the speed of sound. Try it.”
Memoon did it on the margin of her notebook. “Seven forty-two minus six sixty is eighty-two. Seven forty-two plus six sixty is fourteen hundred and two. Eighty-two over fourteen hundred and two is zero point zero five eight five. Times the speed of sound, three hundred and forty-three metres per second.” She looked up. “Twenty metres per second. Seventy-two kilometres per hour.”
“That is a very quick ambulance,” said Simbha, “in a residential road.”
Mr Rao, passing through the terrace door with a basket of laundry, said mildly, “The speed limit is thirty. It was a medical emergency.” And left.
“The calculation is only as good as the assumptions,” said Kachui. “We assumed the sound speed was three hundred and forty-three. The sound speed in air depends on temperature. We assumed the ambulance moved directly toward and away from us. It came along a road next to our building, so it was slightly sideways, and only the part of its speed along our line of sight counts.”
“Which means the real speed was a little higher,” said Simbha.
“If anything,” said Kachui. “And the sound was only two samples.”
“Fine,” said Memoon happily. “A measurement with honest limits.” She sat back. “Now. What happens to light?”
Nimo’s bubble sank slowly. “Memoon. I have a worry. My ripples are in water. Your siren is in air. Sound needs a medium, remember? Book 5. But light does not. Light crosses empty space. What are the ripples travelling in?”
“That was the worry of physicists too,” said Kachui, “for about a century. In the end the answer was that light does not need anything to travel in, and its speed is the same for every observer. But for the speeds we care about, which are much smaller than the speed of light, there is a simple rule that works. It is the same shape as the one for sound.”
Memoon wrote it down:
change in wavelength ÷ original wavelength = v ÷ c
“Here, v is the speed at which the source and observer move apart along the line of sight, and c is the speed of light, about three hundred thousand kilometres per second. If the source is moving away, the lines in its spectrum move to longer wavelengths. We call that a redshift. If it is coming towards us, they move to shorter wavelengths, a blueshift.”
“The sound analogy fails in one way,” said Kachui, because he could not help it. “For sound, the answer depends on who is moving relative to the air. For light, only the relative motion matters. And at speeds close to the speed of light, the formula needs correction. Today’s stars are slow enough that we can ignore that. Book 12 returns to it.”
Simbha stirred. “So the red end. If a star is moving away, it looks red.”
Memoon laughed. “That is a trap, Simbha, and I almost fell into it as well. The shift is tiny at stellar speeds. Let me show you.” She took the printed hydrogen line from Chapter 7. “The hydrogen line is at six hundred and fifty-six point two eight one nanometres in the laboratory. If a star were moving away at thirty kilometres per second, which is fast, the line would move by six hundred and fifty-six times thirty over three hundred thousand, which is zero point zero six six nanometres. The line would still be red. It would still be at six hundred and fifty-six point three. You could not see the shift by eye. The star does not turn red. Only a spectrograph can see it.”
“So I trusted what it looked like,” said Simbha ruefully.
“You trusted a feeling about what a shift would do,” said Kachui kindly. “Check the numbers first.”
Memoon spread a table on the folding table. It was a sheet from the Club’s data folder, an invented one, drawn up by Kachui, labelled Star W, hydrogen line, observed in January. It gave the measured wavelength as six hundred and fifty-six point three three one nanometres.
“Observed minus rest,” said Memoon. “Six hundred and fifty-six point three three one minus six hundred and fifty-six point two eight one. Zero point zero five zero nanometres.”
“Divide by six hundred and fifty-six point two eight one, multiply by three hundred thousand,” said Beautine, cranking the calculator. “Twenty-two point eight kilometres per second. Star W is moving away at twenty-two point eight!”
“Wait,” said Kachui.
Everyone looked at him. He had a way of saying wait that made even Beautine pause with her paw above the calculator.
“The Earth is moving too,” he said. “It travels around the Sun at nearly thirty kilometres per second. On the night of the observation, a note in the table says, the Earth was moving towards Star W at twenty-eight kilometres per second along the line of sight. That means part of what we measured is the Earth’s own motion.”
“So the measured twenty-two point eight is the combination,” said Memoon slowly. “If the Earth were still, the star’s line would be shifted even more. The Earth’s approach takes about twenty-eight off the redshift. So the star’s own motion relative to the Sun is twenty-two point eight plus twenty-eight. Fifty point eight kilometres per second.”
“That is more than double,” said Simbha.
“If we had not corrected, we would have reported the wrong speed by more than half,” said Memoon. “And in July, the same star measured from the other side of Earth’s orbit would give a different raw number. Real astronomers always correct for Earth’s motion before they quote a star’s speed. It is a procedure, not an optional extra.”
“There’s a second thing the wavelength shift does not give you,” said Kachui. “It tells you only how fast the star moves along the line of sight. If a star moves sideways across the sky, the Doppler effect misses that entirely.”
“Just the radial part,” said Memoon, writing radial velocity. “Toward or away, nothing about sideways.”
Noodles had been silent for some time, and the Club noticed. “I have been thinking about a smaller thing,” he said. “Remember Book 7. A star with a planet wobbles. The star goes a little toward us and a little away as the planet pulls it. The lines must shift, back and forth.”
“They do,” said Memoon, “and that is how many of the first exoplanets were found. But think about the size. Jupiter makes the Sun move at about twelve and a half metres per second. At five hundred and fifty nanometres, the shift is five hundred and fifty times twelve and a half over three hundred million, which is two point three times ten to the minus five nanometres. That is a little over two hundred-thousandths of a nanometre.”
“Our instrument resolves two nanometres,” said Kachui. “The shift is about ninety thousand times smaller than our smallest step.”
“Which is why people build special spectrographs in thermally stable rooms and calibrate them against laser combs,” said Memoon, “and measure down to metres per second. Not with a shoebox.”
“I think a shoebox is very good,” said Beautine loyally.
“It is,” said Memoon. “It’s the right size for the first questions. It’s just not the right size for this one.”
Somewhere beyond the buildings, another siren began, thin and faint. The Club listened, and as it came closer Simbha held up his paw and said, “I can hear the pitch bending. Higher, higher... and there. Lower.”
“The universe is full of things that go past,” said Memoon. “And what we know about them is in the pitch of their light.”
She closed the notebook, then opened it again and wrote one line on a clean page: To read a small shift in faint light, we need detail. That is what telescopes are for.
“Everything we have done,” she said, “depends on seeing fine detail in faint light. A line, a gap, a shift. That is what telescopes are for.”
Science Corner The Doppler effect is the change in observed wavelength or frequency when the source and observer move relative to each other. For sound, a source moving toward you raises the pitch, away lowers it. For light at speeds much less than c: change in wavelength ÷ rest wavelength = v ÷ c. A redshift means the source and observer are moving apart; a blueshift means moving together. Doppler measures only the radial velocity (along the line of sight). Measured velocities must be corrected for the Earth’s motion around the Sun, about 30 km/s, before they are quoted for a star. For a Jupiter-like planet the stellar wobble is about 12.5 m/s, a line shift of about 0.00002 nm at 550 nm, far smaller than a hobbyist instrument can measure. Story note: The siren frequencies and the table for Star W are invented for the story. The sound-speed value of 343 m/s is for about 20 degrees Celsius. The light formula is the low-speed approximation; the relativistic correction matters near the speed of light and is for Book 12. The sound-wave picture of bunched and stretched ripples does not carry over fully to light, which needs no medium. Real astronomers also correct for the star’s and the Sun’s gravitational effects and for the motion of the Sun about the Solar System’s centre; the story keeps only the largest correction.
Space Detective 1. Two measurements of a passing siren give 742 Hz approaching and 660 Hz receding. Use (f1 − f2) ÷ (f1 + f2) = v ÷ c to find the speed of the ambulance, taking c = 343 m/s. 2. A hydrogen line with rest wavelength 656.281 nm is observed at 656.331 nm. Calculate the radial velocity, say whether it is toward or away, and say what correction astronomers would apply before reporting the star’s own speed. 3. Sketch a star with two lines drawn, one for a star at rest and one for a star moving toward us, on the same wavelength axis. Mark the direction of the shift and label it.
Try it: Pitch on the Move Time: 20 minutes. Adult: An adult must be present and everyone must stay well away from traffic. You need: a phone with a free spectrum or tuner app, a safe quiet road or footpath, a notebook. Do: From a safe spot on the pavement, record a vehicle with a steady horn or siren passing at a steady speed. Use the spectrum app to read the frequency just before it passes and just after. Compute (f1 − f2) ÷ (f1 + f2) × 343 m/s and compare with the speed shown on the vehicle’s speedometer if the driver can say. What to expect: The pitch drops by a few percent as the vehicle passes. The computed speed should be close to the true speed, but remember that your road may not be exactly in line with the vehicle’s path. Cloudy or low-resource day: Play a recording of a passing siren from a video website and run the same app on the speaker. Limitation: recorded audio may be compressed or pitch-corrected, and you cannot check the true speed.
Next time: To see a fine line, or a faint star, or a small shift, we need big and sharp telescopes. What makes one telescope better than another?
← Chapter 7: Fingerprints of Light · Book 10 contents · Chapter 9: Bigger Eyes, Sharper Eyes →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment