Skip to main content

Featured

Space Explorers Book 12: Next Adventure

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Next Adventure Next Adventure This is the last book in the Memunic Space Explorers series, so the next adventure is yours. Book 1 began with a small slip of paper in the Question Jar: Where did everything come from? You now know much more about how people go about answering it. You know what light can tell us, how a stretching space leaves its mark, and how careful honesty about what we do not know is part of the science. Turn back to Book 1 and read it again. Notice how much more you see in it now. Then take out a fresh slip of paper and write your own question. Memoon will keep the jar open for you. ← Sources and Fact-check · Book 12 contents Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question , or see all twelve books in the series . Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity .

Space Explorers Book 10: Chapter 9 – Bigger Eyes, Sharper Eyes

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow › Chapter 9: Bigger Eyes, Sharper Eyes

Chapter 9: Bigger Eyes, Sharper Eyes

In this chapter: Compare telescope designs by light-gathering power (proportional to aperture squared) and resolution (about 1.22 × wavelength ÷ aperture), explain why lenses suffer from colour fringes and big telescopes use mirrors, and explain how the atmosphere and space telescopes change what a large aperture can achieve.

Guddu’s face filled the screen of the Club’s laptop, with a mountain behind her and the beginning of an enormous dome.

She was sixteen, with her dark ponytail pulled through the back of a cap, wearing the faded T-shirt she wore for every trip, and she was grinning in the specific way that meant she had been saving something up. “Tell me you can see this,” she said. “Behind me. Behind me!”

Guddu on a video call from the observatory.

“We can see a dome,” said Noodles.

“It’s the observatory! It’s the biggest optical telescope in India,” said Guddu. “Three point six metres across. The mirror, I mean. Not the dome. The dome is much bigger. I’m on a school visit and our guide lets me hold up my phone for twenty minutes if I promise to say the words ’thank you’ every thirty seconds. Thank you,” she added, to somebody off screen.

“A three point six metre mirror,” said Kachui, with immense respect. “Why a mirror, and not a lens?”

“That,” said Guddu, “is why I called you. Ask me nicely and I’ll tell you how the guide explained it. Ask me very nicely and I’ll let you put a question to her.”

Memoon was already scribbling. “Wait. Two things first. Why do you want a big telescope at all? What are we getting by making it bigger?”

“Two things, and they are different,” said Guddu, holding up two fingers. “One is collecting light. The other is sharpness. You’d think they would go together, but they are separate ideas.”

“Collecting,” said Simbha, “is area.”

“Collecting is area,” said Guddu. “The telescope’s mirror is like a bucket under a rain of light. A bigger bucket collects more in the same time. Your eye’s pupil, in the dark, is about seven millimetres wide. The Club’s little telescope is seventy millimetres. How many times more light does it collect?”

Memoon did it in her head. “The ratio of widths is ten. Area goes with the square of width. A hundred times more light.”

“Right,” said Guddu. “And the mirror behind me is three thousand six hundred millimetres. Compared with your eye, that is five hundred times wider, which is about two hundred and sixty thousand times the area. It sees stars two hundred and sixty thousand times fainter than your eye can see.”

“Is that really right?” said Kachui, who distrusted large round numbers. “Seven millimetres is the dark-adapted maximum for a young person. In practice a pupil is smaller and an older eye is smaller still. So the ratio is a rough figure.”

“It is,” said Guddu cheerfully. “But the order of magnitude is right.”

“What about sharpness?” said Simbha.

“That’s the part I love,” said Guddu, and looked straight into the camera, as she did whenever she had something to teach. “Here is a thing that surprises people. Light is a wave. When it goes through a round opening, like the front of a telescope, it doesn’t make a perfect point. It spreads a little, the way ripples spread after going through a gap. The smaller the opening, the bigger the spread.”

“Diffraction,” said Memoon, “from Chapter 6.”

“Exactly!” said Guddu. “There is a smallest blur, depending on the wavelength and the size of the opening. Two stars closer than about one point two two times the wavelength divided by the aperture look like one. Memoon, can you do that for the Club’s telescope? Seventy millimetres, green light.”

Memoon calculated: “One point two two times five hundred and fifty nanometres, divided by zero point zero seven metres. Nine point six microradians. Which is about two arcseconds.”

“So two stars less than about two arcseconds apart will look like a single star in your telescope,” said Guddu. “In a hundred-millimetre telescope the limit is about one point four arcseconds. In the three point six metre mirror it is a fortieth of an arcsecond. That is about thirty-five times finer than a hundred-millimetre telescope can manage.”

Beautine sat up. “That means that a bigger telescope makes stars bigger!”

“Beautine,” said Guddu and Kachui at the same time, as if rehearsed.

“It makes the images smaller,” said Kachui, with the patience of a turtle who has explained this before. “A bigger telescope concentrates light into a tighter spot. In your instrument a star is a blob a couple of arcseconds wide. In a bigger one, it shrinks. The real star hasn’t grown. It is a point either way. The image is only the blur of the instrument.”

“My mistake,” said Beautine, with great dignity, “was one of enthusiasm.”

“What is your mistake with magnification?” said Guddu. “Anyone?”

“You can magnify,” said Memoon, “by the focal length of the main mirror divided by the focal length of the eyepiece. A thousand millimetres divided by twenty-five millimetres is forty times. But magnification cannot recover detail that the aperture never collected. If you push a small telescope to a huge magnification, you just get a bigger blur.”

“There is a rough rule that useful magnification stops at about twice the aperture in millimetres,” said Kachui, “so about one hundred and forty times for a seventy millimetre telescope. After that, the image is bigger and dimmer and no sharper.”

“Right,” said Guddu. “Now the guide wants me to say what she told me about the mirror. Lenses have a problem.” She held up a finger. “Light goes through a lens, and it’s bent. But Chapter 5, you know where this is going.”

“Dispersion!” said Noodles, so loudly the laptop crackled. “Blue bends more than red! A lens makes a prism’s rainbow!”

“A lens focuses blue light a little nearer than red,” said Memoon, thinking out loud. “So the star has a blue halo or a purple fringe, because the colours cannot all be in focus at once. This is chromatic aberration.”

“It spoiled early telescopes,” said Guddu. “Newton built a reflecting telescope in 1668 specifically to avoid it. A mirror reflects every colour at the same angle. The law of reflection doesn’t care about wavelength. Mirrors have no colour fringes. And there’s something else: you can only hold a lens by its edges, because light must go through the glass. A big lens sags under its own weight. A mirror can be supported from behind. That’s why every big modern telescope is a mirror.”

“Chapter 2 and Chapter 3 and Chapter 5, in one answer,” said Simbha, admiringly.

“That’s the point,” said Guddu. “Ideas are not separate drawers. They are one big drawer.”

A voice off-screen said something, and Guddu laughed. “The guide says to ask about the atmosphere, because it ruins everything.”

“The twinkling,” said Memoon, sitting up. “Of course. What does it do to a three point six metre mirror?”

“This is the cruel joke,” said Guddu. “The mirror can in principle make a star into a point a fortieth of an arcsecond wide. But the air blobs we talked about make the star dance by about an arcsecond. Over a long exposure, the star is a blurry spot a second of arc wide or so. That is called seeing. On a good mountain on a good night, it may be about one arcsecond or even better. In a poor site it is two or three.”

“So a three point six metre mirror is no sharper than a twenty-centimetre telescope,” said Kachui, “on an ordinary night.”

“In long exposures with no correction, roughly, yes,” said Guddu. “But the big mirror still collects far more light. So it sees fainter things even if it is not sharper.”

“That is the difference,” said Simbha, “between the two jobs.”

Lens: colours focus at different points Mirror: every colour focuses at one point

one focus

blue focus red focus

colour fringes (chromatic aberration) no colour fringes, because no glass is crossed

Smallest angle each can separate (green light, 550 nm) Shorter bar = sharper. Log scale.

Eye (5 mm pupil) 27.7″

Club telescope, 70 mm 1.98″

150 mm telescope 0.92″

Hubble, 2.4 m (above the air) 0.058″

3.6 m mirror (no air) 0.038″

ground seeing, about 1″ Ideal limits: real instruments do slightly worse. 1″ = 1 arcsecond = 1/3600 of a degree. Not to scale.

Lens or mirror, and how sharp each telescope can be. Log scale; ideal limits.

“Which is why people do two clever things,” said Guddu. “One: put telescopes above the air. Hubble is two point four metres across and orbits above the atmosphere. Its diffraction limit is about six hundredths of an arcsecond, and it actually reaches something close to that. The James Webb Space Telescope has a six point five metre mirror and works in infrared, so it is sharp in its own way. Two: use adaptive optics. A sensor measures how the air is distorting a guide star’s light a thousand times a second, and a thin deformable mirror bends itself to cancel the distortion.”

“Hang on,” said Beautine slowly. “Adaptive optics. It takes the twinkling and un-twinkles it.”

“With a mirror that changes shape faster than the air,” said Guddu. “Yes.”

A silence of real admiration followed, until the guide said something else, and Guddu raised a hand. “Okay, last thing, and then I have to go. There’s another trick. You can use two telescopes far apart and combine their light. Then the resolution is set by the distance between them, not the size of each mirror. They don’t collect more light, but they can tell far

finer details. That is how astronomers measured the size of Sirius. Sirius is not a point. It’s a ball of gas about six thousandths of an arcsecond across. A single telescope can’t see that. A combination of telescopes with mirrors separated by tens of metres can.”

“About a hundred and sixty times smaller than a typical seeing blur,” said Memoon, writing. “Six thousandths of an arcsecond.”

“Which means the whole thing about stars being points isn’t exactly true,” said Kachui. “They are discs, just far too small for any single telescope to see.”

Guddu said her thank-yous, waved, and was gone.

The Club sat on the terrace for a while, with the dark folded over the roofs. Then Memoon stood, collected the small telescope, a seventy-millimetre refractor that the Club had built the winter before, and opened its tripod.

“We have a test,” she said. “Let’s see what our instrument can and cannot do. Simbha, Mr Rao is downstairs. We will want an adult.”

They pointed it, in turn, at the Moon, which was safely rising, and then at Jupiter, which showed as a small bright disc with four tiny dots in a line, and at Sirius. Jupiter, in the eyepiece, danced a little, its edges shivering, but it stayed a disc. Sirius was a blinding point that boiled and flashed, spitting colours.

The 70 mm refractor on Jupiter, with four small moons in a line.

“The planet is a disc even in our tiny telescope,” said Simbha, “and it twinkles less, just as the theory says. The star remains a point and boils.”

“That is a new piece of evidence,” said Memoon, “which has nothing to do with brightness or distance, and everything to do with size. Planets are discs. Stars are points. Our telescope shows that directly.”

She set the telescope down. The question was not quite finished. There was something she had been unable to say since the beginning.

“We have all of the evidence,” she said. “Now we need to ask what we are allowed to claim.”

Science Corner Light-gathering power is proportional to the area of the aperture, so to the square of its diameter. A telescope 10 times wider collects 100 times more light. The resolution limit of a telescope is about 1.22 × wavelength ÷ aperture (in radians). For a 70 mm telescope in green light this is about 2 arcseconds; for a 2.4 m telescope it is about 0.06 arcsecond. Magnification equals the focal length of the main mirror or lens divided by the focal length of the eyepiece, but it adds no detail beyond what the aperture resolves; useful magnification tops out near twice the aperture in millimetres. Lenses suffer from chromatic aberration because glass disperses light; mirrors reflect all wavelengths equally and can be supported from behind, so large telescopes use mirrors. Atmospheric seeing (typically around one arcsecond on a good site) limits ground telescopes without correction; space telescopes and adaptive optics avoid or reduce it. Interferometry combines separated telescopes to resolve finer detail. Story note: The observatory visit is a story scene; the 3.6 m figure for the Devasthal telescope is from the operating institute’s page. The 260,000 times figure assumes a 7 mm pupil and is a rough upper bound. Resolution values assume green light (550 nm) and a perfect, unobstructed circular aperture; real telescopes do slightly worse. Seeing varies with site and night. Sirius’s size of about six thousandths of an arcsecond comes from interferometric measurements. Never point any telescope or binoculars at the Sun.

Space Detective 1. Compare the light-gathering power of a 70 mm telescope with a 7 mm dark-adapted pupil. Then explain why a larger aperture does not make a star look bigger. 2. A 100 mm telescope observes at 550 nm. Calculate its smallest resolvable angle in arcseconds (1 radian = 206,265 arcseconds), then say whether it could separate a double star 1.2 arcseconds apart. Explain what else might prevent it. 3. Draw two telescopes, one with a lens and one with a mirror, with rays of red and blue light. Show why the lens does not bring both colours to the same focus.

Try it: Star Test Night Time: 45 minutes. Adult: An adult must be present for night observing, and no instrument is ever to be pointed near the Sun. You need: binoculars or a small telescope, a sky app, a notebook. Do: Choose a double star listed in a sky app with a separation of a few arcseconds. Calculate the smallest separation your instrument can resolve using 1.22 × 550 nm ÷ aperture. Predict whether you will see two stars. Then check, and note the seeing. What to expect: Pairs wider than your limit appear as two points; pairs near the limit merge. On unsteady nights even wide pairs may blur. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use the Moon’s craters with the naked eye and binoculars to compare detail. Limitation: this tests resolution roughly but does not test seeing or double stars.

Next time: We have light, lines, shifts and sharp images. When can we say what a star is doing or made of, and when should we say we do not know?

← Chapter 8: Moving Lines · Book 10 contents · Chapter 10: What Can We Claim? →

Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers

Continue with Book 10: Memoon and the Secret Rainbow, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CA-7 Job Status and Failure Reason Codes

Here are the various status codes that You may see for jobs in the Queue or Logs in CA-7. R-C0002 R-C0003 R-C0099 R-C0255 R-JCLER A-U0002 A-U0004 A-U0015 A-U0043 A-U4095 A-SOC7 A-U4000 Reason Code/Job Status Code explanation: The indication of the job's current disposition. Values and their meanings are: A-Snnnn-- The job has failed with a system abend. A-Unnnn --The job has failed with a user abend. C-Cnnnn --The job has completed successfully and is going through completion processing. E-ARFATT-- An error occurred during the attempt to attach ARF definitions. This can result if the ARFSET specified is not defined. A diagnostic message may have been written to the CA-7 log, the OS console, or to the trailer queue for the job (in which case it can be displayed using LQ,JOB=x,LIST=ALL). E-ARFERR ---The job encountered an error in the ARF processing. Do a LARFQ command for the job to get more specific information. E-SEGERR --The job has been requeued...

Whistling Winds and Waterfalls: 4 Days of Magic in Shillong

Nestled in the clouds, where the scent of pine trees mingles with the rhythm of waterfalls and the tunes of local guitar-strumming youth—Shillong is more than a place. It’s a vibe. If you’ve got 3 nights and 4 days, you’ve got just enough time to fall in love. Here’s how to make the most of it—food, fun, fog and fantastic views included. Day 1: Shillong, We’re Coming for You! You land in Guwahati, barely out of the airport when the hills start calling. You hop into your cab, Spotify on, windows down, and the three-hour ride to Shillong begins. Just when you think it can’t get better, you stop at Umiam Lake —a lake so calm, it looks like someone ironed the water. By evening, you’re sipping hot chai in Laitumkhrah, maybe nibbling on spicy momos or pork jadoh from a roadside stall. You’re checked into your charming hotel ( Tripura Castle if you fancy old-world royalty, Ri Kynjai if you’re into lakeside poetry). The breeze whispers secrets of waterfalls and pine forests. Sleep well, drea...

Installing and Configuring Hadoop on Ubuntu as a Pseudo Distributed Single Node Cluster

Briefly what is psuedo-distributed single node Hadoop cluster: It is a Hadoop distributed cluster having Single Node. All the five daemons (NN,DN,JT,TT,SNN) are running as individual JVM (java process) instances. We will get all distributed features of Hadoop. This mode is used to develop, test, and staging (before production) Map Reduce programs quickly. It writes all the system, daemon and user logs to different files on the cluster To install Hadoop in this mode, we have to modify the hadoop-env.sh, core-site.xml, hdfs-site.xml, mapred-site.xml. hadoop-env.sh contains all the Environment variables which are required for running Hadoop. All the default values are fine, Only we have to modify the JAVA_HOME=“The location of Java Home Directory” Core-site.xml contains all the cluster specific information like io, temp directory, sorting, file system uri etc. Hdfs-site.xml contains all the parameters which are specific to HDFS like name node directory, data node directory...