Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 4: Falling Around the World
Chapter 4: Falling Around the World
In this chapter: Derive the speed and period of a circular orbit from g = v squared / r, compute them for several heights, explain why higher circular orbits are slower and longer, and see why the satellite’s own mass does not matter.
On Tuesday evening Memoon brought a stopwatch, a ball of string, and, at the last moment, her old pair of roller skates.
“The skates are not for riding,” she told Mr Rao, who had appeared at the top of the stairs with the expression of a man who would very much like to know what the skates were for. “They are for the physics.”
“I have a lot of respect for physics,” said Mr Rao. “I have less for physics on the terrace stairs. If anyone is going round in circles, I would like it to be on this level and with a helmet.”
“Understood,” said Memoon, and put on the helmet.
The Club had arranged itself around the water tank, which for the evening served as a pole. Memoon had tied a length of string around the base of it, wrapped the other end around her wrist and her glove, and then pushed off in a slow arc, with Kachui at her side calling out the time. She travelled in a circle as long as the string, keeping the rope tight, and the faster she moved, the more strongly the string tugged at her wrist. When she slowed, it slackened, and she drifted outward and had to be caught.
“Stop,” said Kachui. “Memoon. What is the string doing?”
She coasted to a halt, flushed. “It is pulling me toward the centre. All the time. If it did not, I would go straight, tangent to the circle, off the terrace. The string keeps changing the direction of my speed. It is a force toward the centre, and it makes me go round.”
“In your book,” said Kachui, “it is a centripetal force. ’Centre-seeking.’ Not a new force. A job that some real force does. For you it was a string. For the Moon it is gravity.”
Memoon on skates, held by a string round the water tank
“And the size of it?” asked Simbha.
“The size of it is mass times v squared over r,” said Memoon. “I worked it out this morning. If something moves at speed v around a circle of radius r, its acceleration towards the centre is v squared over r. Faster means more acceleration. A tighter circle means more as well.”
“Which is where our gravity table comes in,” said Simbha. “For a satellite, the only force that turns it is gravity. So the acceleration that gravity gives, g, must equal v squared over r.”
Memoon was already writing. “g is G M over r squared. So:
G M / r squared = v squared / r
Multiply both sides by r and take the square root.
v = √( G M / r )
“There,” she said. “That is the speed for a circular orbit at distance r from the centre. Notice the satellite’s mass does not appear anywhere. It cancelled again, as it did with Galileo’s balls.”
“So a four-kilogram CubeSat and a four-hundred-tonne space station go at the same speed at the same height,” said Kachui. “A fact that I find enormously reassuring.”
“Let us do SkyClub-1,” said Beautine, with her pencil poised. “At four hundred kilometres. G M is about 3.986 times ten to the fourteen, which Kachui got last night. And r is six thousand seven hundred and seventy-one kilometres, which is 6.771 times ten to the six metres.”
She worked slowly, reading each step aloud. “G M over r is three point nine eight six times ten to the fourteen over six point seven seven one times ten to the six. That is fifty-eight point eight eight million. The square root is seven thousand six hundred and seventy-two metres per second.”
“Seven point six seven kilometres per second,” said Kachui. “Say it again in more useful units.”
Beautine blinked. “Twenty-seven thousand six hundred kilometres per hour. That is, give or take, twenty-two times faster than a passenger jet. And it is about seven times faster than a rifle bullet. And I am not going to be dramatic about it, because the number is dramatic enough.”
Noodles had been listening with his head on one side. “But how long does it take to go round?” he asked. “That is the thing I want to know. Because if it goes that fast, a lap is a flash.”
“The circumference is two π r,” said Memoon. “Two π times six point seven seven one million metres, which is forty-two point five million metres. At seven thousand six hundred and seventy-two metres per second, the time is five thousand five hundred and forty-five seconds.” She checked the stopwatch, as though it might have an opinion. “Ninety-two point four minutes.”
“A lap of the whole Earth in an hour and a half,” said Simbha. “That is a very short day.”
“It is,” said Kachui. “The space station sees sixteen sunrises every twenty-four hours.”
A small, practical silence.
“I want to change something,” said Noodles. “Suppose SkyClub-1 is behind another satellite, and I want to catch it. I fire the engine and go faster. That is how it works. Faster means catching up.”
“Think carefully before you answer that one,” said Memoon. “Remember what we said about the mistake of reaching for the obvious.”
“Faster means catching up. That is the obvious answer.”
“It is not wrong on a road,” said Kachui. “It is wrong in orbit. Look at the formula. v is the square root of G M over r. If you fire your engine and speed up, you do not stay on the same circle. You gain energy and move up. Higher means r bigger. Bigger r means a smaller circular speed. So you end up higher and slower than before, and the satellite you wanted to chase falls ahead of you.”
gravity (inward)
r
velocity v (sideways) Earth
v = √(GM/r) T = 2π √(r³/GM) The only force is gravity, and it keeps turning the path.
The orbit is drawn much higher above Earth than a real 500 km orbit, for clarity. Arrows are not to scale.
A circular orbit: the pull of gravity is always at right angles to the motion. Not to scale.
“That is ridiculous,” said Noodles. “I speed up and I slow down.”
“You speed up at first,” said Memoon, “and then on the higher path you travel slower. It is one of the strangest things about orbits, and astronauts have to learn it. To catch someone ahead, you drop to a lower orbit, where you go faster, and then climb back up.” She drew two circles with arrows and a small dot ahead on the outer one.
“Then speed is a result of the orbit,” said Simbha, “not a free choice. For each height there is exactly one speed that gives a circle.”
“Exactly one,” said Memoon, “for a circle. Other speeds give other shapes. Slower than the circle speed, and the path falls inward toward an ellipse that dips closer. Faster, and the path swings outward on a long ellipse. Chapter 5 will be about that.”
Nimo’s bubble had risen to the rim of the tank. “May I be permitted to be useful?” he asked. “A water analogy, and then the limit.”
“Always,” said Memoon.
“When I swim in a circle, I tilt my fins into the water, and the water pushes me inward. The circle is possible because the water supplies a sideways push. It is a centripetal force.”
“That is fair,” said Kachui.
“But I have to keep moving through the water to keep the push, and the water slows me, so I must keep paddling. Orbits are not like that. There is no drag for a satellite in the vacuum, so no one has to keep pushing. The orbit continues by itself.”
“Which is why I do not need a motor,” said Simbha.
“Which is why you do not need a motor,” agreed Nimo, “for a very long time. In real orbits at low heights there is a little air, even at four hundred kilometres, so a satellite slowly loses energy. We will come back to that in Chapter 7. The analogy with swimming fails exactly at that point.”
Memoon was writing the second formula. “We can also find the period without finding the speed first. The period is T equals two π r over v. Substitute v and square it.”
T = 2 π √( r cubed / G M )
“That is a very interesting formula,” said Kachui softly, and stopped, because he had realised something he did not want to say yet, and he held his tongue until Beautine pushed him.
“It says T squared is proportional to r cubed,” he said. “Just as Kepler found, from Tycho’s data, before anyone had a theory. We will do the real thing tomorrow, with real data.”
They filled the notebook with a table of circular orbits, which Memoon later pinned to the wall of the Club’s cupboard:
Orbit Height Speed Period
Just above the ground (no air, no mountains) 0 7.91 km/s 84.4 min
SkyClub-1 first choice 400 km 7.67 km/s 92.4 min
Typical small satellite 500 km 7.62 km/s 94.5 min
Geostationary 35,786 km 3.07 km/s 23 h 56 min
“The last row,” said Beautine, stopping at it. “That is nearly a day. So a satellite there goes round once for every time the Earth goes round once. It would look as if it were standing still above one spot on the ground.”
“That is a geostationary orbit,” said Memoon. “It is a very special kind. We will use it. But first, we are going to watch a satellite do what the formula says.”
Higher circular orbits are slower and take longer
| 7.91 | 7.67 |
|---|---|
| 8 | 7.62 |
7.35 orbital speed (km/s)
3.07
| 0 km | 400 km | 500 km | 1,000 km | 35,786 km |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Just above | SkyClub-1 | Chosen | Quiz | Geostationary |
| the ground | first choice | orbit | example |
lap: 84.4 min lap: 92.4 min lap: 94.5 min lap: 105 min lap: 23 h 56 min
Heights are above the ground. Speeds and laps are for circular orbits and are rounded.
Orbital speed and lap time for circular orbits. Values rounded.
She turned the laptop around. A satellite-tracking page showed a small bright dot sliding across a chart of the sky, with the word ISS beside it and a time: seven minutes from now, rising in the south-west, passing almost overhead, setting in the north-east.
“Everyone out,” said Simbha. “Adults to the parapet.”
Mr Rao, at the top of the stairs, had a better view than any of them. He was already holding a pair of binoculars, which, Memoon noted with relief, he was pointing at the sky, and not the Sun, which was long below the horizon.
The point of light climbed out of the south-west with a steadiness that no star had. It did not twinkle; they all noticed that, and Memoon said, softly, “Book 10.” It was a steady yellow-white dot, brighter than any star except Sirius, and it went up across the sky like a coin on a wire. They tracked it past the roof, past Orion, past the Pole Star direction. Kachui, stopwatch in flipper, called, “Fist!”
Timing a satellite pass with a fist at arm’s length
Memoon held her fist at arm’s length. A fist seen at arm’s length covers about ten degrees of sky. “Start,” she said, when the dot reached its left edge. The dot crossed in under ten seconds. “Stop.”
“Nine point two,” said Kachui.
“About one degree per second,” said Memoon. “Near the zenith, at four hundred kilometres. And the formula says that the angular speed straight overhead is v over h: seven thousand six hundred and seventy metres per second, divided by four hundred thousand metres, is point zero one nine two radians per second, which is just over a degree per second.” She breathed out. “It matches. We just measured the speed of the space station from a terrace, with a fist and a stopwatch, and the answer agrees with the theory to within the error of a fist.”
“Try telling that to the physics teacher,” said Beautine.
“I have,” said Memoon. “Her name is Kachui.”
The dot dipped behind the last roof and went out, not by setting but by entering Earth’s shadow, which was a different kind of disappearance. Down on the stairs, Mr Rao lowered the binoculars very slowly.
“That,” he said, with a quietness that surprised everyone, “was the nicest thing I have seen in a long time. And nobody was in the way of the stairs.”
Science Corner
For a circular orbit, gravity supplies the centripetal force: G M m / r squared = m v squared / r. This gives orbital speed v = √(G M / r), independent of the satellite’s mass. The orbital period is T = 2 π r / v = 2 π √(r cubed / G M). T squared is proportional to r cubed. Higher circular orbits are slower and take longer. Speeding up in orbit does not make you catch up; it raises the orbit. To catch up, go lower, where speeds are higher, then climb. Worked problem (maths track): SkyClub-1 at 500 km. r = 6.871 × 106 m. v = √(3.986 × 1014 / 6.871 × 106) = 7.62 × 103 m/s. T = 2 π r / v = 5,666 s = 94.4 min. Concept track: each height has one circular speed; higher is slower and a longer lap. G M for Earth, written GM, is about 3.986 × 1014 m cubed per second squared, known more precisely than G or M separately. Story note: The skating demonstration shows that a centripetal force can come from a string; gravity plays the same role for a satellite, but gravity acts through empty space and needs no contact. The swimming analogy fails because water drags and a vacuum does not; at 400 km a little air still slows a satellite over time. The station’s mean altitude changes by tens of kilometres over time, and its published period of about 92 to 93 minutes is for heights near 420 km. The fist estimate is rough, because a fist subtends about 10° only approximately and the ISS rarely passes directly overhead; the match is within the accuracy of the method. Nobody should use binoculars on the Sun; here it is night and the binoculars are pointed at a satellite.
Space Detective 1. Derive v = √(G M / r) starting from the equation G M m / r squared = m v squared / r. Explain why the satellite’s mass cancels. 2. A satellite is moved from a 500 km orbit to a 1,000 km orbit. Without calculating, say whether its circular speed rises or falls, and whether its period rises or falls. Then calculate both using G M = 3.986 × 1014. 3. Noodles wants to catch a satellite just ahead of him in the same orbit. Describe in words what he should do with his engine, and explain what happens to his speed and height at each step.
Try it: Fist and Stopwatch Time: 30 minutes outdoors in the evening, after a pass is predicted by a satellite-tracking site or app. Adult: An adult must come with you for night watching.
You need: a stopwatch, a notebook, a clear sky and a view of the pass path. Do: Look up a bright pass of the International Space Station for your location. Hold your fist at arm’s length; it covers about 10°. As the dot passes near the highest point of its path, start the stopwatch when it enters the fist and stop when it leaves. Repeat across several passes if you can. Compute the angular speed in degrees per second. What to expect: Near the top of a high pass the time to cross a fist is around 9 to 10 seconds, giving close to 1 degree per second. Lower passes are slower and farther away, and give smaller angular speeds. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use a free tracking website or planetarium app to watch the dot move at a known rate, or ask a friend to time a small coin rolled along a long table. Limitation: the app shows the path, not your own measurement; a rolling coin shows steady speed but not an orbit.
Next time: We have found the speed and period of a circle. But Kepler found a pattern in the planets before there was any theory. Can the Club rediscover the laws from raw data?
← Chapter 3: The Strength of Gravity · Book 11 contents · Chapter 5: Kepler’s Three Rules →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment