Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 5: Kepler’s Three Rules
Chapter 5: Kepler’s Three Rules
In this chapter: State Kepler’s three laws, test the third law against planetary data, and explain why a planet moves faster when it is closer to the Sun, using only what the data and gravity show.
On Wednesday Kachui arrived with a table and an apology.
“The table is real,” he said, spreading a sheet across the Club’s folding desk. “The apology is because I am about to make you do arithmetic for an hour.”
“I like arithmetic when it is hiding something,” said Beautine.
“It is hiding something very large. Four hundred years ago, a man named Johannes Kepler had a pile of numbers like these and no idea what they meant. He spent years on them. We have a calculator and an evening.”
The table listed six planets. For each one it gave the average distance from the Sun, in a unit called the astronomical unit, or AU, which is the average distance from Earth to the Sun, about 150 million kilometres (a light-year, from Book 6, is a far bigger distance, about 63,000 AU), and the time the planet takes to go once around, in Earth years.
Planet Distance a (AU) Period T (years)
Mercury 0.387 0.241
Venus 0.723 0.615
Earth 1.000 1.000
Mars 1.524 1.881
Jupiter 5.203 11.86
Saturn 9.537 29.46
“Farther planets take longer,” said Noodles. “I can see that. It is obvious. Can I go home?”
“Farther planets take longer because they have more road to cover,” said Memoon, “and because they go slower. That is Chapter 4. But Kepler wanted the exact rule, and ’longer’ is not a rule. Is it twice as far, twice as long? Look at Mars. A bit more than one and a half times as far, but nearly twice the time. So it is not proportional.”
“Try squares,” said Simbha, who had done this exercise at school and had never forgiven it. “Square the period. Cube the distance. See what happens.”
They divided the labour. Beautine did the cubes, because she liked the big numbers, and Memoon did the squares, and Noodles was permitted to press the equals sign. After ten minutes the sheet looked like this:
Planet a cubed T squared
| Mercury | 0.058 | 0.058 |
|---|---|---|
| Venus | 0.378 | 0.378 |
Earth 1.000 1.000
Mars 3.54 3.54
Jupiter 140.8 140.7
Saturn 867.4 867.9
Nobody said anything for a moment.
“They are the same,” said Noodles at last. “Every row. The two columns are the same. This is a trick.”
“It is not a trick,” said Kachui. “It is the third of Kepler’s laws. T squared divided by a cubed is the same number for every planet around the Sun. In these units, the number is one.”
“Wait,” said Noodles. “The columns are not identical. Saturn is 867.4 on one side and 867.9 on the other.”
“Good catch,” said Kachui. “And?”
Noodles frowned. “Rounding? The distances are written with four figures. If you change the last digit of 9.537 a little, the cube changes by a few tenths at this size.”
“That is correct,” said Memoon. “The measurements are good to about four figures, so the third law holds to that accuracy. If I told you the match was perfect to ten figures, I would be claiming more than the table supports.”
Beautine tapped the sheet. “And it holds from Mercury to Saturn. A planet that goes round in less than three months and one that takes nearly thirty years. All on one rule.”
“Remember Chapter 4,” said Memoon. “We derived T equals two π times the square root of r cubed over G M. Square it and you get T squared equals four π squared over G M, times r cubed. The thing in front of r cubed depends only on the central object. Here it is the Sun. That is why every planet has the same ratio. Kepler found the pattern from data. Newton, seventy years later, showed why it must be so, for a circle at least.”
“For a circle,” said Kachui. “Planets do not move in circles.”
Beautine looked up. “They don’t?”
The data hunt: tables, pins and a loop of thread
“This is where Kepler’s story gets interesting,” he said, and settled in a way that suggested he had been waiting.
He told it carefully. A Danish astronomer named Tycho Brahe built large instruments and spent decades measuring where the planets were, night after night, with no telescope. His measurements were accurate to about one arcminute, which is one-sixtieth of a degree, about the width of a pencil seen from a long way off. Kepler took the Mars data after Tycho died and tried to fit it with circles. He tried for years. The best circle he found left an error of about eight arcminutes, a small gap, but eight times larger than Tycho’s measuring error.
“Eight arcminutes,” said Memoon. “A small number.”
“A small number he refused to ignore,” said Kachui. “He trusted Tycho’s data over his own favourite idea. He wrote that those eight minutes would lead to a new astronomy. And they did. He published the first two laws in 1609 and the third in 1619.”
Memoon was drawing. “First law: the orbit of a planet is an ellipse, with the Sun at one focus.”
“What is an ellipse?” asked Noodles, who was beginning to enjoy himself against his better judgement.
Kepler's third law: T² = a³
Saturn period, T (years), logarithmic scale
Jupiter
Mars
Earth Venus
Mercury 0.2
0.5 1 2 5 10
average distance from the Sun, a (AU), logarithmic scale The dots lie on a straight line of slope 3/2 on these scales, which is the same as T² = a³. Data rounded to 3 or 4 figures.
Kepler’s third law with data for six planets. Both scales are logarithmic.
“A squashed circle,” said Memoon. “Technically, it has two special points called foci, and every point on the ellipse has the same total distance from the two foci. If you pin a loop of string over two nails and keep it tight with a pencil, you can draw one. When the foci come together, you get a circle. When they pull apart, the ellipse gets longer.”
“Is the Sun at the middle?” asked Beautine.
“At one of the foci. The other focus is empty space. Not at the middle.”
“So the planet is sometimes closer to the Sun and sometimes farther,” said Simbha. “That is the first claim.”
“And a measure of how squashed it is,” said Kachui, “is called the eccentricity, e. A circle has e equal to zero. Earth’s orbit has e equal to about 0.017. That is very nearly a circle. If you drew it on a sheet of paper a metre wide, you could not tell it from a circle by eye. Mars has e about 0.09. Halley’s Comet has e about 0.97, a long thin loop.”
“Then Earth is closest to the Sun sometimes,” said Beautine slowly, “and farthest at other times. Does that give us the seasons?”
Memoon laughed. “That is one of the great traps. Earth is closest to the Sun in early January, when it is winter in the northern hemisphere, at about 147 million kilometres. It is farthest in early July, at about 152 million, when it is summer in the north. The difference is about three percent.
Seasons come from the tilt of Earth’s axis, not from the distance. We will not need seasons for our satellite, but I do not want anyone to leave this terrace with that wrong idea in their head.”
“Noted,” said Beautine. “With some embarrassment.”
“Second law,” Memoon went on. She drew the Sun at one focus and an ellipse around it, and then drew two long thin wedges, one from the near part of the orbit and one from the far part. “A line from the Sun to the planet sweeps out equal areas in equal times.”
Noodles looked at the two wedges. “They don’t look equal.”
The shape of an orbit: an ellipse
planet
Sun (one focus)
| perihelion | empty focus | aphelion |
|---|---|---|
| (closest) | (farthest) |
the two orange lines always add up to 2a
long axis = 2a (a is the semi-major axis)
Eccentricity e = c/a: here 0.6, drawn large to show the shape. Earth’s real orbit has e = 0.017, almost a circle.
The anatomy of an ellipse. The eccentricity is exaggerated.
“One is long and thin, and the other short and fat,” said Memoon. “That is the point. In the same time interval, they have the same area. When the planet is near the Sun, the line is short, so the planet has to travel a longer arc to sweep the same area. That means it moves faster near the Sun. When it is far, the line is long, so a short arc is enough, and the planet moves slowly.”
“That matches Earth,” said Kachui, pulling out a calculator. “At closest approach Earth moves at about 30.3 kilometres per second. At the farthest point, about 29.3. A difference of three percent, matching the ratio of the distances.”
“Why?” asked Noodles. “What makes it speed up?”
Memoon went quiet. “I do not know,” she admitted. “Not properly. I know that the area law is equivalent to a thing called angular momentum staying the same. I read it in a book last week and could not follow the proof. When the planet falls toward the Sun, the pull has a component along its motion, so it speeds up. That much I understand. But why the speed up matches the areas so exactly, I cannot yet explain.”
“That is allowed,” said Kachui. “We will use the second law as an observed fact for now. We will give it a reason in a later chapter, with energy.”
Nimo, who had been unusually quiet, rose to the top of the tank. “I have a test of the third law,” he said, “if you would like one that does not come from a table.”
“Go ahead.”
“Take a satellite orbiting Earth. The same rule applies, but with a different number in front. Instead of 1 AU and 1 year, use kilometres and hours. For Earth, T squared over r cubed is the same for every satellite. SkyClub-1 at 6,771 kilometres takes 92.4 minutes. The Moon, at 384,400 kilometres, takes 27.3 days. If Kepler is right, the ratio of T squared to r cubed should come out the same.”
Kepler's second law: equal areas in equal times
Sun
near the Sun: short, wide wedge, fast motion far from the Sun: long, thin wedge, slow motion
Both wedges are swept in the same time, and they have the same area. Eccentricity is drawn large (0.6) so the effect is easy to see.
Kepler’s second law. Both wedges are swept in equal time. Eccentricity exaggerated.
They did the sum. Minutes into days, kilometres into the same units. Kachui checked it twice.
“T squared over r cubed for SkyClub-1: (92.4 min) squared divided by (6,771 km) cubed, which is 8,538 over 3.104 times ten to the eleven, which is 2.75 times ten to the minus eight, in minutes squared per kilometre cubed. For the Moon: (27.3 days times 1,440 minutes per day) is 39,312 minutes. Square it: 1.545 times ten to the nine. Cube 384,400: 5.680 times ten to the sixteen. The ratio is 2.72 times ten to the minus eight.” He looked up. “The same, to about one percent.”
“One lonely kilogram of metal and the whole Moon on the same rule,” said Simbha.
“That is the third law at its best,” said Memoon. “It lets us find a mass. If we know a distance and a period, we get G M. That is how people weighed the Sun and the Earth. Not on scales, but by the Moon, and the planets, and satellites going round.”
“A quick trick,” said Beautine, with her pencil. “If I find a new moon around a planet, and I measure how long it takes to go round and how far away it is, I can find the planet’s mass. Without ever touching the planet.”
“Exactly,” said Memoon, and it came out more quietly than she had intended.
Mr Rao appeared at the top of the stairs with a tray of tea and a plate of biscuits, which he set down on a stool with an air of ceremony.
“You’ve been quiet,” he said. “Usually when you’re quiet, there’s either a very good idea or a broken lamp.”
“A very good idea,” said Memoon. “Several hundred years old.”
“Those are the best kind,” said Mr Rao. “May I take a biscuit?”
Beautine passed the plate. Kachui folded the table. On the back, in pencil, Memoon wrote three lines:
- Orbits are ellipses with the central body at one focus. 2. A line from the central body to the orbiting body sweeps equal areas in equal times. 3. T squared is proportional to a cubed.
Below, in smaller letters: These are what is seen. Gravity is why.
Science Corner Kepler’s first law: a planet’s orbit is an ellipse with the Sun at one focus. The eccentricity e measures how stretched it is: e = 0 is a circle; Earth’s e is about 0.017, Mars about 0.09, Halley’s Comet about 0.97. Kepler’s second law: the line from the Sun to a planet sweeps equal areas in equal times, so a planet moves fastest at its closest point (perihelion) and slowest at its farthest (aphelion). For Earth, about 30.3 km/s and 29.3 km/s. Kepler’s third law: T squared is proportional to a cubed, where a is the semi-major axis (half the long width of the ellipse). In years and AU, T squared = a cubed for planets around the Sun. For Earth satellites the constant differs, because it depends on the central mass: T squared = (4 π squared / G M) a cubed. Worked problem (maths track): A hypothetical planet has a = 4.00 AU. T squared = 4.00 cubed = 64, so T = 8.0 years. Concept track: farther away means a longer year, and the year grows faster than the distance. The laws describe motion; Newton’s gravity explains it. Tycho’s data came first, the laws second, the explanation third. Story note: Kepler’s laws are empirical rules found from data; Newton later derived them from gravity for a two-body system. The ’string and pins’ ellipse is a drawing method, not how planets form orbits. The wedge picture exaggerates the eccentricity: a real planetary orbit such as Earth’s looks nearly circular. Planet data are rounded to about four figures, so matches such as 867.4 and 867.9 agree within that rounding rather than exactly. The Sun is treated as fixed at the focus; in truth, the Sun and
planet both orbit their shared centre of mass, which for the Sun lies very close to the Sun’s centre. Distances are mean values; dates of perihelion and aphelion shift by a day or so between years. The Moon and SkyClub-1 comparison is accurate to roughly one percent with these round numbers.
Space Detective 1. Mars has a = 1.524 AU. Use Kepler’s third law to find its period in years, and compare with the table. 2. Earth moves faster in January than in July. Use Kepler’s second law to explain why, and say what this does and does not tell you about the seasons. 3. A new moon orbits a distant planet at a distance of 100,000 km with a period of 2 days. Explain in words how this information can give you the planet’s mass, and why you would not need to visit the planet.
Try it: Draw an Ellipse Time: 20 minutes. Adult: An adult must handle the pins. You need: a sheet of paper, a piece of cardboard under it, two pins or thumbtacks, a loop of thread about 20 cm long, and a pencil. Do: With an adult’s help, push the two pins into the paper and cardboard about 6 cm apart. Place the loop of thread around both pins. Pull the thread tight with the pencil tip and move the pencil all the way around, keeping the thread tight. Draw a second ellipse with the pins 3 cm apart, then one with the pins together. Measure the longest and shortest width of each. What to expect: With the pins far apart you get a long thin ellipse; closer together, a rounder one; with the pins together, a circle. Eccentricity grows as the pins move apart. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use a drawing app with an ellipse tool, or trace around the bottom of a tilted glass on a sheet of paper. Limitation: the app and glass give a shape but not the two foci or the constant string length; this activity is not weather-dependent in any case, so the indoor version is the main one.
Next time: The third law ties an orbit’s size to its time. If a moon’s distance and lap time can tell us what it orbits, can the Club weigh a whole world without ever touching it?
← Chapter 4: Falling Around the World · Book 11 contents · Chapter 6: Weighing a World →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment