Skip to main content

Featured

Space Explorers Book 12: Next Adventure

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Next Adventure Next Adventure This is the last book in the Memunic Space Explorers series, so the next adventure is yours. Book 1 began with a small slip of paper in the Question Jar: Where did everything come from? You now know much more about how people go about answering it. You know what light can tell us, how a stretching space leaves its mark, and how careful honesty about what we do not know is part of the science. Turn back to Book 1 and read it again. Notice how much more you see in it now. Then take out a fresh slip of paper and write your own question. Memoon will keep the jar open for you. ← Sources and Fact-check · Book 12 contents Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question , or see all twelve books in the series . Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity .

Space Explorers Book 11: Chapter 9 – Low or High?

Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 9: Low or High?

Chapter 9: Low or High?

In this chapter: Compare a low Earth orbit with the geostationary orbit using period, ground-station contact time, signal delay, signal strength, Doppler shift and launch energy, and choose an orbit class for SkyClub-1 by weighing several criteria rather than one.

Guddu called on Sunday afternoon, which was not the arrangement, and she looked as though she had been running.

“Sorry,” she said. Her face filled the laptop screen, one strand of dark hair escaping from the ponytail under her cap. “I have news and a problem. The news is good. Our school has been accepted for the contest. The problem is I told the judges we had an orbit design, and we do not.”

“We have most of one,” said Memoon.

“We have numbers,” said Guddu. “I need a decision. The judges want one page that says: this orbit, because of these reasons. And the reasons have to be better than ’it sounded nice.’”

“Then we shall give them reasons,” said Kachui. He had opened a fresh page and ruled it into columns with a ruler, which he did only for what he called serious comparisons. “Tell us the constraints first.”

Guddu held up a sheet. “One. The satellite is four kilograms. Three U. Two. We have one ground station, the school roof, with a simple antenna that does not move. We cannot afford a motor. Three. The instrument needs to be above the twinkling air, and it needs power for about half an hour of observing every day. Four. The contest says the satellite must send us at least one message a day.”

A call with Guddu: low or high?

“Four constraints,” said Memoon, writing. “And two possible kinds of home. A low orbit, like the space station, a few hundred kilometres up. Or a high one, like the geostationary orbit we met in Chapter 4, where it seems to hang above one spot.”

“Geostationary,” said Beautine at once, joining the call from the stairs with a mouthful of toast. “It hangs there. It never moves. Your dish never has to move. The school does not need a motor. Problem solved.”

“That sounds right,” said Guddu. “Doesn’t it?”

“It sounds right,” said Kachui. “Which is why we should test it. Let us compare the two homes on the same list. Same questions, same units.”

He began a table in the notebook. They filled it in together, one row at a time, with Memoon doing the arithmetic and Kachui checking it.

Row one: how long is a lap? Low orbit at 500 kilometres: 94.5 minutes, so about 15 laps a day. Geostationary at 35,786 kilometres: 23 hours 56 minutes, matching one turn of Earth, which is why it seems to stand still.

“Notice,” said Memoon, “that it is not standing still. It is moving at 3.07 kilometres per second. It only seems still from the ground, because the ground is turning at the same rate. ’Stationary’ is a statement about how it looks from Earth.”

“That’s a good thing to correct,” said Beautine, and wrote it on her toast bag.

Row two: how long can the school see it? Memoon sketched a circle for Earth and a smaller circle for the orbit and drew two lines from the school’s roof, one at each edge of the visible sky. She set the minimum useful angle above the horizon at ten degrees, because buildings and trees get in the way lower down.

“At 500 kilometres, the satellite is visible only while it is within about 14° of arc of the school, measured round the Earth. That is 28° in all, about 7.8 percent of the orbit. Of a 94.5 minute lap, that is 7.4 minutes at the very most, and only if the satellite passes straight overhead. Most passes are lower and shorter, from two to seven minutes. And only some of the laps pass anywhere near the school, because Earth turns underneath the orbit. So perhaps four to six useful passes a day, adding up to roughly twenty to thirty minutes.”

“Twenty or thirty minutes a day out of 1,440,” said Kachui. “About two percent.”

“Geostationary,” said Memoon, “is visible all the time, from any place that can see it. That is 100 percent.”

“Then geostationary wins,” said Beautine.

“We are on row two of six,” said Kachui.

Row three: how long does a message take? Radio waves travel at the speed of light, 299,792 kilometres per second. From 500 kilometres straight above, one way takes 1.7 thousandths of a second. From a geostationary satellite, straight above the equator, 35,786 kilometres away, one way takes 0.119 seconds. A signal going up and coming back down takes about a quarter of a second, and a question with its answer takes nearly half a second.

“That’s why there’s a pause on the satellite telephone,” said Guddu slowly. “When my uncle calls from the ship. He talks, and then there’s a gap, and then I hear him.”

“A real effect,” said Kachui. “Half a second is enough to make a conversation awkward. For our purposes, a message once a day, the delay does not matter at all.”

“So that row is a draw,” said Beautine.

“A draw for us,” said Kachui. “It would not be for someone steering a robot.”

How long is a low satellite in view? Orbit at 500 km, station sees it above 10° elevation: about 28° of its orbit, at most 7.4 min per pass.

visible part of the orbit

sight lines 10° above the horizon

horizon ground station

Drawn to scale for the height of the orbit (Earth radius 900 units, orbit 971 units); only the part of Earth near the station is shown.

A pass over a ground station, drawn to scale for the orbit height. Only the part of Earth near the station is shown.

Row four: how strong is the signal? This was the row that made everyone stop.

“The signal spreads out as it travels,” said Memoon. “Like the light from a lamp. Twice as far, one quarter as strong. That is the inverse square law, the same one we used for gravity in Chapter 3. At 35,786 kilometres compared to 500 kilometres, the distance is 71.6 times larger. So the signal power is 71.6 squared times smaller. That is about 5,100.”

“Five thousand times weaker,” said Guddu.

“If the transmitters have the same power and the same antennas, yes,” said Memoon. “A four-kilogram satellite has a battery the size of a cola can. It cannot afford a big transmitter. At low orbit, a small radio is enough. At geostationary distance, you would need a much bigger dish on the satellite or on the ground, or a much stronger transmitter. Both cost weight and power.”

“The school does not have a big dish,” said Guddu.

“And your satellite weighs four kilograms,” said Kachui. “Row four goes to the low orbit.”

Row five: the Doppler shift. Nimo’s bubble came up beside the screen, and Guddu’s eyes widened at the sight of a fish who could talk. Memoon introduced them in one breath, and Nimo gave a polite flick of his fin.

“May I say something about the radio?” he said. “You studied the Doppler effect in Book 10. A moving source changes the pitch of its sound, or the frequency of its radio waves, depending on whether it comes towards you or goes away. My pond analogy is a boat that makes ripples. Ahead of it, the ripples bunch up. Behind it, they stretch.”

“The analogy has a limit,” said Kachui, getting in first for once.

“It does,” said Nimo, mildly. “My ripples move through water, and the boat moves faster or slower through the same water. Radio waves need no medium, and the effect depends only on the relative speed of source and receiver. But as a picture of bunching and stretching, it works.”

“Do the numbers,” said Memoon.

Kachui did. The satellite at 500 kilometres moves at 7.62 kilometres per second, and the speed along the line of sight, at its largest when the satellite is near the horizon, is about 7 kilometres per second. That is its radial velocity, the part of the motion along the line of sight. For a small satellite transmitting at 437 megahertz, a common amateur radio frequency, the shift is the frequency times the speed over the speed of light: 437 million times 7,000 over 299,792,000. That is about 10,000 hertz, plus or minus. Ten kilohertz up as it approaches, ten kilohertz down as it leaves.

“So Guddu’s receiver has to follow the frequency as the satellite passes,” said Kachui, “or it will lose the signal.”

“A geostationary satellite barely moves relative to the ground,” said Memoon. “Its Doppler shift is almost nothing. Another point for geostationary.”

“I like that the problem is getting complicated,” said Guddu. “It means we’re doing it properly.”

Row six: what does it cost to get there? Memoon had prepared this one. Reaching a 500-kilometre orbit, she said, takes about 3.3 times ten to the seven joules for every kilogram. Reaching geostationary needs about 5.8 times ten to the seven joules per kilogram. That is about 75 percent more energy in the best case. And a CubeSat rideshare rocket does not take small satellites to geostationary orbit at all. Almost all of them go to low orbit.

“So we cannot even choose it,” said Guddu.

“The row is not ’which is better,’” said Kachui. “It is ’which can you actually do.’ That matters in engineering.”

He put down his pen and looked at the table.

Question Low orbit (about 500 km) Geostationary

Lap time 94.5 min 23 h 56 min

Contact with school about 20 to 30 min a day continuous

Signal delay (one way) about 2 ms about 0.12 s

Signal strength about 5,000 times stronger much weaker

Doppler shift at 437 MHzup to about +/- 10 kHzalmost none
Energy to reach, per kgabout 3.3 × 10 Jabout 5.8 × 107 J

“Neither wins,” said Beautine, reading it. “I thought one would.”

“That is the real lesson,” said Kachui. “Orbits are not good or bad. They are good for something.”

“Then what is ours good for?” asked Guddu.

“A small, low-power satellite that reports once a day,” said Memoon, “to a simple ground station. Low orbit gives you signal strength and a cheap launch. It costs you contact time and a Doppler shift. Those we can manage. You need a receiver that follows the frequency, and an antenna you can point by hand, or a cheap tracking mount.”

“There is one more thing,” said Kachui. “At 500 kilometres, the satellite spends about a third of every lap in Earth’s shadow. Up to 36 minutes out of 94.5. The solar panels make nothing there.”

“So we need a battery for the dark part,” said Guddu, scribbling.

“And that brings us to the last question,” said Memoon. “We have decided on a low orbit. But how does a four-kilogram satellite get from the ground to 500 kilometres and be moving at the right speed in the right direction? That is the part we have not touched. The rocket delivers it, but where, and how?”

Guddu looked at the table for a long moment.

“I think,” she said, “you’re about to tell me that the answer is a curve.”

“An ellipse,” said Memoon.

“Of course it is,” said Guddu, and for the first time that afternoon, laughed.

Science Corner Low Earth orbit (LEO): a few hundred to about two thousand kilometres up. A 500 km orbit has v = 7.62 km/s and T = 94.5 min, about 15 laps a day. A ground station sees it only for a few minutes per pass (at most about 7.4 minutes at 10° minimum elevation).

Geostationary orbit (GEO): r = 42,164 km from Earth’s centre, 35,786 km above the equator. v = 3.07 km/s, T = 23 h 56 min (one sidereal day). It appears fixed in the sky from the ground because it turns with Earth. Signal delay: radio travels at 299,792 km/s. One way from 500 km takes about 1.7 ms; from GEO about 0.12 s. Inverse square law for signals: received power falls as 1/distance squared. GEO is about 71.6 times farther than 500 km, so signal power is about 5,100 times lower. Doppler shift: df = f x v(line of sight) / c. At 437 MHz and v of about 7 km/s, the shift is about 10 kHz either way. Energy to reach (ideal, per kg): LEO (500 km) about 3.3 × 107 J, GEO about 5.8 × 107 J. A satellite in LEO may spend up to about 36 minutes of each lap in Earth’s shadow. Worked problem (maths track): The delay for a signal going up to GEO and back to the ground is 2 × 35,786 km / 299,792 km/s = 0.239 s. Concept track: the farther away a satellite is, the longer a message takes and the weaker it is. Story note: The contact-time figure is a rough estimate that ignores Earth’s rotation and the exact orbit plane; real passes vary with the station’s latitude and the satellite’s path. The Doppler figure uses the largest line-of-sight speed at the horizon and a typical amateur frequency; it assumes a circular orbit and ignores Earth’s rotation. Nimo’s ripple picture fails because radio waves need no medium. The energy figures are ideal and leave out air drag, rocket losses, and the extra energy needed to move into the equatorial plane. ’Stationary’ is a statement about how the satellite looks from Earth’s surface, not about its speed. The shadow time depends on the season and the orbit’s orientation.

Space Detective 1. The signal from a satellite at 500 km is compared with one from GEO. By what factor does the received power change, and which law explains it? Show the calculation. 2. A geostationary satellite is described as ’not moving’. Correct this in two sentences, giving its actual speed. 3. Choose between LEO and GEO for a small school satellite that sends one message a day, using at least three of the six rows in the table, and say which row you think matters least.

Try it: Pass Planner Time: 25 minutes. Adult: An adult must come with you if you decide to watch a pass outside after dark; the tracking part can be done indoors in the daytime.

You need: a phone, tablet or computer with a free satellite-tracking site or app, a notebook, a calculator. Do: Choose a satellite that the site lists, such as the International Space Station or a small amateur satellite. Look at the list of passes over your location for the next 24 hours. Write down the start time and end time of each pass that rises above 10°. Work out the length of each in minutes and add them up. Compare the total with the 1,440 minutes in a day. What to expect: For a satellite at 400 to 500 km you will usually find a handful of passes a day, each a few minutes long, adding up to perhaps 20 to 40 minutes, a small percentage of the day. A pass of 7 minutes or more is a good one. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use the table from this chapter to compute the longest possible pass (7.4 minutes) and compare it with the 94.5 minute lap. Limitation: the table gives a best case for an overhead pass at one height. Real passes depend on your latitude, the orbit’s tilt and the day.

Next time: We know SkyClub-1 should live low. But a rocket does not drop it neatly at 500 kilometres. How does a satellite climb from one orbit to another, and what is the cheapest path?

← Chapter 8: Escape · Book 11 contents · Chapter 10: The Long Way Up →

Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers

Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

CA-7 Job Status and Failure Reason Codes

Here are the various status codes that You may see for jobs in the Queue or Logs in CA-7. R-C0002 R-C0003 R-C0099 R-C0255 R-JCLER A-U0002 A-U0004 A-U0015 A-U0043 A-U4095 A-SOC7 A-U4000 Reason Code/Job Status Code explanation: The indication of the job's current disposition. Values and their meanings are: A-Snnnn-- The job has failed with a system abend. A-Unnnn --The job has failed with a user abend. C-Cnnnn --The job has completed successfully and is going through completion processing. E-ARFATT-- An error occurred during the attempt to attach ARF definitions. This can result if the ARFSET specified is not defined. A diagnostic message may have been written to the CA-7 log, the OS console, or to the trailer queue for the job (in which case it can be displayed using LQ,JOB=x,LIST=ALL). E-ARFERR ---The job encountered an error in the ARF processing. Do a LARFQ command for the job to get more specific information. E-SEGERR --The job has been requeued...

Whistling Winds and Waterfalls: 4 Days of Magic in Shillong

Nestled in the clouds, where the scent of pine trees mingles with the rhythm of waterfalls and the tunes of local guitar-strumming youth—Shillong is more than a place. It’s a vibe. If you’ve got 3 nights and 4 days, you’ve got just enough time to fall in love. Here’s how to make the most of it—food, fun, fog and fantastic views included. Day 1: Shillong, We’re Coming for You! You land in Guwahati, barely out of the airport when the hills start calling. You hop into your cab, Spotify on, windows down, and the three-hour ride to Shillong begins. Just when you think it can’t get better, you stop at Umiam Lake —a lake so calm, it looks like someone ironed the water. By evening, you’re sipping hot chai in Laitumkhrah, maybe nibbling on spicy momos or pork jadoh from a roadside stall. You’re checked into your charming hotel ( Tripura Castle if you fancy old-world royalty, Ri Kynjai if you’re into lakeside poetry). The breeze whispers secrets of waterfalls and pine forests. Sleep well, drea...

Installing and Configuring Hadoop on Ubuntu as a Pseudo Distributed Single Node Cluster

Briefly what is psuedo-distributed single node Hadoop cluster: It is a Hadoop distributed cluster having Single Node. All the five daemons (NN,DN,JT,TT,SNN) are running as individual JVM (java process) instances. We will get all distributed features of Hadoop. This mode is used to develop, test, and staging (before production) Map Reduce programs quickly. It writes all the system, daemon and user logs to different files on the cluster To install Hadoop in this mode, we have to modify the hadoop-env.sh, core-site.xml, hdfs-site.xml, mapred-site.xml. hadoop-env.sh contains all the Environment variables which are required for running Hadoop. All the default values are fine, Only we have to modify the JAVA_HOME=“The location of Java Home Directory” Core-site.xml contains all the cluster specific information like io, temp directory, sorting, file system uri etc. Hdfs-site.xml contains all the parameters which are specific to HDFS like name node directory, data node directory...