Memunic Space Explorers › Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits › Chapter 10: The Long Way Up
Chapter 10: The Long Way Up
In this chapter: Describe a Hohmann transfer between circular orbits, calculate the speed changes it needs, explain why rockets need so much fuel, and present a complete orbit design with its assumptions for others to check.
The design review was set for Friday at six o’clock, and by half past five the terrace looked like a courtroom.
Mr Rao had brought two extra chairs and put them at the head of the folding table, facing the Club. On the laptop, propped against the tank, Guddu’s face waited, with a second face beside hers: her science teacher, a calm woman with reading glasses on a cord, who had introduced herself with the words, “I am here to be convinced, not to be kind.”
“That is exactly what I need,” said Kachui, and meant it.
Memoon stood at the front with the Sky Notebook in one hand and a single sheet of paper in the other. It was the one-page Orbit Design Sheet, the thing the contest judges would read, and she had rewritten it five times that week. Behind her, on the parapet, Noodles, Simbha, Beautine and Nimo’s tank had been arranged in a line like a jury that had changed sides.
“The brief had six parts,” she began. “Purpose, size, orbit, energy, reach, and assumptions. I will take them in order, and at any point, please stop me.”
“We will,” said Guddu’s teacher.
One: purpose. “SkyClub-1 is a three-unit CubeSat, ten by ten by thirty-four centimetres, with a mass we are taking as four kilograms. It carries a small spectrograph to look at starlight from above the twinkling air.”
Two: the orbit. “A circular orbit at 500 kilometres above the surface, so r is 6,871 kilometres. The speed is the square root of G M over r, which is 7.62 kilometres per second. The period is 94.5 minutes. About fifteen laps a day.”
The teacher raised a pen. “Why not 400 kilometres, like the space station?”
“Because of drag,” said Memoon. “At 400 kilometres a small satellite meets enough air to lose height steadily. Chapter 7 says it also speeds up as it sinks. At 500 kilometres there is much less air, and the satellite stays up longer. Drag changes with how active the Sun is, so I cannot give a lifetime I trust. I can say that 500 is safer than 400, and that I expect a satellite of this size to come down in a few years to some decades, and that I would not put it much lower.”
“Why not higher?”
“Two reasons. Energy: higher costs more. And a satellite that stays in orbit for a very long time becomes a piece of space junk when it stops working. A widely used guideline is that a satellite in low orbit should come down within twenty-five years of finishing its work. At 500 kilometres, that is plausible. Much higher, it is not.”
The teacher wrote something and nodded once.
Three: gravity and weight. “At 500 kilometres, g is 8.44 metres per second squared, which is 86 percent of the surface value.” Memoon glanced at the parapet, where Noodles had suddenly become interested in the sky. “So there is gravity up there. The satellite is weightless because it is falling, not because gravity has gone.”
“I said that,” said Noodles, with dignity. “In Chapter 1. Mostly.”
“He said the opposite,” said Beautine.
“I said the opposite first,” said Noodles, “and then I changed my mind. It is on the record.”
Four: energy. “The total energy of a four-kilogram satellite at that height is minus G M m over two r, which is minus 1.16 times ten to the eight joules. The negative sign means it is bound. The kinetic energy is plus 1.16 times ten to the eight.”
The design review, with the club as a jury
Mr Rao shifted in his seat. “May I ask a question that is probably silly?”
“Those are the best,” said Memoon.
“If the satellite were heavier, say forty kilograms, would the orbit change? Would it need to be higher to stay up?”
“No,” said Memoon. “Speed and period do not depend on its mass. The mass cancelled out in Chapter 4. A forty-kilogram satellite goes at the same speed on the same circle. But the energy is ten times larger, because the energy depends on the mass. And getting it up there needs ten times more.”
“Which is why the contest has a mass limit,” said Guddu.
“It is the best question of the evening so far,” said the teacher. “Mr Rao, you may be hired.”
“I accept,” said Mr Rao. “Payment in biscuits.”
Five: reach. “A ground station on the school roof will see the satellite for two to seven minutes at a time, four to six times a day, for roughly twenty to thirty minutes in all. The radio frequency will shift by about ten kilohertz either way during a pass, from the Doppler effect. The signal is about five thousand times stronger than from a geostationary satellite, which is why a low orbit fits a small radio.”
“And in the shadow?” asked the teacher. “Everything depends on power.”
“Up to thirty-six minutes in each lap, in the worst season,” said Kachui, flipping a page. “A battery covers it, and the observing happens in sunlight. Appendix, page three.”
“There is an appendix,” said Mr Rao, to himself.
Memoon let the room settle, then said the thing she had been saving. “That leaves one question none of us have asked. We know where SkyClub-1 should live. We have not asked how it gets there.”
She turned over the page. “In a real mission the rocket delivers the satellite to a planned orbit. But the idea behind it matters, because every change of orbit uses the same trick. And we have built enough physics to work it out.”
She drew two circles, one inside the other, with a little dot at the centre for Earth.
“Suppose a rocket drops SkyClub-1 on the inner circle, at 400 kilometres. We want it on the outer one, at 500. What is the cheapest way?”
“Fire the engine until it gets there,” said Noodles from the parapet.
“Fire it for how long?” asked Kachui. “And in which direction? And when?”
“Whenever,” said Noodles, and then, seeing their faces, “or not.”
“There is a famous answer,” said Memoon. “It is called a Hohmann transfer, after Walter Hohmann, a German engineer who worked it out in 1925. It is the cheapest two-burn path between two circular orbits in the same plane. And it uses nothing we have not already built.”
She drew a third curve, an ellipse, touching the inner circle at one side and the outer circle at the other.
“Step one. At a chosen point on the inner circle, give the satellite a short push forward. Along its direction of motion. It gains speed, and so energy. Chapter 4 told us that a satellite going faster than circular speed does not stay on the circle. It swings out on an ellipse whose closest point is where we pushed, and whose farthest point is on the other side of Earth. If we choose the push just right, the farthest point lies exactly on the outer circle.
“Step two. Coast along the half-ellipse. No engine. Gravity does the work. Kepler’s second law says the satellite slows as it climbs, and energy says why.
Hohmann transfer: 400 km to 500 km
coast: 47 minutes, no engine
Burn 1: +28 m/s (along the motion)
Burn 2: +28 m/s (along the motion)
400 km orbit
500 km orbit
The gap between the circles is exaggerated: the real orbits are only 100 km apart. Both burns push forward along the motion.
A Hohmann transfer from 400 km to 500 km. The gap between the orbits is exaggerated.
“Step three. At the far point, the satellite is now moving slower than the circular speed of the outer orbit, because it climbed. So we give it a second short push, and now it is going exactly the circular speed. It stays on the outer circle.”
“Two pushes,” said Beautine. “Both forward. And both make it go faster. And yet the satellite ends up going slower than it started.”
“Because of what happens in between,” said Memoon. “Climbing costs speed. The two pushes give speed. The total effect is a bit more energy, and a slightly lower speed.”
She filled in the numbers on the back of the sheet. The inner circle’s radius was 6,771 kilometres and the outer 6,871. The ellipse’s semi-major axis was the average, 6,821 kilometres. The speed at the near point on the ellipse came out at 7,701 metres per second, against a circular speed there of 7,673. The first push was 28 metres per second. At the far point the ellipse speed was 7,589, against 7,617 for the outer circle. The second push was 28 metres per second again. The total, 56 metres per second. The half-ellipse took the transfer time, which was half of the ellipse’s own period: 47 minutes.
“Fifty-six metres per second,” said Beautine. “That’s about the speed of a fast car on a motorway.”
“It is,” said Memoon, “and it is a tiny change compared with 7,600. A hundred kilometres of height costs 56 metres per second. A small thruster could do that. But you notice something about the shape: the two pushes are at opposite ends of the ellipse.”
Guddu’s teacher leaned forward. “How much would it cost to go from 400 kilometres all the way up to geostationary?”
Memoon looked pleased. “Same recipe, bigger numbers. The first push is 2.40 kilometres per second. The second is 1.46 kilometres per second. Total 3.86 kilometres per second. And the half-ellipse takes 5.3 hours.”
“So geostationary needs a lot more than 56 metres per second.”
“Seventy times more,” said Kachui. “Which is why the sums in the energy row made sense.” He added, almost to himself, “And that is without the extra push to move into the equator’s plane, which a real launch from 13.7° would need.”
“Is that the number a rocket needs?” asked Guddu. “3.86?”
“No,” said Memoon. “That is for moving between orbits. To get from the ground to the low orbit in the first place, a rocket needs about 9.4 kilometres per second in total. The orbit’s speed is 7.7. The rest goes on fighting air drag and gravity while climbing. And now the rocket has a problem.”
“What problem?” asked Mr Rao.
Memoon pulled out another page, a small one, and wrote a line on it:
Delta-v = v(exhaust) x ln( m(start) / m(end) )
“This is the rocket equation. It was found by a Russian schoolteacher, Konstantin Tsiolkovsky, in 1903. Delta-v is the change in speed a rocket can make. v(exhaust) is how fast it throws its burnt fuel out of the back. And the last part is the natural logarithm of the ratio of its starting mass, with all the fuel, to its mass at the end, when the fuel is gone.”
She swallowed. “A good rocket engine on kerosene and liquid oxygen throws its exhaust at about three kilometres per second. For a change of speed of 9.4, divide: 3.13. The mass ratio is e to the power 3.13, which is about 23.”
“Twenty-three,” said Mr Rao.
“For every twenty-three kilograms on the launch pad,” said Memoon, “about twenty-two must be fuel, if the rocket were a single stage. Only one kilogram is left for the tank, the engines, and the payload. That is why real rockets are built in stages, dropping empty tanks as they go. And it is the reason a four-kilogram satellite is delivered by a rocket that weighs hundreds of tonnes.”
The terrace was silent. A pigeon landed on the water tank, regarded the company, and left.
“The rocket needs fuel to lift the fuel to lift the fuel,” said Simbha slowly.
Hohmann transfer: low orbit to geostationary (to scale)
coast: about 5.3 hours
400 km orbit
Burn 1: +2.40 km/s
Burn 2: +1.46 km/s
geostationary orbit (35,786 km up)
Orbit sizes and Earth are drawn to the same scale. The turn into the equator’s plane is left out.
A Hohmann transfer from low orbit to geostationary orbit, with orbits and Earth to the same scale.
“That is what makes spaceflight expensive,” said Memoon. “Not gravity alone. The need to carry what you will burn.”
The teacher put down her pen. “I have three more questions. First, how good is your spherical Earth assumption?”
“Not perfect,” said Kachui, ready for it. “Earth bulges at the equator by about 21 kilometres. That makes the orbit slowly rotate in space, and it matters for long-term planning. For a first design and a period good to a percent, it is negligible. I have listed it under assumptions.”
“Second. The Moon.”
“At that height, Earth’s pull is about two hundred and fifty thousand times the Moon’s pull,” said Kachui. “The Moon’s effect is negligible for a design this size.”
“Third. What is the thing you are least sure of?”
There was a pause. Memoon looked at the sheet, then at the Club.
“The lifetime,” she said. “I can show the direction, but not the number. The air at 500 kilometres changes by a large factor with the Sun’s activity, and I do not know how this particular satellite is shaped. I have said that. I would like a real specialist to compute it.”
“Good,” said the teacher. “That is the answer a scientist gives.”
She turned to Guddu. “I think they have earned our approval. With conditions.”
“Conditions?” asked Memoon.
“The lifetime estimate must be checked by someone with the right software. Include the appendix. And I want a paragraph on what you ignored and why it did not matter.”
“We already have the paragraph,” said Kachui. “It is page four.”
Guddu was laughing. “Memoon, you’ve done it. The contest asks for a real design. This is a real design.”
“It is the Club’s design,” said Memoon. “And yours. We only did the physics.”
“You did the physics so the rest of us could do the electronics,” said Guddu. “That’s how engineering works.”
After the call ended, the Club stayed on the terrace. Mr Rao carried the two extra chairs downstairs and came back with a tray of tea, which he set on the table without comment. The sky was beginning to darken, and over the water tank the first star of the evening had appeared, small and white.
“That one is steady,” said Simbha. “It could be a planet. I will check the app before I say which.”
“Check first, then claim,” agreed Kachui. “That is the rule of the whole book.”
Memoon took down Kachui’s Question Jar, the old glass jar on the shelf by the stairs, and began to read slips by torchlight. There were dozens. Why is the sky dark at night? How old is the light we see? Why do stars have colours? She drew one and read it aloud.
“’What is light made of, and what can it tell us about the first moment of everything?’”
The Club looked at each other.
“That one,” said Kachui, “is not for this book.”
“It is not for this book,” agreed Memoon. She put the slip back in the jar, face up, and screwed on the lid. “But SkyClub-1 will carry a spectrograph. And a spectrograph, which records the spectral lines you met in Book 10, is a machine for asking exactly that.”
The end of the evening: a steady dot crosses the sky
She looked up. The star had been joined by others, and above the water tank, very high, a small steady point of light was moving, without twinkling, across the dark.
Nobody needed to say what it was.
Science Corner
Hohmann transfer: the cheapest two-burn path between two circular orbits in one plane. A burn at the inner orbit puts the satellite on an ellipse touching both circles; a second burn at the far point circularises it. Both burns are along the direction of motion when moving outward. SkyClub-1 example (400 km to 500 km): r1 = 6,771 km, r2 = 6,871 km, a = 6,821 km. First burn about 28 m/s, second about 28 m/s, total about 56 m/s. Transfer time = half the ellipse’s period = about 47 minutes. Low orbit to GEO (400 km to 35,786 km): first burn about 2.40 km/s, second about 1.46 km/s, total about 3.86 km/s; transfer time about 5.3 hours (ignoring the plane change). Rocket equation: delta-v = v(exhaust) x ln(m start / m end). For v(exhaust) = 3.0 km/s and delta-v = 9.4 km/s, the mass ratio is e3.13, about 23. A single stage would need about 22 of every 23 kg to be fuel; real rockets use stages. Orbit design sheet: purpose, size and mass, orbit (shape, height, speed, period), energy, reach (contact time, Doppler, delay, signal) and assumptions, each with its number and its limit. Worked problem (maths track): Hohmann transfer semi-major axis a = (r1 + r2) / 2. Transfer time t = π x √(a cubed / G M). For a = 6.821 × 106 m: a cubed = 3.174 × 1020; divided by 3.986 × 1014 gives 7.962 × 105; square root 892.3 s; times π, 2,803 s, or 46.7 min. Concept track: moving up an orbit takes two pushes with a coast between them, and the coast takes half an ellipse. Story note: The Hohmann transfer assumes circular orbits in the same plane, instantaneous burns and no other pulls. Real burns last time, and real transfers add plane changes and corrections. The rocket-equation example is simplified: a real rocket’s exhaust speed, drag losses and staging change the numbers, and 9.4 km/s is a typical total for reaching low orbit, not an exact figure. The lifetime of a small satellite at 500 km depends strongly on the Sun’s activity and on the satellite’s shape and attitude, so no single number is given. The 25-year guideline is a widely used recommendation, not a law of nature. Orbit design here is a contest exercise; nothing in this story was built or launched. The Question Jar and the talking animals are part of the story, not of the science.
Space Detective 1. Describe a Hohmann transfer in three steps, and say why both burns are along the direction of motion when moving to a higher orbit, even though the satellite ends up moving slower. 2. A rocket must change its speed by 9.4 km/s using exhaust at 3.0 km/s. Calculate the mass ratio, and explain in two sentences why this makes rockets mostly fuel. 3. List three assumptions in the SkyClub-1 design and, for each, say what would change if it were wrong.
Try it: Draw a Transfer Orbit Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult must handle the pins and compass. You need: a sheet of thick paper on a piece of cardboard, two pins or thumbtacks, thread, a ruler, a pencil and a compass (or a loop of thread to draw circles). Do: Mark the Earth pin (call it F1). Draw two circles around it with radii 4 cm and 10 cm. On a line through F1, place the second pin (F2) 6 cm from F1 on the side of the outer circle. Tie a loop of thread 20 cm long, place it round both pins and draw the ellipse with the pencil. Mark the half of the ellipse from the inner circle to the outer circle. What to expect: The ellipse touches the inner circle at its nearest point and the outer circle at its farthest point. The half-ellipse you marked is the path of the transfer. The satellite is at its closest on the inner circle and its slowest where it touches the outer circle. Cloudy or low-resource day: This works indoors. If you have no pins, use a drawing app with an ellipse tool and place two circles and an ellipse by eye. Limitation: a drawing shows the shape but not the timing or the speeds, and the sizes are simplified, so it cannot show real distances.
Next time: The Club has chosen an orbit, weighed a world, and followed a satellite from the ground to the sky. But SkyClub-1 will carry a spectrograph, and a spectrograph asks a bigger question: what is light made of, and what can it tell us about how everything began? That is the next adventure.
← Chapter 9: Low or High? · Book 11 contents · What We Found Out →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 11: Memoon and the Laws of Orbits, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment