Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 1: The Last Slip
Chapter 1: The Last Slip
In this chapter: Say what counts as evidence in astronomy, list the four messages light can carry, and use light travel time to show that every telescope looks into the past.
The first evening of December came in cold and clear, and the terrace smelled of Mrs Rao’s masala chai. A steel flask and four small cups had arrived by the stairs with a note: “Biscuits are for the Club. Mr Rao’s share has already been counted.” Mr Rao, sitting on the top step with a biscuit in his hand, pretended not to hear.
Orion was climbing the eastern sky, belt first, and above and to the right of him glowed the orange eye of Aldebaran. Simbha, lying across the warm side of the water tank, had been watching the pair for half an hour without saying a word. He did not need to. Everyone knew what night it was.
Kachui set the Question Jar on the folding table. It was a plain glass jar with a cork lid, and it had been opened twice before. Both times the answer had taken the Club somewhere none of them had planned to go.
“Two slips left,” she said. “The one at the bottom is the oldest. We agreed, a long time ago, that it was too big to open early. The one on top is blue. I folded it myself, the night we finished the orbit design.”
She unscrewed the lid, lifted out the blue slip with two careful claws and unfolded it. She read it silently, then read it aloud.
“What is light made of, and what can it tell us about the first moment of everything?”
The Last Slip: the Question Jar glows on the terrace
Nobody spoke. A scooter went past in the lane below.
“That is two questions,” said Beautine at last. She leapt onto the table, scattering biscuit crumbs, and spread her arms wide. “And I can answer both at once! Light is light. And it tells us EVERYTHING.”
Memoon looked at her with her chin on her fist. “That is a claim, Beautine. It is not yet an answer.”
“What is the difference?”
“An answer has something under it.” Memoon opened the Sky Notebook. It was a thick book now, and the pages showed its age: first drawings of the Moon, then tables of shadow lengths, then graphs, then pages of equations with Kachui’s neat corrections in the margin. She turned to a clean page and wrote three rules across the top.
Rule 1. Say what was measured.
Rule 2. Say what was assumed.
Rule 3. Label the claim: KNOWN, HINT or GUESS.
“We used the three labels when we studied the red star,” she said. “KNOWN means many independent measurements agree. HINT means the evidence points that way but something could still overturn it. GUESS means we are reaching. We will label every sentence of our answer. If we cannot label it, we do not write it.”
“That will be a very short answer,” muttered Beautine.
“Or a very honest one.”
Noodles had been rolling a pencil across the table with one paw. “Light is a wave,” he announced. “Obviously. Like ripples.”
A gentle voice rose from the tank. Nimo’s bubble drifted up to the surface. “In my tank, ripples need water to travel in. If you take the water away, there are no ripples. Light crosses the empty space between us and the stars. So whatever it is, it is not a water wave, Noodles. That is where my picture stops working.”
“Then it is tiny marbles,” said Beautine, still on the table. “Millions of them. I have counted a few.”
“Both pictures have evidence behind them,” Memoon said. “Over the next ten evenings we will find out why, and whether the question is the right shape at all. But first we need to decide what we are allowed to use. What do we actually have, from beyond Earth?”
Kachui answered slowly. “A few meteorites. Some rocks the Moon missions brought back. A little dust. Mostly we have light.”
“Then everything we say has to arrive by light. What can a beam carry?”
Simbha lifted his head. “Where it came from,” he said. “How bright it is. What colour it is, and the pattern in that colour, the dark lines we saw through the CD. And whether any of that changes with time.”
Memoon wrote them in a table: direction, brightness, colour pattern, change over time. She tapped the page. “Four messages. That is our whole toolkit. Everything in this book will be made from those four.”
“There are other messengers,” said Kachui. “Neutrinos. Cosmic rays. Ripples in space itself.”
“True, and they are real and they are wonderful. But we have a terrace and a CD and a phone, so we follow light.”
The next question came from the stairs. Mr Rao, who had been listening with his biscuit halfway to his mouth, called out, “If I may ask something silly. How old is the light?”
“That is not silly,” said Memoon. “That is exactly the right question.” She turned a page. “Light is fast, but it is not instant. Speed equals distance over time, so the time a message takes is the distance divided by the speed of light.”
Maths track: t = d / c, with c = 3.00 × 108 m/s.
“The Moon is 3.844 × 108 metres away.”
Moon: t = 3.844 × 108 m / 3.00 × 108 m/s = 1.28 s.
“So the Moon you see is a second and a bit old,” said Noodles. “Fine. Who cares?”
“The Sun is 1.496 × 1011 metres away.”
Sun: t = 1.496 × 1011 m / 3.00 × 108 m/s = 499 s, about 8.3 minutes.
Beautine sat down. “Then the Sun in the sky is eight minutes old.”
“Yes. And Aldebaran, up there, is about sixty-five light-years away. We worked that out with parallax, remember. A light-year is a distance, how far light travels in a year, but it also tells us how long the message took. The light reaching your eyes tonight left Aldebaran about sixty-five years ago.”
“Before the telephones in the building were digital,” said Mr Rao thoughtfully.
How far is a light-year? A ladder of distances
1.3 light-seconds to the Moon
8.3 light-minutes to the Sun
4.2 light-years to the nearest star after the Sun
100,000 light-years across our Milky Way
2.5 million light-years to the Andromeda galaxy
about 46 billion light-years radius of the observable universe
A light-year is a distance: how far light travels in one year (about 9.46 trillion km). Bar lengths use a logarithmic scale, so each step is far larger than the last. Distances are rounded.
A ladder of distances in light-travel time and light-years. Logarithmic scale, distances rounded.
“And the great galaxy in Andromeda is about two and a half million light-years away. That light left before any person had ever lived. A galaxy a hundred megaparsecs away, which is about 326 million light-years, sent its light before the first dinosaurs.”
Kachui tilted her head. “So when a telescope looks at something far away, it shows us how things were. This idea has a name: look-back time.”
“A telescope is a time machine,” breathed Beautine.
“It is not,” said Memoon firmly. “A time machine would let us go there. A telescope only lets old news arrive. We cannot ask whether Andromeda looks the same tonight.”
“Is the star still there?” Mr Rao asked. “Aldebaran, I mean. If the light is sixty-five years old.”
Kachui took the question seriously, the way she took all of them. “Almost certainly. Stars like Aldebaran last millions of years. But the light alone cannot tell us. We would need to know physics about how stars live, and we will need to be careful about which parts of that are KNOWN and which are HINT.”
A phone buzzed against the water tank, propped up on a stack of biscuit tins. It was a video call. Guddu’s face appeared, a dark ponytail pulled through the back of a cap, a lab coat hung behind her on a hook.
“Hi, Sky Club,” she said. “Sorry I’m late. Big news first. The orbit design sheet got second place in our school round. The district round is in January.”
The terrace exploded. Beautine flung two biscuits in the air. Noodles caught one. Mr Rao stood up on the step and applauded, still holding the flask.
“Second news,” said Guddu when it was quiet. “We started dual nature of radiation this week. And atoms, and nuclei, are next. My teacher says the Big Bang is not in our book. So I’m borrowing your jar. What’s in it?”
Memoon turned the phone so the blue slip was in view. Guddu read it twice, the way Kachui had.
“Then do it properly,” said Guddu. “Ten evenings. Then the Geminid night. The whole building will be up on the terrace and you can put the answer on a poster. Every claim labelled. Nothing you cannot defend.”
“Ten evenings,” said Memoon.
“I’ll bring the school lab to you. If the teacher lets me photograph the hydrogen tube.”
When she had gone, Kachui put the cork back and placed the jar in the middle of the table, where all of them could see it. “The oldest slip waits for the last evening,” she said.
“How will we know where to start?” asked Beautine, who had stopped being dramatic for almost a whole minute.
Noodles had stopped rolling his pencil. He looked suddenly pleased with himself. “With a bet. Last month I got my old science kit out of the cupboard. It has a multimeter and a bag of little coloured LEDs. I will bet a biscuit that the brightest torch always wins. If you want to find out what light does to a thing, you shine more of it.”
“A biscuit?” said Simbha, lowering his voice to a rumble. “I accept.”
Memoon closed the notebook. Above them, Orion kept climbing, and the old light of Aldebaran kept arriving, minute by minute, sixty-five years late.
Science Corner Light carries four messages: direction, brightness, colour pattern (its spectrum, from Book 10) and change over time. Light travel time is distance divided by speed: t = d / c, with c = 3.00 × 108 m/s (exactly 299,792,458 m/s in a vacuum). Look-back time is how long the light has been travelling. A telescope shows an object as it was when the light left it, not as it is now. Evidence means measurements that other people can repeat. Claims in this book are labelled KNOWN (many independent measurements agree), HINT (the evidence points that way but could be overturned) or GUESS (a reach beyond the evidence). A light-year (Book 6) is a distance, the distance light travels in one year, about 9.46 × 1015 m. Story note: The Moon and Sun times use the mean distances and c = 3.00 × 108 m/s, so they are rounded; the Moon’s distance varies by a few per cent. Aldebaran’s 65 light-years (Book 6) is a rounded value. A telescope is not a time machine: it brings old information and cannot show what a place looks like now. For a galaxy a hundred megaparsecs away, look-back time is close to distance divided by c, but for much more distant galaxies the stretching of space matters and the simple rule fails (Chapter 6). The “four messages” is a simplification: polarisation is a fifth, and neutrinos, cosmic rays and gravitational waves are other messengers that this book does not follow. Noodles’s ripples and Beautine’s marbles are pictures that each fail, which is the point; Nimo’s tank waves need water, but light needs no medium.
Space Detective 1. Explain in your own words why the Sun you see is eight minutes old, and why a telescope is not a time machine. 2. At its closest, Jupiter is about 5.9 × 1011 m from Earth. How long does its light take to reach us? Show t = d / c with units. 3. Pick a lamp at home. Make a four-row table: for each message (direction, brightness, colour pattern, change over time) write one way you could measure it.
Try it: Four Messages of Light Time: 20 minutes in the evening. Adult: An adult should supervise lamp switching and must be present; never point the spectroscope or the phone at the Sun. You need: two kinds of lamp (for example a filament bulb and an LED or tube-light), a CD or DVD spectroscope from Book 10 or a CD and a card with a slit, a phone with slow-motion video, your Sky Notebook. Do: For each lamp, record the four messages. Direction: which compass direction is it from where you stand? Brightness: at what distance can you just read a page by it, or what does a phone light-meter app show? Colour pattern: look through the spectroscope and draw the bands you see. Change over time: film the lamp in slow-motion and look for rolling dark bars, which show flicker. What to expect: A filament bulb gives a smooth rainbow. A tube-light or compact fluorescent shows a few bright lines on a faint background. An LED shows a blue peak and a broad yellow and red region. Some lamps flicker at 100 times a second on India’s 50 Hz supply, and some do not. Cloudy or low-resource day: Without a CD, compare lamps by eye and record only direction and brightness. Limitation: your eyes cannot see the spectral pattern or fast flicker, so you collect two messages out of four.
Next time: Noodles has bet a biscuit that the brightest torch always wins. Can a dim blue torch beat a very bright red one?
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment