Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 2: Light in Packets
Chapter 2: Light in Packets
In this chapter: Use E = hf and the photoelectric equation to find photon energies and to predict whether a colour of light can free electrons from a metal, and use Wien’s law to link colour to temperature.
The second evening smelled of ginger again, and Noodles was early. He had laid out his old science kit on the folding table like a surgeon’s tray: a small digital multimeter, a bag of coloured LEDs, a red headlamp, and his phone with its torch glowing.
“The bet is on,” he said. “Brightest torch wins. Simbha, you may wish to say goodbye to your biscuit now.”
Simbha, stretched along the parapet, did not move. “I never say goodbye to biscuits.”
Memoon pulled a blue LED from the bag and held it up between finger and thumb. “This is the sensor. An LED is a sandwich of two layers of material. Run a current through it and it gives out light. But the sandwich works backwards too. If light of the right kind falls on it, it can push charge across the join and make a tiny voltage. Not a good sensor, but a fair one.”
Kachui clipped the two legs of the LED to the probes and turned the multimeter to its lowest voltage range. The screen read zero. “Rule 1. What was measured? Voltage across the LED, in millivolts, on the lowest range. Rule 2. What is assumed? That the meter and the clips are fine. I will check that in a minute.”
“The phone torch first,” said Memoon. She held it fifty centimetres from the blue LED. The number on the screen crept up and settled at a small positive value, a few tens of millivolts. She brought the torch to five centimetres and it jumped to a few hundred.
“Good,” said Noodles, grinning. “That is the phone. Now the real test.” He picked up the red headlamp, set it to its brightest red mode and held it almost against the LED. “This one has more watts printed on the box than the phone. Watch.”
The screen stayed at zero. It flickered once around nothing and went back to zero.
“Meter is stuck,” said Noodles. He tapped it.
“It is not stuck.” Kachui swapped the blue LED for a red one from the bag and held the red headlamp to it. The screen leapt to a positive number.
Noodles stared. “Then try the blue LED again. Closer.”
The red headlamp, one centimetre from the blue LED, gave nothing. The phone torch, half a metre away and nowhere near as bright, gave a clear reading.
“A dim torch is beating a bright torch,” said Beautine, spreading her arms like a lawyer. “More light is more light! This is impossible!”
“It is not impossible,” said Memoon. “It is a result.” She wrote it down.
They ran the rest of the test in ten minutes. A green LED answered the phone torch, which has some blue and green in its glow, but not the red headlamp. A red LED answered the red headlamp, the phone torch, and anything bluer. Kachui drew a little table in the notebook and a line under it. “Each LED answers its own colour and every colour bluer than that. It does not answer redder colours, however bright they are.”
“Bluer means higher frequency,” said Memoon. “Frequency is how many wave crests pass a point each second. The speed of light is wavelength times frequency, so a shorter wavelength is the same thing as a higher frequency.”
Maths track: c = f x λ. Red 700 nm: f = 3.00 × 108 / 700 × 10−9 = 4.29 × 1014 Hz. Blue 450 nm: f = 6.67 × 1014 Hz.
Noodles said nothing. He picked up a biscuit from the plate, looked at it sadly, and slid it across the table to Simbha.
“A wave should not behave like this,” said Memoon, tapping the pencil on her chin. “Think about a water wave hitting a boat. A bigger wave is a bigger push. If you wait long enough, a gentle wave and a huge wave should both build up enough energy to move the boat. If light were just a wave of that kind, a bright enough red beam should eventually shake electrons loose. It should only take longer. But it does not happen at all.”
Kachui turned the pages of the notebook to the back, where she kept a short list of names. “Heinrich Hertz noticed in 1887 that ultraviolet light helped a spark jump. Others found that it was the colour, not the brightness, that decided whether electrons came off a metal. And in 1905 a young man named Albert Einstein proposed a strange idea to explain it.”
“Light comes in packets,” said Memoon. “Each packet is called a photon, and its energy depends only on its frequency.”
E = h f = h c / λ, with h = 6.626 × 10−34 J s.
“Max Planck had used the same number five years earlier,” said Kachui, “to explain why glowing objects have the colours they do. Einstein took it one step further and said the packets are real.”
“Is a joule too big?” asked Beautine.
“For one photon, yes. We use a smaller unit, the electronvolt, eV. It is the energy an electron gains when it moves through one volt.” Memoon wrote: 1 eV = 1.602 × 10−19 J. “And there is a shortcut.”
h c = 1240 eV nm, so E (in eV) = 1240 / λ (in nm).
Red, 700 nm: E = 1240 / 700 = 1.77 eV.
Blue, 450 nm: E = 1240 / 450 = 2.76 eV.
Nimo’s bubble bobbed up. “May I give you a picture, and tell you where it breaks? Imagine a vending machine that sells one sweet. It only takes a single coin worth at least a certain amount. If you push in a hundred small coins, one at a time, the machine does nothing. The coins are photons, and the price is what the metal charges to let an electron out.”
“Where does the picture stop working?” asked Kachui, who always asked.
“In my tank, I could pay the price over time, a little at a time, and the water would remember. The electron does not remember. Each photon either pays the whole price or pays nothing. And in very strong laser light, an electron can sometimes take two photons at once, which a vending machine would not allow. That is not what a torch does.”
Memoon was already writing. “The price has a name: the work function, φ, the least energy needed to free an electron from a metal. Let us say our test plate has φ = 2.3 eV. Real metals sit between about two and five.”
Photoelectric equation: K(max) = h f − φ.
Threshold: h f0 = φ, so lambda0 = 1240 / 2.3 = 539 nm.
“A photon with a wavelength longer than 539 nanometres has less than 2.3 eV. The red photons, with 1.77 eV, pay too little. The blue ones, with 2.76 eV, pay enough. What is left over becomes the electron’s movement.”
Blue 450 nm: K(max) = 2.76 − 2.30 = 0.46 eV. A stopping voltage of 0.46 V would just halt the fastest electrons.
“That is called the photoelectric effect,” she said. “And the smallest frequency that works is the threshold frequency.”
Beautine was frowning at the numbers. “But how many red photons does the headlamp send? Maybe it’s not enough.”
“Say one watt of red light.” Memoon did the division on the page.
Photon energy: 1.77 eV x 1.602 × 10−19 J/eV = 2.84 × 10−19 J.
Photons per second in a 1 W beam: N = P / E = 1 / 2.84 × 10−19 = 3.5 × 1018.
“Three and a half million million million photons every second. And not one of them has enough energy to free a single electron from our plate. Brightness, or intensity, is how many photons arrive. Colour is how much each one carries. Above the threshold, a brighter beam frees more electrons. Below it, a brighter beam frees none.”
“So brightness decides how many and colour decides whether,” said Kachui, and wrote it down.
Simbha had finished his biscuit and was looking up at Orion. “Hot things glow,” he said. “The iron in the blacksmith’s shop is red first, then yellow, then white. And the Sun is white-yellow. Is that this too?”
“Same family,” said Memoon. “A glowing object of any temperature gives out light across a range of colours, called blackbody radiation, and the peak of the range moves to shorter wavelengths as it gets hotter. The rule is Wien’s law.”
λ(max) x T = 2.898 × 10−3 m K.
Sun, T = 5800 K: λ(max) = 2.898 × 10−3 / 5800 = 5.0 × 10−7 m = 500 nm.
A person, T = 310 K: λ(max) = 2.898 × 10−3 / 310 = 9.3 × 10−6 m, about 9 micrometres.
“Nine micrometres is infrared,” said Kachui. “So we all glow, but not in a colour you can see.”
Memoon smiled and wrote one more line, then underlined it. If λ(max) were 1 mm, T = 2.898 × 10−3 / 1 × 10−3 = 2.9 K.
“Why would anything be at 2.9 kelvin?” asked Beautine.
“I do not know yet. Keep that number.”
Nimo’s bubble hung over the table, thoughtful. “So light is packets after all? Not ripples?”
“When we send it through two narrow slits, it makes the bands of bright and dark that only waves can make,” said Memoon. “When it lands on a metal or an LED, it arrives one packet at a time. So I think our pictures are too small. A photon is not a tiny marble and not a ripple. It is something we have only two partial pictures of. We will use whichever picture fits the question, and say where it fails.”
“That feels like cheating,” said Beautine.
“It is the opposite,” said Kachui. “Cheating would be pretending we had one picture that did everything.”
On the table, the blue LED still sat in the clips. Memoon unclipped it, held it up, and watched the light from the nearest lamp slide across it.
“One more thing,” she said. “An electron in a metal can be freed by any photon with enough energy. But inside a single atom, an electron is held at certain energies and nowhere in between. So an atom should be fussy about the photons it takes, and about the photons it gives. Guddu says she can get us a photo from the school lab tomorrow. A hydrogen tube.”
“Hydrogen,” said Simbha. “The simplest atom. I hope it is simple.”
Science Corner A photon is a packet of light with energy E = h f = h c / λ, where h = 6.626 × 10−34 J s. A handy form is E (eV) = 1240 / λ (nm). In the photoelectric effect, electrons leave a metal only if each photon carries at least the work function φ: K(max) = h f − φ. Below the threshold frequency f0 = φ / h, no electrons come off, however intense the light. Intensity (how bright) sets how many photons arrive each second; frequency sets how much energy each photon carries. Above threshold, more intensity gives more electrons; below it, none. Blackbody radiation is the glow of a hot object. Wien’s law, λ(max) T = 2.898 × 10−3 m K, gives the wavelength where it peaks, so hotter means bluer. An LED used backwards is a crude colour-sensitive detector: it answers light of its own colour and every colour with shorter wavelength. Story note: The LED test shows the on-or-off pattern but not exact thresholds, because torches are not single-colour and the LED responses are not sharp. The phone torch spectrum is broad with a blue peak. The plate with φ = 2.3 eV is invented for the Club’s calculation; real metals have work functions of roughly 2 to 5 eV. Nimo’s vending machine fails where an electron in very intense laser light absorbs two photons at once, which a torch cannot do. A photon is neither a marble nor a ripple; each picture works for some experiments and fails for others. The Sun is close to, but not exactly, a blackbody at 5,800 K, and Wien’s law gives the peak of the curve plotted per unit wavelength. The 2.9 K line is only arithmetic so far; nothing yet says anything in space has that temperature.
Space Detective 1. Explain why a very bright red torch cannot free electrons from a plate with work function 2.3 eV, while a dim blue torch can. Use the word photon in your answer. 2. A violet photon of wavelength 400 nm falls on the 2.3 eV plate. Find its energy in eV, the maximum kinetic energy of the freed electrons, and the stopping voltage. 3. Draw a table with three LEDs (red, green, blue) down the side and two torches (red, white) across the top. Predict which cells will show a reading, then test and compare.
Try it: LED Light Detector Time: 25 minutes. Adult: An adult should supervise; use only the meter and the LEDs, no batteries or mains in the circuit, and never look straight into a bright torch. You need: a multimeter set to its lowest DC voltage range, three LEDs (red, green, blue), two crocodile clips, a red torch or red headlamp, a white torch or phone torch. Do: Clip one LED to the meter probes. Hold each torch about 5 cm and then about 50 cm from the LED and note whether the reading rises. Repeat for all three LEDs and fill your table. What to expect: Look for on-or-off behaviour, not exact voltages, which vary with the LED and meter. A red LED should answer both torches, a green LED the white torch only, a blue LED the white torch only. Cloudy or low-resource day: With no meter, make a paper table of six colours with their photon energies (1240 / wavelength) and a list of work functions, and predict which pairs would release electrons. Limitation: predicting from numbers is not the same as measuring, and the work functions you use come from a book.
Next time: In a metal, any photon with enough energy frees an electron. Inside a single atom, electrons are held at fixed energies. Which colours does a hydrogen atom give out, and why only those?
← Chapter 1: The Last Slip · Book 12 contents · Chapter 3: Atoms Speak in Colours →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment