Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 4: Inside the Sun’s Furnace
Chapter 4: Inside the Sun’s Furnace
In this chapter: Use mass-energy to show that chemical burning and slow shrinking cannot power the Sun for billions of years but hydrogen fusion can, and explain why fusion needs extreme heat and density.
The fourth evening was hazy, and the stars came out one at a time, as if they were being counted in. Nobody had lit anything. Memoon had banned flames from the terrace long ago, and tonight the ban felt almost funny.
Noodles was lying on his back with his paws behind his head, looking at the sky with enormous satisfaction. “It is perfectly simple,” he said. “The Sun is a very large bonfire. Fire makes heat. Heat makes light. The Sun is the hottest fire there is. I do not know why it took the humans so long to notice.”
“Then we test it,” said Memoon, opening the notebook. “Rule 1, what is measured. Rule 2, what is assumed. Kachui, what is the Sun’s output?”
Kachui consulted the page where she kept her tables. “The luminosity of the Sun is the total energy it gives out every second. It is 3.83 × 1026 watts. One watt is one joule per second. The Sun’s mass is 1.989 × 1030 kilograms.”
“And a bonfire?”
“Coal and charcoal give about thirty million joules per kilogram when they burn. That is the best chemistry does.”
“Then here is the generous version of Noodles’s idea,” said Memoon. “Suppose the entire Sun is made of coal, and every kilogram burns. How long does it last?”
Maths track: Energy available = 1.989 × 1030 kg x 3 × 107 J/kg = 6.0 × 1037 J.
Time = E / L = 6.0 × 1037 / 3.83 × 1026 = 1.6 × 1011 s = 4,900 years.
There was a pause.
“Five thousand years,” said Noodles at last.
“About the age of the oldest cities,” said Kachui. “Rocks on Earth are more than four billion years old, and they were baked by a Sun that was already shining. So your bonfire fails by a factor of nearly a million. I am sorry. I like the idea of a very large bonfire.”
Simbha had been quiet on the parapet. He turned his great head. “What about falling?” he said. “A cloud of gas pulls together under its own weight. When it falls inward it heats up. A Sun that slowly shrinks would give out heat.”
“That is a serious idea,” said Memoon. “Lord Kelvin took it very seriously in the nineteenth century. Let us give it the same test, and be generous. The energy released by pulling a Sun together is about G M2 / R.”
Maths track: G M2 / R = 6.674 × 10−11 × (1.989 × 1030)2 / 6.96 × 108 = 3.8 × 1041 J.
Time = 3.8 × 1041 / 3.83 × 1026 = 1.0 × 1015 s = 3 × 107 years.
“Thirty million years,” said Kachui. “Longer, but still a hundred times too short, and this is an order-of-magnitude estimate, not a careful one. Two answers, both wrong by a lot.”
“So something stores about a million times more energy per kilogram than coal,” said Memoon. “What could that be?”
The phone buzzed. It was Guddu, back at her desk at home with her textbook open to a page full of boxes and arrows. “I think I know,” she said. “This is what I was going to ask you. Everything we found out about atoms was about electrons. But the middle of the atom is something else. The nucleus is made of protons and neutrons. And Einstein says mass is energy.”
E = m c 2.
“Mass-energy,” said Memoon. “If an object loses mass, the energy comes out. If it gains energy, it gains mass. Let us put the Sun’s luminosity through it.”
Maths track: m = L / c2 = 3.83 × 1026 / (3.00 × 108)2 = 4.3 × 109 kg every second.
“Four million tonnes,” said Beautine in a small voice. “Every second.”
“And the Sun has lost about the same every second for billions of years,” said Kachui, “and is still more or less the same. In a year it loses less than one part in ten trillion of its mass.” She checked the figure twice before saying it.
“So how does the Sun lose mass?” said Noodles.
“It does not just lose it. It turns it into light, by changing hydrogen into helium,” said Memoon. “This is the fusion from the red star, the one that faded. Here is the mass bookkeeping. In atomic mass units, u, one hydrogen atom is 1.007825 u. A helium-4 atom is 4.002603 u.”
Four hydrogen atoms: 4 × 1.007825 = 4.031300 u.
One helium-4 atom: 4.002603 u.
Mass missing: 4.031300 − 4.002603 = 0.028697 u, which is 0.71% of the original.
“A conversion factor,” said Guddu. “One u is 931.5 million electronvolts of energy.”
Energy = 0.028697 × 931.5 MeV = 26.7 MeV for each helium nucleus made.
“That missing mass is the binding energy at work,” said Guddu. “The nucleus holds together with less mass than the pieces apart. Helium is more tightly bound than hydrogen. When hydrogen fuses to helium, the difference leaves as energy.”
“How much per kilogram of hydrogen?” asked Beautine.
Maths track: 0.0071 x c2 = 0.0071 × 9.0 × 1016 = 6.4 × 1014 J/kg. Coal: 3 × 107 J/kg. Ratio = 2 × 107.
“Twenty million times coal,” said Kachui.
“Now the lifetime,” said Memoon. “Only the hot, dense core of the Sun can fuse. Say ten per cent of the Sun’s mass is available as fuel and all of it goes at the usual rate.”
Fuel = 0.10 × 1.989 × 1030 = 2.0 × 1029 kg. Energy = 2.0 × 1029 × 6.4 × 1014 = 1.3 × 1044 J.
Time = 1.3 × 1044 / 3.83 × 1026 = 3.3 × 1017 s = 1.0 × 1010 years.
“Ten billion years,” said Simbha softly. “That is the right order. We could have guessed it from the rocks.”
“Something is odd, though,” said Kachui, her pen against her chin. “Two protons both have positive charge. They push each other apart. To fuse, they must get within about a femtometre, that is 10−15 metres. The push at that distance is huge.”
Maths track: Barrier = k e2 / r = 8.99 × 109 × (1.602 × 10−19)2 / 10−15 = 2.3 × 10−13 J = 1.4 MeV, called the Coulomb barrier.
Typical energy at the core, T = 1.5 × 107 K: (3/2) k T = 1.5 × 1.38 × 10−23 × 1.5 × 107 = 3.1 × 10−16 J = 1.9 keV.
“The barrier is about seven hundred times bigger than the usual energy,” said Memoon. “Almost no pair of protons gets over it the ordinary way. Fusion in the Sun happens because a few protons are unusually fast, and also because of quantum tunnelling, where particles sometimes get through a barrier that classical physics says they cannot. Even so, the chance for any one proton is tiny. NASA says a given proton in the core waits something like fourteen billion years for its turn.”
“That is slower than the Sun has existed,” said Beautine.
“Yes, for one proton. But there are about 1057 of them.”
“So the Sun is not an explosion,” said Kachui, with relief. “It is a very slow, very large leak.”
Memoon grinned. “How much power does one cubic metre of the Sun produce, on average?” She did the sum on the notebook and then held it up.
Maths track: Volume = (4/3) π R3 = 1.41 × 1027 m3. Power per m3 = 3.83 × 1026 / 1.41 × 1027 = 0.27 W/m3. A person gives off about 100 W from about 0.07 m3, which is 1,400 W/m3.
“You,” said Memoon, pointing at Noodles, “make about five thousand times more power per cubic metre than the average cubic metre of the Sun.”
Noodles looked down at himself. “I knew I was warm.”
Nimo’s bubble drifted up from the tank. “Would you like to see it? Not as it is. As a picture.”
Imagine Mode. Nimo’s bubble slid into the Sun, past the thin bright skin and into the thick glowing gas below. There was no flame, no smoke, no ash. In the core the gas was a hot dense soup, a hundred and fifty times denser than water, so crowded that protons bumped into each other billions of times a second. Almost every bump ended in a bounce. Once in a very long while, two protons slipped through the barrier and stuck, and a little burst of light was born that would take ages to reach the surface. End of Imagine Mode. That was a picture, not an explanation. No one can ride a bubble into the Sun.
“How do we know any of this is real?” said Kachui. “All we see from outside is the surface.”
“Remember the other messengers,” said Memoon. “Fusion in the core also makes tiny particles called neutrinos. They almost never interact with anything, so they leave the core and cross the Sun in a couple of seconds. Detectors deep underground have counted neutrinos arriving from the Sun. That is a message from the core itself, not the surface.”
“A fifth message,” said Beautine.
“A different messenger,” said Memoon. “We do not follow neutrinos in this book, but we can count them as evidence.”
She turned to a clean page and made three labelled lines.
KNOWN: The Sun’s power comes from fusing hydrogen to helium in its core.
HINT: The exact rates at which each step happens; these come from lab measurements and models, and small differences remain.
GUESS: Nothing yet. We have not reached the edge.
Over the parapet, a plane blinked slowly across the haze. On the table, the notebook lay open at the page with the number that Kachui had checked twice: the Sun had been losing four million tonnes of itself every second, and shining on this rooftop with the proceeds.
Science Corner Mass-energy: E = m c2. The Sun’s luminosity, 3.83 × 1026 W, equals a mass loss of L / c2 = 4.3 × 109 kg every second. A nucleus contains protons and neutrons. Binding energy is the energy released when they bind, equal to the mass that goes missing. Helium-4 is more tightly bound per particle than hydrogen, so fusing hydrogen into helium releases energy. Fusion of four hydrogen nuclei into helium-4 releases about 26.7 MeV, 0.71% of the mass, or about 6.4 × 1014 J per kilogram: roughly twenty million times the energy of burning coal. Two protons repel, with a Coulomb barrier of about 1.4 MeV at one femtometre. At the core’s 15 million kelvin the usual energy is only about 2 keV, so fusion depends on a few fast protons and on quantum tunnelling, and happens slowly. Neutrinos from fusion cross the Sun in seconds and have been detected on Earth, a direct message from the core. Story note: The numbers are rounded, and the 10% of the Sun’s mass as available fuel is an assumption; the real figure depends on how far the core’s fusing zone extends. GM2 / R is an order-of-magnitude estimate that ignores how the Sun’s mass is spread. In the Sun about 99 per cent of the energy comes from the proton-proton chain, which turns four protons into helium in several steps, with a small share from another cycle; a few per cent of the 26.7 MeV is carried off by neutrinos. The mass loss in the story is only the mass converted to light; the Sun also loses some matter in the solar wind, which is a separate effect. The picture of the ’average power per cubic metre’ hides the fact that almost all fusion happens inside roughly the inner third of the Sun’s radius, where the rate per cubic metre is much higher. Imagine Mode was a picture, not an explanation, and Noodles’s very large bonfire fails by a factor of nearly a million.
Space Detective 1. Explain why neither chemical burning nor slow shrinking can power the Sun for billions of years. 2. The fusion of hydrogen releases 0.71% of the mass as energy. Use L = 3.83 × 1026 W to find how many kilograms of hydrogen the Sun fuses every second, and say how this compares with the 4.3 × 109 kg of mass it loses. 3. Look up the energy per kilogram for three fuels (for example wood, petrol and coal). Draw a bar chart on a logarithmic scale that also shows hydrogen fusion at 6.4 × 1014 J/kg, and describe what the picture shows.
Try it: Power Per Cubic Metre Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult can check your conversions and help find the figures; use a typical person, not your own measurements. You need: a calculator, your Sky Notebook, a table of energy values (a nutrition guide will do). Do: A typical adult eats about 2,000 kilocalories a day, which is 8.4 × 106 J. Divide by 86,400 s to find the average power. Take a typical body mass of 70 kg and a density close to 1,000 kg per cubic metre to estimate the volume. Find the power per cubic metre and compare it with the Sun’s average of 0.27 W per cubic metre. What to expect: About 100 W, a volume of about 0.07 cubic metres, and about 1,400 W per cubic metre: thousands of times the Sun’s average. Cloudy or low-resource day: This activity needs only paper. Limitation: the Sun’s average hides its core, where most of the fusing happens inside about 30 per cent of the radius, so the core’s rate per cubic metre is higher than the average.
Next time: We know what lights the Sun. Tomorrow the Club will point its eyes at galaxies, where hydrogen’s lines turn up in the wrong place.
← Chapter 3: Atoms Speak in Colours · Book 12 contents · Chapter 5: The Stretching Light →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment