Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 5: The Stretching Light
Chapter 5: The Stretching Light
In this chapter: Calculate redshift from a shifted spectral line, estimate the Hubble constant by fitting a straight line to distance and redshift data, and explain why the expansion of the Universe is not an explosion into empty space.
On the fifth evening, Mr Rao came up the stairs carrying his old tablet in both hands, like a man delivering a cake. “The Wi-Fi reaches the terrace if you hold it near the water tank,” he said. “Beautine, you asked for open data. I have found a place where the astronomers leave their tables lying about for anyone.”
“I did not ask for that,” said Beautine. “I asked whether there was a website where I could see the largest number of things.”
“Same thing.”
Memoon took the tablet and held it where everyone could see. A survey of galaxies had released its measurements to the public: positions, brightnesses, spectra, and for a handful of galaxies, careful distances. She copied five rows into the notebook. The table gave each galaxy’s distance in megaparsecs, a unit of distance used in astronomy, equal to about 3.26 million light-years, or 3.09 × 1022 metres, and the wavelength at which the hydrogen line, the red one that Guddu’s lab tube showed at 656.3 nanometres, appeared in each galaxy’s light.
Galaxy A: distance 30 Mpc, line at 661.3 nm. Galaxy B: 60 Mpc, 665.0 nm. Galaxy C: 100 Mpc, 672.5 nm. Galaxy D: 150 Mpc, 678.6 nm. Galaxy E: 200 Mpc, 688.0 nm.
“They are all longer,” said Kachui, almost to herself. “Every one of them is shifted to the red.”
“Beautine, you are about to say something dramatic,” said Memoon.
“They are all running away from us!” said Beautine. “We are in the middle of a gigantic explosion and everyone is fleeing!”
“Wait,” said Memoon. “Let us define the shift first, then see what it does.” She wrote:
z = (λ observed − λ emitted) / λ emitted.
“This number is the redshift. It says by what fraction the wavelength has grown. For Galaxy A:”
Maths track: z = (661.3 − 656.3) / 656.3 = 0.0076.
Kachui did the other four on the calculator and read them out. “B, 0.0133. C, 0.0247. D, 0.0340. E, 0.0483.”
“We have met the Doppler shift before: when a source moves away, its light is shifted to longer wavelengths,” said Memoon. “For speeds much smaller than light, the fractional shift is the speed divided by c.”
v = c z, with c = 3.00 × 105 km/s.
A: v = 2,300 km/s. B: 4,000. C: 7,400. D: 10,200. E: 14,500 km/s.
“Fast,” said Simbha. “Galaxy E recedes at about five per cent of the speed of light.”
“Now draw them,” said Memoon. “A graph. Distance across, speed up.”
They drew it together. The five points did not sit in a perfect line, but they lined up like geese: a slope rising from the origin. Further away, faster.
“Draw the best straight line through the starting point,” said Kachui. “A galaxy at distance zero has speed zero. The line has to pass through the origin.”
“How?” said Beautine. “They are scattered.”
“We choose the slope that makes the vertical misses as small as we can,” said Kachui. “For a line through the origin, there is a formula. The slope is the sum of v times d, divided by the sum of d squared.”
Maths track: sum of v d = 2,300 × 30 + 4,000 × 60 + 7,400 × 100 + 10,200 × 150 + 14,500 × 200 = 5,479,000.
Sum of d2 = 900 + 3,600 + 10,000 + 22,500 + 40,000 = 77,000.
Slope = 5,479,000 / 77,000 = 71 km/s per Mpc.
“That slope has a name,” said Memoon. “It is called the Hubble constant, H0, and the statement that speed goes up in proportion to distance is the Hubble-Lemaitre law.”
v = H0 d, with H0 about 71 km/s/Mpc from our five galaxies.
“It says a galaxy twice as far goes twice as fast,” said Kachui. “A very simple rule for something so large.”
“I have a bet to make,” said Noodles, sitting up. “I will predict the next galaxy. Mr Rao, find one at two hundred and fifty megaparsecs.”
“What is your prediction?”
Prediction: v = 71 × 250 = 17,750 km/s. z = 17,750 / 300,000 = 0.0592. λ = 656.3 × 1.0592 = 695.1 nm.
Noodles makes his bet about the red line
“Six hundred and ninety-five point one,” said Noodles, as grandly as a cat can.
Mr Rao scrolled. After a minute he squinted. “There is one at two hundred and fifty. The line is at ... six hundred and ninety-seven.”
Observed 697.0 nm: z = 40.7 / 656.3 = 0.0620; v = 18,600 km/s. The prediction was within 0.3 per cent in wavelength.
“A prediction that could have failed, and did not,” said Kachui. “That is worth a biscuit.”
“I accept,” said Simbha, handing one over, a little sadly.
Beautine was not finished. “But I still say it is an explosion. Everything flying away from us, from one place. We are the middle.”
Nimo’s bubble came to the surface. “May I try a picture in my tank? I do not have an explosion in my tank. I have a long elastic band. Simbha, hold that end, please. Kachui, the other.”
Simbha pinched one end of the band in his huge paw. Kachui held the other, which did not require much of her at all. Nimo, from the water, called out, “I have drawn dots every centimetre. The first dot is us. Now stretch it to twice as long, slowly, in one second.”
They stretched. The dot a centimetre away moved to two centimetres: it had moved by one centimetre. The dot ten centimetres away moved to twenty: it had moved by ten.
“Notice,” said Nimo. “Every dot has moved away from the first. The ten-centimetre dot moved ten times as far in the same time. Now the key part. Let us pretend we are the dot at five centimetres.”
They looked. From the dot at five centimetres, the dot at six centimetres had moved a little; the dot at fifteen had moved ten times as much. The pattern was the same: faster, the farther.
“No dot is the centre,” said Memoon slowly. “Every dot sees every other dot moving away in proportion to the distance. That is exactly the Hubble-Lemaitre law. And it needs no explosion and no centre.”
“And no galaxy moves through the band,” said Kachui. “The band itself gets longer. That is not an explosion from a point. It is what we mean by the expansion of space: the distances between far-apart galaxies grow, as if the band stretches.”
“Where does your picture stop working?” Kachui asked Nimo, because she had to.
“The band has two ends and sits in a room,” said Nimo, a little apologetically. “The Universe in this model has no edge to hold and no room outside it. My band is only a picture of the distances growing.”
Memoon uncapped a pen. “Hold the band again. I am going to draw a little wave on it.” She drew a squiggle, one crest to the next, along a few centimetres of the band. “Now stretch.”
The squiggle stretched. The distance from crest to crest grew along with everything else.
“That is why the light is redshifted,” said Memoon. “Not because the galaxies are throwing their light at a slower rate. The wave travels through space that is stretching, and the wave is stretched with it. The wavelength grows by the same factor as the distances. That is called cosmological redshift.”
(1 + z) = (size of the Universe now) / (size when the light left).
“For Galaxy E, z = 0.0483, so the Universe is now 4.8 per cent larger than when that light left,” said Kachui.
“Then it is not the Doppler shift after all?” asked Beautine.
“For small redshifts, the numbers agree, and the Doppler picture is a handy shortcut,” said Memoon. “But the two pictures are not the same thing. In one, a galaxy moves through space. In the other, space grows. The second picture is the one that keeps working when the redshifts get large. The simple rule v = cz works only for small z.”
Beautine looked towards the Andromeda direction. “Wait. If all galaxies are flying away, then why is Andromeda coming towards us? I read that it is.”
“A sharp point,” said Kachui, delighted. “The nearby galaxies are held by gravity. Our Milky Way and Andromeda pull on each other and are falling together, which is a blueshift. The law only shows up when you look far enough that the stretching beats the local pulling. Atoms, planets, the Sun, and the Milky Way do not expand either. They are bound.”
“So I had too little evidence,” said Beautine meekly.
“You had a good pattern,” said Memoon. “You needed a second look.”
Mr Rao raised a hand. “How do the astronomers know how far each galaxy is? I would have thought that was the hard part.”
“It is the hard part,” said Memoon. “Redshift is easy. Distance is hard. You cannot measure the distance to a galaxy with a ruler. You use a standard candle, an object whose true brightness you know. A pulsating star called a Cepheid is one, and a particular kind of exploding star is another. Compare how bright it looks to how bright it really is, and you can compute how far away it is. Henrietta Leavitt found the rule for Cepheids over a hundred years ago.”
“And the person who first announced that galaxies are receding?” asked Mr Rao.
“Georges Lemaitre, a Belgian priest and physicist, calculated it in 1927. Edwin Hubble published his observations in 1929. Astronomers voted in 2018 to call it the Hubble-Lemaitre law, to give both men credit.”
Kachui wrote three lines in the notebook and boxed them.
KNOWN: Light from distant galaxies is redshifted, and the shift grows with distance.
HINT: The best value of H0. Our five galaxies gave 71 km/s/Mpc. Other methods may differ.
GUESS: What “the whole Universe” looks like beyond what we can see.
Five dots on a stretched rubber band, all evenly spaced
“There is one more thing,” said Memoon, looking at the band that Simbha was still politely holding. “If distances are growing at a steady rate, then we can run the film backwards. Distances shrink. Everything gets closer.”
“How close?” asked Noodles.
“Let us find out tomorrow.”
Simbha let go of the band. It snapped back, as bands do, and flicked a biscuit off the table. Noodles caught it without looking.
The rubber-band model of expanding space
Before: the band is relaxed
A B C D E
Gap between neighbours: 1 unit
After: the band is stretched to twice its length
A B C D E
Gap between neighbours: 2 units Every gap doubled, and A to E went from 4 units to 8 units.
Every dot sees all the others move away, and no dot is the centre. The dots do not slide along the band: the band between them stretches. A one-dimensional model. Real space has three dimensions and no edge to stretch from.
The rubber-band model of expanding space. A one-dimensional picture: real space has three dimensions.
Science Corner Redshift is the fractional stretch of a wavelength: z = (λ observed − λ emitted) / λ emitted. For small z, the recession speed is v = c z. The Hubble-Lemaitre law says distant galaxies recede at a speed proportional to their distance, v = H0 d. The Hubble constant H0 is the slope; the Club’s five galaxies give about 71 km/s per Mpc. A megaparsec (Mpc) is a distance unit: 1 Mpc is about 3.26 million light-years, or 3.09 × 1022 m. Cosmological redshift happens because space expands while the light travels: (1 + z) is the factor by which the Universe has grown since the light left. Bound systems such as atoms, the Solar System and the Milky Way do not expand. A standard candle is an object of known true brightness, such as a Cepheid variable or a particular kind of exploding star, used to find distances by comparing how bright it looks. Story note: The five galaxies’ numbers are invented to follow the pattern that real survey data show; real galaxies scatter around the line because of their own motions, which matter most for nearby ones. The straight-line fit through the origin assumes that all points have the same scatter, and the Club’s slope has a statistical uncertainty of a little over one unit. The rubber band has two ends and sits in a room; the Universe in this model has neither an edge nor an outside, and the band is only a
picture of distances growing. Nothing here claims the whole Universe is only what we can see; the word ’Universe’ in the model means the observable part and what we can extrapolate. v = cz is a small-redshift approximation, and the cosmological redshift is not really a Doppler shift, even though the numbers agree when z is small. The sixth galaxy’s prediction was a real test: it could have failed.
Space Detective 1. Using the rubber-band picture, explain why every galaxy sees the others moving away in proportion to distance without there being a centre. Name one place where the picture fails. 2. A galaxy’s hydrogen line, rest wavelength 656.3 nm, is observed at 700.0 nm. Find z, then v = c z, then its distance using H0 = 71 km/s per Mpc. Give the distance in megaparsecs and in millions of light-years. 3. Add the sixth galaxy (250 Mpc, 18,600 km/s) to the Club’s table. Recompute the slope with the formula (sum of v d) / (sum of d2) and say how much H0 changed.
Try it: Stretch the Band Time: 20 minutes. Adult: An adult should check that the band is not over-stretched and keep faces away from it, because bands can snap. You need: a long rubber band or elastic strip, a marker, a ruler, a friend, a timer. Do: Relax the band on a table and mark a dot every 2 cm. Draw a small wave squiggle between two dots. Hold one dot fixed and have your friend stretch the band slowly to twice its length over two seconds. Measure how far each dot moved and divide by the time to get its speed. Plot speed against starting distance. Measure the squiggle before and after. Repeat with a different dot held fixed. What to expect: A straight line through the origin, whichever dot you hold. The squiggle’s wavelength grows by the same factor as the band. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use a balloon instead: mark dots, inflate it a little, and measure with a piece of string. Limitation: the balloon’s surface is curved and has an inside and an outside, which the Universe in this model does not.
Next time: If distances grow steadily, what happens when you run the film backwards? Tomorrow the Club will find out, and find two published values of the Hubble constant that do not agree.
← Chapter 4: Inside the Sun’s Furnace · Book 12 contents · Chapter 6: Rewinding the Film →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment