Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 7: The Oldest Light
Chapter 7: The Oldest Light
In this chapter: Explain what the cosmic microwave background is and why it is a thermal glow, calculate its temperature at the time it was released, and use its dipole to find our speed, while stating what this light cannot tell us.
Mr Rao arrived on the terrace at the same moment as the biscuit plate. He took one, settled on the top step with the air of a man about to give a lecture, and cleared his throat.
“In 1964,” he said, “there were two radio engineers in New Jersey, named Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson. They worked for a company called Bell Laboratories. They had an enormous horn-shaped antenna on a hill, built for talking to satellites. They wanted to use it to listen to the sky, very carefully, for faint radio waves. To do that they had to get rid of every bit of noise they could.”
Beautine had stopped eating. She was sitting on her tail with both paws on her chest.
“And there was noise,” said Mr Rao. “A faint steady hiss, in the microwave band, at a wavelength of about seven centimetres. It was the same in the morning and the evening. It did not change with the seasons. It did not matter where they pointed the antenna. They checked the wiring. They checked the connectors. They found that a pair of pigeons had been nesting in the horn. They caught the pigeons and sent them away. They cleaned out the droppings. They put tape over the joints. The hiss stayed.”
“Was it the city?” asked Noodles.
“They thought of that. They thought of everything. It was coming from every direction in the sky, equally. And the strength of the hiss was equal to what you would get from something at a temperature of about three kelvin.” Mr Rao spread his hands. “They did not know what it was. By chance, they spoke to some people at the university in Princeton, a few hours away. A group there, led by Robert Dicke, was working out what leftover radiation from a hot early Universe ought to look like, and was getting ready to build an antenna to look for it. Both groups published a pair of papers together, in 1965. Penzias and Wilson won the Nobel Prize in 1978.”
Kachui, who had been taking notes, looked up. “Someone predicted it before that. In 1948, Ralph Alpher and Robert Herman worked out that a hot start should leave a glow of about five kelvin. Nobody went looking.”
“A prediction nobody tested, and a discovery nobody expected,” said Mr Rao, with satisfaction. “And that is where my story stops. I am a retired bank clerk. You are the astronomers. What was it?”
Memoon looked at the notebook. “We have it already,” she said. “Let us put the pieces together. Remember the line I underlined on the second evening.”
λ(max) = 1 mm gives T = 2.9 K.
“A body at about three kelvin glows most strongly at a wavelength near one millimetre,” said Kachui. “The antenna measured at seven centimetres, which is on the long-wavelength side of the same curve. If it is a glow from a thermal source, then at a shorter wavelength there should be a peak, and the strength should follow Planck’s law.”
“That is a test,” said Memoon. “A prediction that can fail. It was done, many times, and finally by a satellite called COBE in the early 1990s. It measured the spectrum across a wide range of wavelengths. Mr Rao, you will like this. The curve it gave was the best blackbody spectrum ever measured.”
T = 2.725 ± 0.002 K. Peak wavelength: 2.898 × 10−3 / 2.725 = 1.06 mm.
“After only nine minutes of observing, they had the shape,” said Mr Rao, who had clearly read about this.
“A perfect blackbody means a hot, dense, mixed-up state,” said Memoon. “Radiation that has bounced back and forth with matter so many times that all memory of where it came from has been lost, and only the temperature is left. Nothing in space today does that for the whole sky. So the glow has to have been made when the Universe itself was in that state.”
Nimo’s bubble came to the surface. He looked, for once, rather solemn. “I would like to show you the state. Not as it was. As a picture.”
Imagine Mode. Nimo’s bubble slid into a very early Universe, not into any place but into everywhere. All around it was a hot, thick, glowing haze. There were no atoms, only separate protons and electrons whizzing about with light in between. A photon flew a short way and hit an electron and bounced off. It flew a short way and bounced again. It could never go far. The whole Universe was a fog, bright and opaque, like the inside of a lamp. Then, little by little, the fog thinned. The electrons and protons joined into atoms. The photons, suddenly free, flew straight out across space, and have been travelling ever since. End of Imagine Mode. That was a picture, not an explanation.
“The fog is the word to remember,” said Memoon. “The matter was a hot gas of charged particles called a plasma. Free electrons scatter light very easily. So light could not travel far. When the Universe cooled enough, the electrons and protons joined to make neutral hydrogen. This is recombination, though the electrons had never been combined before, so the name is a
historical accident. After that, light flew straight. The last place where each photon scattered is the surface of last scattering. It is not a surface in space, but a moment in time, and we see it in every direction.”
“When?” asked Beautine.
“About three hundred and eighty thousand years after the hot dense state began. And at a temperature of about three thousand kelvin.”
“Why three thousand?” asked Kachui at once. “Hydrogen needs 13.6 electronvolts to ionise. That would be a temperature of something like a hundred and sixty thousand.”
Maths track: T = E / k = 13.6 eV / (8.617 × 10−5 eV/K) = 1.6 × 105 K.
“A sharp question,” said Memoon. “There are about a billion photons for every atom. Even if the average photon has too little energy, a tiny fraction of the photons in the high-energy tail of the glow are enough to knock electrons loose again. So the Universe had to cool to far below that simple estimate before neutral atoms could survive. The full calculation uses Saha’s equation. I will trust it, but I will not derive it tonight.”
“And how do we get from three thousand kelvin to 2.7?” said Mr Rao.
“The stretching,” said Kachui. She turned to the page with the scale factor. “The light left when the Universe was about a thousand times smaller. Every wavelength has been stretched by the same factor. The redshift of that moment is about 1,090.”
T(then) = T(now) × (1 + z) = 2.725 × 1,091 = 2,970 K, about 3,000 K.
Peak wavelength then: 2.898 × 10−3 / 2,970 = 9.8 × 10−7 m, about 980 nm, near-infrared, almost red light.
Stretched by 1,091: 980 nm x 1,091 = 1.07 mm. It matches.
“So at that moment, the sky in every direction was as bright as the surface of a cool orange star,” said Simbha, who had been very still. “And it has been cooling since. Every part of the sky. All the time. A glow of ordinary light, stretched out until it is a faint hiss in a radio antenna.”
“Is it a lot of light?” asked Beautine.
Memoon did the count on the page. Photon density = 410 per cubic centimetre, from Planck’s law at 2.725 K. That is 4.1 × 108 per cubic metre.
“Four hundred million per cubic metre,” said Kachui. “And the average number of atoms in the Universe is far fewer.”
Maths track: Average density of atoms = about 0.25 per cubic metre. Photons per atom = 4.1 × 108 / 0.25 = 1.6 × 109.
“One hydrogen atom in every four cubic metres, on average,” said Mr Rao, a little stunned. “A single breath of air holds as many molecules as a cube of that average space about three Earths wide.”
Maths track (rough): A breath of 0.5 litre = 5 × 10−4 m3 holds about 1.2 × 1022 molecules (2.5 × 1025 per m3). Average space with that many atoms: 1.2 × 1022 / 0.25 = 4.9 × 1022 m3, a cube about 3.7 × 107 m on a side, about three Earth-diameters.
“A great deal of nothing, and a great deal of light,” said Memoon. “There is more to this glow. It is not exactly the same in every direction. Mr Rao, show them the map.”
Mr Rao held out the tablet. On the screen was an oval map of the whole sky, flattened like a map of the world, speckled in blotches of faint colour. “This is the whole sky in microwaves,” he said. “Blue spots a tiny bit colder, red spots a tiny bit warmer.”
“How different?” said Noodles.
“By about one part in a hundred thousand,” said Memoon. “Less than a hundredth of a thousandth. The map is stretched to show it.”
“There is a bigger difference first,” said Kachui. “The glow is slightly warmer in one half of the sky and slightly cooler in the other. At its warmest and coolest points the glow differs from the average by 3.37 thousandths of a kelvin. This pattern is called a dipole. It means one thing.”
“We are moving,” said Memoon. “Light coming towards us from the direction we are heading is Doppler shifted bluer and hotter. Light from behind is redder and cooler.”
Maths track: v = c x (delta T / T) = 3.00 × 105 km/s x (3.37 × 10−3 / 2.725) = 3.00 × 105 × 1.24 × 10−3 = 371 km/s.
“That is how fast the Solar System is moving relative to the glow,” said Memoon. “About three hundred and seventy kilometres per second. We are not sitting still, even though the terrace feels still. But that does not make the glow a special resting place in the sense of relativity. It is only a convenient reference.”
“Take out the dipole and look at what is left,” said Kachui. “The ripples. They are the seeds. Regions that were a tiny bit denser pulled in a little more matter. Over billions of years those became galaxies.”
“So the map is a baby photograph of the Universe’s structure,” said Mr Rao softly.
“The photograph from a very specific day,” said Memoon. “The day the fog cleared.”
Beautine was on her feet. “Then this is the Big Bang! The first moment! We have photographed the first moment!”
“No,” said Memoon gently. “This is the dramatic claim, and I have to take it down. The glow comes from about three hundred and eighty thousand years after the hot dense state began. Before that, the fog was opaque, and light cannot come through a fog. So with light alone we cannot see earlier than that. It is the oldest light we can see, not the first moment.”
“So the slip asks for something light cannot directly give,” said Kachui, slowly.
“Exactly. We need other evidence for what came before the fog cleared. That is what tomorrow is for.”
Mr Rao looked at the tablet for a long time. “The hiss in the antenna,” he said at last. “It was this. The whole time. They cleaned the pigeons out of a telescope that was listening to the beginning of everything.”
A timeline of the early universe
time
| Hot, dense start | Light set free | Stars and galaxies |
|---|---|---|
| too hot for atoms | about 380,000 years, 3,000 K | first stars, then galaxies |
| Glowing fog | Dark ages |
|---|---|
| light keeps scattering | neutral gas, no stars yet |
Today: 13.8 billion years, the background is 2.725 K The stretching of space cooled the light by a factor of about 1,100 (redshift z ≈ 1,090).
The sections are NOT drawn to scale: the first three together last less than 0.003% of the whole timeline.
A timeline of the early universe. Not to scale.
Kachui wrote three lines, and her pen did not hesitate.
KNOWN: A nearly perfect blackbody glow at 2.725 K fills the sky, almost the same in every direction.
HINT: It was released about 380,000 years after the hot dense state began, when the fog cleared.
GUESS: Nothing about the first moment itself. This light cannot reach that far back.
Noodles had been quiet for some time. “I have a confession,” he said. “Tomorrow I would like to argue against it. Someone has to. If everyone just agrees, how do we know?”
“That,” said Memoon, “is the best plan anyone has had all week.”
Science Corner The cosmic microwave background (CMB) is a nearly perfect blackbody glow at 2.725 K that fills the sky almost equally in every direction. Its peak wavelength is about 1.06 mm, in the microwave band. It was found by Penzias and Wilson in 1964 and 1965 and measured by the COBE satellite in the early 1990s. Before about 380,000 years, the matter was a hot plasma whose free electrons scattered light like a fog. At about 3,000 K, recombination formed neutral hydrogen and the light flew free. The surface of last scattering is a moment in time, not a place, and we see it in every direction. The glow has cooled by the stretching of space: T(then) = T(now) × (1 + z). With z of about 1,090, 2.725 K today was about 3,000 K then. There are about 410 CMB photons in every cubic centimetre, about 1.6 billion for each atom. The dipole (3.37 mK) shows our motion, about 371 km/s. After removing it, tiny ripples of about one part in 100,000, called anisotropy, remain: the seeds of galaxies. Story note: Mr Rao’s account of the pigeons is simplified; Penzias and Wilson did not know what the signal was until they spoke to the Princeton group. The recombination temperature of 3,000 K comes from a calculation (Saha’s equation) that the Club does not derive. The 380,000 years and redshift of 1,090 depend on the cosmological model. The CMB cannot show the first moment, since light cannot cross the fog; every statement about earlier times needs other evidence. The ’surface’ is a convenient word, not a physical wall. The dipole gives our speed relative to the CMB, which is a convenient reference, not a special resting place in the sense of relativity. Nimo’s fog picture fails as a literal picture because nothing was blown by wind; it is only about how light scatters. The sky map is shown stretched in colour, and the real differences are about one part in 100,000.
Space Detective 1. Explain why the CMB, the oldest light we can see, cannot show us the first moment of the Universe. 2. Using T(z) = T0 (1 + z), find the CMB temperature at redshift z = 3, then the peak wavelength at that time from Wien’s law. 3. Draw a timeline from the hot dense state to today. Mark the fog, the moment the fog cleared, the first stars, the Sun’s birth and now, and shade the part of the timeline that light cannot show us directly.
Try it: Hunt the Hiss Time: 25 minutes. Adult: An adult should supervise any switching of mains devices; do not unplug anything yourself, and keep the volume low. You need: a battery radio (AM or FM), your Sky Notebook. Do: Tune the radio between stations until you hear steady hiss. Test one cause at a time and note its effect on the hiss: switch off a lamp, move to another room, go to the terrace, rotate the radio, extend and retract the antenna, switch off a phone charger. Make a table of cause tested and effect. What to expect: Some causes make a big difference, such as certain lamps, chargers and phones, and some make none. A hiss remains whatever you do. Penzias and Wilson did exactly this kind of elimination on a much bigger scale. Cloudy or low-resource day: This works indoors or out and needs only a radio. With no radio, write a plan for how you would rule out causes of an unexplained signal. Limitation: the hiss left on your radio is mostly its own electronics and natural radio noise, not the sky’s glow, so it is not the CMB.
Next time: The hot glow is one piece of evidence. Noodles will argue against it tomorrow, and Simbha will ask why the Universe is three-quarters hydrogen.
← Chapter 6: Rewinding the Film · Book 12 contents · Chapter 8: The Big Bang Story and Its Edges →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment