Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 8: The Big Bang Story and Its Edges
Chapter 8: The Big Bang Story and Its Edges
In this chapter: Calculate the primordial helium fraction from the neutron-to-proton ratio, set out the evidence for the hot Big Bang model as a ladder of independent observations, and state clearly what the model does not say.
On the eighth evening the Club unrolled a very long sheet of chart paper across the terrace floor. Mrs Rao had sent up a roll of masking tape and the steel biscuit tin to hold one corner down. The other corners were held by the flask, the notebook and, after some discussion, Beautine.
Across the top, in Memoon’s neat capitals, was written WHAT THE LIGHT SAYS. Underneath were three columns headed KNOWN, HINT and GUESS.
“The poster for the Geminid night,” said Memoon. “Every claim goes in a column, with the evidence under it. Anyone who walks up to it can ask, ’How do you know?’ and we must be able to point.”
“I promised something yesterday,” said Noodles. He had put a paper hat on, for dignity. “I am going to argue against everything. I am the Steady State.”
“Explain what that is,” said Kachui, who was already taking notes.
“A very sensible idea. The Universe has always looked the same. Galaxies are moving apart, yes, but as they do, new matter appears in the gaps, a little at a time, and new galaxies form. So the Universe never starts and never changes. It is the same at every time and in every place. It looks the same in every direction. It looks the same tonight as it will tomorrow. How much more obvious can it be?”
“This was a real idea,” said Memoon, “and clever people held it. Fred Hoyle, Hermann Bondi and Thomas Gold proposed it in 1948. It deserved a proper test, and it got several. If the Universe is the same at all times, what should we see?”
“Distant galaxies, which we see as they were long ago, should look just like nearby ones,” said Simbha.
“And?”
“They do not quite. Galaxies seen at great look-back times differ from nearby ones in their typical shapes and sizes. The nearby Universe is not the same as the old one.”
“What else?” said Memoon.
Kachui turned a page. “A glow filling the sky at 2.725 kelvin, with a perfect blackbody shape. The Steady State, in its original form, has no easy way to make that. A hot early state does.”
Noodles took off his hat and put it on again. “I withdraw. For now. That is what I would have said anyway. A good argument against a good idea. May I keep the hat?”
“Keep it,” said Memoon. She wrote on the poster, under KNOWN: The Universe was not always the same. It was hotter and denser, and it has been expanding and cooling. “This is called the hot Big Bang model. A model is a set of rules that predicts what we will see. Let us test one more prediction of it, from the other end of the chain.”
She turned to Simbha. “You asked a question on the way up the stairs.”
“I asked why the Universe is three quarters hydrogen and one quarter helium,” said Simbha. “By mass. We are told stars make helium by fusion. Perhaps the helium simply came from stars.”
“It is a good thought, and testable,” said Memoon. “If stars made the helium, then a place with more stellar processing should have more helium, along with other elements that stars make, such as carbon, oxygen and iron. And a place with hardly any stellar processing, very old gas with little of those elements, should have very little helium.”
“And?” said Kachui, looking up.
“Astronomers have looked at gas clouds and galaxies with almost no heavy elements,” said Memoon. “They all show the same thing. Helium is never below about twenty-three per cent. There is a floor, whatever the amount of stellar processing. The helium was there before the first stars.”
“So it is older than the stars,” said Beautine, delighted. “Where did it come from?”
“From the first few minutes of the hot state,” said Memoon. “Let us calculate it. This is a problem you can do with what we already know. At about one second, the temperature was around ten billion kelvin, and the Universe was a hot soup of protons and neutrons, with light, electrons and neutrinos. A neutron is slightly heavier than a proton, so protons are slightly easier to make. At that moment, the ratio of neutrons to protons got fixed at about one to six.”
“Fixed?” said Kachui.
“The reactions that flip neutrons into protons and back became too slow to keep up with the cooling. But a free neutron is not stable. It decays, on average, in about 880 seconds, about fifteen minutes. And the helium cannot start forming until the temperature falls enough for the first step, deuterium, to survive. Before that, the photons are so energetic that they smash deuterium to bits as fast as it forms. That happens after about three minutes. In those three minutes, some neutrons decay.”
Maths track: Fraction of neutrons surviving after 180 s = e(−180 / 880) = e(−0.2045) = 0.815.
n / p = (1/6) × 0.815 = 0.136, which is about 1 in 7.
“Then nearly every neutron ends up in a helium-4 nucleus,” said Memoon. “Helium-4 has two protons and two neutrons. So for every two neutrons, there are two protons locked in helium, and the rest of the protons stay as hydrogen.”
Maths track: Take 100 protons. Neutrons = 100 × 0.136 = 13.6. Helium nuclei = 13.6 / 2 = 6.8, containing 6.8 × 4 = 27.2 units of mass. Total mass = 100 + 13.6 = 113.6 units.
Helium mass fraction Y = 27.2 / 113.6 = 0.24.
“Twenty-four per cent,” said Kachui, and her pen stopped. “It matches.”
“And if the ratio had been one in six rather than one in seven?” asked Simbha.
Y = 2 (n/p) / (1 + n/p). For n/p = 1/7: Y = 0.25. For 1/6: Y = 0.29. For 1/8: Y = 0.22.
“So the helium tells us the ratio, and the ratio tells us something about the very early Universe,” said Memoon. “The prediction depends only on the Universe having passed through a hot dense stage. It does not depend on the details of when galaxies formed. And that is why it is a good test.”
“What about deuterium?” said Kachui. “I wrote down that deuterium is only about one part in ten thousand of hydrogen.”
“Deuterium is fragile. Stars destroy it; they do not make it. So whatever deuterium we see must be left over from the early Universe. How much is left depends on how many ordinary atoms there were, since a denser Universe burns more of it to helium. The amount we see gives a measure of the density of ordinary matter. It agrees with the density from the ripples in the glow, which is a completely different measurement.”
“Two independent roads to the same number,” said Kachui, and underlined something.
Beautine was hunting through the notebook. “There is something about lithium here. The calculation does not quite work for lithium?”
“A sharp eye,” said Memoon. “The model predicts about three times more of one kind of lithium than we find in old stars. Either the model is missing something, or our estimate of what the early lithium was is wrong. Nobody knows. It is a loose thread. It does not unravel the whole sweater, but it should not be hidden.” She added a line to the HINT column of the poster: Lithium-7: the prediction and the observation disagree. Cause unknown.
Kachui took the marker and began, slowly, to write on the poster, but she kept her answers narrow. When she reached HINT she hesitated, the marker hovering.
“What is it?” said Memoon.
“I do not like putting things there,” said Kachui. “I am afraid of being wrong.”
“That is a good instinct and a bad habit,” said Memoon. “A HINT is not a failure. It is an honest label for a reasonable stretch beyond the evidence. If we only write what is certain, we write nothing about the edge, which is where the interesting things are.”
Kachui wrote. When they stood back, the poster read:
KNOWN: Distant galaxies recede in proportion to distance, so space is expanding. A 2.725 K blackbody glow fills the sky. About one quarter of ordinary matter, by mass, is helium made in the first minutes, as the calculation predicts. Two independent clocks, the expansion and the oldest stars, give an age of about 13.8 billion years.
HINT: The glow was released about 380,000 years after the hot dense state began. A very brief period of extremely rapid growth, called inflation, may have come first. Why the lithium and the Hubble constant do not match.
GUESS: What came before the hot dense state. Whether there was a before.
“One more column,” said Memoon, pulling out a fourth piece of paper and taping it beneath the poster. “What the model does not say. Because people say it for us.”
She wrote slowly.
It does not say there was an explosion at a point in space. The expansion has no centre and no edge in the model.
It does not say what caused the hot dense state, or that nothing existed before it. If you wind the equations back, they give infinite density at a moment. That is where the equations stop being trustworthy, not a discovery. We need a theory that joins gravity with quantum physics, and we do not have a tested one.
It does not say why there is more matter than antimatter. This is unexplained.
It does not say what most of the Universe is made of.
Beautine read the last line twice. “Wait. We have been talking about the ordinary matter. What is the rest?”
“That is tomorrow,” said Memoon. “I have wanted to say it all week. Everything we have measured so far, the atoms in the Sun and in us and in the glow, is about five per cent of the total.”
The terrace was silent. Even the water in Nimo’s tank was still.
“Five per cent,” said Kachui at last.
“About that. We know where the other ninety-five per cent leaves its footprints. We do not know what it is.”
Noodles pulled his hat down over his eyes, which, for him, was a form of respect.
Science Corner The hot Big Bang model says the Universe has expanded and cooled from a hot dense state. Its predictions have been tested in four independent ways: the expansion, the CMB, the light-element abundances, and the ages of the oldest stars. Big Bang nucleosynthesis happened in the first few minutes. With a neutron-to-proton ratio near 1 in 7, nearly all neutrons end up in helium-4, giving a helium mass fraction Y = 2 (n/p) / (1 + n/p) of about 0.24 to 0.25. Deuterium and a little lithium were also made. Baryons are protons and neutrons, the ordinary matter. They make up only about 5 per cent of the total content of the Universe; the deuterium abundance and the CMB ripples agree on this value, two very different routes to the same number. Helium is never seen below about 23 per cent, even in gas with almost no heavy elements, so most helium was made before the first stars. The model does not say there was an explosion at a point in space, does not describe what came before the hot dense state, and does not explain the excess of matter over antimatter. Inflation, a brief period of extremely rapid growth at the very start, is an idea under test, not an established result. Story note: The neutron-proton numbers are simplified: the real calculation is done by computer and gives a helium fraction close to 0.25, and the freeze-out ratio and the timing depend on details the Club skips. The Steady State was a serious scientific hypothesis, and testing alternatives is how science works; the original form is now ruled out, but the habit of arguing against a consensus is useful. The lithium disagreement is a real loose thread, and whether the fault lies in the model or in the estimate of the early lithium is not known. ’Infinite density’ when winding the equations back is a sign of where the theory fails, not a discovery. The name Big Bang is misleading because it suggests a bang in space, which the model does not say. The poster summarises; the evidence for each line is in the chapters before.
Space Detective 1. Explain why a floor of about 23 per cent helium, even in very old gas with almost no heavy elements, is evidence that helium was made before the first stars. 2. Suppose a neutron’s mean lifetime were 440 s instead of 880 s, with the same starting ratio of 1 in 6 and the same 180 s delay. Find the neutron-to-proton ratio and the helium mass fraction. 3. Choose one thing the Big Bang model does not say, such as ’it was an explosion’, and write a three-sentence correction that includes one piece of evidence.
Try it: Neutron Survivors Time: 25 minutes. Adult: An adult can help count and check the arithmetic; there are no hazards. You need: 60 small objects (beads or buttons), a die, graph paper. Do: Start with 60 beads, each one a free neutron. Each round stands for about three minutes. For each bead, roll the die; if it shows a six, remove the bead (it has decayed). Count the survivors. Repeat for six rounds and plot survivors against round number. Then use the first round’s survivors to find n/p = (1/6) × (survivors / 60) and the helium fraction Y. What to expect: About 50 survivors after round 1, about 42 after round 2, and so on, a smooth curve that falls by about one sixth each round. The real neutron figure after three minutes is e(−180/880) = 0.815, about 49 survivors out of 60. Cloudy or low-resource day: This activity is indoors and needs only a die and objects. Limitation: a die gives exactly one chance in six per round, which is not exactly the neutron’s 18.5 per cent in three minutes, so the model is only an illustration of exponential decay.
Next time: Only about five per cent of the Universe is ordinary matter. Tomorrow the Club looks at a galaxy that spins too fast, and at a map that shows the expansion speeding up.
← Chapter 7: The Oldest Light · Book 12 contents · Chapter 9: What We Cannot See →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment