Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 9: What We Cannot See
Chapter 9: What We Cannot See
In this chapter: Use a rotation curve to show that a galaxy contains much more mass than its light shows, explain why most of that mass cannot be ordinary matter, and describe how distant supernovae revealed accelerating expansion, labelling dark matter and dark energy as open questions.
On the ninth evening the wind had dropped, and the terrace was so quiet that they could hear the water ticking in the tank. Mrs Rao’s steel lantern stood on the table for light. It was an electric one with a pleasantly orange bulb, because Memoon had long ago insisted on that.
Nimo’s bubble hung just under the surface of the tank. He had stirred the water with a spoon until it spun in a slow whirlpool, and he was watching the little scraps of paper he had dropped on the surface.
“The inner ones go round fast,” he said. “The outer ones go round slowly. It is always like that. The farther from the centre, the slower the turn. I think I have found a rule.”
“Do we have an example in the sky?” asked Memoon.
Kachui flipped the notebook open. “The planets. We worked out in the orbit design that the speed in a circular orbit is the square root of GM over r. So the speed should fall as one over the square root of the distance.”
Maths track: v = √(G M / r), so v is proportional to 1 / √(r). Earth, at 1 AU: 29.8 km/s. Neptune, at 30.07 AU: 29.8 / √(30.07) = 5.4 km/s.
“Neptune does indeed go at about five and a half kilometres per second,” said Kachui. “A match.”
“And my whirlpool matches it,” said Nimo, pleased. “So galaxies must do the same. Stars in the outer parts must go slower.”
Nimo’s whirlpool bowl and the flat rotation curve
“Where does your picture fail?” said Memoon, kindly.
“In my tank the slowing comes from friction against the water,” said Nimo, thinking. “In the Solar System it comes from weaker gravity farther out, because nearly all the mass is in the Sun. In a galaxy, the mass is spread out. I think I assumed something.”
“You assumed the rules of your tank,” said Kachui, with a small smile.
“A good habit to catch,” said Memoon. She took the tablet from Mr Rao, who had gone down for more chai and left it on the table. “Here is what is measured. A spiral galaxy, a big one like ours. Its stars and gas have been measured by the Doppler shift of their light, and each gives a speed at its distance from the centre. I have copied a few. The distances are in kiloparsecs, a thousand parsecs.”
Distance (kpc) and speed (km/s): 2 and 150; 5 and 200; 10 and 220; 20 and 222; 30 and 220; 40 and 218.
“These numbers are invented to follow the pattern real galaxies show,” said Memoon, “but the pattern itself is real.”
“They do not fall,” said Simbha, leaning close. “They stay flat. Two hundred and twenty, two hundred and twenty-two, two hundred and twenty. From ten out to forty.”
“A flat rotation curve,” said Memoon. “What does it mean for the mass? Use the formula backwards.”
Kachui rearranged it. “M = v squared times r over G. That gives the mass inside radius r, if the mass is roughly spherical. The units are awkward. Kiloparsecs, kilometres per second, solar masses. Let me convert G once.”
Maths track: G x (1 solar mass) = 6.674 × 10−11 × 1.989 × 1030 = 1.327 × 1020 m3/s2. In kpc and (km/s)2: 1.327 × 1020 / (3.086 × 1019 × 106) = 4.30 × 10−6.
So M(r) = v2 r / (4.30 × 10−6) solar masses, with v in km/s and r in kpc.
At 10 kpc: M = 2202 × 10 / (4.30 × 10−6) = 1.1 × 1011 solar masses.
At 30 kpc: M = 2202 × 30 / (4.30 × 10−6) = 3.4 × 1011 solar masses.
“The mass keeps growing as you go out,” said Kachui slowly. “Between 10 and 30 kpc, the enclosed mass triples.”
“And the starlight?” asked Memoon.
“The light fades long before that. Most of the stars and gas in a galaxy like this sit inside about 10 kpc.” Kachui looked it up. “A big spiral like ours has about six times ten to the ten solar masses of visible stars and gas, say.”
Maths track: If all the visible mass, 6 × 1010 solar masses, sat inside 10 kpc, the speed at 30 kpc would be v = √(4.30 × 10−6 × 6 × 1010 / 30) = √(8,600) = 93 km/s.
Observed: 220 km/s. The observed speed is 2.4 times larger.
Mass needed inside 30 kpc: 3.4 × 1011. Visible: 0.6 × 1011. The unseen fraction = (3.4 − 0.6) / 3.4 = 82%.
“There is much more gravity than the light accounts for,” said Memoon. “This is the clue. It was found, in different ways, by a number of people. In 1933 a Swiss astronomer named Fritz Zwicky saw that the galaxies in a big cluster were moving so fast that the cluster should have flown apart. He called the missing stuff dark matter. In the 1970s Vera Rubin and her colleague Kent Ford measured the speeds of stars in Andromeda and in dozens of other spiral galaxies, and every one of them was flat. It was the sheer number of them, one after another, that made people take it seriously.”
“So there is invisible mass out there that pulls things,” said Beautine, rubbing her paws together, “and it is probably ordinary stuff. Dim stars. Cold dust. A lot of small black holes. Planets nobody has found. We just have not counted properly.”
Rotation curve of a spiral galaxy
observed: stays flat
orbital speed (km/s)
expected if only the visible matter pulled
0 10 20 30
distance from the galaxy centre (kpc)
Invented practice data with a simplified shape. The dashed curve assumes all the visible mass sits inside 10 kpc.
A galaxy rotation curve, with invented practice data and a simplified expected shape.
“That is a good proposal,” said Memoon. “Is it testable?”
Kachui drew a line in the notebook. “The amount of ordinary matter, protons and neutrons, is fixed by two independent measurements: how much deuterium came out of the first few minutes, and the pattern of ripples in the glow. They agree. Ordinary matter makes up only about 4.9 per cent of the total content of the Universe. The total amount of matter that pulls, of every kind, is about 31.5 per cent. So ordinary matter cannot make up more than a sixth of it.”
Maths track: Dark fraction of all matter = (0.315 − 0.049) / 0.315 = 0.84.
“Eighty-four per cent of the matter is not ordinary,” said Beautine, and her tail drooped. “Even if I found every dim star and every black hole.”
“More evidence,” said Memoon. “In a famous pair of colliding galaxy clusters called the Bullet Cluster, most of the ordinary matter is hot gas, which glows in X-rays. The mass, measured by how it bends the light of galaxies behind it, which is called gravitational lensing, is somewhere else. The gas slowed in the collision. The mass did not. Many astronomers take that as strong evidence for a separate kind of matter, one that passes through itself without a fuss, interacting by gravity and almost nothing else. A few have proposed instead that gravity itself works differently at very low accelerations. That idea can match some galaxy curves, but it has found the cluster and the glow harder to match.”
“Even the dark things are known by light,” said Simbha. “The speeds came from Doppler shifts. The lensing came from bent light.”
“Yes. Everything we know about the sky is a message of light. Even about what is not shining.”
“What is it?” said Noodles, who had stopped joking for some time.
“Nobody knows,” said Memoon. “Most physicists think it is a new kind of particle that hardly ever bumps into ordinary matter. There are experiments deep underground, in old mines, in tanks of liquid xenon, waiting for a single rare collision. They have been searching for decades without a confirmed detection. The searches go on, and every year the results get sharper.”
“A search that finds nothing is still a result,” said Kachui, firmly.
“The word dark does not mean mysterious or magic,” said Memoon. “It means that it does not give out or absorb light. Dark matter is a name for what we measure by its pull. It is not an explanation of what it is.”
She drew a slow line under the page and started a new one. “There is another puzzle, and it is about the stretching. Think of the rubber band. If gravity from all the matter is pulling the Universe together, the stretching should slow down as time goes on. That was the expected answer. It was tested in 1998 by two competing teams, using the exploding stars we met before. Type Ia supernovae can be used as standard candles. Compare how bright they look with how bright they truly are, and you get a distance. Compare the distance to the redshift, and you get the history of the stretching.”
“And?” said Beautine.
“The distant ones were fainter than expected,” said Memoon. “More than fifty of them. Fainter means farther. Farther than they should have been means the stretching had been speeding up.”
Maths track: Brightness (flux) goes as 1 / d2. If a supernova’s measured flux is 80% of what was expected, then d(true) / d(expected) = 1 / √(0.8) = 1.12. It is 12% farther than expected.
“The two teams found the same thing from different directions,” said Kachui. “Saul Perlmutter, Brian Schmidt and Adam Riess shared the Nobel Prize in 2011.”
“We expected a brake,” said Memoon. “We found an accelerator. We call whatever is causing it dark energy. The simplest idea is that space itself has a constant amount of energy in every cubic metre, which Einstein had once added to his equations and later dropped. It is called the cosmological constant.”
“How much of the Universe is it?” asked Noodles.
What the universe is made of (today, by total energy)
4.9% 26.5% 68.5%
Dark matter Dark energy
Ordinary matter (atoms: stars, gas, us)
Dark matter and dark energy are names for things we measure but do not yet understand.
Rounded Planck values. They add up to about 100%. These are the best current estimates and they can change.
What the universe is made of today. Rounded Planck values.
Planck results: ordinary matter 4.9%, dark matter 26.5%, dark energy 68.5%.
“Over two thirds,” said Beautine, awed. “So dark energy is a force that will tear the Universe apart!”
“That is a guess, and a loud one,” said Memoon. “If dark energy is constant, the Universe goes on stretching faster and faster, and distant galaxies fade from view. If it changes with time, the future is different. In 2025, a large survey of galaxy positions, called DESI, found hints that dark energy might be weakening over time. It is not settled. The survey finished its planned map in 2026, and its first results from the full five years of data are expected in 2027. A good moment to be curious.”
“A constant, or a changing thing, or something else altogether,” said Simbha. “And this might be connected to the two Hubble numbers.”
“It might,” said Memoon. “It might not. We do not know.”
Kachui wrote three lines at the bottom of the page.
KNOWN: There is far more gravity in galaxies and clusters than their visible matter explains, and the expansion of the Universe is speeding up.
HINT: Most of the extra gravity comes from a new kind of matter, not ordinary matter. The simplest account of the acceleration is a constant energy of space.
GUESS: What dark matter is made of. What dark energy is. Whether it changes. How the Universe ends.
“That is a lot of GUESS,” said Beautine, a little breathless.
“That,” said Memoon, “is what the edge looks like.”
The lantern’s orange glow lay on the notebook. On the table, between the biscuit tin and the flask, Kachui’s Question Jar stood where it had stood all week, with one slip left inside.
“Tomorrow is the Geminid night,” said Kachui. “And the oldest slip.”
“And a very big question,” said Memoon. “Not ours. Yours. Each of you will tell me tomorrow the question you want to spend the next year finding out about, and how you would begin. That is what a researcher does.”
Noodles looked uncharacteristically nervous. “I have never had a question I wanted to ask for a year.”
“You will have one by morning,” said Kachui.
Science Corner A rotation curve plots orbital speed against distance from the centre. Around the Sun, v falls as 1 / √(r). In spiral galaxies it stays flat far beyond the starlight. The mass inside radius r is M(r) = v2 r / G, which is v2 r / (4.30 × 10−6) solar masses for v in km/s and r in kpc. Dark matter is unseen matter known only by its gravity, from rotation curves, cluster motions, gravitational lensing (mass bending light) and the ripple pattern in the CMB. Ordinary matter is only about 4.9 per cent of the total content, while all matter is about 31.5 per cent, so about 84 per cent of matter is not ordinary. What it is remains unknown. Dark energy is the name for whatever makes the expansion accelerate. It was found in 1998 when distant Type Ia supernovae looked fainter, and so farther, than expected. The simplest model is a constant energy of space, the cosmological constant. Planck’s model-dependent fit gives about 4.9 per cent ordinary matter, 26.5 per cent dark matter and 68.5 per cent dark energy. Hints from DESI in 2025 that dark energy may change with time are not settled; first results from its full five-year survey are expected in 2027. Story note: The galaxy’s numbers are invented to follow the pattern real galaxies show, and the formula M = v2 r / G assumes a roughly spherical mass distribution, which a flat disc is not, so real galaxy models are more careful. The 6 × 1010 solar masses of visible stars and gas is a typical figure for a big spiral, assumed for the exercise. Some ordinary matter is hard to see too, such as thin hot gas around galaxies, which is why the Club used the total ordinary-matter figure from the CMB and the deuterium abundance rather than counting. ’Dark’ means that it gives out and absorbs no light, not
that it is mysterious in any magical sense. Modified-gravity ideas are tested against the same data, and so far the dark-matter account has fitted the widest range of evidence, though some galaxy-scale details are debated. Underground searches have not yet confirmed a dark-matter particle, and new results continue to appear. The flux example is an illustration of the size of the effect, not a real measurement. Whether dark energy is constant or changing is an open question.
Space Detective 1. Explain why a flat rotation curve points to unseen mass, and how it differs from the speeds of the planets around the Sun. 2. Use M(r) = v2 r / (4.30 × 10−6) to find the mass inside r = 20 kpc if v = 222 km/s, and compare it with the 6 × 1010 solar masses of visible matter. 3. Write one sentence each for the evidence for dark matter and for dark energy, label each KNOWN, HINT or GUESS, and say which you find stronger and why.
Try it: The Solar System’s Rotation Curve Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult can check the unit conversions; there are no hazards. You need: a calculator, graph paper, the data below. Do: Use v = 2 π r / T, with 1 AU = 1.496 × 108 km and T converted to seconds. Data: Mercury 0.387 AU, 87.97 days; Earth 1.000 AU, 365.25 days; Jupiter 5.203 AU, 4,333 days; Neptune 30.07 AU, 60,190 days. Work out each speed in km/s, plot speed against distance on graph paper, and add the flat 220 km/s line of the galaxy for comparison. What to expect: About 48, 29.8, 13.1 and 5.4 km/s: a falling curve like 1 / √(r). The galaxy’s curve does not fall, which is the whole puzzle. Cloudy or low-resource day: This activity is indoors and needs only paper. Limitation: planet orbits are slightly elliptical, so using the mean radius is an approximation, and nearly all the Solar System’s mass sits in the Sun, unlike a galaxy.
Next time: Tomorrow is the Geminid night, the building comes up to the terrace, and the oldest slip in the jar is finally opened. Each friend must bring a research question of their own.
← Chapter 8: The Big Bang Story and Its Edges · Book 12 contents · Chapter 10: Your Own Question →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment