Memunic Space Explorers › Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question › Chapter 10: Your Own Question
Chapter 10: Your Own Question
In this chapter: Write a research proposal that states a question, data, method, uncertainty, a prediction made in advance and a way to be wrong; use open data or citizen science; and answer the series’ first question with every claim labelled KNOWN, HINT or GUESS.
By nine o’clock on the Geminid night, the terrace had never been so full. Families had brought mats and flasks up the stairs. Children lay on their backs in rows, wrapped in blankets. Mrs Rao stood at the top of the stairs handing out cups of chai as if she were running a small border post, and Mr Rao, with a clipboard he had borrowed from a neighbour, was trying to look like an organiser.
The poster lay unrolled on the floor beside the table, held at its corners by the steel tin, the flask, the notebook and four stones. People kept stopping to read it. A boy of about seven was reading the GUESS column aloud to his grandmother, one word at a time, and she was nodding gravely at each.
“Is the Moon going to get in the way?” a woman asked Simbha.
“A thin crescent,” said Simbha. “It will set early this evening, and then the sky will be darker. It is a good year for it.”
“The meteors come from where?” asked the boy.
“From the direction of the constellation Gemini, which is why they are called Geminids,” said Kachui, who was crouched beside him. “But they are not from the stars at all. They are tiny grains of dust and rock, left behind by an asteroid called Phaethon. When Earth runs through the stream, the grains hit the air at tens of kilometres a second and glow.”
“Glow like a spark?”
“The air around the grain glows. The grain itself is about the size of a grain of sand.”
Memoon set up a folding table at the edge of the crowd, put the notebook in the middle, and tapped it with her pen until the chatter died down. “Before we count meteors,” she said, “we have something to read. Kachui.”
Kachui brought out the Question Jar and set it on the table in front of everyone. She lifted the cork and took out a slip so old that it had gone the colour of weak tea. The paper was soft at the folds. The writing on it was large and round and a little uneven.
“This is the oldest slip,” she said. “It is in my records. First evening of the Club. It was written by all of us together, one word each, because we could not agree on a question and so we agreed on a sentence. Memoon wrote the first word. Simbha drew the question mark, because he said he could not spell.”
“I could,” said Simbha mildly, “and I did not feel like it.”
Kachui unfolded it and read.
“Where did everything come from?”
The terrace was quiet. In the quiet, a child said, in a whisper, “That is a big one.”
“It is,” said Memoon. “It is the biggest one. When we first wrote it we meant it as a question for later, and later has been a long road. Tonight we answer it as far as light allows.” She turned to the poster. “Rule 3. Every sentence gets a label. Kachui, will you read it back?”
Memoon spoke slowly. Kachui wrote.
“The atoms in your body are mostly made of hydrogen, carbon, oxygen and a few others. The hydrogen atoms in your body, about a tenth of your mass, are about as old as the hot early state of the Universe, made in its first few minutes. KNOWN.”
“The carbon in your cells, the oxygen in your breath, the iron in your blood, were made inside stars and flung out when stars died. KNOWN.”
“The stars and galaxies grew from tiny differences in density, the ripples we can still see in the glow, pulled together by gravity, over billions of years. KNOWN as a picture, and HINT in many details.”
“The Universe has been expanding and cooling from a hot dense state for about 13.8 billion years. KNOWN.”
“What caused that hot dense state, and whether there was anything before it, or whether ’before’ even makes sense. GUESS.”
“So the answer,” said Memoon, “is in layers. The things you can touch came from the hot early Universe and from stars. Where the hot early state came from, we do not know.”
The boy’s grandmother lifted a hand. “That is a very honest answer,” she said. “I have waited seventy years for an astronomer to say that.”
“That is the best sentence of the evening,” said Kachui.
Guddu’s face appeared on the phone, wedged against the biscuit tin. “Happy Geminids,” she said. “Sorry to interrupt. I wanted to ask the thing my teacher asked me. What did you want to find out? Not what you were told. What do you want to find out?”
There was a pause.
“That is what the evening is for,” said Memoon. She uncapped her pen. “A research question is a question that the world can answer if you measure the right thing. It should be small enough to answer and big enough to matter. Not ’what is dark matter’. Something like ’how does this galaxy’s speed change with distance’. And you need a plan. I have a sheet. Eight lines.”
She wrote them, one at a time, at the top of a fresh page, and they were the shortest and strictest list in the notebook.
- Question: one sentence.
- What is already known, with labels.
- Data: where it comes from, and whether anyone can check it.
- Method: the steps, and what I am assuming.
- Uncertainty: what could shake my numbers, and how I will estimate it.
- Prediction: what I think I will find, written down before I look.
- How I could be wrong: what result would change my mind.
- What I will call KNOWN, HINT or GUESS when I am done.
“Beautine,” said Memoon. “Go first.”
Beautine stood on the table. Then she looked at the crowd, and the crowd looked at her, and she got down again and stood on the floor, which for her was a sign of growth. “I want to know whether the shapes of galaxies change with how far back we look. I will use the volunteer project where people classify galaxy pictures. I will count spirals and ellipticals at different distances. My prediction is that there will be fewer neat spirals far back. My claim is that all of the oldest galaxies are messy.”
“All?” said Kachui.
Beautine winced. “A fraction. A larger fraction. I will say how many I counted.”
“Better. Step seven?”
“If the fraction of messy galaxies is the same at all distances, I am wrong.”
“Good,” said Memoon, and wrote it down.
“Mine,” said Kachui, stepping forward without being asked, which surprised everyone. “I would like to follow the brightness of the red star we watched fade, over a full year. People around the world send in their estimates of its brightness, and the collection is open to anyone. I do not usually like to guess in advance. I will write my guess.” She took a breath. “I predict the brightness does not stay steady. It rises and falls in a pattern I can measure. I could be wrong if the data show only random scatter.”
“That is a very brave prediction,” said Noodles. Nobody laughed.
Simbha went next, with the poise of a lion who had spent the week in thought. “I will build a model on a spreadsheet. The age of the Universe, as a function of the Hubble constant, the amount of matter and the amount of dark energy. Change one number and see how the age moves. My prediction is that a bigger H0 gives a younger Universe. I will check it against the oldest stars, which must not be older than the model’s answer.” He stopped. “I used to say ’it looks right.’ I do not say that anymore.”
“Noodles?” said Memoon.
Noodles had a paper hat on again, and he took it off. “I want to fit the Hubble constant myself, using a hundred galaxies from the open survey, not five. And I predict that I will get the higher number, seventy-three.”
“Why seventy-three?” asked Kachui.
“Because it is bigger.”
“That is not a reason,” said Memoon, gently. “A prediction needs a reason. Where might the data push you? Which galaxies, which method?”
Noodles thought. “Our five gave seventy-one with a bar of one point two. With a hundred, the bar gets smaller. I would expect something between the two big numbers. But I do not know which side. So my prediction is: between sixty-seven and seventy-three, and the error bar will be about three times smaller than ours.”
“A prediction with a reason,” said Memoon. “And one that could fail. Well done.” Noodles’s whiskers trembled with pride.
Nimo’s bubble came up to the water’s edge. “I want to know whether a drop of water can bend light the way a heavy galaxy does. I will photograph the arcs made by a water drop lens on a printed grid and compare them with pictures of gravitational lenses.”
“My concern is the same as yours,” said Kachui. “A water drop bends light by changing its speed. A galaxy bends it by curving space. Where does your picture fail?”
“I believe it fails at the very centre,” said Nimo. “A drop has a focus. A galaxy lens does not make one clean focus. I will test where the two kinds of image differ. My step seven is that they will look alike far from the middle and unlike near it.”
“That is a proposal that already knows its own limits,” said Memoon. “I like it very much.”
“And yours?” said Guddu from the phone.
Memoon opened the notebook to the last page, where she had been writing all evening. “Mine is not a question about the sky. It is about us. I would like the Sky Club to run a desk for the whole building. One evening a month, with a laptop, and a pile of open data, and a list of questions, so that anybody who lives here, any age, can learn how to ask one and find out. That is my research.” She put down her pen. “Step six is that at least ten people will come. Step seven is that nobody does.”
“I will be one,” said Mr Rao at once.
“I will bring my neighbour,” said the grandmother.
The Geminid night on the terrace
“Eleven,” said Beautine, writing it down.
The proposals went on round the terrace. A girl of fourteen asked whether she could do hers on tides. A man from the third floor, who worked in a bank, wanted to know who counts sunspots, and whether he could help. The boy of seven had a question about whether Moon craters were
round, and Kachui showed him how to write down his prediction, and he did it carefully in pencil with his tongue between his teeth.
Then the first meteor went over. A bright streak, silent and white, from the Gemini end of the sky to somewhere behind the water tank, and a hundred people gasped at once.
“Count!” said Memoon. “Everyone with a pencil. Fifteen-minute shifts. Mr Rao, you are the timekeeper.”
They counted for thirty minutes in a pool of orange lantern light and a great deal of shuffling. By the end of it the Club’s tally had eleven meteors.
Maths track: Rate = 11 meteors / 0.5 hour = 22 per hour.
Counting error: for random events, the scatter in a count N is about √(N) = √(11) = 3.3. So the count is 11 ± 3, and the rate is 22 ± 7 per hour.
“Under a very dark sky, the best nights can give a hundred an hour or more,” said Simbha. “We are in the middle of a city with lanterns and streetlights. Twenty-two is a good number for a bright sky.”
“We do not have to guess how many we would have seen,” said Kachui. “We can say what we saw, with an error bar.”
Late in the evening, when the Moon had long since set and the children had begun to nod, Memoon took out a handful of little badges that Kachui had made from steel bottle caps, with a tiny white star painted on each. She pressed one into each friend’s hand.
“Cosmic Researcher,” she said. “Not because you know the answers. Because you can say how you would find one, and how you might be wrong.”
“What about you?” Beautine asked.
Memoon smiled and held up the last badge, a larger one with a small silver rim. “Research Astronomer,” she said. “For the Club.” And she pinned it, not on herself, but on the corner of the poster, where everyone could see.
Everyone gathers round the Question Jar
The notebook was almost full. On its last page, under the eight lines, Memoon wrote in her round hand: Your question: and left a space beneath, long enough for anyone to fill.
Far above the water tank, the Geminids fell, one by one, the old light of burning dust. Beyond them, in the east, Orion stood over the city, and orange Aldebaran shone beside him. Somewhere behind both was a hot glow that had been cooling for nearly fourteen billion years, still arriving in every direction, and still carrying news. The Club lay back on the warm concrete, and watched, and counted, and asked.
Science Corner A research question is small enough to answer by measuring something, and big enough to matter. A prediction (a hypothesis with a number) is written before looking at the data, together with what result would show it wrong. The Club’s eight lines cover question, what is known, data, method, uncertainty, prediction, how it could be wrong, and the labels for the result. Open data is data released for anyone to use, such as public galaxy surveys and the CMB maps. Citizen science lets volunteers contribute to real research, for example by classifying galaxy shapes, estimating the brightness of variable stars, or counting meteors.
For random events counted in a fixed time, the scatter in a count N is about √(N), so a rate is N / t with uncertainty √(N) / t. For a fitted value, report the value and its uncertainty; compare two values by the gap divided by the combined uncertainty. Peer review (other experts check the work) and replication (other people repeat the measurement) are how claims become KNOWN. The answer to “Where did everything come from?” comes in layers: hydrogen and helium from the first minutes of the hot early state, heavier elements from stars, galaxies from the ripples in the glow, and, for what came before the hot early state, GUESS. Story note: The galaxy-shape, variable-star and meteor projects exist as real citizen-science activities, but the Club’s particular plans are invented. The Poisson estimate assumes a constant rate, but meteor rates change through the night, and a city sky hides faint meteors, so the count is a lower limit on what a dark sky would show. About a tenth of a person’s mass is hydrogen, and almost all of it dates from the first minutes of the hot early state; the figure is rounded. The eight-line template is a teaching device, not a formal standard, and real proposals are longer. Who wrote the oldest slip, and the way it was written, is part of the Club’s story. ’Where did everything come from’ is a question this book answers in layers, with the last layer marked as unknown.
Space Detective 1. Choose any proposal on the list, such as “I will find out what dark matter is”, and use the eight lines to say what is wrong with it and how to shrink it into a question that can be answered. 2. Your group counts 18 meteors in 40 minutes. Find the rate per hour and its uncertainty using √(N). 3. Write your own eight-line proposal for a question you could answer with open data. Label what you expect to find as KNOWN, HINT or GUESS.
Try it: Count the Sky Time: 30 to 60 minutes after dark. Adult: An adult must be present for all night watching; wear a hat, carry water, and stay on safe ground with no edges. You need: a mat, warm clothing, a watch, a red-light torch, your Sky Notebook. Do: Choose a wide view of the sky. Count meteors for fifteen minutes at a time, recording the time, rough brightness and the direction each one travelled. After two or more blocks, find the rate per hour and its uncertainty using √(N). The Geminids peak around 13 and 14 December each year, but other nights have a few meteors an hour, and the method is the same.
What to expect: On the Geminid peak under a bright city sky, a couple of dozen an hour; on an ordinary night, a few. Meteors traced backwards appear to come from one patch of the sky, called the radiant. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use an indoor citizen-science project on a computer, such as classifying galaxy shapes, with an adult setting up any account. Limitation: classifying pictures is a different kind of counting, and your classifications only count when many people agree.
Next time: There is no next book. There is a page that says Your question:, and the sky above you.
← Chapter 9: What We Cannot See · Book 12 contents · What We Found Out →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 12: Memoon and the Biggest Question, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment