Memunic Space Explorers › Book 6: Memoon and the Light from Long Ago › Chapter 1: How Far Is Far?
Chapter 1: How Far Is Far?
The November air on the society terrace smelled of woodsmoke and somebody’s frying pakoras. The sky over the hill was turning from orange to violet, and the first stars were pricking through.
Beautine was already standing on top of the water tank. She had a torch in one paw and a look of great importance on her face.
“Members of the Rooftop Sky Club,” she announced, “tonight is a historic night. Tonight, I shall send a message to my star.”
Everyone looked where she was pointing. Low over the hill in the east, a single star shone with a warm orange glow, brighter than anything near it. It was the star Beautine had chosen at the end of their rocket adventure. She had named it Beautine’s Lantern, and she had made everyone promise to call it that.
Beautine plans to signal her star. It looks bright, so she is sure it is close.
“Your star,” said Noodles, licking his paw, “is very orange.”
“My star,” said Beautine, “is very close. Look how bright it is! It is just past the hill. Practically next door. If I flash my torch three times, it will see me, and it will flash back.” She held up the torch like a sword. “One. Two...”
“Wait,” said Memoon.
Beautine lowered the torch with the air of a squirrel who has been interrupted at the most important moment of her life. “Yes?”
“How do you know it is just past the hill?”
“Because it is bright,” said Beautine. “Bright things are close. Everybody knows that.”
Noodles nodded wisely. “That is true. My food bowl is very bright when it is full, and it is very close.”
Memoon pulled her Sky Notebook out of her jacket pocket. “Let us test it. Bright things are close. So the brightest things in the sky must be the closest.” She looked around. “Kachui, what is the brightest light up here right now?”
Kachui turned his head slowly, the way he always did, as if the sky might change if he hurried. “That one,” he said at last. He was pointing at the tall lamp on the corner of the building next door. It glared white and hard, so bright it was difficult to look near it.
“How far is it?”
“About thirty metres,” said Kachui. “I counted the steps once.”
“And Beautine’s star is fainter than the lamp,” said Memoon. “So by the rule, it is farther than thirty metres.”
“Slightly farther,” agreed Beautine. “Thirty-one metres.”
Simbha laughed, a deep, warm rumble. He was lying on the blue mat with his chin on his paws. “My friends, I have a puzzle for you. In the day, the Sun is the brightest thing in the sky. By far. Is the Sun the closest thing to us?”
There was a pause.
“The Moon is closer,” said Memoon slowly. “We learned that. The Moon goes round Earth, and Earth goes round the Sun. The Moon is much closer than the Sun, but the Sun is much brighter.”
“Then the rule is broken,” said Kachui quietly. He wrote it down. Rule: bright means close. Test: the Sun and the Moon. Result: the rule fails.
Beautine’s tail drooped a little, then sprang up again. “Fine. Then my star is not thirty-one metres away. It is far. But how far is far?”
“Let me test it another way,” said Kachui. He walked slowly to the parapet and looked down at the road. Two streetlamps stood along it. The near one, just outside the gate, was old and flickering, with a yellow glow so weak that moths hardly bothered with it. The far one, at the corner by the school, was new and blazing white.
“The near lamp is fainter,” said Kachui. “The far lamp is brighter. If bright meant close, the far lamp would be the near one.” He wrote it down. Second test. Result: the rule fails again.
“So a light can look bright for two reasons,” said Memoon, thinking aloud. “Because it is close. Or because it is really, truly strong. And from here, we cannot tell which.”
“The Sun is both,” said Simbha. “Very strong and quite close, for a star. That is why it fills the day.”
Noodles frowned at the orange star. “Then Beautine’s star might be a weak little star nearby. Or a giant star very far away.”
“Or something in between,” said Kachui. “We do not have enough evidence to guess.”
“Kachui,” said Memoon, smiling, “you are allowed to guess. You just have to say it is a guess.”
Kachui thought about this for a long time. “Then my guess,” he said at last, “is far. Farther than the Sun. But it is only a guess.” He wrote guess beside it and
underlined it twice.
A guess was not an answer. Nobody actually knew.
Memoon turned to a fresh page and drew a table with two columns. “Let us write down every distance we know. Then maybe we can see where your star might fit.”
They started close. The lamp next door: about 30 metres. The hill: Kachui had seen it on a map, about 3 kilometres. “Remember from Book 5,” said Memoon, “the space station: about 400 kilometres up.” The Moon: about 3 lakh 84 thousand kilometres. The Sun: about 15 crore kilometres.
When she reached the stars, she stopped. Her pencil hovered. The stars column was empty.
How far is far? From the terrace outwards
Beautine's star ?
The Sun about 15 crore km
The Moon about 3,84,000 km
The space station about 400 km up
The hill 3 kilometres
The lamp next door 30 metres
Not to scale. Each step up is far, far bigger than it looks.
Not to scale. Each step up is far, far bigger than it looks.
“That,” said Simbha softly, “is the most interesting empty box I have ever seen.”
Nimo had drifted up beside them in his bubble. He had been quiet, watching the orange star. “In my pond,” he said, “a big fish far away and a small fish nearby can look the same size. You cannot tell which is which just by looking. You have to swim to them, or watch them move.”
“We cannot swim to a star,” said Noodles. “I have tried swimming. It is horrible.”
“Then we need a way to measure the distance without going there,” said Memoon. She tapped her pencil against the empty box. “That is our mission. By the time Beautine’s star sets in the west, before the summer, we find out how far away it is. Without leaving this terrace.”
“And then,” said Beautine, recovering her grandeur, “I shall know exactly how long my torch message takes to arrive.”
She flashed her torch three times anyway, just in case.
The orange star did not flash back.
Science Corner Brightness is how bright something looks to us. It depends on how much light the object really gives out and on how far away it is, so brightness alone cannot tell you the distance. Remember from Book 1: the Sun is a star. It looks much bigger and brighter than the others because it is much closer to us than any other star. Distances in space are so big that we need careful ways of measuring them. Writing them in a table helps us compare.
Object Rough distance from the terrace
The lamp next door 30 metres
The hill 3 kilometres
The space station (Book 5) about 400 kilometres up
The Moon about 3,84,000 kilometres
The Sun about 15 crore kilometres (150 million km)
Beautine’s star ?
Story note: Talking animals and Nimo’s bubble belong to the story; real animals do not talk. “Beautine’s Lantern” is the friends’ own nickname; official star names are agreed by the International Astronomical Union, and star names sold by businesses are not official. Beautine’s torch could never be seen from a star: its light spreads out and fades long before it gets there. The pond comparison works for size and distance, but where this idea stops working is that fish can be reached; stars can only be studied by the light they send us.
Space Detective 1. Noodles says, “The Sun is brighter than the Moon, so the Sun is closer.” Use the table to explain why he is wrong. 2. A bicycle lamp close to you and a car headlight far away can look equally bright. Write two things that make a light look bright or faint. 3. Draw a line across a page and mark the lamp, the hill, the Moon and the Sun in order from near to far. Why is it hard to draw them to scale on one page?
Try It: Bright or Close? Time: 15 minutes. You need: two torches of different strengths, a dark room or corridor, a notebook. Adult: An adult switches off the lights and stays with you. Do: Put the strong torch at the far end of the corridor and the weak torch close to you. Ask a friend to look at both and say which is closer, using only how bright they look. Then swap the torches and ask again. What to expect: Your friend may say the brighter torch is closer even when it is farther away. Brightness can trick our eyes. Cloudy or indoors: Use two phone screens at different brightness settings, or draw two lamps of different sizes on paper and talk through the idea. Limits: torches are not stars, but the trick is the same one the sky plays on us.
Next time: If we cannot fly to a star, and brightness tells us nothing, how could we possibly measure how far away it is?
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 6: Memoon and the Light from Long Ago, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment