Memunic Space Explorers › Book 6: Memoon and the Light from Long Ago › Chapter 2: Measuring Without Going
Chapter 2: Measuring Without Going
It started with a wink. Noodles had something in his eye, a speck of dust from the terrace, and he was winking hard, first one eye and then the other, while holding up a paw to rub it.
“Memoon,” he said suddenly, “my paw is jumping.”
“Your paw is not jumping.”
“It is! Look. Left eye, my paw is in front of the water tank. Right eye, my paw is in front of the door. Left eye, tank. Right eye, door.” He kept winking, faster and faster, until he fell over.
Memoon held up her own thumb at arm’s length and tried it. Close one eye: her thumb covered the corner of the water tank. Close the other: her thumb jumped sideways and covered the stair door instead. She did it again and again. The thumb did not move, but it seemed to jump.
“It is because each eye looks from a slightly different place,” she said. “My eyes are a few centimetres apart. Each eye sees my thumb against a different part of the background.”
“What happens if you bring your thumb closer?” asked Kachui.
She tried it. Thumb close to her nose: it jumped a lot, right across the terrace. Thumb far away at arm’s length: it jumped only a little.
“Closer things jump more,” said Memoon. “Farther things jump less.” She stared at her thumb as if it were a treasure. “So the size of the jump tells you how far away something is.”
Simbha stood up and shook his great mane. “This is a famous trick,” he said. “It has a name. Parallax. It is how surveyors measure mountains they cannot climb, and how astronomers measure...” He stopped, smiling. “But let us not jump ahead. Let us measure something first.”
“The peepal tree!” said Memoon. Across the road and past the school playground stood a huge peepal tree, too far to walk to before dinner and on the other side of a busy road. “Can we find out how far it is without going there?”
Kachui, who loved a plan, made one. The terrace was long, and they measured its length along the parapet with Simbha’s measuring tape. Twenty metres exactly. “That is our baseline,” said Simbha. “Two viewpoints, a known distance apart. Our two eyes, but much farther apart than real eyes.”
Two ends of a 20-metre baseline, two angles, one far peepal tree.
At one end of the terrace, Memoon laid a big school protractor flat on the parapet with its straight edge along the baseline. She looked along a ruler over the protractor until the ruler pointed straight at the peepal tree’s trunk. Kachui read the angle between the baseline and the ruler. “Eighty-four degrees.”
They carried everything to the other end and did it again. “Eighty-four degrees again,” said Kachui. “The tree is almost in the middle.”
“So now what?” asked Noodles. “We have two numbers and a sore neck.”
“Now,” said Memoon, “we make a scale drawing.”
On a big sheet of chart paper, she drew a line 4 centimetres long. “One centimetre on the paper stands for five metres on the terrace. So 4 centimetres is our 20-metre baseline.” At each end she used the protractor to draw a line at 84 degrees, leaning in towards the other. The two lines went up and up and up the paper, closer and closer together, and finally crossed near the top.
“Where they cross is the tree,” said Memoon.
Scale drawing: 1 cm on paper = 5 m on the terrace
peepal tree
measured: 19 cm 19 × 5 m = about 95 m
84° 84°
baseline 4 cm = 20 m Drawn smaller than the real scale drawing; the angles are drawn a little smaller so the crossing fits.
The tree measured with a 20-metre baseline and a scale drawing. Drawn smaller than the real drawing.
Kachui measured with his ruler from the middle of the baseline to the crossing point. “Nineteen centimetres.”
“Nineteen times five metres...” Memoon wrote it down. “Ninety-five metres. The peepal tree is about ninety-five metres away.”
“How do we know that is right?” asked Kachui, who never trusted a number on its own.
Simbha produced the society’s printed site map from the office, which showed the playground and the road with a scale bar. Kachui measured it carefully. “About ninety-eight metres.”
“Before we celebrate,” said Kachui, “we should measure again.” So they did. Three times from each end, taking turns so that nobody’s eyes were used twice in a row. Kachui wrote every angle down: 84, 83, 85 at the first end; 84, 84, 83 at the other.
“They are not all the same,” said Noodles, disappointed. “Somebody did it wrong.”
“Nobody did it wrong,” said Kachui. “Every measurement has a little wobble. That is why we measure more than once.” He added up the first three and divided by three. “Eighty-four on average. The middle of the wobble.”
Memoon drew the lines again with 83 degrees and then with 85, to see what would happen. With 85, the lines met higher up the paper, much farther away. With 83, they met lower down.
“One degree changes the answer by a lot,” she said. “Fifteen or twenty metres.”
“Ninety-five and ninety-eight,” said Memoon. “Close! Our angles were only as good as our eyes and a school protractor, and we have just seen what one degree can do.”
“So a longer baseline would help?” asked Kachui.
“A longer baseline makes the jump bigger,” said Simbha, “and a bigger jump is easier to measure. Remember that. It is the most important thing about parallax.”
Memoon looked up at the sky. The orange star had climbed higher over the hill. “Could we do this with Beautine’s star?”
She held up her thumb and blinked at the star. It did not jump at all. Not even a little.
“Nothing,” she said. “So stars do not have any parallax at all. They must be too far for the trick to work.”
“Careful,” said Kachui. “That is a big conclusion from one thumb.”
Memoon’s ears went pink. “I said that too fast.”
“You did,” said Simbha, smiling. “The star does shift. Just far too little for your eyes. The star is so far that your two eyes, or even our twenty-metre terrace, are like two ants standing next to each other. You would need a much, much longer baseline.”
“How long?” asked Memoon.
Simbha looked up at the sky, then down at the friends. “What is the longest journey you have ever been on?”
Memoon thought about it. “Earth’s journey round the Sun,” she said slowly. “We are all on it, all the time. In January Earth is on one side of the Sun. Six months later, in July, it is on the other side. That is about thirty crore kilometres apart.”
“A baseline of thirty crore kilometres,” said Simbha, “and every one of us is riding on it.”
Star parallax: Earth's path round the Sun is the baseline far background stars
nearer star
Earth in January Earth in July
about 30 crore km apart Not to scale. The real shift is far too small to draw: less than one arcsecond.
Not to scale. A real star’s shift is less than one arcsecond.
Kachui looked worried. “Even with that, would the star jump?”
“A tiny, tiny bit,” said Simbha. “So tiny that nobody could see it for hundreds of years after people first tried. The first person to measure it for a star did it in 1838.” He lay down again. “We will need to find out how far the measurers have got since then.”
Memoon wrote in her notebook: The farther away, the smaller the jump. Stars: the smallest jumps of all. Baseline: Earth’s path round the Sun.
Science Corner Parallax is the way a near object seems to shift against a far background when you look at it from two different places. The baseline is the distance between the two viewing places. A longer baseline gives a bigger shift, which is easier to measure. Farther objects shift less. If you measure the angle to an object from both ends of a baseline, a scale drawing can show how far away it is.
For stars, astronomers use the biggest baseline we have: Earth’s position in one season and six months later, about 30 crore kilometres apart. Even then, the shift of the nearest stars is far too small to see with the eye. Story note: The tree numbers are an example; a real measurement depends on careful angles. A school protractor reads to about one degree, and one degree of error changes the answer by many metres. Where this idea stops working: stars do not really move back and forth because of Earth; they only seem to shift because we look from a different place, just as Memoon’s thumb did not really jump.
Space Detective 1. Explain, using Memoon’s thumb, why a closer object seems to jump more than a farther one. 2. Kachui wants a more accurate answer for the peepal tree. Give two changes he could make to the measurement, and say why each would help. 3. Draw the scale drawing for a 20-metre baseline where both angles are 80 degrees. Measure how far away the object is (use 1 cm for 5 m).
Try It: Measure the Far Tree Time: 40 minutes. You need: a long measuring tape, a protractor, a ruler, chart paper, a pencil. Adult: An adult chooses a safe place, such as a playground or a courtyard, and stays with you; never measure near a road or a roof edge. Do: Pick a far object you cannot walk to, such as a tree or a pole. Measure a straight baseline of 10 to 20 metres. At each end, line up the protractor with the baseline and read the angle to the object. Make a scale drawing and measure the distance. What to expect: Your answer will be close to the real distance, but not exact. Repeat the measurement and see how much the angles change. Cloudy or indoors: Do it indoors with a far object across a big hall, or make the thumb-jump test with objects at different distances on a table. Limits: the shorter the baseline, the harder the angles are to read, and small mistakes matter more.
Next time: If a star’s shift is so tiny, its light must have come a very long way. How fast does light travel anyway?
← Chapter 1: How Far Is Far? · Book 6 contents · Chapter 3: Speed of Light →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 6: Memoon and the Light from Long Ago, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment