Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Chapter 2: What Makes Earth Livable?
Chapter 2: What Makes Earth Livable?
In this chapter: Explain why distance from the Sun alone cannot make a world livable, and name what Earth’s air, gravity, water and magnetic field each do.
“The best home we know is Earth,” said Simbha the next morning. “So we start there. We will find out exactly what it does right, and then we can check every other world against the list.”
The Sky Club had met on the terrace at seven, before the sun made the floor impossible to stand on. Nimo’s bubble hung over the Scorecard, which Memoon had pinned to the tank with four clothes pegs.
“That is easy,” said Noodles, who had not yet had breakfast and was therefore at his most confident. “Earth is the right distance from the Sun. Not too close, not too far. That is the whole story. Can we go and eat now?”
“It is certainly part of the story,” said Memoon. “Let us test whether it is the whole story.” She flipped back through her notebook to a page from Book 4 and held it up. “Kachui, how far is the Moon from the Sun?”
Kachui thought about it with his usual care. “About the same as Earth. The Moon travels round the Sun with us. Any difference is tiny compared with the distance itself.”
“So the Moon gets exactly the same sunshine as Earth.”
“Yes.”
“Then it must be just as good a home,” said Memoon, “if distance is all that matters.”
Noodles opened his mouth, closed it, and looked at the Moon, which was still hanging faintly pale in the west like a forgotten plate. “Hm,” he said.
“On the Moon,” Kachui went on slowly, “there is almost no air. In the lunar daytime the ground can be hotter than boiling water. At night it falls to far, far below freezing. Any water on the surface would either boil away or freeze solid.”
“And the gravity is only a sixth of ours,” added Simbha. “Remember from Book 5: gravity does not switch off in space, it just changes with the size of the world. The Moon’s pull is too weak to hold an atmosphere for long.”
“So something else is going on,” said Memoon, drawing a long arrow from the Sun to Earth, and another to the Moon, and writing SAME SUNSHINE between them. “Same Sun. Very different worlds. What does Earth have that the Moon does not?”
They went round the terrace, and a list built itself.
“Air,” said Beautine.
“Oceans,” said Nimo. “Obviously.”
“Gravity big enough to keep the air,” said Simbha.
Memoon looked at Nimo’s bubble, shining in the early light. “Nimo, your bubble does three jobs. It keeps your water in, it keeps your air steady, and it keeps out most of what is bad for you. Is that what the air does for Earth?”
“That is what I was going to say,” said Nimo, “but I think it is only partly right. My bubble has a skin. The air has no skin. It just thins out slowly until there is no more of it. And the air is held in by gravity, not by being stretched tight like me.”
“Good,” said Kachui, and wrote it into the Story note column on the Scorecard. Bubble = Earth’s air, but with a skin. Does not work: Earth’s air has no skin.
That was the moment Beautine said the thing that started the first experiment. “But why does the air matter so much? Air is just air.”
Memoon thought about the pressure cooker that had whistled three times the evening before. “Beautine, what does Mr Rao’s cooker do?”
“It cooks dal in a hurry.”
“How?”
“By being sealed. The steam cannot get out, so the pressure inside goes up, and the water gets hotter than a hundred degrees without turning to steam.” Beautine looked at the sky. “Oh.”
“On a mountain it is the other way round,” said Simbha. “When we visited my uncle in the hills, the water in the kettle boiled long before it was really hot. The air up there presses less. Water turns to steam at a lower temperature.”
“So how much air there is decides whether water stays a liquid at all,” said Memoon. “Too little pressure and it boils off or freezes. Enough, and you get seas and rain and fish.”
“Which is why the Moon has none,” said Nimo, a little faintly.
“We have only found one half of the answer,” said Kachui. “I want to know the other half. It is warm here, but the Sun’s heat should go out into space again every night. What keeps Earth from freezing?”
Memoon had an idea she had been saving. She sent Beautine for two plastic bottles, a woollen shawl and Simbha’s uncle’s thermometers, and she asked Mr Rao, who had come up to water his tomato plants, whether he would fill both bottles with warm tap water, not boiling. He did, with a long look at the mat of animals and the notebooks, and went back to his tomatoes without a word.
“A fair test,” said Memoon. “Same bottle. Same water. Same starting temperature. I wrap one in the shawl and leave one bare. We read the thermometers every ten minutes.”
“The shawl is Earth’s air,” said Kachui.
“The shawl is a model of Earth’s air,” said Memoon. “A very rough one, as we will see.”
They wrote down the numbers. Both bottles began at 52 degrees. Ten minutes later, the wrapped one read 49. The bare one read 47. After half an hour the difference was clear.
At this point there was an accident.
A fair test changes only one thing. Noodles was a second thing.
Noodles had been told to supervise. He had interpreted this as lying down next to the bare bottle, because it was warm and he was tired. He lay curled round it, purring, for twenty minutes.
“Noodles,” said Kachui, when he came back with the stopwatch. “The bare bottle is now warmer than the wrapped one.”
“I was keeping it company,” said Noodles.
“You were heating it.” Kachui looked at the page. “The test is spoiled. The bare bottle was no longer cooling on its own.”
“This is very useful,” said Memoon, trying not to laugh. “It is exactly why we call it a fair test. Everything has to be the same except the one thing we are testing. Noodles was a second thing.”
They ran it again, this time with Noodles in charge of the stopwatch, and a ring of pebbles round the bare bottle to keep him away. By the end the wrapped bottle had cooled more slowly, as expected. Memoon drew a graph with two lines on the same axes. The lines did not cross, and the gap grew.
“The blanket slows down the heat leaving,” she said. “That is a bit like what Earth’s air does. Sunlight comes in, warms the ground, and the ground sends heat out again as a kind of invisible glow. Gases in the air catch some of it and send some back down. That is called the greenhouse effect. Without it, the average temperature of Earth would be about eighteen degrees below freezing. With it, it is about fifteen above.”
“Thirty-three degrees of difference,” said Kachui. “Just from the air.”
“Then the air is the reason I do not freeze,” said Nimo.
“The air, and the oceans,” said Memoon, thinking of the beach holiday last winter. “The sea is cool in the afternoon when the sand is burning, and warm at night when the sand has gone cold. Water changes temperature slowly. “
Simbha added the last item, and wrote it carefully. “Earth also has a magnetic field, which helps push away the stream of charged particles blowing out of the Sun. And a layer of ozone high in the air, which soaks up much of the harmful ultraviolet light. Without those, living things on the surface would have a very hard time.”
Memoon filled in the Scorecard. Earth got a tick in every row: water, air, steady temperature, energy, shield. She stepped back and looked at it.
| Air = a blanket | Oceans |
|---|---|
| holds in heat | even out the heat |
| Gravity | Magnetic field + ozone |
|---|---|
| holds the air on | shield from space radiation |
A steady Sun light and warmth that stay constant
Layers are drawn much thicker than they are in real life
Earth’s tricks. Sizes and layers are simplified.
“That is a lot of things all going right at once,” she said. “No wonder it is hard to find another one.”
“There is one planet,” said Beautine, who had gone very quiet and then very bright, “that is almost exactly the same size as Earth. People call it Earth’s twin. It is the brightest light in the evening sky, and it is a beautiful golden colour, and I think that is where we should look first.”
Kachui sighed. “I knew she was going to say that.”
Science Corner Distance from the Sun is not enough. The Moon is the same distance from the Sun as Earth, yet it has almost no air, no oceans and extreme temperatures. Atmosphere is the layer of gas around a planet. Its pressure decides whether water can stay liquid, and its gases warm the planet through the greenhouse effect: without it Earth’s average temperature would be about 18 degrees Celsius below zero; with it, about 15 degrees Celsius above zero. Gravity must be strong enough to hold the air. The Moon’s gravity is about one-sixth of Earth’s. Remember from Book 1: the Sun is a star, and it is Earth’s energy source. Oceans store heat and keep temperatures steady. Earth’s magnetic field and ozone layer help protect living things from harmful particles and ultraviolet light. Story note: Nimo’s bubble helps picture an air-and-water home, but real air has no skin and thins out gradually, held by gravity. The blanket test shows that insulation slows cooling; it is only a rough model, because the atmosphere warms the planet by absorbing and returning heat that the ground sends out as infrared light, which a woollen shawl does not do. The pressure cooker shows that pressure changes the boiling point of water, but a planet is not a sealed pot. Numbers are rounded. Human activities are adding greenhouse gases, which is why scientists study this blanket so carefully.
Space Detective 1. Noodles says, “Earth is livable because it is the right distance from the Sun.” Use the Moon to show why this cannot be the whole story. 2. Explain how a pressure cooker and a hill-station kettle show that air pressure affects whether water can stay liquid. 3. Draw a labelled picture of Earth with four of its “tricks” (air, gravity, oceans, magnetic field). Write one sentence beside each saying what it does.
Try it: Blanket Test Time: 45 minutes. Adult: An adult handles the warm water and checks the starting temperature. You need: two identical plastic bottles with lids, warm (not boiling) tap water, a thermometer, a woollen cloth, a clock and graph paper. Do: Fill both bottles with the same warm water, read the temperature and write it down. Wrap one bottle in the cloth and leave the other bare, then put them side by side away from any other warm thing, including pets. Read each bottle every ten minutes for 40 minutes. Draw both lines on one graph. What to expect: The wrapped bottle cools more slowly, so its line stays above the other line. Cloudy or low-resource day: The test works indoors, anywhere in the house away from sunlight. Use two steel or glass cups if you have no bottles. Limitation: a cloth slows heat escaping by touch and trapped air, and the atmosphere works in a different way, by absorbing and sending back heat that rises from the ground, so the test shows the idea of a blanket but not the real mechanism.
Next time: If air and water make a home, then a planet almost exactly Earth’s size, our twin in the evening sky, should be a home too. Should it?
← Chapter 1: Nimo’s Question · Book 7 contents · Chapter 3: Venus, the Overheated Twin →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment