Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Chapter 3: Venus, the Overheated Twin
Chapter 3: Venus, the Overheated Twin
In this chapter: Compare Venus with Earth using a table, explain how a thick carbon dioxide atmosphere makes Venus the hottest planet, and separate what spacecraft have measured from what is only a guess.
Beautine had been planning for two days, and it showed. She stood on the water tank in a bedsheet cape, one paw held high, in front of a poster she had drawn on the back of a calendar. It showed a very round, very golden planet with a smile.
Beautine presents her new home
“Members of the Rooftop Sky Club,” she announced, “I give you our new home. Venus! The brightest light in the evening sky. The one Memoon told me about in Book 1, when I thought it was a very low star.”
“It was a very good mistake,” said Memoon kindly. “It is not a star at all. It is a planet, and it shines by reflected sunlight, just like the Moon. Remember from Book 3.”
“And look at this,” said Beautine, ignoring that completely and tapping the poster. “Venus is almost exactly the size of Earth. Ninety-five out of every hundred, and nearly as heavy. It is one of Earth’s closest neighbours. Everybody calls it Earth’s twin. If Earth is a good home,
then its twin must be too. I have already started packing.”
She had. A small basket stood beside the tank with her best acorns, a spare bow and a sandwich.
Kachui looked at the basket, then at the poster, then at the sky, where the evening star blazed low in the west, bright enough to cast the faintest shadow on the terrace wall. “Before we go anywhere,” he said carefully, “I think we should fill in the Scorecard.”
“I am not afraid of the Scorecard,” said Beautine. She was, a little.
So they filled it in, row by row, the slow way, the Sky Club way. Water. Air. Temperature. Energy. Safety. Kachui had found the numbers in his grey notebook, copied from the NASA planetary fact sheets, and he read them out one by one, in a voice that grew quieter with every line.
The size was right. The weight was roughly right. And then he reached the line for the surface.
“The average temperature at the surface of Venus is about four hundred and sixty-four degrees Celsius.”
There was a silence.
“That is a misprint,” said Beautine.
“It is not a misprint. I checked it twice. Four hundred and sixty-four.”
“My dal cooks at one hundred,” said Noodles, in a hushed voice. “I mean, Mr Rao’s dal.”
“Lead melts at about three hundred and twenty-seven,” said Memoon, who had found it in her notebook. “On Venus the ground is hot enough to melt a lead pencil and keep going.”
“There must be a cool bit,” said Beautine. “A mountain. A shady valley.”
“There is not,” said Kachui. “It is almost the same temperature at night as by day, and from the equator nearly to the poles. The air spreads the heat around the whole planet.” He turned the page. “And the air pressure at the surface is ninety-two times Earth’s. That is like being nearly a kilometre under the sea. Mostly carbon dioxide. Clouds of sulphuric acid.”
Beautine sat down on the tank. Noodles patted her on the shoulder with one paw.
95% as wide
Earth Venus
about 15 °C · air pressure 1 about 464 °C · air pressure 92
Colours are simplified. Sizes are drawn to one scale (widths in proportion).
Same size, very different worlds. Colours are simplified.
Memoon was staring at the numbers. “But that does not make sense. Venus is nearer the Sun than Earth, but not that much nearer. It is nearly twice as far from the Sun as Mercury, and Mercury is the closest planet of all. Yet Venus is hotter on average than Mercury. So it is not just distance. It is something else.”
“The thing we found yesterday,” said Nimo slowly. “The blanket.”
“Exactly,” said Memoon. “Earth’s air makes Earth thirty-three degrees warmer than it would be with no air at all. That is the greenhouse effect, and it is a good thing for us. Venus has a much, much thicker blanket, and the gas in it is carbon dioxide, which is very good at trapping heat. Sunlight gets in, the ground warms, and the heat cannot get out again. Imagine every layer of blanket you own, on a hot day, with the windows sealed.”
“Venus must always have been a furnace,” said Noodles.
“Careful,” said Kachui. “We have no proof of that.”
“We have no proof of the opposite, either,” said Simbha, who had been listening from the shade. “Some computer models suggest that early Venus might have had water, perhaps even oceans, before the blanket grew too thick. Others say it never did. Scientists disagree. Put it down as a Guess.” He watched Kachui write it. “It matters, because it might mean a world can go wrong over time.”
Beautine looked up. “A twin that went wrong.”
“A twin that is the same size and went in a very different direction,” said Memoon gently. “I think that is why people use that word. Not because it is a copy. Because it is a warning about how much a planet’s air can change things.”
“Why is it so bright, if it is so terrible?” asked Beautine in a small voice, looking at the bright dot in the west.
Kachui actually smiled. “Two reasons. It is close to us, for a planet. And its thick clouds are white and shiny, and they reflect most of the sunlight that hits them. It is a perfect mirror for the Sun. Remember from Book 6, Beautine: brightness alone cannot tell you how far away something is, or what it is like.”
“Or what it is like to stand on,” said Noodles.
He got a very long look from Beautine, and then, to everyone’s surprise, a hug.
“At least the tour guide poster was nice,” she said.
It was then that Nimo found the Scorecard’s last surprise. “Kachui, can you read me the last line on your sheet? The one at the bottom, about fifty kilometres up.”
Kachui turned the page. “Oh. Yes. High above the surface, about fifty kilometres up, inside the clouds, the temperature is between thirty and seventy degrees, and the air pressure is about the same as at the Earth’s surface.”
Beautine leapt to her feet. “The clouds! We could live in the clouds! Floating cities! Balloons!”
“Those clouds are made of sulphuric acid,” said Kachui. “The comfortable temperature and pressure are real. But everything else about it is dreadful for a fish.”
“Some scientists have asked whether tiny microbes could live up there,” said Simbha, “because the temperature and pressure are not too extreme. They have not found anything to say so. It is a question. A Guess.”
Nimo, who was in no way interested in living in acid, gave a small bubble of laughter. “Then I have to admit that of all the places in the Solar System, the evening star is the one I would like least.”
Memoon pulled the poster toward her and added a small label at the bottom. Venus: same size, very different world. Then underneath: Known: hot, high pressure, acid clouds. Guess: it once had water. Guess: microbes in the clouds.
“We are not the only people looking at Venus,” she said. “Spacecraft from the Soviet Union landed on it in the nineteen seventies and eighties. The longest-lasting ones survived for about two hours before the heat and pressure stopped them. Now India is planning a visit too. ISRO’s Venus Orbiter Mission was approved in September 2024. It is planned to launch in March 2028, and it is an orbiter, which means it will study Venus from above, not land. Planned, not launched,” she added firmly, to Kachui, who had opened his mouth.
“I did not say anything,” said Kachui.
“You were about to.”
Beautine unpacked her basket, one acorn at a time, with great dignity. “I still love Venus,” she said. “But I do not want to live there.”
“Loving a planet and living on it are different things,” said Kachui. “I have found that to be true of most places.”
He flipped to a different page of his grey notebook, and for the first time in the whole chapter, he looked excited. “The other neighbour, the one on the far side of Earth, is a different story. Cold, thin air. And possibly water long ago. I have a box of cuttings about it. Newspaper cuttings, mostly from ISRO. I have been saving them for years.”
Science Corner Venus is close to Earth in size and mass, but very different. Its thick atmosphere is mostly carbon dioxide, and its clouds contain sulphuric acid. This thick blanket produces an extreme greenhouse effect. Venus’s average surface temperature is about 464 degrees Celsius, hotter than Mercury’s average even though Mercury is much closer to the Sun. Surface air pressure is about 92 times Earth’s. Venus’s white clouds reflect much of the sunlight that reaches them, and it is close to us, so it is very bright. Remember from Book 3: planets shine by reflected light. Remember from Book 6: brightness cannot tell you what a place is like. About 50 km above the surface, Venus’s temperature and pressure are close to Earth’s, but the clouds are acidic. Whether any microbe could live there is an open question; no evidence has been found. Dated facts: Soviet Venera landers survived up to about two hours in the 1970s and 1980s. ISRO’s Venus Orbiter Mission was approved in September 2024 and is planned for launch in March 2028. It has not launched.
Earth Venus
Size (radius) about 6,378 km about 6,052 km
Mass (Earth = 1) 1 about 0.82
| Average surface temperature | about 15 degrees C | about 464 degrees C |
|---|---|---|
| Surface air pressure (Earth = 1) | 1 | about 92 |
| Main gas in the air | nitrogen and oxygen | carbon dioxide |
|---|---|---|
| One spin (a day) | 24 hours | about 243 Earth days |
One trip round the Sun (a year) about 365 days about 225 Earth days
Story note: “Twin” describes size and weight only. The “blanket” picture explains why a thick atmosphere traps heat, but Venus’s real atmosphere also presses down with enormous force and contains acid, which no blanket does. Whether Venus ever had oceans is debated by scientists, so it stays a Guess. Venus spins backwards and so slowly that its day is longer than its year, which you can check in the table. Numbers are rounded from the NASA planetary fact sheets.
Space Detective 1. Beautine says, “Venus is Earth’s twin, so it is a good home.” Use two numbers from the table to show where “twin” is true and where it is not. 2. Venus is nearly twice as far from the Sun as Mercury, yet it is hotter on average. Explain what could cause this. 3. The clouds of Venus have Earth-like temperature and pressure about 50 km up. Write two reasons they still would not make a good home for Nimo, and label each Known, Hint or Guess.
Try it: Cloud Mirror Time: 20 minutes. Adult: An adult switches off the lights and stays in the room with you. You need: a torch, a sheet of white paper, a sheet of black paper, a phone camera or a friend’s eyes, a dark room. Do: In the dark, shine the same torch from the same distance first at the white paper and then at the black paper, and take a photograph of each from the same spot. Compare how bright each looks. Then hold the torch twice as far from the white paper and compare again. What to expect: The white paper looks much brighter than the black, and the white paper at double the distance looks fainter. A shiny surface and a short distance both make something look brighter. Cloudy or low-resource day: Use a bedside lamp and a white wall and a dark cloth in an evening room. Limitation: paper reflects light differently from clouds, so the experiment shows the idea of a reflective surface but not the exact brightness of Venus.
Next time: If Venus is a furnace, what about the planet on the other side of Earth, the cold, rusty-red one that Kachui keeps clippings about?
← Chapter 2: What Makes Earth Livable? · Book 7 contents · Chapter 4: Mars: Cold, Thin, Once Wet? →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment