Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Chapter 5: Ocean Moons
Chapter 5: Ocean Moons
In this chapter: Explain how a moon far from the Sun can hold liquid water under ice, name the evidence and the dated missions for Europa and Enceladus, and separate Known, Hint and Guess.
“Here,” said Simbha, “is my challenge.”
He had laid two large prints side by side on the blue mat and weighted their corners with the Club’s four best pebbles. On the left was a pale, cracked ball, scratched all over with long reddish lines, like a ball of string that had been dropped in tea. On the right was a smaller, whiter one, with blue-white fountains rising from the bottom edge into black space.
Two ocean moons
“On the left, Europa, a moon of Jupiter. On the right, Enceladus, a moon of Saturn. My challenge is this. Find me a place in the Solar System, with evidence, that has liquid water and is not a planet’s surface. And tell me which parts are Known, which are Hints, and which are Guesses.”
Nimo had been looking at the prints for exactly four seconds before his bubble began to spin.
“Water!” he said. “They have oceans! I have found it. A moon of oceans. Beautine, where is my sunhat? Noodles, I will need someone to carry my pond.”
“Nimo,” said Kachui.
“I know what you are going to say, and I have thought about it,” said Nimo. “But there is water. Water means a home. It is the first thing we put on the list.”
“Is it the only thing we put on the list?” asked Memoon gently.
Nimo’s bubble slowed. It was a small, dignified slowing, the kind of slowing a fish does when he has made a mistake and would like to pretend he is simply thinking.
“In my pond,” he said slowly, “the Sun warms the top of the water. Little green plants grow in the light. They make food and put air into the water. Small things eat the plants. Bigger things eat the small things. Then there is me.” He paused. “If there is a layer of ice on top of the ocean, then there is no Sun.”
“How thick is the ice?” asked Beautine.
“On Europa,” said Simbha, reading from his notes, “scientists think the ice shell is about fifteen to twenty-five kilometres thick. Beneath it, an ocean sixty to a hundred and fifty kilometres deep. By their best estimates, Europa’s ocean may hold about twice as much water as all of Earth’s oceans put together.”
There was a long silence.
“Twice as much water as Earth,” said Noodles. “On a moon smaller than ours.”
“Slightly smaller than our Moon,” said Memoon, “but with an ocean under all that ice. And it is nowhere near the Sun. Why is it not frozen solid? Jupiter is about five times as far from the Sun as Earth. Light takes about forty minutes to get there.”
Ice shell about 15–25 km thick
Salty ocean about 60–150 km deep
Rocky mantle
Core
Orange dots: heat made by tides inside the moon
Layers are drawn thicker than true scale; thicknesses are estimates and scientists differ.
Europa’s layers are estimates and the picture is not to scale.
“Something is warming it from inside,” said Kachui.
“It is the same pull that makes the tides on Earth,” said Simbha. “Our Moon pulls on our oceans and makes them rise and fall. Jupiter is enormous, and its gravity is huge. As Europa goes round it, Jupiter squeezes and stretches the whole moon, a little bit more, a little bit less, again and again. That flexing warms the inside.”
“Like a paperclip,” said Memoon, who had found one in her pocket and was bending it back and forth. “Do it enough and the bend gets warm.” She held it out. Noodles touched it with the tip of one paw and said, “Oh! It is hot!”, and sat down with a very important expression.
“The analogy only goes so far,” said Kachui, rubbing the paperclip between his fingers. “A paperclip warms because the metal rubs against itself inside. Europa is warmed by tides pulling on ice and rock. But the idea is right: bending can make heat.”
“Now the second moon,” said Simbha, pointing to the white ball with the fountains. “Enceladus. About five hundred kilometres across, which is less than one-seventh of the Moon’s width. Very small. But it has geysers.”
“Geysers on a moon?” said Beautine.
“A spacecraft called Cassini, which orbited Saturn from 2004 until 2017, saw them in 2005, jetting out of long cracks near the south pole. It flew straight through the spray. It found salty water, and carbon-based chemicals, and later scientists studying the old Cassini data in 2023 found something else. In June of that year, a team led by Frank Postberg reported phosphorus in the icy grains.”
“What is phosphorus?” asked Noodles.
“One of the chemical ingredients that all life on Earth uses,” said Memoon. “It is in your bones, and in every cell of your body, and in the molecules that carry your energy. And it is the rarest of the main ingredients. Nobody had ever found it in an ocean beyond Earth. Until then.”
Nimo stared at the white moon. “A salty ocean under the ice. With the ingredients.”
“Do not get excited,” said Kachui, and he opened his notebook and wrote three lines. “Known: Enceladus has a salty ocean beneath its ice shell. That is very strongly supported, because the spacecraft flew through the spray from it. Hint: that ocean contains ingredients for life. That is measured too. Guess: that anything lives there. Nobody has found any sign of that.”
“I hate your lines,” said Nimo, quite cheerfully. “They are very fair. But I still have my problem: there is no Sun under all that ice.”
“Not on top,” said Simbha. He looked pleased, as if he had been waiting for this. “But here is something about Earth that will surprise you. At the bottom of our deepest oceans there are cracks in the sea floor where hot water full of minerals comes out of the rock. There is no sunlight there at all. Yet whole communities of animals live around those vents, tube worms and crabs and shrimps. They live on chemical energy from the rocks and hot water, not from sunlight.”
Nimo was staring at him. “Are you saying fish do not always need the Sun?”
“I am saying some life on Earth does not need the Sun. And if rock meets water on Europa or Enceladus, something like that might be possible. It is only a Guess, and we have to be honest about that. But it changes the list.”
Memoon crossed out the word sunlight in the Energy row of the Scorecard, and wrote underneath, in smaller letters, sunlight OR chemical energy.
It was Beautine who pulled the print of Saturn’s biggest moon from under the pile and waved it. “And this one has lakes! I can see them in the picture. Lakes, Nimo! You could swim!”
“That is Titan,” said Kachui, reading the label on the back. “The lakes are liquid methane and ethane. It is about a hundred and eighty degrees below zero there. I would be a solid fish.”
“A frozen fish,” said Noodles. “I have seen those. They are not the same thing.”
Nimo gave a bubble of laughter, but his face stayed thoughtful. “So nobody has even been to one of these places. Nobody has tested the water.”
“Not yet,” said Simbha. “But we are going. NASA’s Europa Clipper launched on the fourteenth of October 2024. It is planned to reach Jupiter on the eleventh of April 2030, and then to fly past Europa nearly fifty times, as close as twenty-five kilometres above the ice. It will not land. It will not drill. It has an ice-penetrating radar, which uses radio waves to look through the ice and find out how thick it is.”
“Radio waves!” said Memoon. “Remember from Book 6, the GMRT, and light we cannot see. Radio waves can go through some things we cannot see through.”
“Another mission, Dragonfly, is planned to launch to Titan in July 2028 and arrive in 2034,” Simbha went on. “It is a drone, a helicopter with eight rotors, which will fly from place to place on the surface and sniff the chemistry. Planned, not launched,” he added, glancing at Kachui, who nodded.
“So nobody will know about Europa’s ocean for years,” said Nimo.
“It will be 2030 before anything even arrives, and several years after that before the data are studied,” said Memoon. “By then a twelve-year-old will be sixteen, and the answers will take longer still.”
Nimo floated down until his bubble rested on the print of Europa, on the cracked, scratched surface. He was quiet for a long time.
“I think,” he said at last, “that this is the most hopeful thing I have ever heard, and the most frustrating.” He looked at the pale ice. “A sea under a lid, in the dark, at the other side of the Solar System. And nobody has seen it yet.”
“We have only looked at a few worlds,” said Memoon. “There are thousands more going round other stars. But how would anybody ever find a planet that small, hidden next to something that bright?”
Science Corner An ocean world is a world with liquid water beneath its surface. Jupiter’s moon Europa and Saturn’s moon Enceladus are leading examples. Europa’s salty ocean is estimated to hold about twice as much water as Earth’s oceans, below an ice shell about 15 to 25 km thick (estimates vary). These moons are warmed from inside by tidal heating: the gravity of Jupiter or Saturn squeezes and stretches them as they orbit, which warms their interiors. The sunshine out there is very weak. The Cassini spacecraft (at Saturn 2004 to 2017) saw geysers on Enceladus in 2005 and flew through them. In June 2023 scientists reported that the icy grains contain phosphates, the first time the key element phosphorus was found in an ocean beyond Earth. That is a Hint about habitability, not a sign of life. On Earth, animals live around deep-sea vents in total darkness, using chemical energy from rocks and hot water. So life does not always need sunlight. Remember from Book 6: radio waves can pass through things that block visible light, which is how Europa Clipper’s radar will probe the ice. Dated missions: Europa Clipper launched on 14 October 2024 and is planned to arrive at Jupiter on 11 April 2030, then make nearly 50 flybys of Europa. It will not land. Dragonfly is planned to launch to Saturn’s moon Titan in July 2028 and arrive in 2034. Neither has reached its target. Story note: The paperclip shows that bending can make heat, but its warmth comes from friction inside the metal, while Europa’s comes from tides; the analogy stops there. Nimo’s idea that “water means fish” is the mistake the chapter corrects: water is only one item on the Scorecard. The ocean on Europa and its size are scientists’ estimates from spacecraft measurements, and the ice thickness is still uncertain. No life has been found at any ocean moon. Titan’s lakes are methane and ethane, not water, at about 180 degrees Celsius below zero. All mission dates are as of November 2026.
Space Detective 1. Nimo says, “An ocean means a home for fish.” Give two reasons from this chapter why that does not follow. 2. Europa is about five times as far from the Sun as Earth. Explain how it can still have liquid water, using the paperclip idea and saying where the idea stops working. 3. A friend says, “Europa Clipper will land on Europa and dig for fish.” Write two corrections using the dated facts in the Science Corner.
Try it: Paperclip Tide Test Time: 15 minutes. Adult: An adult watches while you bend the clips and checks that the bent metal is never too hot to touch. You need: two plain metal paperclips, a ruler, a pencil and paper. Do: Straighten both paperclips. Bend one back and forth quickly, 20 times, at the same spot. Then touch the bend gently with the back of one finger, and compare it with the other clip. Draw a cross-section of Europa in your notebook with three layers: an ice shell, an ocean and a rocky centre, and mark where heat could come from. What to expect: The bent spot feels a little warm. The untouched clip feels the same as the room. Cloudy or low-resource day: The test works anywhere indoors. If you have no paperclips, use a thin strip of metal from a clean tin lid, with an adult’s help. Limitation: your paperclip warms because the metal rubs against itself, while Europa warms because tides stretch ice and rock, so the test shows the idea of bending making heat, not the real process.
Next time: We have found worlds with oceans in our own Solar System. But how would anybody find a planet around another star, hidden next to something that bright?
← Chapter 4: Mars: Cold, Thin, Once Wet? · Book 7 contents · Chapter 6: Finding Hidden Planets →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment