Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Chapter 6: Finding Hidden Planets
Chapter 6: Finding Hidden Planets
In this chapter: Explain why exoplanets are hard to see directly, find planets with the transit and wobble methods, and use the squared rule to read a transit graph.
Guddu’s face filled the phone propped against the water tank, slightly tilted, because the phone was slightly tilted. Behind her a ceiling fan turned lazily and a physics textbook lay open on a bed.
“Right,” she said, “you want to find a planet that goes round another star. Let me show you why that is horrible.”
“Because they are far?” said Beautine.
“Because they are faint,” said Guddu. “Remember from Book 3: a planet does not make its own light. It only shines by reflecting its star’s light. Even a big planet like Jupiter would be about a billion times fainter than its star. An Earth-like planet would be about ten billion times fainter. And it sits right next to the star’s glare.”
“Like trying to spot a firefly next to a searchlight,” said Memoon.
“A firefly next to a searchlight, from forty kilometres away,” said Guddu. “So astronomers mostly do not look at the planet at all. They look at the star, and ask how the planet changes it.”
“What does a planet do to a star?” asked Noodles, who had already stretched himself out in front of the lamp, with his tail curled behind him.
“Two things. I will show you the first with your own lamp.”
So they built the experiment. Simbha’s uncle had sent a bright white LED lamp with a round shade, and Memoon put it on a stool at one end of the terrace. At the other end, Kachui set up a phone with a light-meter app, which could read the brightness of the lamp as a number. A ball hung from a long stick, so that Beautine could sweep it slowly between the lamp and the phone.
The lamp is the star and the ball is a planet
“The lamp is the star,” said Memoon. “The ball is a planet. The phone is the telescope. Kachui, what is the brightness with nothing in front?”
“Three hundred and twenty,” said Kachui, and wrote it down.
That was when the accident happened.
Noodles got up to supervise, and his tail, a long, fluffy ginger tail, swept slowly across the light. On Kachui’s screen, the number dropped to two hundred and fifty. Then it came back up to three hundred and twenty.
“Stop!” cried Kachui. “Do that again!”
“I did not do anything,” said Noodles.
“Your tail. It is a planet. It passed in front of the lamp, and the brightness went down. Then it moved away and the brightness came back.” Kachui looked up, looking more excited than he had in ages. “Noodles, you have discovered a planet.”
“Planet Noodles,” said Noodles, with a shiver of joy. “Planet Noodles B. It is a very handsome planet. It is ginger.”
“Wait,” said Guddu from the phone. “Before you name it. Is one dip enough?”
Everyone thought about it.
“No,” said Kachui at last. “A real planet goes round and round. It would pass in front again, and again, at the same gap each time. And the dip would have the same depth. Noodles’s tail went across once, because he is sitting down.”
“You can also get dips from a spot on the star, or from a second star that happens to pass in front,” said Guddu. “That is why astronomers do not announce a planet until they have watched the dip repeat, and ruled out the other things it could be. Competing explanations, remember?”
“Planet Noodles B is disappointed,” said Noodles.
“It was a very good demonstration,” said Memoon, kindly. “Now we do it properly. We call this a transit: when a planet crosses in front of its star, as seen from us. Beautine, sweep the ball. Kachui, read out the lowest number.”
The ball swung across the light. The meter fell to three hundred and six, and rose again.
“Fourteen less,” said Kachui. “Out of three hundred and twenty. That is about four per cent.”
“The ball is two centimetres wide,” said Memoon, “and the lamp’s disc is ten. That is a fifth of the width. And four per cent is...” She did the sum on her notebook. “A fifth times a fifth is one twenty-fifth. Four per cent! The dip matches.”
“I have a prediction,” said Noodles. “Very bold. If you use a ball that is twice as wide, the dip will be twice as big. Eight per cent. Obviously.”
“Test it,” said Guddu, grinning.
Beautine swapped the two-centimetre ball for one that was four centimetres wide. She swept it carefully. Kachui read the lowest number and frowned.
“Two hundred and sixty-eight,” he said. “Fifty-two less. That is about sixteen per cent.”
“Sixteen! Not eight!” said Noodles, deeply wounded.
Brightness of the lamp as a ball passes in front
100% 100%
time → time →
2 cm ball, dip 4% 4 cm ball, dip 16%
Twice as wide, four times the dip. Numbers are from the lamp-and-ball test; the curves are tidied.
Twice as wide, four times the dip.
“Twice as wide, four times the dip,” said Memoon, drawing a graph with the dips on the vertical axis and the width of each ball along the bottom. The points rose in a curve. “Because the ball blocks an area of light, and area depends on width times width. Double the width, and the area is four times as big. A ball three times as wide would block nine times as much light.”
“So that is the secret of the transit,” said Guddu. “The size of the dip tells you how big the planet is compared with its star. Compare the planet’s width with the star’s, and square it. Jupiter is about a tenth of the Sun’s width. A tenth squared is a hundredth, so a Jupiter-sized planet dims a Sun-like star by about one per cent.”
“And Earth?” asked Nimo.
Memoon worked it out, with Kachui checking each line. “Earth is about nine-thousandths of the Sun’s width. Squared, that is about eight hundred-thousandths. The dip is about one part in twelve thousand. About eight thousandths of one per cent.”
“That is a very, very tiny dip,” said Nimo, a bit sadly. “For a planet like my home.”
“It is measurable,” said Guddu. “From space. Without the air wobbling the starlight. NASA’s Kepler telescope, launched in 2009, stared at one patch of sky for years, watching about a hundred and fifty thousand stars for dips. TESS, launched in 2018, scans nearly the whole sky. Most of the planets found so far were found by transits.”
“Only if the planet’s orbit lines up so that we see it cross,” said Kachui, who had been thinking about it. “If the orbit is tilted the wrong way, we never see a dip, and the planet is invisible to this trick.”
“Exactly. So that is one method,” said Guddu. “The second one is the wobble.”
Memoon pulled out the skates she kept in her bag, because she never went anywhere without them. “Imagine two skaters holding hands and spinning. One is heavy. One is light. The light one swings round in a big circle. The heavy one hardly moves, but it moves a bit. It goes round in a small circle too.”
star (a tiny circle)
planet
shared point
The star wobbles in a tiny circle. Sizes are not to scale; the real star circle is far smaller.
The star wobbles in a tiny circle. Sizes are not to scale.
“That is a star and a planet,” said Guddu. “The planet’s gravity tugs the star. The star does not stand still. It wobbles round in a tiny circle. We cannot see the wobble directly, but we can measure it in the star’s light. Book 10 will tell you how. For now, you only need the idea.”
“How big is the wobble?” asked Noodles.
“If you were watching the Sun from far away, Jupiter makes it move at about twelve metres per second,” said Guddu. “About as fast as a racing cyclist. Earth makes it move at about nine centimetres per second.”
Kachui sat up very straight. “That is slower than a tortoise.”
“Slightly slower, yes,” said Guddu. “Which is why it was only in 1995 that two Swiss astronomers, Michel Mayor and Didier Queloz, found the first planet round a Sun-like star using it. It was called 51 Pegasi b. They won the Nobel Prize in Physics for that in 2019. And a few years before them, in 1992, two other astronomers had found the first planets of all, round a very different kind of star, a pulsar.”
Memoon was staring at the graph. “Transit tells you how big. Wobble tells you how heavy.”
“And if you know how big and how heavy, you know the density, which tells you if it is rock or gas. Rock is heavy for its size. A gas giant is light for its size.” Guddu smiled. “India has done this. At Mount Abu, in Rajasthan, there is an instrument called PARAS, built by the Physical Research Laboratory in Ahmedabad. It measures the wobble. In 2018 the team announced a planet called K2-236b. NASA’s K2 mission had seen it transit, and PARAS measured its mass. It was India’s first exoplanet discovery, about 600 light-years away. And in February 2025 the team reported another, TOI-6038A b, with a newer instrument called PARAS-2.”
“Is either of them a home?” asked Nimo hopefully.
“K2-236b is about six hundred degrees at the surface,” said Kachui, who had found the page. “Nobody could swim in it.”
“You can find planets, though,” said Memoon. “That is the point. Six thousand one hundred and forty-seven of them, in March.” She held up the transit graph. “A tiny, tiny dip in a distant star. And somebody notices.”
Nimo floated down to look at the graph, with its small, steady curve. “Then I think I would like to look for the right place,” he said. “I would like to know where, round a star, a planet should be if I am to swim there.”
Beautine had begun sorting the planets in her notebook into piles. “I think I know what I want to be in charge of,” she said. “The cards.”
Science Corner A planet shines only by reflected starlight (Remember from Book 3). It is about a billion times fainter than its star for a Jupiter-like planet, and about ten billion times fainter for an Earth-like one, and it sits next to the star’s glare. So astronomers mostly watch the star. In the transit method, a planet crossing in front of its star makes the starlight dip slightly. The dip is about (planet width divided by star width) squared. A Jupiter-sized planet dims a Sun-like star by about 1 per cent; an Earth-sized planet by about 0.008 per cent. A real planet repeats the same dip at regular gaps. In the wobble method (radial velocity), a planet’s gravity makes its star move in a tiny circle, and the motion can be measured in the star’s light. Jupiter makes the Sun move at about 12 metres per second; Earth about 9 centimetres per second. Wobble gives the planet’s mass. Transit gives size and wobble gives mass; together they give density, which shows whether a planet is rocky or gassy. NASA’s Kepler (launched 2009) and TESS (launched 2018) find planets by transits. Mayor and Queloz found 51 Pegasi b by wobble in 1995. India: the PARAS spectrograph at Mount Abu (Physical Research Laboratory) measured the mass of K2-236b, announced in 2018 as India’s first exoplanet discovery, about 600 light-years away. TOI-6038A b was reported in February 2025 using PARAS-2.
Planet (in front of a Sun-like star) Width compared with the star Dip in starlight
Jupiter-sized about 0.10 about 1 per cent
Earth-sized about 0.009 about 0.008 per cent
Story note: The lamp-and-ball model shows the squared rule, but it is not a real orbit: the ball is moved by hand and the lamp is a flat disc. The firefly-and-searchlight picture shows why planets are hard to see; astronomers can photograph some young giant planets far from their stars with special masks, but most known planets were found indirectly. The skater model shows both bodies circling a shared point; real stars are far heavier than planets, so the wobble is tiny. Transits only appear when the orbit lines up edge-on to us. Light-year distances come from Book 6. Numbers are rounded.
Space Detective 1. Noodles predicted that a ball twice as wide gives a dip twice as big. Use the squared rule to explain what happened, and say how big the dip would be for a ball three times as wide. 2. Give two reasons why one dip in starlight is not enough to announce a planet. 3. Explain why astronomers want both a transit and a wobble measurement for the same planet, and what they can work out from the two.
Try it: Lamp and Ball Transit Time: 40 minutes. Adult: An adult sets up the lamp safely and keeps cords out of the way. You need: a bright LED lamp or torch, a phone with a free light-meter app (or a camera), two balls of different widths on sticks (for example 2 cm and 4 cm), a ruler, graph paper. Do: Put the lamp at one end of a room and the phone at the other, with the meter pointing at the lamp. Read the brightness with nothing in front. Sweep the smaller ball slowly across the line between them and write down the lowest reading. Repeat with the larger ball. Work out each dip as a percentage of the first reading and plot dip against ball width. What to expect: The larger ball makes a dip about four times as deep, not twice, so your points curve upward. Cloudy or low-resource day: The test works indoors with no daylight. With no meter, photograph a white wall lit by the lamp with each ball held in the beam and compare how dark the shadow looks, or simply compare the shadows’ sizes with a ruler. Limitation: the lamp is a flat disc, the ball is moved by hand rather than carried by gravity, and rough readings can differ by a few per cent, so your numbers will only be close to the squared rule.
Next time: We can find planets. But which of them is in a good place for a home: not too close to its star and not too far?
← Chapter 5: Ocean Moons · Book 7 contents · Chapter 7: Strange New Worlds →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment