Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Chapter 7: Strange New Worlds
Chapter 7: Strange New Worlds
In this chapter: Describe the kinds of planets astronomers have found, explain the habitable zone and why it depends on the star, and explain why being inside it is a starting point and not a guarantee.
Beautine spent four days making the cards.
They were cut from the back of an old cereal box and each was about the size of a playing card. On the front she had drawn a planet in coloured pencil, and on the back she had written its name, its star, its distance in light-years and a number from one to ten called THE HOME SCORE. She had made sixty-three of them. When she laid them out on the blue mat in rows, the Club stood round and stared, because they looked like a very odd museum.
“Planets,” said Beautine. “Real ones. Sorted by type.”
Beautine’s planet cards
She picked up the first. It showed a fierce orange ball with a tiny black dot in front of it. “This is 51 Pegasi b, the very first planet found round a Sun-like star. It is a hot Jupiter: a giant planet, like Jupiter, but so close to its star that it goes round in about four days. Home
Score: nought.”
“Four days for a year?” said Noodles. “I would have a birthday every Thursday.”
“Next, the super-Earths. These are planets bigger than Earth but smaller than Neptune. And the sub-Neptunes, a bit smaller than Neptune. Astronomers have found lots of these, and here is the strange part: our own Solar System does not have a single one.” She waved a card in triumph. “Nothing between Earth and Neptune in size. We are the odd one out!”
“We are one system,” said Kachui. “It may be that other systems are just as strange to them as theirs are to us.”
“And here,” said Beautine, laying down a card with gold edges, in the middle of the mat, with a flourish, “the best of all.”
It said TRAPPIST-1. It showed seven small planets in a row, each with a Home Score written in thick marker. Three of them, the fourth, fifth and sixth, had been circled in green.
“TRAPPIST-1 is a small, cool, dim red star, about forty light-years away,” said Beautine. “It has seven planets, all about Earth’s size, all rocky. And three of them are in the Habitable Zone!” She tapped the green circles. “A place where it is not too hot and not too cold. That means home! A guaranteed home! I have already given them a ten. I think we should write to somebody.”
There was a pause.
“Beautine,” said Memoon, “what is the habitable zone?”
“It is where it is just right.”
“For what?”
“For... living.”
“Let us find out,” said Kachui, who had put down the card and picked up the lamp.
He set it at one end of the terrace on a stool, and a phone with a light meter at the other. “Here is a star. The meter is a planet. Memoon. How much light does the planet get at one metre?”
“Four hundred,” said Memoon, reading the meter.
“And at two metres?”
She walked it out. “One hundred.”
“Four times less, at twice the distance,” said Kachui. “At three metres?”
“Forty-four.”
“Nine times less at three times the distance,” said Kachui. “The same squared rule you used with the lamp and the ball, Memoon. Light spreads out from a star the way spray-paint spreads from a can. Twice as far, and the same light has to cover four times as much area. So you get a quarter.”
“That is Book 6 again,” said Noodles. “Brightness depends on how far.”
“Right. Now, here is a much dimmer lamp.” Kachui swapped in a small torch. “This is a red dwarf, a small, cool star like TRAPPIST-1. Memoon, find the distance where the meter reads four hundred, the same light as Earth gets from the Sun.”
She walked and walked. The reading was only twenty at one metre. She walked back and forth until she was nearly in front of the stool. “Here,” she said. “About twenty-two centimetres. I have to be almost touching it.”
“So for a dim star,” said Kachui, “a planet needs to be very close to get the same warmth as Earth does. That is the habitable zone: the range of distances where a planet with the right air could have liquid water on its surface. Dim star, close zone. Bright star, far zone.”
“That is why TRAPPIST-1’s planets go round in days, not years,” said Simbha. “They are tucked in close, where the zone is, and that makes them go round quickly.”
Beautine nodded very fast. “Exactly what I said. Home!”
“Now put Venus on the Sun’s zone,” said Memoon. She drew it on a strip of paper. “Earth is in the middle. Venus is on the hot edge, or just outside it, depending on whose estimate you use. Mars is near the cold edge. Neither is a good home. Why not?”
Our Sun
habitable zone (estimates differ)
Venus Earth Mars
A small, dim red dwarf star
its zone is close in
Not to scale. Positions are approximate. Being in the zone does not make a planet a home.
A dim star has a close habitable zone. Distances are not to scale.
Beautine was quiet for a while. “Because of their air,” she said at last. “Venus’s blanket is much too thick. Mars’s blanket is much too thin.”
“So the zone says where the Sun could keep liquid water on a planet that has air like Earth’s,” said Memoon. “It does not say what the planet’s air is like. It is a place to look, not a verdict.”
“And for the TRAPPIST-1 planets...” Kachui searched his notebook. “The James Webb Space Telescope has been studying them. The innermost planet, TRAPPIST-1 b, probably has no thick atmosphere. The next, c, has no thick carbon dioxide atmosphere. Studies of the habitable-zone planet e, published in 2025, found that it probably does not have a thick hydrogen-rich atmosphere, but a thinner Earth-like one is not ruled out. The star flares, which makes the data hard to read. So nobody knows. It is a Guess.”
Beautine looked at her gold card. Slowly, she crossed out the ten and wrote a question mark.
“Do not be sad,” said Nimo. “It is an excellent card. It has just moved from certainty to curiosity. Those are the same thing for a scientist.”
“There is another problem with the cool dim stars,” said Simbha. “They flare. Sometimes they let off bursts of radiation that could strip a planet’s air. And a planet that close may become tidally locked: one side always facing the star, the other side always in the dark. Like the Moon with the Earth. Some scientists think the atmosphere could carry heat round to the dark side, and some think it could freeze there. We do not know.”
“What about the next-door planet?” asked Noodles. “The Proxima one. I remember that name.”
“Proxima b,” said Kachui, finding the card. “It goes round Proxima Centauri, the nearest star beyond the Sun, 4.2 light-years away. Remember from Book 6. It was found in 2016, by the wobble. It is in its star’s habitable zone and goes round in just over eleven days. It also has a flaring star. We know almost nothing about its air.”
“How long would it take us to reach it?” asked Beautine.
Kachui did the sum on the back of a card. “The fastest spacecraft that has left the Solar System is Voyager 1, going about seventeen kilometres every second. At that speed it would take about seventy-five thousand years to cover four point two light-years.”
“Seventy-five thousand,” said Noodles. “I would need so many snacks.”
“So we study them from here,” said Memoon. “With telescopes. With patience.”
Nimo was looking at the strip of paper with Earth, Venus and Mars marked on it, and the line of the zone. Then, after a while, at the print of Europa, which was still lying where Simbha had left it on the mat. “Europa is nowhere near the Sun’s zone,” he said. “It is much farther out. Yet it may have an ocean.”
“Because the heat comes from tides, not from the Sun,” said Simbha. “Remember from Chapter 5. So the zone is one kind of home. A home that is warmed by its star. There may be others.”
“Then I do not know what to put on the cards,” said Beautine, with great honesty. “Home Scores that are not tens. Hm.”
“Put Known, Hint, Guess,” said Kachui.
So she did. She sat all afternoon, sorting out sixty-three planets again, this time by what they knew about each one, and by the end, nearly all of them said GUESS.
“That is very honest,” said Memoon. “And very hard.”
Beautine put the last card down and looked at them. “I always wanted the answer,” she said. “I did not know that wanting it too much was the problem.”
Science Corner The habitable zone is the range of distances from a star where a planet with a suitable atmosphere could have liquid water on its surface. Estimates differ, but Earth is inside, Venus is near the hot edge or just outside it, and Mars is near the cold edge. Light spreads over an area that grows with distance squared, so twice as far gives a quarter of the light. A dim star’s zone is close in; a bright star’s zone is farther out. Remember from Book 6: brightness depends on distance. Being in the zone is a starting point, not a guarantee. A planet’s air matters (Venus, Mars). Red dwarf stars flare, and planets very close to them may be tidally locked, with one side always facing the star. Ocean moons like Europa are far outside the Sun’s zone but warmed by tides. Planets come in many kinds: hot Jupiters (51 Pegasi b goes round in about four days), super-Earths and sub-Neptunes (sizes between Earth and Neptune, which our Solar System does not have), and rocky planets. NASA’s archive sorts them into gas giants, Neptune-like, super-Earths and terrestrial planets. TRAPPIST-1, about 40 light-years away, has seven Earth-sized planets, three in the habitable zone. JWST results so far: planet b probably has no thick atmosphere; planet c has no thick carbon dioxide atmosphere; 2025 studies of planet e found a thick hydrogen-rich atmosphere unlikely but did not rule out an Earth-like one. Proxima b orbits the nearest star, 4.2 light-years away, in its zone; its air is unknown. Story note: The lamp-and-torch test shows that a dimmer star has a closer zone, but real zones also depend on a planet’s air, its reflectivity and the colour of its star’s light. The spray-paint picture shows how light spreads out; real light does not stop at the edge of anything. Beautine’s Home Scores are the story’s device, and the chapter replaces them with Known, Hint and Guess. The Voyager sum uses rounded numbers and ignores the pull of other stars. TRAPPIST-1 distances and the JWST results are as of November 2026 and may change.
Space Detective 1. Beautine says, “A planet in the habitable zone is a guaranteed home.” Use Venus or Mars to show why she is wrong. 2. A star gives out one quarter as much light as the Sun. Use the squared rule from this chapter to work out how far from this star a planet would be to get the same light as Earth gets from the Sun, compared with Earth’s distance. 3. Europa is far outside the Sun’s habitable zone but may have liquid water. Explain how this shows the zone is only one kind of home.
Try it: Zone Finder Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult sets up the lamps safely in a dark room and keeps cords out of the way. You need: two lamps of different brightness (for example a bright LED bulb and a small torch), a phone with a free light-meter app, a tape measure, a strip of paper. Do: Put the bright lamp on a table. Move the phone away from it until the meter reads about 400 and mark that distance on your strip of paper. Switch to the dim lamp and find the distance where the reading is again about 400. Mark it on a second strip. Compare the two zones. What to expect: The dim lamp’s matching distance is much shorter. A dim star’s habitable zone is close to it. Cloudy or low-resource day: The test works indoors at any time. With no meter, use a sheet of white paper and judge when both pages look equally bright. Limitation: real zones also depend on a planet’s air and on what its surface is made of, so the model only shows how brightness and distance trade off.
Next time: We have a way to find planets and a way to guess which might be good. But if one of them had life on it, how would anybody ever tell from here?
← Chapter 6: Finding Hidden Planets · Book 7 contents · Chapter 8: How Would We Know? →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment