Memunic Space Explorers › Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home › Chapter 8: How Would We Know?
Chapter 8: How Would We Know?
In this chapter: Explain what a biosignature is, why one signal is never enough, and use the Evidence Ladder to judge claims about life beyond Earth.
“Time for the Headline Game,” said Guddu.
Her face was on the phone again, propped against the water tank. She had a mug of tea in one hand and, in the other, three pieces of paper which she held up to the camera one by one, face down.
The Headline Game
“Rules. I read you a headline. You tell me which of Kachui’s three labels fits it. Known, Hint or Guess. But there is a catch. You must also tell me what else could explain it. One mistake and Noodles has to read the next one out loud.”
“I will be very good,” said Noodles, who hated reading aloud.
“First,” said Guddu, “let us do the easy part. Suppose one of those thousands of planets did have life on it. How would we find out from here? Nimo?”
Nimo had been floating in a very thoughtful manner. “If I lived on a planet round a faraway star, and you looked at it with a telescope, you would not see me. I am the size of my own bubble.”
“You would not see you,” Guddu agreed. “But you might see what a lot of living things do to a planet. Look at Earth. Plants and tiny sea creatures have been making oxygen for billions of years. It is a fifth of our air. Without life, the oxygen would have reacted with rocks and other gases and vanished long ago. Life keeps making more.”
“So oxygen is the sign,” said Noodles at once. “If a planet has oxygen, it has life. Obviously.”
“Is that your final answer?” asked Guddu.
Noodles looked at her for a long, uncertain moment. “Is it a trick?”
“It is a check,” said Memoon, who had seen this coming. “What else could make oxygen without living things?”
There was a silence.
“Oh,” said Kachui. “On a planet that is losing its water. If ultraviolet light from its star splits the water apart, the hydrogen can float away into space and leave the oxygen behind. That would give oxygen with no life at all.”
“Correct,” said Guddu. “Scientists call a wrong ’yes’ of this kind a false positive. So they look for combinations. On Earth there is oxygen and a little methane. Those two gases react with each other and destroy each other. Finding both in the air at once means something is keeping on making them. On Earth, that something is living things.”
“But how would you ever see gases in the air of a planet forty light-years away?” asked Beautine.
“With the very trick you did in Chapter 6,” said Guddu. “When a planet crosses in front of its star, a little of the starlight passes through the edge of the planet’s air on its way to us. The gases soak up certain colours. They leave a kind of fingerprint in the light. A telescope that can split the light into its colours, like the James Webb Space Telescope, launched on Christmas Day 2021, can read it. It looks in infrared, one of those kinds of light beyond our eyes that you met at the GMRT.”
“Colour fingerprints,” said Memoon. “Book 10?”
“Book 10.”
So much for the easy part. Guddu turned over the first piece of paper.
“Headline one. LIFE ON VENUS? SCIENTISTS FIND GAS MADE BY MICROBES. September 2020.”
“Phosphine,” said Kachui at once, because he had the page. “A team led by Jane Greaves at Cardiff University reported a trace of the gas phosphine high in the clouds of Venus, about twenty parts in every billion. On Earth, some microbes make it, in places without oxygen, and so do factories.”
“What else could explain it?” asked Guddu.
Kachui read on. “Other teams looked at the same data and said the signal might be sulphur dioxide, which looks similar at that colour. Other observations found much less, or nothing. The original team disagrees. The debate has gone on for years.”
“So what do you give it?”
“Guess,” said Kachui. “Perhaps a Hint. But a disputed one.”
“Headline two. JAMES WEBB FINDS POSSIBLE ALIEN LIFE ON DISTANT WATER WORLD. April 2025.”
Memoon knew this one. “K2-18b. A planet bigger than Earth, smaller than Neptune, about a hundred and twenty light-years away. A team using Webb said they saw a tentative sign of dimethyl sulphide, a gas that on Earth is made by tiny sea creatures, and maybe a close cousin of it.”
“And?”
“And other teams re-examined the numbers and did not find a reliable signal. A NASA-led study said the evidence is not conclusive. And even if the gas were there, it might be made without life. And we are not even sure the planet has an ocean.” She frowned. “As of this year, people call it tentative and disputed. It is a Guess, with a very small question mark.”
“Headline three.”
“Mars rock has possible signs of ancient life,” said Nimo. “The Sapphire Canyon sample. September 2025. Kachui, I think I can do this one.”
He did, and he did it well: the leopard spots, the peer-reviewed paper, the careful phrase potential biosignature, the fact that the scientists themselves said non-living chemistry might explain it, and the fact that the best test would be to bring the rock to labs on Earth.
“A Hint,” he finished, “and the best Hint on the list. But still a Hint.”
“Good,” said Guddu. “Now I want to give you a tool. Because three headlines, three different answers, and you got there by arguing. I want you to be able to argue fast.”
She held up a piece of paper on which she had drawn a ladder with five rungs.
“Rung one,” she said. “A claim. Somebody says, we have found something.
“Rung two. Data. The measurements are shown openly, so others can look.
“Rung three. Other explanations. The scientists ask what else could cause it, and try to rule each one out.
“Rung four. Independent checks. Other teams, using other instruments, find the same thing.
“Rung five. Repeat. It keeps happening, in more observations, and different lines of evidence agree.
“It is called the Evidence Ladder. A claim only really counts as knowledge at the top.”
Memoon was already copying it into the Sky Notebook. “Where do the three headlines go?”
| Higher = more | 5 Repeat |
|---|---|
| trustworthy | keeps happening; different lines of evidence agree |
4 Independent checks other teams, other instruments
3 Other explanations Venus phosphine (rung 3) what else could cause it?
2 Data K2-18b gases (rung 2–3)
measurements shown openly Sapphire Canyon rock (rung 2)
1 Claim somebody says we found something
Headline claims on the ladder (Nov 20
The Evidence Ladder.
They argued it out. Venus phosphine had reached rung three, because people had asked what else could explain it, and the answer was still being fought over. K2-18b had reached rung two or three, but not four. The Sapphire Canyon rock was more secure at rung two, with rung three handled openly in the paper, and rung four needed the rock back on Earth.
“What about before?” asked Kachui. “Has there ever been a claim that fell off the ladder?”
“Yes,” said Guddu. “In 1996, scientists reported tiny features in a meteorite from Mars that they thought might be the fossils of tiny living things. It made the front page of newspapers all over the world. Then other scientists found that ordinary, non-living processes could make similar features. Most scientists no longer think it shows life.”
“That is a very big fall,” said Beautine, looking at the ladder.
“It is also exactly how science is supposed to work,” said Guddu. “Nobody was foolish. The claim was checked, and the checking took it down. If it had been right, the checking would have held it up.”
Beautine had been scribbling. She held up the notebook with a flourish. “My headline for K2-18b. ALIENS FOUND ON WATER WORLD! JAMES WEBB SEES LIFE!“
“Beautine,” said Memoon.
“I know, I know.” She crossed it out and wrote a new one, much more slowly. Webb telescope team reports tentative signal of two gases on faraway planet. Other teams disagree. More observations needed.
“That,” said Guddu, “is not as exciting. But it is true. And that is the job.”
Nimo had floated up close to the ladder and was looking at the five rungs. “If I were really on a planet round another star,” he said slowly, “and I did not change my planet’s air, you would never know I was there. I could be the happiest fish in the galaxy, and your ladder would say nothing.”
The terrace went very quiet.
“That is true,” said Memoon. “Not finding a signal does not mean there is no life. It only means we have not found one that changes a planet’s air in a way we can read. There may be a great deal of life that leaves no trace we can see from here.”
“Then the honest answer to my question,” said Nimo, “is that nobody knows.”
“Nobody knows yet,” said Guddu. “And, Nimo, people are working on it.”
Nimo was smiling again. “I have decided that I like this answer better than the other kinds. It is the one that does not lie to me.”
It was Memoon who closed the notebook, because there was another idea in it, one that had been at the back of her mind since the first night on the terrace.
“There is one place,” she said, “where we know for certain that there is life. And we have never really looked at it from outside.”
Science Corner A biosignature is a sign, such as a gas in a planet’s air, that might be made by living things. Astronomers study a planet’s air by watching the starlight that passes through its edge during a transit. Gases leave a fingerprint in the light (Book 10 explains how). The James Webb Space Telescope, launched 25 December 2021, observes in infrared light, one of the kinds of light beyond our eyes (Remember from Book 6). Oxygen together with methane is a famous pair on Earth, because each destroys the other, so both staying in the air suggests something keeps making them. But oxygen alone can also be made without life, for example when a star’s ultraviolet light splits water and the hydrogen escapes. A wrong “yes” like this is a false positive. The Evidence Ladder has five rungs: claim, data, other explanations, independent checks, repeat. A claim is knowledge only near the top, when different teams and methods agree. Dated examples: the Venus phosphine claim (reported September 2020) is disputed. The K2-18b claim of dimethyl sulphide (2023, and again in April 2025) is tentative and disputed as of September 2026. The Mars Sapphire Canyon sample (Nature, 10 September 2025) is a potential biosignature that needs more study. A 1996 claim about a Martian meteorite did not survive checking. No life beyond Earth has been confirmed. Not finding a signal also does not prove there is no life, because life that does not change a planet’s air would be hard to see. Story note: The Evidence Ladder is the Club’s own teaching tool; scientists use standards such as repeated detections by independent teams, but they do not use this exact ladder. The headlines were written for the story, and the facts in them are real. “Fingerprint” is an analogy: real spectra are messy and hard to read, which is why Book 10 comes later. Venus and K2-18b results may change; the dates here are as of November 2026.
Space Detective 1. Explain why finding oxygen alone in a planet’s air does not prove life, and why finding oxygen and methane together is stronger evidence but still not proof. 2. Choose one of the three cases (Venus phosphine, K2-18b, Sapphire Canyon). Place it on the Evidence Ladder and name one thing that would move it up a rung. 3. Rewrite this headline so that it is accurate: “ALIENS FOUND! JAMES WEBB SEES LIFE ON FAR PLANET.” Use words such as tentative, disputed or potential where they fit, and label the claim Known, Hint or Guess.
Try it: Headline Detective Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult helps you choose a reliable source and checks that you only visit trusted sites. You need: a newspaper or a phone to find a science story, a notebook, a pen. Do: Find a news story about a science discovery. Write its headline. Underline the claim. Place it on the Evidence Ladder, then find the researchers’ own statement or the agency’s page and write a more careful headline. List one other explanation that the scientists mention. What to expect: The scientists’ own words are usually more careful than the headline. They often say “may”, “suggests” or “needs more study”. Cloudy or low-resource day: The task works without any equipment: use the three headlines in this chapter and rate each on the ladder. Limitation: you only see summaries, and news stories can also be wrong or oversimplified, so always check what the researchers themselves said.
Next time: We know how hard it is to find life on a faraway planet. But there is one place where we know it exists. What does it look like from very far away?
← Chapter 7: Strange New Worlds · Book 7 contents · Chapter 9: Our Only Known Home →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 7: Memoon and the Search for Another Home, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment