Memunic Space Explorers › Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars › Chapter 1: Fading Shoulder
Chapter 1: Fading Shoulder
In this chapter: Use a brightness ladder and reference stars to decide whether a star’s brightness has really changed, and record the answer as KNOWN, HINT or GUESS.
The first cool evening after the monsoon smelled of wet soil, Mr Rao’s tomato plants and, on the Rooftop Sky Club’s terrace, hot printer ink.
Simbha had printed two photographs on glossy paper and was holding them against his chest the way a lion holds a secret, which is to say not very well. One corner stuck out. Noodles had already spotted it.
“That’s a picture of a fish,” said Noodles, squinting with his green eyes. “No. A fish in the dark. A very dark fish.”
“It is Orion,” said Simbha. “My uncle sent them. He photographs the sky from a hill town, and he was clearing old files from his computer.” He laid the pages side by side on the blue mat and weighed down the corners with Memoon’s sneakers, a pencil case and a tomato Mr Rao had left on the parapet.
N (up)
Aldebaran Betelgeuse Bellatrix
Alnilam Mintaka E Alnitak W
Orion Nebula
Saiph Rigel
Looking south. Dot size shows brightness; dot colour shows colour (approximate).
Orion as seen facing south. Dot sizes show brightness; colours are approximate.
Beautine, hanging upside down from the parapet as she always did when something interesting was about to happen, swung her head toward the pages. Her pink bow dangled. “That is the Hunter. Three stars in a row for the belt, one at each foot, one at each shoulder.”
Memoon slid her round glasses up her nose and crouched over the pictures. Both showed the same hunter, taken from the same hill, with the same three belt stars in the same straight line. Her uncle had written dates on the back in blue ink: January 2019 on the first, February 2020 on the second.
Two photographs of Orion, thirteen months apart. Look at the orange shoulder star.
“Look at the shoulder,” said Simbha quietly. “The orange one. Betelgeuse.”
In the first photograph, the shoulder star glowed like a coal, one of the brightest points in the whole picture. In the second, it had sunk into the crowd. It looked no better than an ordinary star.
“It’s fading,” said Simbha. His voice was not quite steady. “I think it’s dying.”
Nobody said anything for a moment. A scooter honked far below.
“Obvious,” said Noodles at last. “Stars are lamps. Lamps burn out. Somebody has switched it off, or it ran out of battery.”
“BREAKING NEWS!” cried Beautine, dropping from the parapet onto the mat so fast that the photographs rustled. “ORION LOSES AN ARM! The Hunter is going to be a one-shouldered hunter! I am writing the headline now!”
“Beautine,” said Kachui, in the slow voice of a turtle who has seen many headlines come and go. He had opened his small grey notebook with the red ribbon. “Before we write anything, which of these sentences do we actually know?”
Memoon grinned. This was their game. After the planet cards of the monsoon, she and Kachui had invented three labels, and the Club still used them: KNOWN for things they had checked, HINT for things that pointed somewhere but did not prove it, and GUESS for anything that went beyond the evidence. She pulled out her Sky Notebook and drew three columns.
“Simbha says the star is dying,” she said. “That’s a GUESS, and a big one. Noodles says it was switched off. Also a GUESS. Beautine says Orion lost an arm.”
“A dramatic GUESS,” said Beautine, with some pride.
“What do we KNOW?” asked Kachui.
“That the two photographs look different,” said Memoon. “That’s all so far.”
“Not even that,” said Kachui gently. “They were taken thirteen months apart. Maybe on different cameras. Maybe one night was hazy. Maybe one photograph is simply darker, because the shutter stayed open for a shorter time. If every star in the second picture were fainter, we would not blame Betelgeuse.”
Simbha’s ears flattened. “I looked at the star. I did not think about the camera.”
“Lots of scientists make that mistake,” said Memoon kindly. “You looked from one place and trusted what you saw. It happens. We can fix it.” She tapped the second photograph. “We need a yardstick that was photographed at the same moment as Betelgeuse. Something that would change with the camera but not with the star.”
“The other stars,” said Kachui.
“The other stars,” said Memoon. “If the whole photograph is darker, every star gets fainter. But if only Betelgeuse drops compared with its neighbours, then it is Betelgeuse and not the camera.”
They worked it out together on the blue mat, with the torch, the notebook and a ruler. Memoon had a plan: ignore how bright each star looked in absolute terms, and instead rank the stars in each photograph from brightest to faintest. A ranking does not change if the whole picture goes lighter or darker. Kachui added a second rule: they would only use bright, well-known stars that were in both pictures.
The ranking took ten minutes. In the 2019 photograph, the order was Rigel, the blue-white star at the Hunter’s foot, then Betelgeuse in second place, then a pack of stars that were all about equal: Bellatrix at the other shoulder and the three belt stars. In the 2020 photograph,
Rigel was still first. But Betelgeuse had fallen into the pack, no brighter than Bellatrix and no brighter than the belt.
Brightness ladder
normal Great Dimming, February 2020
Rigel Rigel
Betelgeuse's slide Betelgeuse Aldebaran
Bellatrix and Aldebaran Betelgeuse (level)
Bellatrix
Approx. magnitudes: Rigel 0.1, Betelgeuse 0.5 (range 0.0 to 1.6), Aldebaran 0.9, Bellatrix 1.6. Order only, not to scale.
The Betelgeuse Brightness Ladder. Order only, not to scale.
“So that’s different,” said Memoon, writing it down. “Not because of the camera. All the other stars kept their places.”
“KNOWN,” said Kachui. He wrote it in his notebook with a very small, very firm tick.
Simbha let out a breath that was almost a growl. “So it did fade. Betelgeuse really was fainter in February 2020 than in January 2019.”
“In those two photographs, yes,” said Memoon. “That’s the KNOWN. We have no idea yet why. And a star getting fainter is not the same as a star dying, so that part stays GUESS.” She wrote GUESS: dying at the bottom of the third column and underlined it twice.
“Then we should check tonight,” said Noodles, who had been rolling a pencil between his paws. “Maybe it is still fading and we have been sitting here doing paperwork while it goes dark.”
It was a good point, even coming from Noodles. They switched off the shielded terrace lights, the new ones the society had installed after the Club’s proposal, which hid every bulb under a hood so that light shone down and not up. Without the glare, the sky looked deeper. The Hunter had risen clear of the water tank. Betelgeuse burned at his shoulder, orange-red and steady.
Memoon draws the brightness ladder while the Club checks the sky.
Memoon worked the way she always did: find the stars, then compare. Rigel at the foot, a clean blue-white. Aldebaran, orange too, the eye of the Bull, the star whose distance they had measured, shining to the west of Orion. Bellatrix at the other shoulder, pale and cool-looking. She asked everyone to rank them by eye, without talking.
“Rigel, Betelgeuse, Aldebaran, Bellatrix,” said Kachui.
“Rigel, Betelgeuse, Aldebaran, Bellatrix,” said Simbha, relieved.
“Rigel, Betelgeuse, then Bellatrix and Aldebaran look the same to me,” said Noodles, and then, because he is Noodles, added, “but I had a very long dinner.”
“Mostly the same,” said Memoon. “Betelgeuse is clearly brighter than Bellatrix tonight. Not in the pack.” She turned to a fresh page and drew a ladder with four rungs: Rigel at the top, then Betelgeuse, then Aldebaran, then Bellatrix. “This is the Betelgeuse Brightness Ladder.
On a normal night, Betelgeuse sits on the second rung. In February 2020, it had slid down to the bottom.”
“So tonight it is normal,” said Simbha.
“Tonight it looks normal,” said Kachui. “One night proves very little. A star that fades and recovers might simply have recovered.”
“Recovered?” Simbha sat up.
“If the star was already back on its second rung tonight, it did come back,” said Memoon. “The faded photograph is the past. We are looking at the present. Well, nearly.”
She stopped.
“Nearly,” said Beautine. “Oh no. She has gone quiet and mathematical.”
“Light-years,” said Memoon, tapping her nose. “We measured Aldebaran’s distance, remember? A light-year is a distance, not a time, but it also tells us how old the light is. Betelgeuse is somewhere between five hundred and fifty and seven hundred light-years away. Astronomers still disagree, because it is too far and too big for the simple parallax trick we used to be precise. So the light that made the faded photograph left the star more than five hundred years before the camera clicked. The dimming we saw in 2020 actually happened in the fourteenth or fifteenth century, depending on which distance is right.”
Beautine’s whiskers trembled. “Then Betelgeuse might have already exploded, and we would not know for centuries!”
“It might have,” said Kachui calmly. “And nobody could tell until that light arrives. That is not a GUESS to build a headline on, though. It is a reason to be careful with the word now when we talk about stars.”
Simbha looked at the shoulder star for a long while. Tonight it did not look like something dying. It looked like something very far away, and very old, and not bothered by anyone’s opinion. The Hunter stood over the water tank. Mr Rao’s last tomato rolled slowly off the parapet and was caught by Noodles, who ate it.
“Here is what I want to know,” said Simbha at last. “Why did it fade and come back? Why is it orange, when Bellatrix, right next to it, is almost white? And if a fading star is not necessarily a dying star, how do stars end? Where do they even begin?”
“That,” said Memoon, closing the notebook on the three columns, “is more than one question. It is a whole book.”
She tore a clean page from the Club Logbook and wrote on the top, in capital letters: THE BETELGEUSE LOG. Under it she drew the ladder, and next to the ladder she wrote one rule. Rank them by eye. Write down what you see, not what you expect.
“One more thing,” said Kachui. He lifted the lid of the Question Jar, which he had carried up in his shell, and fished out a small orange slip. Beautine’s handwriting, bold and loopy: Why is my star orange? It had been sitting in the must-wait pile since the night they measured Aldebaran’s distance. “I think, tonight, we have a good reason to open it.”
Science Corner A star’s apparent brightness is how bright it looks from here. Astronomers measure it in magnitudes, where a smaller number (or a negative one) means a brighter star. It depends on how much light the star gives out and on how far away it is. A variable star changes brightness over time. Betelgeuse swings up and down in a rhythm of roughly 400 days, with other, slower rhythms as well. A reference star (or comparison star) is a star you trust to stay almost constant. Comparing a variable star with reference stars in the same picture cancels out camera settings, haze and moonlight. The Great Dimming of Betelgeuse began in October 2019, took away well over half of its brightness by mid-February 2020, and was over by April 2020 (NASA, Hubble team; checked 2 November 2026). Because light takes time to arrive, what we see of Betelgeuse today left it centuries ago. Its distance is still uncertain; estimates from different methods fall between about 550 and 700 light-years. Story note: The two photographs and the rankings in this chapter follow what astronomers recorded (Betelgeuse was the second brightest star in Orion before the dimming and fell to about the level of its neighbours at the lowest point), but the Club’s ranking method is a simplified version of real photometry. A camera does not record colour the way an eye does, so a red star can look slightly brighter or fainter in a photograph than to the eye; that is why the Club also checks with its own eyes. The star’s distance is uncertain, and no one knows when it will end. The friends, the Club, the printed pages and the Betelgeuse Log are story elements.
Space Detective 1. Explain why ranking the stars in one photograph is a better test than comparing Betelgeuse’s brightness between two photographs taken with different cameras. 2. On the Club’s ladder, Betelgeuse usually sits on the second rung. Describe what the ladder looked like at the lowest point of the dimming, and which two things stayed the same. 3. Draw the four-rung ladder (Rigel, Betelgeuse, Aldebaran, Bellatrix) and mark with an arrow where Betelgeuse fell to in the February 2020 photograph.
Try it: Start the Betelgeuse Log Time: 10 minutes on any clear evening, repeated over several weeks. Adult: An adult should come along for night watching, and you should sit or stand somewhere safe, such as a terrace with a parapet or an open yard. You need: Sky Notebook, pencil, a torch covered with red cellophane, a printed star chart or a star-chart app set to night mode. Do: Find Orion, then find Rigel, Betelgeuse, Aldebaran and Bellatrix. Without talking to anyone first, rank the four from brightest to faintest by eye. Write the date, the time, how clear the sky was and your ranking. Compare your ranking with a friend’s afterwards, and label each difference KNOWN (you both agree), HINT (you disagree slightly) or GUESS (you cannot tell). What to expect: On most nights Betelgeuse sits between Rigel and Aldebaran. The brightness changes of a normal year are small and slow, so you may see no change for weeks. That is a result too. Cloudy or low-resource day: With an adult, open two photographs of Orion taken on different dates from a space-agency or observatory website, and rank the same four stars in each. Limitation: stars close to the horizon look fainter because we look through more air, so compare only when the stars are at similar heights, and eyes are not accurate enough to measure small changes.
Next time: Betelgeuse and Bellatrix are the two shoulders of the same Hunter, and one is orange-red while the other is blue-white. What does the colour of a star have to do with how hot it is?
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment