Memunic Space Explorers › Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars › Chapter 2: Colours Are Temperatures
Chapter 2: Colours Are Temperatures
In this chapter: Explain that a star’s colour tells its surface temperature (cool stars glow orange-red, hot stars blue-white), and that colour together with size explains why a cool star can still be extremely bright.
Beautine took the orange slip out of the Jar herself.
She unfolded it carefully on the blue mat, smoothed it twice with her tail and held it up to the terrace lights so that everyone could see her own handwriting from months ago: Why is my star orange?
“I wrote it the night we measured Aldebaran,” she said. “Everyone else was thrilled about the distance. I was thrilled about the colour. Why is it orange? Why not green? Or purple? Or, like, polka-dot?”
“Polka-dot,” said Noodles with approval, “is the best colour.”
“The slip says orange, Noodles,” said Kachui, who was sorting the rest of the must-wait pile into neat rows. “Not polka-dot. It is a real question. I have been looking forward to it.”
Nimo’s bubble floated to the middle of the group, a blue fish with golden fins turning slowly inside his own small piece of water. “I know this one,” he said. “Hot water is red and cold water is blue. Every tap in the world says so. So red stars are the hottest ones, orange are warm, white are cold, and blue stars are freezing.”
“Fire is red,” Noodles added. “Hot things are red. Obvious.”
Memoon looked from one to the other. She liked this part of an investigation, when two different friends were wrong in exactly the same way, because it meant the wrong idea was a natural one. “Two good clues pointing the same way,” she said. “Tap colours and fire. That is exactly when we should test it, because a tap’s colour code is something people painted on to help them. Nobody paints stars.”
“I can paint stars,” said Beautine.
“Later,” said Memoon. She opened her Sky Notebook and wrote, in two columns, TAP RULE: red is hot and WHAT STARS DO: ??? “How can we find out what a hot thing really does, colour-wise? We cannot visit a star. We can visit something we can heat.”
They needed an adult, and the adult they wanted was on the fourth floor with his tomato plants. Mr Rao came up the stairs a few minutes later with a toolbox, a long extension cord and a look of deep happiness. He was a retired engineer, and being asked to help with an experiment made him feel twenty years younger. From the toolbox he took a clear old-fashioned bulb with a thin coil of wire inside it, a small dimmer switch from his workshop and a metal stand. He wired them together on the terrace table, away from the water tank, and made everyone stand a metre back.
“The thread inside is called a filament,” he said. “It glows because electricity heats it. I will turn the dimmer up very slowly. Do not touch the glass, ever, and do not look closer than your seat. Memoon, you take the notes. What do you see?”
Mr Rao switched off the shielded lamp above the table and the terrace went dim. At first, nothing. Then Mr Rao turned the dimmer a little and the filament began to glow a deep, dull red, the colour of the last ember in a stove.
“Red,” said Memoon, writing. “Dull red.”
He turned it up. The red grew brighter and turned orange.
“Orange!” said Beautine, bouncing. “It is Aldebaran!”
Mr Rao turned it up again. The orange paled to yellow, then to a yellowish-white, and finally the whole coil shone with a clear white light that made them all squint.
“Stop there,” said Memoon. “Write down the order. Dull red, orange, yellow, white. And Mr Rao, the filament is getting hotter all the way?”
The glowing filament: dull red, then orange, then yellowish-white as it gets hotter.
“Hotter all the way,” said Mr Rao. “At full power it is well over two thousand degrees Celsius. It started dull red because at that low setting it was only a fraction of that. Hotter, whiter. Colder, redder.”
Nimo had gone very quiet in his bubble. “My tap is wrong,” he said at last.
“Your tap is not wrong,” said Memoon gently. “It was painted for people who need to know which side is warm. In water, nothing glows. Out there, gas glows, and the glow follows a different rule. Your water rules are excellent for water, Nimo,” she added, grinning. “Stars are not water.”
“I am beginning to notice that,” said Nimo, with dignity.
Kachui had already written the new rule in his notebook. “A hotter surface shifts toward blue-white,” he read. “A cooler surface shifts toward red. So Aldebaran, which is orange, is cooler than the Sun, which is yellow. And Bellatrix, pale and blue-white, is hotter than the Sun.”
“Much hotter,” said Mr Rao, who knew a little astronomy. “I would not be surprised if Bellatrix were three or four times the Sun’s surface temperature.”
Memoon looked it up on the Club’s tablet. “Astronomers use kelvin, a scale that starts at the coldest possible temperature, and to get close to degrees Celsius you subtract 273. The Sun’s surface is about 5,800 kelvin, which is about 5,500 degrees Celsius. Aldebaran is about 3,900. Betelgeuse is about 3,300 to 3,600. Rigel is about 12,000. And Bellatrix is about 21,000.”
Colour is a thermometer
| 3,900 K | 5,800 K | 12,000 K | 25,000 K |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aldebaran | Sun | Rigel | Alnilam |
| Betelgeuse | Arcturus | Sirius | Bellatrix |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3,500 K | 4,300 K | 9,500 K | 21,000 K |
Cooler Hotter
Temperature scale is compressed (it is not a straight line). Colours are approximate; screens and paper show colours differently. Temperatures are surface values, rounded.
Colour is a thermometer. The temperature scale is compressed and colours are approximate.
“So Betelgeuse is cool,” said Beautine slowly, “and Bellatrix is the scorcher. But Betelgeuse is brighter than Bellatrix! You said so yourself, in the photographs!”
“That,” said Memoon, “is the best question anyone has asked this evening.”
She flipped to a clean page. “Brightness depends on two things. How hot each patch of a star’s surface is, because hotter patches give out much more light. And how many patches there are, which is the surface area. Betelgeuse is cooler, but it is enormous.”
She found the numbers the way Memoon always does: by writing them down and not being impressed. “Betelgeuse’s radius is somewhere between seven hundred and nine hundred times the Sun’s. Let us take eight hundred. Surface area goes with the radius squared, so its surface is 800 times 800, or 640,000 times as large as the Sun’s. Its temperature is about 3,500 kelvin, and the Sun’s is about 5,800, so Betelgeuse is about 0.6 of the Sun’s temperature. Hotter surfaces shine much, much more: if you double the
temperature, each patch gives out sixteen times as much light. That is two multiplied by itself four times. So at 0.6 of the Sun’s temperature, each patch gives out 0.6 multiplied by itself four times, which is about 0.13.”
“So,” said Kachui, “640,000 times 0.13.”
“About 83,000 times the Sun’s light output,” said Memoon. “Real measurements say somewhere around a hundred thousand. We are in the right neighbourhood.”
Why a cool star can still be very bright
Betelgeuse
Sun
(not to scale)
radius 1 about 800
surface area 1 about 640,000 times larger
temperature 5,800 K about 3,500 K (about 0.6 times)
light from each patch 1 about 0.13 times as much
total light 640,000 × 0.13 ≈ 83,000 Suns
Sizes are not to scale: drawn to scale, the Sun would be a dot. Inputs are estimates; the measured light output is about 100,000 Suns.
A cool star can be very bright if it is very big. Sizes are not to scale.
Noodles whistled. “That is a lot of cat-lamps.”
“If you put Betelgeuse where the Sun is,” said Mr Rao, “its surface would swallow Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars, pass through the asteroid belt and head toward Jupiter.”
Beautine, who loved a record, fainted slowly onto the mat. “I wrote my slip about the wrong star,” she murmured. “Aldebaran is cool, I mean it is a tiny orange cousin, and the real giant is on Orion’s shoulder.”
“Aldebaran is a giant too,” said Memoon. “Just not as big. There are many ways to be cool and bright.”
Beautine sat up with a new idea shining in her small eyes. She ran to her bag and came back with a fan of paint-shop colour cards, the sort that come in strips of five shades. “I have been collecting these,” she said, “for no reason. Now I have a reason. Tonight we sort every star we can see by colour. Not by how I feel about the colour. By matching the card.”
“A star-colour chart,” said Memoon. “Beautine, that is the best idea you have had since the acorn labels.”
They spent an hour matching cards to stars until the Hunter was well above the water tank. Betelgeuse was a deep orange. Aldebaran was a slightly paler orange. Capella, high overhead, was yellow. Rigel and Bellatrix were both a cold white-blue. It was very hard to tell some colours apart, and Beautine kept saying that Aldebaran was red, until Memoon asked her to compare it with the actual red card and she admitted it was orange. By the end they had two reds, three oranges and a great many arguments.
Beautine matches paint cards to the stars. Colours are approximate.
When Memoon finally closed her notebook, she added a line at the bottom of the Betelgeuse Log. Colour is a thermometer we can read from across space. Not the whole story, but a good start.
Science Corner Thermal glow: any hot object glows, and as it gets hotter the glow shifts from dull red to orange, yellow, white and then blue-white. A star’s colour therefore shows how hot its surface is. Star temperatures are given in kelvin (K). To get close to degrees Celsius, subtract 273. Surface temperatures in this chapter are approximate: Betelgeuse about 3,300 to 3,600 K, Aldebaran about 3,900 K, the Sun about 5,800 K, Rigel about 12,000 K, Bellatrix about 21,000 K. Luminosity is the total light a star gives out. It depends on the surface temperature and on the surface area, which grows with the square of the radius. A red supergiant such as Betelgeuse is cool but vast: roughly 700 to 900 times the Sun’s radius (estimates differ) and about a hundred thousand times its light output. Colour card matching (a star-colour chart) gives a repeatable way to compare colours, because our impressions of colour change from person to person and night to night. Story note: The filament experiment is a model. A bulb filament is a solid metal wire, while a star is a ball of glowing gas, so the match in colour is approximate, and the tap colours on a water tap are simply a human colour code. The simplified rule “double the temperature, sixteen times the light per patch” is accurate for an ideal glowing surface and works well for stars; Book 10 returns to it in more detail. Colours in a telescope image may be enhanced, and our eyes cannot see colour well in dim light, so only the brightest stars look clearly coloured. The Club, Mr Rao and the paint cards are story elements.
Space Detective 1. Nimo believed red stars must be hottest because the hot tap is red. Use the filament experiment to explain why that is wrong for stars, and why the tap colour code does not apply to stars. 2. Using the temperatures in the Science Corner, put Bellatrix, Aldebaran and the Sun in order from coolest to hottest and say what colour you would expect each to look. 3. A star has the same surface temperature as the Sun but twice the radius. How many times larger is its surface area, and so (by this simple model) how many times more light does it give out? Show your working.
Try it: Glow Watch Time: 15 minutes. Adult: An adult must switch the appliance on and off, and nobody should touch any glowing part or the glass. Keep everyone a metre back. You need: an electric heater, toaster or a filament bulb on a dimmer switch (ask an adult before you start), your Sky Notebook, a pencil and paint-shop colour cards if you have them. Do: With the room dimmed, an adult turns the heat up slowly from low to high. Watch from a safe distance, and note the colour you see at each stage. Match the colours to the paint cards and write the order in your notebook. Then rank the stars of Orion by colour from your own sky or from the table. What to expect: The glow starts dull red, becomes orange, then yellow, and may reach a yellowish-white at high settings, so “hotter” matches “whiter” in the same sequence as the stars. Cloudy or low-resource day: Look up photographs of red-hot and white-hot metal from a safe, reputable source with an adult, and sort the colours by temperature using the table above. Limitation: LED lamps, phone screens and warm-white or cool-white lights make their colours in a different way, so they do not show temperature in the way a glowing wire does.
Next time: Stars are bright, hot and different colours. But where does a star begin? Look at the middle of Orion’s sword, below the belt, where a faint blur hangs. Something is being built there.
← Chapter 1: Fading Shoulder · Book 8 contents · Chapter 3: Star Nurseries →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment