Memunic Space Explorers › Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars › Chapter 5: Endings
Chapter 5: Endings
In this chapter: Compare how a low-mass star, a Sun-like star and a massive star end (white dwarf, or supernova leaving a neutron star or black hole), and explain why only massive stars explode.
The next evening, the sky closed up like a lid.
Grey clouds rolled in from the west and sat over the terrace, so the Club carried its folding table, a roll of chart paper and three pots of markers down to the society hall on the ground floor. It smelled of floor polish and old committee biscuits. Mr Rao had left the projector on, humming to itself, in case anyone needed it.
Beautine was standing on a chair.
“BREAKING NEWS,” she announced, to an audience of five friends and a stack of folding chairs. “The fate of the stars has been decided! In five billion years our Sun will EXPLODE and all of us will be fried! And Betelgeuse will blow up tonight and destroy the Earth!”
“Get down,” said Kachui, without looking up from his notebook. “We have not written either of those claims on a ladder.”
Beautine climbed down with a certain dignity. “They sounded true.”
“They sounded dramatic,” said Memoon. “Which is not the same thing. Let us find out how stars really end. Simbha, you wanted to know.”
Simbha sat with the Sun torch in his paws, the big yellow one that always stood in for the Sun in his models. “I know one thing,” he said. “A star runs out of fuel and then it goes boom. Betelgeuse looks like it is going to. So everything must end the same way, and since our Sun is a star, it will go boom too, in a few billion years.”
“A reasonable guess from one example,” said Memoon kindly. “Let us find out if it is true for the others.”
She unrolled the chart paper across the table. Along the top she wrote three words in three colours: SMALL. MEDIUM. HEAVY. Below them she drew three empty columns. Noodles was given the job of cutting out little cards, which he did slowly and with commentary. Each card named a stage: Nebula. Main sequence. Red giant. Red supergiant. Planetary nebula. White dwarf. Supernova. Neutron star or black hole.
The Club sorts star fates in the society hall.
“Start with small,” said Memoon. “A star with a tenth or a quarter of the Sun’s mass. Red dwarfs. Remember the Fuel Race? They burn their fuel very slowly.”
“For trillions of years,” said Kachui, with pleasure. “The Universe is only thirteen point eight billion years old. So not one red dwarf has had time to end. We can only predict what happens, not watch it.”
“They will slowly fade into cold, dim, dead cinders called white dwarfs,” said Memoon. “But that is a prediction, not an observation. Mark it as a HINT.”
Kachui wrote HINT on the card with a very small flourish.
“Now medium,” said Memoon. “Stars like the Sun, up to about eight times heavier. What do you think happens when the core runs out of hydrogen?”
“The balance fails,” said Simbha, who had been listening. “Gravity wins, and the core squeezes in.”
“The core squeezes in and heats up. That sets off fusion in a shell around it, and the outer layers swell, cool and turn red. The star becomes a red giant. Aldebaran is one, right now. The Sun will become one in about five billion years, and it will swell so far that it swallows Mercury and Venus, and maybe Earth.”
Beautine gasped. “There. I was right. We get FRIED.”
“Earth will be uninhabitable far sooner than that,” said Memoon. “We will come to that. But the Sun will not explode. It will do something quieter.”
She tapped the next card: Planetary nebula.
“The red giant’s outer layers drift away, puffed off over thousands of years into a glowing shell of gas. Early astronomers looked at those shells through small telescopes and thought they looked like planets, so they gave them a confusing name. They have nothing to do with planets. The Sun will make one, and all that gas will glow for tens of thousands of years.”
“And in the middle?” Nimo’s bubble drifted up, golden fins swaying.
“The core is left behind. About the size of Earth, but as heavy as a Sun’s worth of stuff squeezed into it. It no longer fuses anything. It glows because it is still hot, and cools slowly for billions of years. A white dwarf.”
Simbha put down the Sun torch and turned it off. The hall dimmed a little. “So the Sun will not go boom. It will end quietly.”
“It is not a failure to end quietly,” said Kachui. “Most stars do.”
“Are there limits?” asked Nimo. “Can any core become a white dwarf?”
Memoon grinned. “Good question. A white dwarf cannot be heavier than about 1.4 Suns. If the core is heavier, nothing stops it from collapsing further. The limit is named after an Indian scientist, Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, who worked it out when he was very young. We will meet him again in the back of the book.”
She tapped the third column, HEAVY. “And now the big ones. Stars above about eight times the Sun’s mass. Betelgeuse is one, with fifteen to twenty. They keep fusing after hydrogen, and after helium: carbon, then oxygen, then heavier elements, each stage faster and hotter than the last. In a very massive star the last stages last only days. At the end, the core is iron.”
“What is wrong with iron?” asked Noodles, who had been cutting a card very crookedly.
“Nothing, if you are a bridge. But a star cannot get energy by fusing iron. It uses energy up. The core runs out of ways to hold itself up, and in less than a second it collapses.”
The hall seemed very quiet.
“The outer layers fall inward, crash into the stiff, dense core and bounce back out. The whole star is blown apart in an explosion called a supernova. For weeks it can shine brighter than all the other stars in its home galaxy put together.”
“Would it look like a new star?” asked Beautine, wide-eyed.
“Like a very bright new star,” said Memoon. “In the year 1054 Chinese astronomers wrote that a ’guest star’ had appeared in the sky. We now know it was a supernova. Its remains are a glowing cloud we call the Crab Nebula. Astronomers still study it.”
“And what is left in the middle?” said Nimo.
“Either a neutron star, an astonishingly dense ball only about twenty kilometres across, or, if the star was heavier still, a black hole. We will not go into either of those today. That is a story for later books.”
Nimo had been thinking in his bubble, turning slowly. “Would we hear it?” he said. “If Betelgeuse explodes, would the boom come across space?”
“Remember sound?” said Memoon, smiling. “Sound needs something to travel through: air, water, something. Space is almost empty. We would see it. We would never hear it.”
“Rather like my Imagine Mode,” said Nimo. “All visuals, no noise.”
“One more thing,” said Kachui, to Beautine, and the squirrel braced herself. “Is Betelgeuse going to explode tonight?”
Beautine swallowed. “I do not know.”
“That is exactly the answer I wanted,” said Kachui. “It will explode someday, almost everyone agrees. But how soon? Even astronomers disagree. We will look at that properly. For now: nobody knows, and the Great Dimming is not a countdown clock.”
“It is too far away to hurt us, though,” said Simbha, thoughtfully. “Six hundred light-years.”
“Far too far,” said Memoon. “It would be bright enough to see in daylight for a while, I think. But it could not harm us.”
They sorted the cards in the three columns. When they finished, two paths ran down the paper: one gentle, one violent. The gentle one ended in a glowing shell and a cooling white dwarf. The violent one ended in a flash and a leftover core.
“The Sun is on the gentle path,” said Simbha, quietly. “And Betelgeuse is on the other one.”
“Yes,” said Memoon. “And in both cases, something important is thrown into space. Gas. Dust. Material the star made while it shone. Where does that stuff go?”
Nebula (gas and dust)
Main sequence
less than about 8 Suns more than about 8 Suns
Red giant Red supergiant red dwarfs: live trillions of years; their end is predicted, not observed Planetary nebula Supernova
Neutron star White dwarf or black hole
The Sun is here (main sequence) Betelgeuse is here (supergiant)
Cut-off masses are approximate. Stars in pairs can follow different paths.
Star Fate Cards: the main paths. Cut-off masses are approximate.
Nobody had an answer yet. But Nimo had stopped turning, and Kachui, who knew him well, noticed that he was looking at the Question Jar. At a slip near the bottom, folded small, in his own blue handwriting.
Science Corner Red giant: when a Sun-like star’s core runs out of hydrogen, the core shrinks, and the outer layers swell and cool. Aldebaran is a red giant. The Sun will become one in about five billion years. Planetary nebula: the shell of gas a red giant puffs off. It has nothing to do with planets; the name is historical. What is left of the core is a white dwarf: about Earth-sized, no longer fusing, slowly cooling. A white dwarf cannot be heavier than about 1.4 Suns (the Chandrasekhar limit). Supernova: a star of more than about eight Suns builds an iron core that cannot release energy by fusion. The core collapses in under a second, and the outer layers are blown off in an explosion. What is left after a supernova is a neutron star or a black hole. The Crab Nebula is the remains of a supernova recorded by Chinese astronomers in 1054. Red dwarfs (small stars) live so long that none has yet had time to end; their fates are predictions, not observations. Story note: The cut-off masses (about eight Suns, 1.4 Suns) are approximate and vary with a star’s make-up. Stars in pairs can follow different paths; for example, a white dwarf that pulls gas from a companion can explode. A white dwarf is described as Earth-sized yet roughly as heavy as the Sun, which is why it is called “squeezed”. Nobody knows when Betelgeuse will end; the star is not expected to harm Earth. Sound cannot cross empty space, so a supernova would be seen and not heard. The Star Fate Cards are the Club’s own device.
Space Detective 1. Simbha thought every star ends in an explosion because Betelgeuse will. Use the Star Fate Cards to explain why that is true only for some stars, and what the Sun will do instead. 2. A star has 0.5 Suns of mass, another has 1 Sun and another has 20 Suns. For each, say how it will end and how you know. 3. Nimo asked whether we would hear a supernova. Use what you know about sound to answer, and say what we would detect instead.
Try it: Star Fate Cards Time: 20 minutes. Adult: An adult should check scissors are used safely. You can do this indoors on a cloudy day. You need: card or paper, scissors, markers, chart paper or a large sheet and tape. Do: Make cards for these stages: Nebula, Main sequence, Red giant, Red supergiant, Planetary nebula, White dwarf, Supernova, Neutron star or black hole. Make three mass cards: 0.2 Suns, 1 Sun, 20 Suns. For each mass card, arrange the stage cards in order to show how that star ends, and write HINT on any stage that has not yet been observed. Compare with a friend. What to expect: The 0.2 and 1 Sun cards follow the gentle path to a white dwarf, and the 20 Sun card follows the violent path. The 0.2 Sun path should be marked HINT, since no such star has had time to end. Cloudy or low-resource day: This activity is designed for indoors with paper only. Limitation: cut-off masses are approximate, and stars in pairs, rotating fast, or with different chemical make-up can follow different paths, so the cards show the usual routes only.
Next time: The Sun will blow a glowing shell of gas into space, and Betelgeuse will scatter itself across the sky. Where does all that gas go, and what does it have to do with your own hands?
← Chapter 4: The Long Middle · Book 8 contents · Chapter 6: Star Stuff →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment