Memunic Space Explorers › Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars › Chapter 6: Star Stuff
Chapter 6: Star Stuff
In this chapter: Explain that stars recycle their gas into space, that most elements heavier than hydrogen and helium were made in stars and their explosions, and that the Sun, Earth and our own bodies contain atoms made in earlier stars.
Memoon was frying onions when the question came back to her.
It was Saturday afternoon. Her mother had gone out, her father was asleep in front of a cricket match, and the kitchen belonged to her, a steel pan, a pile of vegetables and the Club tablet propped against the sugar jar. Guddu’s face filled the screen from her own kitchen across the city, a mug of tea in her hand and her ponytail tucked behind one ear. Kachui had come over for the afternoon. He sat on the kitchen table in his red scarf, writing very small notes in his grey book.
“The gas goes somewhere,” said Memoon, stirring. “When a Sun-like star puffs off its outer layers, and when a massive star blows itself up, all that gas goes into space. It cannot disappear. So where does it end up?”
“Back in the nurseries,” said Guddu. “A nebula is a cloud of gas and dust. Some of that gas is the leftovers of dead stars. So the next round of stars is born out of the remains of the last round.”
“Recycling,” said Kachui, pleased. “I do like recycling.”
“Yes, but here is the clever part,” said Guddu. “What did the first stars make themselves from? Only the gas that was there at the very start, which was almost entirely hydrogen and helium. No iron. No carbon. No oxygen. No calcium. But the Sun has all of those, and so does Earth. So who made them?”
Memoon stopped stirring. “Stars did.”
“Right. Stars are factories. In a star’s core, fusion does not stop at helium. In a Sun-like star, helium fuses into carbon and oxygen. In a massive star, the factory keeps going: carbon, oxygen, neon, magnesium, silicon, all the way up to iron. And when that star dies in a supernova, it throws all those new elements into space.”
Kachui lifted his head. “How do we know? Nobody has seen a star make iron.”
“Good question,” said Guddu, setting down her tea. “Two sorts of evidence. One: starlight carries the fingerprints of elements, and astronomers have used it to measure what stars are made of. You will meet how that works in a later book. Two: the oldest stars we know have far less of the heavy elements than the Sun does. That is just what you would expect, if the heavy elements were made by earlier stars and slowly built up over time. It is a HINT, a strong one, with a lot of tested science behind it.”
Kachui wrote HINT (strong) in his notebook.
“There is a lovely story about this,” Guddu went on. “In 1925, a student called Cecilia Payne was studying starlight. Before her, people had assumed stars were made of the same stuff as Earth: rock and iron. Cecilia worked out that stars are mostly hydrogen and helium. That was a shock. An important astronomer told her it looked impossible, and she put a line in her thesis saying her numbers were probably not real. Four years later, that same astronomer reached the same answer.”
“She was right,” said Memoon, “and she was told she was wrong.”
“Which is a good reason,” said Kachui, “to check evidence, not rank.”
Memoon set the onions aside and put her hands on her hips. “Let us test this. A kitchen is full of elements. Where did each come from? I will make a list.”
They worked as a team: Memoon walked around the kitchen reading labels and naming things, Kachui wrote them down, and Guddu looked up the answers. Salt: sodium and chlorine. Sugar: carbon, hydrogen, oxygen. Water: hydrogen and oxygen. The steel pan: mostly iron, with a little carbon. Aluminium foil: aluminium. A calcium tablet from the shelf: calcium. Her grandmother’s thin gold bangle, brought out of the cupboard for the occasion, which she held very carefully: gold.
Memoon’s kitchen is full of star stuff.
Guddu was building a quick table on her side of the call. “Hydrogen: the early universe. Most of the helium: the early universe. Carbon and nitrogen: mostly Sun-like stars near the end of their lives, and some from massive stars. Oxygen, calcium, sodium, aluminium, silicon: mostly massive stars and their supernovae. Iron: a lot comes from supernovae, including some of the kind that happen in star pairs. And gold...”
She stopped.
“What about gold?” said Memoon.
“Gold is the interesting one. Elements heavier than iron cannot be made by ordinary fusion in a star’s core, because that uses up energy instead of giving it. They need extreme events: supernovae, and the collisions of neutron stars. In 2017, astronomers watched a collision of two neutron stars, and the light afterwards had the signs of heavy elements being made. So collisions certainly make some. How much of Earth’s gold came from supernovae and how much from collisions is still being worked out.”
Kachui, who is cautious, put down his pen. “So we do not know where this bangle’s gold came from.”
“We know it was made in an extreme event in a star or between stars,” said Memoon, “and we do not know which. Can you write that as a GUESS? Not just ’we do not know’? A scientist should be able to say what is most likely, and say how sure she is.”
Kachui blinked. This was the thing he found hardest. He had patience for anything except being wrong. After a while he wrote, in his smallest handwriting: GUESS (low confidence): neutron-star collision or supernova, probably both.
“That is a good one,” said Guddu, warmly. “A guess with its confidence written beside it.”
Memoon sat down at last, with the bangle in her lap. “So the iron in this pan, and the calcium in my bones, and the oxygen in my breath, all of it was made inside a star that died before the Sun was born.”
“All of it,” said Guddu. “Not the hydrogen in your water, which is older still, from the early universe. But most of the rest. Let me say that properly. Oxygen is about two-thirds of your body’s mass, carbon about a fifth, hydrogen about a tenth, then nitrogen, calcium, phosphorus. Most of those were made in stars.”
Where do the first 30 elements come from? (simplified)
H He
Li Be B C N O F Ne
Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Ar
K Ca Sc Ti V Cr Mn Fe Co Ni Cu Zn
early Universe Sun-like stars massive stars and supernovae
extreme collisions (heavier elements such as gold, not shown here)
cosmic rays and other sources (Li, Be, B) beyond iron: shares still debated
Sources are simplified: many elements have several sources Table layout is simplified (rows 1 to 4 only)
Where the first 30 elements come from. Sources are simplified.
“We are made of star stuff,” said Memoon, quietly.
“A phrase worth keeping,” said Kachui, “and worth checking. I checked it. It is true.”
They finished the onions. Memoon’s father woke up long enough to say it smelled wonderful and went back to sleep. Out of the kitchen window, a grey afternoon sky hung over the city. Somewhere above it, older than anyone had words for, were the stars whose ashes were now in her hand.
“One more question,” said Memoon, as Guddu waved goodbye. “If all those dead stars scatter their ashes, and new stars are born from them, where does it all happen? There must be a place where all the stars live together.”
“There is,” said Guddu. “You live in it.”
Science Corner An element is a substance made of one kind of atom, such as hydrogen, carbon or iron. The periodic table lists about 118 of them. Hydrogen and most of the helium in the Universe formed in the very early Universe (the story of that is for a later book). Heavier elements were made later, in stars. Fusion in stars makes carbon, oxygen and heavier elements up to iron. Massive stars and their supernovae make much of the oxygen, calcium and iron we know. Elements heavier than iron need extreme events such as supernovae and neutron-star collisions. How much comes from each is still being worked out. Recycling: dying stars return gas and dust to space, and new clouds form with these heavier elements. The Sun and Earth contain atoms made in earlier stars, which is why “we are made of star stuff” is true for most of our body. Story note: The sources of each element are simplified; most elements come from more than one process, and the shares are debated. The percentages of oxygen, carbon and hydrogen in the body are rounded and are by mass. The 2017 neutron-star collision is a real observation, and what it proves about gold is still being worked out. Cecilia Payne’s 1925 work and her wording are historical. A kitchen is not a star, and the “factory” picture is an analogy: a star does not plan what it makes. Memoon’s kitchen and the bangle are story elements.
Space Detective 1. Explain what “we are made of star stuff” means. Which important element in our bodies was probably not made in stars, and where did it come from? 2. Why must the material that formed the Sun include atoms that were made in earlier stars? Give one piece of evidence. 3. Write a labelled note (KNOWN, HINT or GUESS, with your confidence) about where the gold in a ring probably came from.
Try it: Element Origin Map Time: 30 minutes. Adult: An adult should handle the items and help with labels; do not taste anything from the activity. You need: a printed periodic table, coloured pencils, five or six household items with ingredient labels (salt, sugar, an iron or steel pan, aluminium foil, a calcium tablet), your Sky Notebook. Do: List the main elements in each item. Colour a copy of the periodic table using four colours: early Universe, Sun-like stars, massive stars and supernovae, extreme collisions (neutron-star mergers and other explosions). For each item you chose, mark which colours its elements fall into. Mark any elements whose source is uncertain with a question mark. What to expect: Most of the elements on your list are marked as made in stars. Hydrogen is marked early Universe. Gold and other heavy elements get a question mark. Cloudy or low-resource day: This works indoors. If you do not have a printed table, draw a grid of the 20 most common elements. Limitation: the colour categories are simplified, because many elements are made by more than one process and the shares are still debated.
Next time: The ashes of dead stars drift between the stars and gather into new clouds. All of it happens inside one vast wheel of stars that you live in. What does it look like, and where are we inside it?
← Chapter 5: Endings · Book 8 contents · Chapter 7: Our Galaxy →
Keep exploring with Memunic Space Explorers
Continue with Book 8: Memoon and the Life of Stars, or see all twelve books in the series. Find more Memunic ebooks on MemuniCity.
Comments
Post a Comment